"And now... Which will it be?" Captain Hook asked his hostages after they got over the 'loss' of Atticus and Peter. "The pen... Or the plank!?"
"Captain Hook, we will never join your crew." Wendy said with a deep scowl.
"And I would rather die than be in your crew." Cherry glared at the evil captain.
"Suit yourself." Captain Hook glared in her face.
Cherry in return spit in his eye.
"Bad choice, my dear." Captain Hook said.
Cherry lowly growled.
"You and Wendy are going to be the first ones to walk on the plank." Captain Hook told her.
Cherry and Wendy nodded, then came to the group of the others.
"Goodbye, boys." Wendy told her brothers.
"Oh, Wendy, we'll miss you." Michael frowned.
"It was really nice meeting you." Pat sniffled.
Chris hugged Wendy and then Cherry as goodbyes.
"Be strong, John." Wendy told him.
"I shall strive to, Wendy." John promised his sister.
"Goodbye..." Michael started to cry.
"Come on you brats, let's get this over with!" Muscles glared.
The other pirates roared and growled, forcing Cherry and Wendy to get on with it. This looked like it could be the end of both of them. The two girls climbed up on the plank, looking down to their future watery grave. Cherry bore a grim expression while Wendy let a tear roll down her cheek. The both of them, thinking this was the end, took one last step and fell off the plank, heading into the ocean.
"Wendy! Cherry!" Michael cried.
The two then dropped down. Captain Hook grinned eagerly, but then instantly frowned as something was missing: The splash of death.
"N-N-No splash, Captain." Smee said, scared after not seeing a ripple in the ocean.
"Not a sound." Hook added.
Smee pointed into the water. "Not a bloomin' ripple!"
"It's a jinx, that's what it is." another pirate added in.
Unknown to any of them; Atticus, Peter, and Tinkerbell had survived the blast and had saved Cherry and Wendy. Peter carried Wendy while Atticus carried Cherry, they stayed quiet and hidden for now. Even if it was funny for the pirates to believe that the ocean could be jinxed. The Lost Boys, Darling brothers, Chris and Pat just stood in stunned silence and confusion.
"No splash, Captain." another pirate said.
"So... You want a splash, Mr. Starsky?" Captain Hook smirked to him, then grabbed him and threw him into the water. "THERE'S YOUR SPLASH! Who's next!?"
"You're next, Hook!" two voices called to the pirate captain.
"Those voices." Chris smiled.
"It can't be..." Pat added, surprised, but happy, she had to be imagining or hearing things though.
Captain Hook and Smee were spooked, they saw Atticus and Peter were alive and well.
"Say your prayers, Hook!" Peter drew out his sword.
"Yeah, because it'll probably be the last one you'll ever make!" Atticus added.
The others cheered to see Peter and Atticus.
"And the girls!" Michael smiled once he saw his older sister and cousin were okay.
"They're blooming ghosts, Captain." Smee said, scared.
"We assure you, these two ghosts are going to feel pain!" Muscles told him.
"I'll show you the ghosts have blood in their veins!" Captain Hook snarled. "I'll run 'em right through!"
"Come on, Atticus, this is not a drill!" Peter told his new ally.
"I know and I'm ready to fight." Atticus said.
"Captain, I shall fight by your side so then we can get rid of these brats for good." Muscles said.
"I'd like nothing more of it." Captain Hook agreed.
"Perfect." Muscles said.
It was now a fair fight, two-against-two. Peter and Atticus nodded to each other and got ready.
"I've been waiting for this." Muscles glared at Peter Pan.
Captain Hook drew his sword as it was a pirate attack between good against evil. The two boys were now about to fight them and Peter was going to be surprised with how strong Muscles was. Peter was tormenting Hook like he usually does. The others watched the fight in suspense and worry, especially when Muscles grabbed one of the cannons.
"What in the world?" Peter reacted in shock to that.
"Captain, permission to destroy these two?" Muscles asked.
"Permission granted." Captain Hook growled.
Muscles grinned evilly as he now used the cannon at his own club against the two boys. This actually looked like a fatal end for Atticus and Peter. Captain Hook was liking this very much as Muscles was hitting the boys with the cannon like a club.
"Batter up!" Muscles called out before hitting the two like baseballs, sending them flying into the front of the ship.
Wendy was horrified and worried. "We have to help them and get away!"
"But how?" Cherry asked.
"Hmm..." John tried to think, being the logical one of all of them now since Atticus and Peter were fighting.
Muscles came over to the two boys as did Captain Hook as the muscular pirate lifted up the two boys like they were nothing, but then he felt half of his strength gone.
"I'm sorry, Peter..." Atticus said. "I feel like I'm no match for this guy..."
The pirates went after the Lost Boys, the Darling siblings, Cherry, Chris, Pat, and Nana. Nana snarled and jumped in front of the pirates, barking like a mad dog since they were threatening the children she looked after back at home. This caused the pirates to laugh, thinking that she couldn't hurt them. Nana growled and went after one pirate and bit him firmly on his backside. This made the pirate yell out in pain.
"You mess with my children, you mess with me!" Nana snarled.
"Yeah, go Nana!" Michael cheered.
One pirate got Nana off and threw her down on the board. Nana growled and kept lunging after the pirates.
"Come on, while they're distracted!" Cherry said, running off the other way on deck.
The crocodile came into the water, waiting for Captain Hook to possibly fall into the water so he could eat. Atticus and Peter began to fight back as they now realized that Muscles somehow lost half of his strength, Atticus fought him while Peter fought Captain Hook.
"Let's try this again." Peter said with a smirk.
"You got it." Atticus agreed.
Captain Hook and Muscle weren't going to give up though, this madness in Never Land had to end now. And where it would end with two of the four of them victorious while the other two were defeated.
"Hold your fire..." John said as he grouped with the Lost Boys, Chris, Pat, and Cherry as the pirates were climbing after them. "Steady men... Steady... FIRE!"
The Lost Boys then used their weapons against the pirates. One pirate came up and was trying to slice John, but Tinkerbell helped him dodge each blade strike. And where it was annoying the pirate as he was trying to kill John. Michael hit the pirate on his head with his teddy bear which actually made a painful clanging noise.
"Michael, what is your teddy bear made of?" Chris asked.
"I put a cannon ball inside him." Michael explained.
"That makes sense and that's really smart." Pat said then.
Michael smiled bashfully.
"How do you think it's going for Atticus and Peter?" Chris asked.
"I'm sure they got it," Cherry said before one pirate grabbed her and pulled her down. "LET GO!"
The pirate laughed at her. Michael used his teddy bear as a weapon again as he hit the pirate on the head. The pirate let go of Cherry. Cherry nearly fell, but she grabbed onto the rope and did her best to climb after the others.
Peter kept tormenting Captain Hook like he usually did. Atticus continued to fight off Muscles like a boxer.
"Get that brat!" Captain Hook told Muscle.
"Aye-Aye, Captain!" Muscles saluted before began to fight like a boxer against Atticus.
Atticus dodged every chance he got, but this guy was a lot stronger than he had hoped for. But he was able to hold on in the fight as it seemed as this guy was now easy to fight.
"I don't know where you came from, but you're gonna wish you were there with your mommy." Muscles mocked Atticus.
This didn't faze Atticus as he just continued to fight him. The others were able to make the pirates throw themselves overboard. The only ones left now where just Captain Hook and Peter along with Muscles and Atticus.
"This is it..." Cherry whispered as she stayed close to the Lost Boys, Nana, and her cousins.
"We just have to pray that Atticus and Peter will win." Pat whispered.
Cherry said nothing about mentioning pray, but she rolled her eyes on the inside.
"I still don't know if I'm ready to grow up." Cubby pouted.
"Maybe when we take them back to home when Peter and Atticus win, we'll stay here." the rabbit agreed.
"Uh-huh." the raccoon twins agreed.
"I'm still going back home." Chris said.
"Suit yourselves." the Lost Boys told their 'Lost Girls'.
The Lost Boys then hugged Chris and Pat, going to miss them very much.
"We'll miss you boys too." Pat said.
The fox wiped his eye with his tail as he seemed to cry.
They would all say their goodbyes after they knew Peter and Atticus would defeat Captain Hook and Muscles the pirate. And where it seemed as though the two of them were going to win against the two pirates pretty easily. The crocodile was eagerly and anxiously waiting for his dinner.
"Come on Captain Hook and Muscles, you two are making this too easy." Atticus smirked.
"I've had just about enough of your childish games!" Captain Hook sneered.
"Same here!" Muscles included.
Tinkerbell looked worried for Peter at some points.
"Captain, I have a brilliant idea." Muscles whispered before he began to whisper his whole plan to the evil captain.
"Time out!" Captain Hook called before leaning in to listen to Muscle's secret plan.
Atticus and Peter just smugly smirked as they knew they could already win this one. Once Captain hook heard Muscles' entire plan, he smiled evilly, liking this plan.
"I don't like that look in his eye..." Atticus whispered.
"Ah, come on, what's the worst that could happen?" Peter scoffed.
"You're right." Atticus shrugged.
"We could fight you two with one hand tied behind our backs!" Peter glared to the two pirates.
"Yeah!" Atticus included.
"Oh, Atticus, why do you have to be so foolish?" Cherry groaned to her best friend's determination.
"Is he always like this?" Wendy asked.
"You have no idea..." Cherry sighed as Atticus went to help Peter against Captain Hook once and for all, though she was sure this would not be the last she would hear of Never Land.
"You boys are cowards." Muscles said.
"We'll show you cowards, codfish bait!" Atticus sneered bravely.
"Then how's about you two fight us without flying?" Muscles smirked.
This made the others worried.
"Very well." Peter gave in then about the no flying deal.
Captain Hook and Muscles then battled against Peter and Atticus to be done with them for good and they had promised not to fly which seemed like a dumb move. Atticus looked like he was having a bit difficulty. Muscles laughed darkly to Atticus.
"I won't let you win!" Atticus glared. "Good always triumphs over evil!"
"We'll see about that, kid." Muscles smirked as he grabbed Atticus's wrist and was about to throw him off.
Atticus's eyes widened slightly at that. Captain Hook managed to get Peter on the ground and chucked away his sword. It looked like doomsday for both Atticus and Peter.
'Atticus, Peter, be careful.' Wendy thought to herself.
Cherry grabbed on her bandanna in slight worry for Atticus and Peter's safety. Muscles soon began to spin Atticus around above him like a lasso.
"Whooooa!" Atticus yelped as he spun around and cupped his mouth.
"Fly, guys, fly!" Cherry urged.
"No, we gave our word!" Peter replied firmly.
Muscles soon sent Atticus flying towards Peter.
"Whoa!" Atticus yelped.
The crocodile swam through the waters and smirked to Captain Hook, wanting for him to fall so he could eat the evil captain at last. Atticus and Peter collided with each other. Peter nearly toppled from Atticus's pressure.
"Excellent work." Captain Hook smirked.
"Sure, Boss." Muscles smirked back.
"Peter, we're gonna lose!" Atticus sounded horrified.
"No we're not, if you could give me a boost, I can jump up and grab the flag and we can use it on Captain Hook and Muscles." Peter whispered to him.
"You sure?" Atticus asked.
"I'm always sure." Peter firmly promised.
"Alright then." Atticus said.
"Now!" Peter called.
Atticus then helped Peter up as promised and agreed upon while everyone else watched. The crocodile looked rather impatient and hungry for Captain Hook, but he did wait. And where Peter soon got the flag and used it to trap Hook and Muscles and took their swords so he and Atticus could use them as their defense.
"You're ours, Hook!" Atticus and Peter glared as they had turned the tables while keeping true to their word with the fiendish pirates.
This made everyone cheer.
"Cleave him to the brisket!" Michael cheered as Wendy then hugged him.
"Now, boys, why don't you just put those swords down?" Muscles smiled nervously.
"You wouldn't do old Hook in, would you, lads?" Hook looked very anxious himself. "We'll go away forever... We'll do anything you say!"
"Well, alright..." Peter said before smirking to his old enemy. "If you... Say you're a codfish!"
"Yeah and same with you, Muscles." Atticus smiled.
Captain Hook gulped nervously. "I'm a codfish."
"LOUDER AND BOTH OF YOU!" Atticus pointed the sword firmly to them.
"WE'RE CODFISH!" Hook and Muscles yelled out then.
This caused for Wendy, Cherry, Michael, John, and the Lost Boys and Girls to cheer. Even the crocodile was enjoying this.
"Alright, boys, you're free to go and never return!" Peter said before chucking away Hook's sword and did his infamous rooster call out of victory.
Hook then grinned darkly as he was going to kill the boy with his hook instead of his sword this time.
"GUYS!" Cherry gaped.
Muscles was about to grab Atticus into a bear hug. Atticus and Peter smirked and dodged them as if they knew that was going to happen. And where Captain Hook and Muscles soon fell overboard.
"Bye-Bye, bad guys." Cherry waved.
Captain Hook, Muscles, and Smee soon rowed as fast as they could from Tick Tock as it began to chase them. Captain Hook cried out for Smee as the crocodile's wishes had finally been fulfilled.
"We'll get you for this, you brats!" Muscles called out.
"In your dreams!" Atticus called with a laugh.
"Something tells me this won't be the last of them." Cherry shrugged.
The pirates escaped as the crocodile tormented Captain Hook and Muscles as they left Never Land, perhaps and hopefully, forever.