Italics indicate thinking.

Lucy's POV

When I woke up I was surprised to find my bed was empty. I was sure I had brought Evergreen back here last night. I was naked and I only sleep naked when I fall asleep after sex.

I thought Virgo came by to?

"You like that don't you, you skank."

Ever?

"Please punish me more Mistress Evergreen."

Virgo?

I opened my eyes and saw Virgo on the floor being groped by Evergreen.

That's right! Virgo came by for her reward and it turns out her and Ever have similar tastes.

"Did I tell you, you could speak? Lick don't talk."

"Yes Mistress."

"I said no talking worm."

Ever was lying back with her legs spread and Virgo licking her pussy.

"You to look like you're having fun." I said.

"Princess!"

"Lucy!"

I walked up and wasted no time penetrating Virgo.

"HA!"

"It's rude to start without me. You've upset your Mistress Virgo."

"Please punish me for my unfaithfulness!"

I thrust my hips into Virgo again and again.

"Ohh~!"

"Lick more." Ever cooed squeezing her own breasts.

"Virgo you've been alive for centuries how are you still so tight?" I said forcing my big cock deeper.

"I can change to fit my master's needs, AHHH! You like tight girls so that's what I made myself! Would you like me to change more, Larger breasts or longer hair? You can pick how I look. AHH! I'M CUMMING!"

"Did Lucy say you could cum?"

"I'm sorry! Punish me more!"

"You're fine the way you are Virgo I'd tell you if I wanted you to change."

Virgo kept eating Ever while I pounded her from behind.

"VIRGO!" I came inside Virgo and the spirit stopped licking Ever.

"Thank you…"

I pulled out of Virgo and got cleaned up.

"Virgo you need to be punished for cumming to early." I told her "You can spend the day being Ever's plaything."

"Yes Mistress."

Ever took Virgo back to the girl's dorm to 'train' her.

I was sitting in the guild talking with Mira when Lisanna came up to me. The three of us talked for a while but Lisanna seemed awkward the entire time.

"It's getting late I'm going home." I told them.

I arrived back at my apartment and got ready for bed when there was a knock at my door.

"Lisanna?"

"Hi."

"You need something?" I said.

"We need to talk about something." She said.

I took a seat and the white haired girl played with her fingers.

"Um…I was hoping we could be friends."

"Of course we're already friends." I told her.

"I was pretty good friends with Edolas Lucy."

"Well I'm sure we can be good friends to."

She shook her head "I should be more specific. I was more than just Edo-Lucy's friend."

I looked at the girl confused.

"I was her lover."

"Uhh…"

"Lucy…are you like her? Do you have a penis to?"

I looked at the short haired girl and blushed "Yes."

"Oh good." She let out a breath.

"Huh?"

"I was worried I wouldn't be able to get any relief here." She turned around and shook her butt in front of me "I'm ready whenever you are."

"Lisanna what are you!" The girl kissed me.

"I was one of Edo-Lucy's favorites." She said "Let me show you why she liked me so much."

"Lisanna we…" I tried to speak but she kept kissing.

"Please I'm quivering over here."

She lifted my tee-shirt and freed my breasts.

"They're just as big."

She flicked her tongue over my nipple making me gasp. I pushed her head harder against my breasts making her moan.

"So tasty." She said before standing up and getting undressed.

Lisanna got on all fours and shook her butt at me "Come on…"

I walked up and went to enter her.

"No not that." She said "Spank me."

"What?!"

"Edo-Lucy used to knock me around when we did it. Please spank me, spit at me, do nasty things to me."

"Lisanna I'm not into that." I told her.

"One slap, choke me out, come on do something!"

"Lisanna I…"

Lisanna took my hand and rubbed it over her butt.

"I need this." She said "My little booty needs to be all red."

I cringed, pulled my hand back and spanked her.

"Oh Yes! More! Give me another!"

I cringed and did it again.

"Again! Spank me more!"

She's sick!

Every time I slapped her butt it jiggled around and she asked for more.

"Lisanna I think that's enough."

"One more please. I need to feel the sting!"

Her ass had gone from pale white to beat red over the last few minutes. She kept begging and despite my better judgment gave her one more.

"AHHH! YESSS!"

Did she just orgasm from a spanking?

I moved back on the bed and Lisanna laid down on her stomach and I moved myself towards her entrance.

"Put that big cock in me." She said "Stretch me out. Make it hard to walk."

She's a total masochist!

I pushed into Lisanna and she groaned.

"Mmmmm Fuck it's so big!"

"You're awfully tight." I told her.

"Edo-Lucy rarely went for where you are. She preferred to punish my butt more."

I smashed into Lisanna and she moaned with every thrust.

"Hit me!"

"No."

"Please Lucy! Hit me!"

"I don't want to hurt you."

"It's fine I love it! It makes me feel good! Beat me!"

I cringed and grabbed her hair while I fucked her.

"YES! Pull harder!"

I pulled back and moved so Lisanna so she was on top. She rolled her hips and moaned.

"Pull my arms back! Twist me like a pretzel!"

"Lisanna stop I'm not doing that."

"Uhh! Fine just fuck me!"

There was a creaking noise and I looked over and saw my front door open.

I didn't lock it!

Lisanna quickly got off my cock and covered herself with a sheet "Mira!"

"What are you two doing?" Mira asked.

"Mira this isn't what it looks like" Lisanna pleaded.

I just blushed when Mira looked at me.

"No I mean why did you stop." She said.

"Huh?"

"Don't mind me keep going I'll be in the kitchen if you need something."

Mira walked off into the kitchen. Lisanna moved and went to get off the bed.

"Where are you going?"

"I think it's best for me to go." She said.

I pulled her back to the bed and went right back inside her.

"She said to keep going so were gonna keep going." I told her.

"Lucy!"

"That's it moan so your sister can hear you being fucked."

"OH!"

The bed creaked and groaned with every one of my thrust.

"Pull my hair! Please!" Lisanna yelled.

I sighed, grabbed a handful of her white locks and tugged.

"HAA!"

"Mmmmm." I looked over and saw Mira sitting on the couch fingering herself while watching Lisanna and I have sex.

That's so hot!

I kept fucking Lisanna while she asked me to hit her more and more. I kept denying her request because I found it wrong.

I don't want to hurt her. Virgo likes to be punished but not like this.

"OHH! LUCY!"

I felt Lisanna's walls tighten as she climaxed and sent me over the edge.

"LISANNA!"

I ejaculated inside Lisanna and after a few second I fell out of her.

"So good!" Lisanna rolled over "Will you hurt me now?"

"No Lisanna!" I told her.

"You're a naughty girl Lisanna" A naked Mira said walking to the bed "To think a few years in Edolas turned you into a submissive slut."

Mira grabbed Lisanna and bent her over her knee.

"Mira?!"

Mira caressed Lisanna butt "You may think you're a grown woman now Lisanna, to me you're still a little bratty little sister that needs to be punished."

I looked at the two confused when Mira suddenly spanked her sister.

"AH!" Lisanna bit her lip "Sis!"

"I'll hit you till you learn you lesson." Mira said spanking her again.

I sat there watching Mira slap her little sister. Lisanna looked like she was in heaven.

"Have you learned you lesson?" Mira asked "Don't ask Lucy to do things she doesn't like. If you like to be spanked like the little child you are I'll be happy to punish you."

*SMACK*

"MIRA!"

*SMACK*

"I've been a naughty girl!" Lisanna yelled "I need to be taught a lesson!"

These two are insane!

Mira slapped Lisanna a few more times before the girl was thrown off her knee and onto the ground. Mira turned around and kissed me.

"Let me make up for my little sister's mistakes. I guess I have to show you not all Strauss girls are so childish."

The much more mature Mirajane took my cock into her mouth and started giving me a blow job. I saw Lisanna was on the floor quivering.

*Slurp* "We haven't done it in a long time Lucy." Mira smiled "I forgot how big you were."

"You're still so good Mira. More experienced than your sister."

"I'll make sure to teach her the proper way to please you." Mira smiled grabbing Lisanna off the floor and making her kneel before me "Suck it!"

"Mira?"

"You need to learn how to make Lucy feel good. You're Edolas Lucy spoiled you. Here you'll have to learn the proper way. I won't have a little sister who doesn't know how to please her lover."

"Please teach me." Lisanna said getting close to Mira.

"Watch and learn Little Sister." Mira said as the two began kissing.

I didn't waste any time grabbing my cock and jacking off to the two kiss.

Mira reached up and groped Lisanna's breast "They've gotten bigger." Mira reached back and rubbed Lisanna's ass "This is bigger to."

Lisanna panted as Mira rubbed her body "I wanted to be just like you. A sex idol!"

"Not even close." Mira said rubbing the girl's folds "I'll always be the more attractive one. I have the bigger breasts, the sexier face, and I've pleased more people than you can even count. And I'm not a sex idol. People view me as a Sex God, I'm the woman all men want and all women want to be."

"Yes!" Lisanna said as Mira played with her while I watched.

"You can never be on my level; you're not even close to a Sex God, maybe a sex demigod." Mira moved her fingers faster making Lisanna moan "You have changed in the few years you were gone. You're not some little girl you are a woman now. My little sister has grown up into such a sexy minx."

"Thank you MIRA!"

Lisanna came from Mira's fingers and Mira licked them clean.

"You taste sweet."

Mira pulled Lisanna over to the bed and placed her in front of me.

"Show Lucy how much you just learned."

"Yes Mira." Lisanna said sitting up and taking me into her mouth.

Lisanna started bobbing her head while Mira gave her instructions.

"Listen from now on you don't make demands of Lucy. She gets to tell you what to do."

"Okay!" Lisanna said as she took me out for air "I'm Lucy's bitch!"

"Welcome then" Mira said rubbing the girl's back as she sucked "Lucy's harem just got another member."

"When did this become a thing?" I asked.

"What?"

"This harem?"

"Oh that, it was Cana's idea. She heard Ever talking about it yesterday while you two were in the forest. We all love you Lucy. So we just decided to make it official and share you. Officially you have ten bitches to please you whenever you want. 8 humans and 2 spirits."

O…Okay…Lisanna I'm gonna!"

"You better swallow all of it." Mira told her.

"AHHH!" I exploded in Lisanna's mouth and she gagged on the cum.

She wasn't able to swallow it all and some spilled out onto her breasts.

"You disobeyed me." Mira said.

"It's fine Mira." I said picking Lisanna up and laying her down "She's just tired. You mind finishing up."

"I apologize for my sister's weakness. I'll make sure she's ready for the next time you need her."

"You don't have to do that." I said as I entered Mira.

"Hmmmm."

"The way you treated Lisanna. Sometimes I forget you're a little demonic." I told her.

Mira gave me a cute smile and giggled "Sometimes it just slips out."

As I fucked Mira Lisanna moved over and started sucking Mira's left breast while playing with the nipple on the right.

"Ohh~!"

"There so big Mira." Lisanna said "I love you're big boobs. I wish mine were this big."

"You're still…AH!.. A growing girl! Maybe you'll grow. Levy had a growth spurt a few weeks ago. We ahLLL! Thought she was gonna be flat forever."

"I saw." Lisanna said kissing Mira's nipples while watching me fuck her big sister "They're big."

"Shit…Mira I'm gonna cum."

"Fill me up Lucy!" Mira moaned.

"MIRA!" I jizzed inside Mira and filled her full of cum.

"OHH! SO GOOD!" Mira yelled as I slid out of her.

Lisanna took it upon herself to clean Mira out.

"Lisanna!"

I laid back and when Lisanna was finished she crawled on top of me and inserted my dick into her pussy.

"Yeassss!"

"Oh Lisanna you're so warm!" I told her.

I looked over and saw Mira was laying her head on my chest half asleep.

"Your breasts are so soft Lucy." Mira said "I'm gonna use these as pillows."

"Go ahead." I said as she moved and rubbed her face over my breasts.

"Lucy you're so big!" Lisanna said as her hips moved.

"Who is better me or Edo-Lucy?"

"It's you by a mile!" Lisanna moaned "You may be the same size but you know all the right places to hit! I'm already so close!"

"I'm just about there. Cum with me Lisanna."

"Okay." I thrust into the girl a few more times when I felt my balls clench.

"HAAA!"

"LUCY!"

I filled Lisanna up and she fell off my cock. Lisanna laid down and put her head on my breasts.

"They are soft."

Mira moved around and started spooning Lisanna.

"Night you two." I said turning off the light.

"See you in the morning Lucy." They both said.

So it's official. I have a harem?

AN

Thank you for reading. Feedback is appreciated. Feel free to message me any questions or concerns.

Please feel free to suggest who you want to see in future chapters.

PS- If you guys are interested in seeing Side Chapters showing some of the girls with each other and not Lucy (I.e.: Ever and Virgo, Angel and Aries, Mira and Erza, Etc…) let me know.

Next Chapter Hint- Bull's-eye.

I've come to the decision that barring the one special case pregnancy won't come in till post-time skip (which to be honest isn't too many chapters away). This will just make keeping the actual plot of Fairy Tail in line much easier.

Till next time