Unforgettable Love

by CollegeStar21

Summary

Brittany Pierce and Santana Lopez were finally a couple and not to be open at McKinley High. Everybody knew they had something going with them and didn't care because they knew that Santana would kick their asses for messing with her girlfriend.

But what happens when Brittany's old childhood best friend/first ever girlfriend, Rachel Berry moves back to Lima after being in California for so long, shows up Brittany's and her Senior year all grown up and not the same girl she was when she was younger,sparking up feelings that Brittany struggled to long forget while also putting a strain on her relationship with Santana Lopez?

Will Brittany and Rachel start their friendship over as just best friends or will they finally admit that they still want each other? Find out what happens.

Season 4 Rachel Berry clothes and hair style in this story. Minor Brittana relationship but Brittberry and Quinntana romance hopefully in the end.

I'm adding two girls to this story who are part of New Directions and good friends with the group.

Enjoy.

At McKinley.

Brittany and Rachel were at Brittany's locker talking about their date tonight when some guy walks up to with a box of Lucky Charms. Brittany smiles taking the box so happy with her box of Lucky Charms with just marshmallows.

"This is magic. Oh my god. Thank you Rory Leprechaun. You know, now you're like two wishes away from getting my pot of Gold." Rachel stares at her girlfriend confused wondering if she heard Brittany's words right of Leprechaun's and what was with this pot of gold crap? she will talk to Britt later.

They were offically dating now and they were open about at school.

"Who is this Brittany?" Rachel heard the guy ask her girlfriend while glancing at her with a love struck smile on his face.

"Rory this is Rachel Berry, Fluffy this is Rory my Leprechaun." Rachel looked at her girlfriend raising an eyebrow.

"Wait you were serious about him being your Leprechaun last night on our date? B he's a real person you know that right?" Britt frowned slightly then looked at Rory.

"Tell her Rory that she's being silly and you are magic. You wouldn't lie to me would you?" Britt asked hopefully. Rory glared at Rachel not liking that she was messing up his chances with the girl he wants.

"She's being silly Britt. Of course I wouldn't lie to you! I am a Leprechaun and how about I walk you to class?" Britt turned back to her girlfriend.

"Your just jealous that I have one real Leprechaun and you don't." Rachel scuffed.

"Are you serious? he's lying to you Bunny and you believe him but not me? He's the new foreign Exchange student from Ireland. You know what I'm going to leave before I do or say something I might regret." She walked off pissed off and a little hurt.

"She's just jealous that you have your very own Lepr-" He gets cut off by Brittany pulling him over to a few people and asked if they could see him and they all nodded.

"You were just trying to have sex with me right? that's what you meant by my pot of gold?" Britt demanded pissed off and hurt.

"I'm sorry for tricking you but now that girl won't be in our way of us being together." She shook her head slapping his arm.

"Okay first of all? I told you to work on your English and second? I don't want to be with you Rory because you're a jerk and Rachel is my girlfriend. Not a girl who is just my best friend which she is but I love her and we were dating." Rory starts to protest but Brittany stops him once again.

"Now I have to beg for her forgiveness. She's my true love and I should have believed her when she told me the truth, she's mad and might break up me." She walked off to her class feeling like she lost everything if Rachel isn't by her side.

Rory stood there not having a clue what just happened.

Later That Day.

Brittany was standing in the hallway watching Rachel at her locker and wished they were talking or atleast kissing and making up.

"Hey Britt what are you doing?" Santana asked walking up to her.

"I'm just staring at Rachel. I think we broke up a few hours ago." Santana stared at her ex girlfriend as she looked at Rachel with a longing look on her face.

"Do you want her back?" Britt looked at her best friend and nodded sadly.

"I really do San but she's never going to forgive me after I told she was jealous of mine and Rory's friendship." Santana placed her hand on her shoulder.

"Don't think that way B, go over to her and get your girl back. I see the way you two are together and it's cute." Brittany smiles at her nodding before slowly walking over to Rachel and Santana stands there watching them hoping they makeup or she was going to kick the midgets ass.

"Hey Rachie." Rachel looked at her and grabbed her books putting them in her bag before closing her locker.

"Hi Brittany." Rachel just stood there looking away awkwardly.

"I'm sorry for not believing you when you told me that Rory was a real person. He's actually staying at my house for a year and I should of know that not just my family saw him and he was just trying to have sexy time with me." Rachel had no idea that Rory was trying to have sex with her girlfriend. That made her angry.

"Can we still be girlfriends please?" She asked hopefully with a pouty smile.

Rachel walks closer to her with a soft smile sighing.

"I don't know Bunny, I was hurt that you sided with him and not me but maybe a kiss could change my mind?" She said with a flirty smile.

"I guess we need to change your mind then." Rachel leans up kissing her sweetly before pulling back. Britt waited with a hopeful look.

"Of course we can still be girlfriends. we were never broken up. Couples fight baby but they are still a couple." Rachel tells her leaning in again.

Brittany grins loving that they were still together. She starts kissing her again then they pull back smiling at each other.

"I missed not talking to you." She whispered to her girlfriend.

"Let's try not to fight again." Rachel whispers holding her hand and Britt nods agreeing with her.

"Another a kiss before class?" Rachel giggles pecking her lips but Britt pulls her close capuring her lips holding her by the hips,so in love with her girlfriend.

Quinn walked over to Santana and wrapped her arm around her shoulder.

"It's rude to stare at couples who are kissing. That was very sweet of you to help them back to each other." Santana looks at her best friend and smiles slightly.

"I just want her to be happy even if it's with some girl that's not me. Britt is important to me and I'll do whatever I can to make sure there is a smile on her face." She tells her firmly then looked back to see Brittany wrap her arm around Rachel's shoulder and they smiled at each other walking down the hallway talking and they both waved at both girls before walking off to their class together before lunch sharing a few pecks on the lips.

"Are you still planning on getting her back or are you going to try to move on?" Santana looked at Quinn.

"Not sure yet but for now I'm going to focus on being her best friend. Are you still friends with Berry?" Quinn nodded.

"Yeah she's actually pretty cool once you get to know her and she makes the best cookies even though it's vegan." Santana wasn't ready to be friends with the girl that stole her girlfriend but if Britt was happy then she was going to deal with it.

"There is nobody like her." Santana thought staring at Quinn wondering if they would be cute together as a couple.

Find out what happens next.