Italics indicate thinking

Lucy's POV

We had a big party since Lisanna was back. I had fun till Natsu punched me in the face. When I final made it back home I wasted no time getting into bed and getting some sleep.

I couldn't help think about Lisanna while I was trying to get to sleep.

Mira may be the model, but Lisanna could be one to. Mira's the sexy one. Lisanna is cute. She defiantly has the whole little sister thing going for her.

Now I had thought about maybe getting Mira to help me bring Lisanna back here but she had just come home after being gone for years so I thought it was best to wait.

Somehow when we got back Juvia's hair was back to curls. How she grew it so fast don't ask me, but she did still have on the clothes I had picked out. Not much else had changed, Ever had let her hair down instead of having it tied up.

Evergreen…She's cute, kind of bitchy though.

The next day at the guild I was sitting around with Erza and Juvia talking about random stuff. I was keeping Juvia close and running my hand over her thigh and back making her shiver and pant in her seat.

"Lucy-Sama…"

One of the people I had been thinking about last night walked up to us.

"Hello Evergreen."

The brown haired woman walked up to my table and asked to talk to me. I followed her outside into the forest.

"What's up?"

"What did you do to Juvia?" she asked.

"What are you talking about?" I asked.

"I heard her talking to you in her room the other night and now she's acting strange, changing the way she dresses and hanging around you. What did you do to her?"

She's catching on…what do I do? Should I come clean and tell her I made Juvia into my lapdog or do I make up and excuse?

"Umm…I"

"You know it seems like a lot of the girls from the guild have been acting strange around you. Cana, Erza, Mira even Levy…I want answers Lucy."

Shit! Shit! Shit!

"Now!"

"Uhh…" I just stood there shaking.

Ever pressed me up against the tree, her breasts pressing into mine. Her hand shot down and grabbed my crotch.

"I thought so…just what are you?"

How does she know?

She flipped my skirt up and looked at me.

"What the hell…"

I pushed my skirt back down "Don't do that. What if someone was watching?"

"It all makes sense now; all those girls are your harem."

"What no!" I said "They never said that! I may have had sex with them but they're not my harem."

Although that would be awesome.

"So you did!"

"Uhh…well you see." I looked down and saw right into Ever's deep cleavage.

Come on not now…

I accidently let out a verbal groan and Ever realized what I was doing and backed away.

"Ewww!"

"Sorry…" I mumbled "you just…well yeah…"

"You used that thing and turned them all into your slaves!"

"They are not my slaves." I told her "Well Juvia kinda is." I mumbled after.

"I can't believe they could all be seduced by a freak like you!"

A freak…

I walked closer "None of the other girls called me a freak. I recall them telling me how much they loved me."

I pinned Evergreen against a tree.

"I broke Erza and Mira. Hell I even broke a member of the Oracion Sies. Don't think I can't break you Evergreen."

"What are you…?"

"You said I had a harem right. You know so much I think you'll make an excellent addition."

Ever tried to get her glasses off and I kept her hands down.

"Where's the fun if you do that?"

"Lucy…just let me go and I won't tell anybody. You can do whatever you want to the other girls."

"I don't think so. Virgo!"

"Yes Mistress?"

"Blindfold her."

"Of course." Virgo wrapped a cloth around Ever's eyes "Will that be all?"

"Yes thank you. Stop by tonight for a reward."

"Thank you Mistress."

"Even your spirits, you're sick!" Ever said

"Just relax Ever." I said sliding her coat off "I'll make you feel good."

I have to break her; I can't risk her telling people.

I kissed her neck "Don't bother trying, that Blindfold won't come off."

"You bitch!"

"You smell delicious."

I squeezed one of Ever's large breasts.

"Ha!"

"See you like it." I cooed.

"No I don't. Let me go."

I felt her nails digging into my back.

"Keep struggling and I'll make Virgo come and tie your hands. I was nice enough to let you have them. So just sit here and enjoy it."

I pulled Ever's dress off and got naked as well.

"You look great." I told her "Shame you can't see my body. I think you'd like it. But I can't trust you to not turn me to stone so too bad…"

"I can't believe this!"

I moved Ever to her knees and moved my cock closer to her mouth.

"Say Ahh."

Ever kept her mouth clamped shut.

"Come on it'll be over faster if you just comply. I don't want to force you."

"Force me what do you call this?!" While Ever's mouth was open I shoved myself in.

"MPHM!"

"You don't have to see to know what that it right."

I moved Ever's head back and forth forcing her to blow me.

"So have you come around yet?" I said sliding out of her mouth.

"Fuck you…" She spat.

"You're worse than Angel was, you'll take a lot of work." I smirked "I'm gonna enjoy this."

I pushed Ever's breast around my cock and started thrusting into her cleavage.

"Hey! What are you doing?! Stop that!"

"You have such nice breasts. I feel like I'm between two big marshmallows." I told her.

"No Stop it!"

"I'm gonna cum Ever. I'm gonna cover you face!"

"Don't you dare!"

"HAA!" I blew my load and covered Ever's face in jizz.

"AAHHHHH!" the woman let out a high pitch scream.

I shoved my dick in her mouth "Keep your mouth shut you bitch. I don't need the whole guild back here."

I pulled out of her mouth and dragged her deeper into the forest. I put her down in a small field in the forest.

"How's it feel to be covered?" I asked her.

"Screw you. When I get out of here I'll tell the council and Master and everybody."

"I think I'll change your mind." I said sliding into her.

"AHH!"

"Nice and tight." I smiled "Just how I like it."

"No! Get out of there!"

I thrusted into Ever a few times.

"Stop it!"

"You so tight Ever." I said "My big cock barely fits."

"Help!"

"No one's coming to help you." I told her "Just give in and become mine."

"Let me go!"

"Better hurry up Ever I'm getting close. If you don't want me to cum inside you you'll have to ask."

"Don't you dare do that inside me!"

"Then just give in and I'll pull out. I always give my girls what they want."

A strained look crossed her face.

"Just say one sentence. 'I'm yours Lucy' that's all it takes."

"Ahhh!" I felt Ever's pussy clencth in climax.

"Hurry up I'm almost there."

"No get out!"

"Say it then!"

"P…Please Lucy pull out! If you do I'll be yours forever!"

"That's it!" I smiled.

She's been broken.

I pulled out and came all over Ever's stomach.

"Lucy~ it's so warm…"

I untied Ever's blindfold. She stood up and kissed me.

"Thank you."

"For what?" I asked.

"Showing me what I was missing out on."

"It was my pleasure." I said as she stroked my cock.

Ever laid back and spread her legs.

"Again?" she asked.

"We're not even close to finished." I told her as I entered her "Look me in the eyes this time. I want you to see the face of your lover."

"I wouldn't have it any other way." She smiled as I thrust into her.

"We can't stay out here to long someone might come looking." I informed.

"You said no one was coming." She pouted.

"We can always go back to my apartment after this." I smiled "No one will bother us there. The other girls know better than to interrupt me when I'm with someone else."

"Who…Ah!...Who else is in this little harem you have? AH!" Ever moaned out her question.

"You, Cana, Erza, Mira, Levy, Sherry from Lamia Scale, Aries & Virgo. Juvia too but she's my special plaything."

"A sizable group. HAAA!" She said as she climaxed.

"I'm close Ever."

"You can stay inside it's safe." She said "I just panicked earlier.

"EVER!"

"Oh! Lucy!"

I jizzed inside Ever's tight pussy.

"One more time?" she asked rubbing my breasts.

"Give me a sec to get hard again."

Normally I'm quick but I still need a few seconds.

"I'll take care of that." She said as her eyes glowed.

Instantly I was rock hard again.

"Stone eyes are good for a lot of things." She explained.

Ever hopped up and wrapped her hand around my neck and her legs around my waist.

I groaned at the sudden shift in weight.

It's way heavier than it was when I did this position with Levy.

Ever started bouncing up and down as I held her up. Our hips made load smacking noises as she hopped.

"Mmmmm…So big." Ever moaned

"It feels so good Ever!" I moaned "You're so tight. The shift in weight every time you move feels so good!"

"Fuck Lucy! I want more!"

"I can't fit anymore in!" I told her "Your pussy is just too small for my big dick!"

"Ahh! Please more cock!"

I pushed a little harder and managed to squeeze more meat into Ever.

"OH YES!"

"Shit Ever!"

"Ha…Ha…Ha!" Ever moaned "I'm so close Lucy!"

"Me too!" I warned "Cum with me Ever."

I felt myself start cumming.

"EVER!"

"LUCY!"

I pulled out of Ever and she slumped to the ground.

"I can't believe I tired resisting."

I saw that the sun was setting.

"Get dressed so we can go back to my apartment, it's gonna be a long night."

AN

Thank you for reading. Feedback is appreciated. Feel free to message me any questions or concerns.

As always suggest who you want to see next.

Next Chapter Hint- Hey Little Sister (Insert Hook from White Wedding)

Till Next Time