"Girls, I called you here because I need your help." Beca began.
"Is this why Stacie locked herself in the bathroom all day?" Emily asked timidly.
"Yes." Beca said sadly.
"What did you do, Shortstack?" Amy asked, getting to her feet quickly.
"I hurt her." Beca admitted. "But I want to make it up to her." She said quickly before anyone could interrupt.
"What did you do?" Emily asked.
"I had sex with her." Beca told them. "While I was with Jesse. I didn't realise what it was doing to her. But I was confused about my feelings and now I know for sure."
"I'm out." Cynthia Rose scoffed, heading for the door.
"Wait." Beca called. Cynthia Rose paused.
"No. Don't you think I've been some bi-curious girl's experiment? It sucks, Beca. And you're just going to go back to Jesse like they all went back to dick, and Stacie's gonna be left heartbroken. I'm not gonna stand by and let you hurt her, and I definitely won't be a part of it." Cynthia Rose said, leaving the house and slamming the front door behind her. The other Bellas looked at the door, as if they were contemplating following her.
"Guys, please. I'm in love with her." Beca admitted. "I broke up with Jesse so I could be with Stacie. And CR's right. I'm not sure what my sexuality is, really. But I love Stacie. I'm in love with her. And I love her in a way I never loved Jesse. I was with him and all I could think of was Stacie and how he wasn't anything like her. And I hated it. I hated being there with him because I knew I could be with her and I had chosen to be with him. And now I want to make it right. I broke up with Jesse, and told him about how I felt about Stacie and that I wanted to be with Stacie. And now I have to fix things with Stacie. Please help me." Beca's voice broke on the last few words, and the Bellas saw tears in her eyes.
"But what if CR's right? How do we know you won't go back to Jesse, or men in general once you decide you're done with Stacie?"
"Because I think of you guys as my family, so I am standing here in front of my family and telling you honestly that I am in love with Stacie. I have never felt this way about anyone before and I might never feel this way again. I can't lose her. I won't lose her."
"She's telling the truth." Chloe said from the foot of the stairs. "Guys, I know Beca. She's telling the truth. And Stacie feels the same. I think."
"You think?" Beca asked, brokenly.
"I know." Chloe said firmly. "I know she feels the same as you, Beca. She just needs proof."
"Proof?"
"Assurance. She needs a gesture. She needs to know you're serious about her."
"So are you?" Fat Amy asked Beca. "Serious?"
"As a heart attack." Beca replied.
The Bellas all looked at each other, and Beca panicked slightly at the silent conversation. Finally they smiled. "Hands in." Amy called. Beca grinned and placed her hand in the middle. "On 3!"