A/N: The italics are the letter.
Disclaimer: I do not own Pretty Little Liars. It belongs to Sara Shepard.
Pretty Little Liars
Drama/Mystery
Characters: Spencer/Ali/Aria/Hanna/Emily/Toby/Ian/C/Courtney
Stay Safe
When the mailman stopped at each of the four pretty little houses that had four pretty little girls living at each of them, they would find a pink envelope with each of their names on it. Typed up neatly for each of them to easily be able to read, there was no room for mystery as to whom and where it came from. No, they could not trace it back to its owner, but they would know. They would know exactly who sent it to them.
Dear Aria, Alison, Emily, and Hanna,
A wild goose chase is what I currently have you four involved in. Who am I? You'll find out in time. I can tell you that I know who killed your little friend. Are you sitting down? Are you ready? Is your face already pale? Is sweat pouring off your body in nervousness? Good, that's what I want you to feel like, to be doing. This may not come as a surprise, but, just so you know and hear it from me, I was the one to kill Spencer Hasting's. There you go; it's all out in the open. If you find me, bitches, then you have finally brought justice to that poor girl's death.
One problem with that. You don't know who I am nor will you ever. I'm watching your every move, ladies, but you don't know where I am. I'm a shadow creeping after you, tracking you and black mailing you. Now, ladies, one by one I am going to tell some lies that I believe you all need to know.
Let's begin with the small, minor things. Hanna Marin, stuffs her face when she get's stressed and it shows. Her so called friend Mona just had her arrested for shoplifting a beautiful necklace. I will give you a thumbs up on that, Han, it was worth it. Her parents are fighting, her father doesn't even live at the house anymore. What to do, Hanna? Do you think that, maybe, all the stress you've caused in his life that you might just be the problem behind it all? That it is your fault your parents may or may not be getting separated. Perhaps that is true. I know, though, that your little shoplifting adventure is what caused your father to return, if only it was for just a short time. Oh, oh, Hanna. What are we ever going to do with you?
Emily Fields, you're the player up to bat next. Here we go. Something that Emily hasn't told anyone is the fact that she shared a moment with someone special that was a female, and when I say moment, I mean a kiss. I'll keep the information about who it was to me for now, but it will come out, Em. You've been warned. I think that she also has a crush on the new girl, Maya. Just thought you would also be interested in that, as well. Sorry for spilling your, ahem, secret, Em.
Aria Montgomery. I don't even know where to begin with you. You hooked up with the cute English teacher only to dump him for Noel Kuhn. Huh, downgrading a bit, are we? Weren't you in on accusing Toby of murdering Spencer? Weren't you the one to flip out on Ali when she didn't believe what you were saying? Good luck, Aria.
Now, now for the main event. Alison DiLaurentis. Oh, my, my head hurts just to write what all you've done. Let's begin with what you did to your twin sister, Courtney. Girls, did you know that the DiLaurentis' had a secret twin that they accused of being insane? Yeah, they did. It's the truth. You can even go and visit her at that mental hospital. Alison managed to send her back to that hellhole. Guess one is smarter than the other. Now, what about Ian? How about the fact that Spencer was in love with him before she died? How about the fact that Alison saw him while he and Spencer were sneaking around? Yes, I know about that, too, Alison. Or, how about the fact that it was you who confronted Toby Cavanaugh when you knew that Spencer loved him, too? You convinced Jason that Courtney was insane and you weren't, and the fact that you weren't such a bitch so you are now on his good side. And, finally, the kicker. When you left the barn on the night of the sleepover and ran after Spencer, you were attacked. You didn't tell anyone, but you and Spencer both saw someone that night. Until now, your secret has been just that, but now it's not. It's out there in the open, and, Ali, I'm not afraid to use it against you unless you and your friends do whatever I say.
Ladies, that's all I'm revealing about you for now. Remember, though, that I am watching your every move and I will be in contact with you soon enough. Until then, stay safe girls.
-C