(Revenge)

One shot that I wrote after 4x01.

After Spencer found out Toby joined the A-team to protect her, they got back together. But there are some questions still unanswered. While Toby's in the Brew he over hears Spencer talking with her friends about notes between Alison and Cece. During their conversation they mention Alison's visit to Toby when he was in juvie. Realizing what he said back than, Toby now feels guilty. Later he talks to Spencer about it and things do work out like you'd think.

(T pov)

I walk into the Brew after a long hard day at work. As soon as I get up to my loft I plain on calling Spencer over to have a little us time. I'm so glade Spencer forgave me and that we're back together. I love her so much and I just don't know what I would do without her. As I was walking up to the counter I noticed Spencer sitting at a table talking with her friends. Their probably talking about the craziness that's been going on with "A", Wildens murder, and every other crazy thing that's happened this week. I was about to head up to my loft, but froze when I heard them mention my name.

Spencer: "Ali was the first one to get texts from "A."

Hanna: "Yeah but if Mona was the one that was after her and Mona isn't "A" anymore, so whose after us now?"

Aria: "Well we know that Cece hates us."

Hanna: "Why would Cece hate us? All we've ever done is help her."

Spencer: "Yeah but Alison could have done something that made her hate us."

Emily: "What we didn't even know Cece than."

Spencer: "Yeah well Alison, knows how to drag people into a game before you even realize it. By the time you do it's to late."

Hanna: "What could Cece know about us?"

Emily: "Everything; Alison told Cece stuff about us. Stuff that we still don't know."

Spencer: "Yeah Ali told her a lot. Stuff about me, Melissa, our family's, Toby, Jenna, her false alarm when she thought she was pregnant."

Hanna: "We have to find Alison and get her to tell us what she knows."

Aria: "How can we find her? We don't even know if she's alive."

Hanna: "I saw her the night of the fire and so did Mona."

Emily: "Yeah well Mona isn't actually the most trustworthy person around."

Hanna: "I saw Alison and so did you Spencer!"

Spencer: speechless.

Hanna: "oh so now I'm the crazy one?"

Spencer: "ok the blonde looked a lot like Alison, so I'm not ruling that out."

Aria: "if only we had Alison's journal then maybe we would have better luck figuring this out."

Spencer: Hey what about Emily's biology notebook. The one with all the notes between Ali and Cece."

Emily: bits lip, "um I turned it into the police."

All three girls: "What!?"

Spencer: "There are things in there that can get us into a lot of trouble."

Aria: "Stuff about my dad's affair."

Spencer: "Fights between me and Alison. There are even things in there that can get Toby in trouble."

Hanna: "Yeah the fact that he took the fault for blinding Jenna, Alison visiting him in juvie, Alison confronting him about being "A", her trying to hook up with him.

Hanna stops and looks at Spencer, who is now glaring at her.

Hanna: "uh sorry Spence my bad. You really don't want to relieve what you already know."

Aria: "Spencer's right Emily, we shouldn't of given that notebook to the police. Knowing that Wilden probably saw it."

Once I heard them mention Alison coming to see me I knew what they were talking about. I could tell that Spencer was pissed about that when her friends brought it up. I don't blame her. Seeing how the girls are now, I feel really bad for saying those things. The only question I have is when did Spencer find out about it? She never said anything to me about it. I'm surprised she never threatened to kill me or something, considering how protective she can be over her friends.

I grab my coffee and head towards the stairs, right when they started getting up. "Hey you." I turn around and see Spencer walking up to me with a smile on her face. Even though she was smiling I could still see anger in her eyes, from her previews conversation. "Hey, I was just heading up stairs," I said. "Funny, I was just coming up to see you," she said. I gestured for her to fallow me, "well you can come up now if you want." She nods and fallows me up the stairs. After I fixed us something to eat we sat on the couch and watched a movie.

Every few seconds I would look over at Spencer and she would be sitting close to me, while watching the movie. I couldn't get that conversation I over heard out of my mind. If she knows about Alison's visit than home come she's never confronted me about it? Maybe she's waiting for me to tell her. Or maybe she's to pissed at me to say anything. I wouldn't blame her if she is pissed. On the other hand I hope she's not to mad at me, because I don't like it when she's mad at me. Maybe she's not mentioning it, because she knows how much I love her.

"You okay?" She asked, breaking me out of my trance. "Yeah why do you ask?" "Because, I've called your name twice and you didn't respond," she noted. "Sorry I'm just really into this movie," I lied. She chuckled," but you were looking at me." I faked a smile and said, "I got distracted by you. I just love you so much and you're so beautiful, I couldn't stop staring." She eyes me curiously and then she takes the remote and turns off the T.V.

She sits up on the couch and faces me. "Ok what's going on?" I sighed and said "it's nothing." "Are you still thinking about the time we were apart? Toby I told you to stop thinking about it and let us move on," she said. "It's not that," I interrupt. "Then what is it?" She asked with full concern. I took a deep breath and said," the truth is when I walked into the Brew, I over heard you and your friends taking and I heard you mention Alison visiting me in juvie." "So that's what's distracting you? A conversation me and my friends had?" She questioned. "It's just... I'm confused if you knew about that then how come you never confronted me about it?" I asked. "Because it's not my secret to tell you it's your secret to tell me," she said. "I just didn't know how to tell you," I admitted. "How about Alison visited me the summer I was arrested?" She replied sarcastically. "I didn't know how you would react," I said. "What did you expect Toby? That I would break up with you or yell at you?" she said. I shrugged, "I don't know maybe."

"Toby," she said while turning to face me more. "How do you think that made me feel to find that out just a couple days after I found out you joined the A-team?" I shrugged, "you probably felt like everything we had was a lie." She nodded "yes I'll admit I did feel like that, but I also felt guilty." I looked up at her as she spoke. "Do you honestly think that I could do something like that and not feel guilty at all? That decision I made was not easy and was defiantly not a win-win situation. Meaning you're screwed if you tell and you're screwed if you don't. You may have been the one to take the blame, but you weren't the one left to carry on the guilt and the never ending reminders of what you did. If anyone's the real loser in that situation it was us."

"I just feel really guilty about what I said. I should of known that keeping something like that would not be easy and knowing that you girls are now being blackmailed, makes me feel even worse," I said. "Don't be sorry," she said. I looked at her with confusion. "You're right we do deserve worse."

I shook my head frantically and take her hands, "no, nobody deserves to go through something like this." "Yeah well in all honestly. I would rather be locked up than having to worry about me or someone I love having a risk of dying everyday, because of some crazy stalker," she said. "I'm sorry I feel really bad and I should have told you. I understand if you hate me now and don't want to be with me anymore," I said.

The next thing I know she hits me with a pillow and shouts, "Toby Cavanaugh, I do not hate you! Encase you haven't noticed I love you and I don't wanna lose you!" "You just hit me with a pillow," I said while rubbing the side of my head. "Yeah so I could knock some sense into you. Do you think I would hit you with a pillow if I hated you?" she questioned. "No you probably would have hit me with something harder like a brick or your physics book," I said. She hits me with the pillow again, "stop that I love you ok so shut up!" "I love you too, but I still feel guilty," I said.

She sighed and threw her hands up in the air "ok what can I do you make you not feel guilty?" "I don't know I feel like you should get me back. Do something to get revenge on me," I said. "Do you want me to hit you with a pillow again?" she asked. "That's not enough. Just do something to get me back. Pick something that will torture me," I begged. She thinks for a minute, "okay, no sex for two weeks." She said and then gets up off the couch. "Wait wait wait no Spencer wait!" I said while following her.

The end

Okay so I wrote this after 4x01. I was disappointed that Spencer and Toby never talked about Alison's visit, so I came up with something. I can't let this go until they actually do talk about it, so I hope everyone liked it. Please review thanks for reading!