In the evening, Dean sat on his couch drinking his thoughts away. No matter what he did, he couldn't stop thinking about Cas. There was nothing that could mend his broken heart.
Charlie sat next to her best friend and asks, "Are you okay?" She was worried about him since he was drinking too many beers.
He nods his head. "No, Charlie, I'm not. This is like my sixth drink and I'm still not dead yet."
"Hey, don't worry, Dean. It'll be alright. You fought for him. You did everything for him." She couldn't find the words to cheer him up.
"Well I fought a bald human torch, a stuck-up brit brat, a crazy bitch, a cocky vegan, the Wonder Twins, and I haven't even faced Lucifer yet. This wasn't supposed to end like this." All of a sudden, Dean's phone rings. He grabs it and answers, "Hello?"
"Dean Winchester, have you healed from your so-called broken heart yet?" A voice asked him. Dean knew exactly who it was.
"What do you want now, Lucifer?" He rolled his eyes.
"Look, man, I want to check up on you and see how you're doing. Honestly, I felt bad after what happened with Castiel and all."
Dean takes a deep breath. "Is he with you?" He asked him.
"Yes, yes, he is. Poor little thing. I found him crying once I took him back to my home. Ever since he dumped you, he hasn't really been the same." His tone of voice was mockery. How dare he toy with Castiel's feelings? "So, Dean, I'm opening the Chaos Theatre tonight. The Free for Alls are playing and I was wondering if you wanted to stop by or whatever. I will be there…so will Castiel."
The more he kept talking the more it made Dean angry. "What are you going to do to him?" Dean demanded.
"Nothing much. I figured that you would come just to save him, but you know very well that you can never save him from this. He's weak and he can't fight us. This is a league game, Dean. Once I'm done with you, I'm gonna make sure that he wishes that he never left me in the first place. So you better get your ass over here in forty-five minutes or else the first thing I'm gonna cut off is his tongue so you won't hear him scream. Bye."
Once he hung up on Dean, Charlie tells him, "Forget what I said. Finish him."
Dean quickly gets dressed and hops into his car. He drives to the Chaos Theatre and parks in the parking lot. In front of the door was a guy lighting his cigarette. "Password," he says.
"Whatever," Dean groans.
"Go in." He nods.
The door opens and Dean walks into an empty hallway. At the end of the hall was two guys in front of an elevator. "Second password," one of them says.
"Fuck you," Dean guesses.
Then, the let him into the elevator. Dean anxiously waits as the elevator goes to the seventh floor. Finally, the elevator doors open.
Dean had never seen a club this huge. The ceiling was about a hundred feet above his head and the room was the size of a basketball court. It includes two mini pyramids and Team Free Will was playing on one of them.
Once they saw Dean, they stopped playing. "Dean, let it go," Chuck warns him. "Don't give him the satisfaction."
"What if I want the satisfaction?" Dean pointed out to them.
"Dean Winchester!" Lucifer called out his name. He was sitting on top of the other pyramid with Castiel next to him. "Hey, buddy, you are right on time! Could one of you ladies get this young man a Shirley Temple?"
One of the servers came up to Dean with a Shirley Temple on a tray. Dean angrily flips it out of her hand and growls at Lucifer, "I'm not here to drink. I'm here to get Cas."
"Oh, why so angry?" Lucifer mocks his innocence. "I got no beef with you."
"Well I got beef with you! If you don't let Cas go right now, I'll destroy you!" He warns him.
Lucifer stands up and brushes his fingers through Cas's black hair. "I didn't choose this. Castiel made his choice and I think you need to learn how to deal with it."
Seeing him near his Castiel made Dean's stomach twisted into a knot. "I don't care if I don't get him back or not. All I care about is protecting him from you."
"You want to fight me…for him?" Lucifer calmly asked.
"Was that not clear?" Dean asked.
During a moment of silence, Lucifer took a step away from Cas and glares at Dean. "Now why the hell would you wanna do that?" He asked.
"Because I am in love with him!" Dean admits. A flow of happiness grew inside of Cas once he heard that.
Out of the blue, a ninja sword appears lodged in Dean's chest. Even though it scared him, he yanks it out and holds it with two hands.
Lucifer grins. "I think this needs some music. Joanna!" He yells at Jo.
Jo mumbles into the microphone, "We are Team Free Will. We are here to sell out and make money and stuff. One, two, three, four!" The band started playing the music.
Suddenly, seven guys from all different directions charge towards Dean. The first thing he does is duck once they came at him. Everybody at the party screams and runs. Garth, Jo, and Chuck watch Dean in amazement as they keep playing.
Dean finally kills one of them by slicing them with his sword. One by one he swatted them with his sword and they disintegrated into piles of coins.
Once he was done with them, Dean looks up at Lucifer. "Is that all you got, Lucy?" He hollered.
"Welcome to the last level, bitch!" Lucifer cackles. He slides a sword out of his sleeve and holds it up.
Both men charge towards each other leaping into the air. The first one to swing his sword was Lucifer. Dean tried to block himself, but the villain was too strong and smashes Dean's sword into a thousand pieces. Dean collapses on the stairs along with the pieces of his broken sword. Team Free Will stops playing and watch intensely.
Lucifer elegantly lands on his feet and chuckles, "You wanna know the reasons why I started this: pride, lust, greed, gluttony, sloth, envy, and mostly…anger. That's right, man, I am angry. I work everyday and I was only trying to give my boyfriend the perfect life, but no, he leaves me for a tool like you. At least I would never leave him for anybody else."
"The only tool here is you," Dean groans as he weakly stands up. "If you did love him, then he wouldn't have left you. Cas is everything good in the fucked-up world and he deserves way better than you."
Cas stays where he is and watches them both. "He has his own life," Lucifer informs him. "You don't tell him what's best for him. Now I think it's time to pay a little visit…into hell!" He lifts up his sword above his head.
Before anything could happen, a female voice screams, "DEAN!" Lucifer turns around and a foot kicks him in the shoulder causing him to drop his sword.
The person falls on the stairs and gets back up on their feet. It turns out to be Becky wearing all black and has two ninja swords in both of her hands. "Becky?" Dean says her name.
Lucifer bursts out laughing, "This is so hilarious! Your ex-girlfriend is here to save you! That's so adorable!"
Becky angrily yells, "You'll pay for what you did to him!"
"Listen, Shortcake, your ex-boyfriend knew what he was going up against." Lucifer explains. "Everybody warned him about what happens when you date Castiel. Did he listen? No, he just—"
She cuts him off. "I'm not talking to you! I'm talking to him!" Becky points her sword at Cas.
"What?" Cas asked, confused by Becky's revenge.
"Get ready to have your fat ass kicked!" She growls as she leaps into the air.
In a quick moment, Cas grabbed long, skinny stand next to Lucifer's throne and shields himself from Becky. "You're kidding, right?" He asks her. She wouldn't answer him. Instead, Becky swings her sword at him only to have it blocked with a stand.
After a few moments of watching, Lucifer swings his arm at Dean. Luckily, he catches it and kicks him in the stomach. They continuously hit and kicked each other in anger.
During that, Becky and Cas battled it out on the top of the pyramid. "What the hell is your problem?!" Cas demanded from her.
He attempted to stab her, but Becky blocks them and pushes the top to the floor. "You stole Dean from me, you fat ass!" She cries out.
Castiel pulls the stand away and they kept swinging at each other. "I didn't steal Dean! I didn't steal anybody!"
"Liar!" Becky hollers. "You lair! Liar!"
As he fights Lucifer, Dean could hear the arguing between Castiel and Becky. Soon he realized that Becky was blaming Cas for the breakup. He had to stop them.
Lucifer swings both of his arms at Dean, but he manages to block them. Then, he slams his forehead against his and kicked him in the chest. Lucifer goes flying back off of the mini pyramid and onto the floor.
After that, Dean runs up to stop Becky and Cas. He comes in between them before they could kill each other. "Stop it!" He yells at them. "Enough! Cut it out!" Both of them had stopped and looked at Dean. "Nobody stole anybody. Becky, I cheated on you with Cas. I wasn't planning on it. It's just that I met him and I completely forgot about you."
Becky's eyes widen and she gasps, "You cheated on me, Dean? You cheated on both of us?!"
"How could you cheat on me?" Castiel asked him.
Dean looks at them. "Cas, I couldn't help myself around you. And I'm sorry for hurting you both."
All of a sudden, a sword is plunged through Dean's back and out of his chest. The person holding the sword was Lucifer, who was grinning as he twisted the sword. Garth and Chuck's jaws drop, and Jo covers her mouth with her hand in shocked. Becky gasps in horror and Castiel breathlessly screams, "NOOOO!"
With his last breath, Dean chokes, "I'll see you…in hell."
"Tell them Lucifer sent you," he murmurs. At last, he lets go of the sword. Dean falls like a puppet with its strings cut off. Cas rushes to his side and cradled Dean's body in his arms. He caresses his face and lets out a whimper as Dean's eyes roll to the back of his head. "Oh, Dean, you can cheat on whoever, but you can't cheat death." Lucifer cackles.