Disclaimer: I do not own Pretty Little Liars

Hanna (P.O.V)

I am holding Spencer as she cries. Aria rubs her back while Emily holds her hand. I want to cry a little too, even though this doesn't necessarily affect me as much. I can't stand to see Spence like this.

*one hour earlier*

I am going to Spencer's house. She is home alone since the boys are out for a guys' night. When I walk upstairs, I see her sobbing with her face in her hands.

"What's wrong, Spencer? What happened? Did you get a B again on a test?" I ask her kneeling in front of her.

She shakes her head. She points to her phone. I pick it up and turn on, and a pictures flashes onto the screen. It is a picture of Alison and Toby kissing. At the bottom of the picture it said,

So your boyfriend wasn't as sweet as you thought. -A

What?! "Spencer, this is crazy. Toby loves you."

"He never said it. It makes sense now." She sobs. This really breaks my heart. I text the other girls, and they are over before I can say high heels.

Aria (P.O.V)

When Hanna told Emily and I what happened, we were on our way. I was supposed to take Mike out for something to eat, but I decided to bring him with me. I can't believe Toby. I mean honestly, I really thought he would change for her. I have seen them over the years. Spencer was there for him when people were bullying him, when his mother died, and when he needed a place to stay, she let him live with her. That jerk! Well, I don't think he actually cheated.

Mike, Emily, and I get to Spencer's house, where we can already hear her crying. We go up to her room to see Hanna holding her. Emily and I rush over to her while Mike just stands there awkwardly.

"I'm just going to….. leave." He walks out of the room.

Emily (P.O.V)

I don't understand. I thought Toby and Spencer were so adorable together. But no, Toby just has to screw up. He is such an idiot! I am interrupted from my thoughts when Hanna says, "I'll be right back."

"Where are you going?" I ask, though I am afraid of the answer.

"I'm just going to get Spencer some ice cream."

I nod and she leaves.

Hanna (P.O.V)

I wasn't lying when I said that I was getting Spencer ice cream. I will, after I kick Toby's ass for hurting her. Thankfully I see him in the ice cream shop, so I can kill two birds with one stone- that's how I use that phrase, right?

Anyway, I see him in there so I storm up to him.

"Hey, Hanna." He says. I continue to glare at him.

I walk back outside, knowing Toby enough to know that he will follow me. Sure enough, he does.

"What was that about?" He asks. I turn around and slap him.

"What was that for?!"

"How dare you do that to Spencer?"

"What are you talking about?"

"Oh, give it up! I know you cheated."

"No I didn't. I don't know what you are talking about!"

"Spencer was sent a picture of you and some bitch named Alison making out!"

"Let me see the picture." It's a good thing that I took Spencer's phone with me. I take it out and give it to him.

He looks shocked.

"Shocked because you were finally caught? Why did you do it? When did it start?"

He puts both of his hands on my shoulders and says, "Hanna, listen. I. DID. NOT. CHEAT!"

"Don't say that to me. Say it to Spencer."

He walks past me into his truck. He gestures for me to get in so I do, and we drive back to the house.

Spencer (P.O.V)

Why is this happening? I can't believe Toby would do this to me. To us. Aria strokes my back while Emily holds my hand. As much as I hate for people to comfort me- it makes me feel weak- it's nice to know that my friends would be here for me.

This hurts. Even more than when- no, I refuse to think about it.

Hanna walks in, with not only ice cream, but with Toby as well.

Toby (P.O.V)

I was supposed to be at guys' night right now, and they are probably wondering where I am, but this is more important. How could Spencer believe that I cheated on her?

I walk into her room after Hanna, and see her with Aria and Emily. Spencer is in her pajamas, (a tank top and sweatpants), hair is wet so I assume she took a shower, and she looks like she has been crying. I know she has.

"What do you want?" Aria asks. I don't answer. I simply ask, "Can I Talk to Spencer alone?"

Spencer nods at them and they reluctantly walk out.

I sit on Spencer's bed next to her. She is laying on her stomach and she faces away from me.

I put my hand on her lower back. "Spencer, I didn't cheat, I swear it."

"I know you didn't. I was upset for a while but a few minutes ago I realized that it was photoshopped."

"Then what's the problem?"

She sits up and says, "Toby, I haven't been completely honest with you."

"What is it? You can tell me anything."

"Remember how I told you about what Wren did?"

"Yes." I answer as my fists clench at the thought of him putting his hands on my girlfriend.

"Well, that isn't all. That wasn't the first time he hurt me. I think I should tell you what happened, but my brothers don't even know."

I prepare myself for what she is about to tell me.