Libby stood in the ring with Roman as Adam made his entrance. "Okay, I'll be right here at ringside," Roman whispered in Libby's ear before kissing her on the forehead and leaving the ring. Libby and Adam stood there facing each other. Adam had a lollipop in his mouth as the ref signaled for the bell. Adam took the lollipop out of his mouth and started handing it to Libby with a smile on his face. Adam started to mock Libby and she just wouldn't stand for it. Libby super kicked Adam and then Irish Whipped him into the turnbuckle. Libby ran up to Adam with a screech and did a Frankensteiner on him. She stood there watching Adam as he started getting up and looked to the turnbuckle. A smile crept on her face and she started mounting the top turn buckle. She had her back turned a gave a quick glance over her shoulder. Adam was exactly where she needed him to be. Libby threw her arms up to the crowd as Adam, now on his feet, turned towards her. Libby hit him successfully with her Petals on the Wind. She went to cover Adam but when the ref counted 2 Libby sat up. She was going to savor every moment of this as possible.
Libby stood up and paced around Adam as he started getting up. Libby reached down and grabbed a handful of Adam's hair at the top of his head. "Are you enjoying the party?" Libby mocked. Adam counters Libby's advances with a leg hook causing Libby to fall on her back. Adam stood up and started hoisting Libby on her feet. Adam had this crazy look in his eyes. He Irish Whipped Libby to the ropes in hopes to send her over and started charging after her, but when Libby hit the ropes she turned ducked down while holding down the top rope. Adam flew over the top rope but landed on his feet. Libby ran across the ring, slingshot her body off the ropes and hit Adam with a Somersault plancha. Libby and Adam both laid on the floor outside the ring. Roman wanted to go to her but couldn't interfere. So Roman did the only thing he could do and that's motivate her.
"Come on Libby get up!" The referee started counting but only got to four. Adam was on his feet first and he rolled Libby into the ring. Libby was getting up in a corner and Adam placed himself in the opposite one, setting up for his CHOO CHOO. Adam started running after Libby, but Libby surprisingly reversed his advance on her by lifting Adam over her shoulders and laying out a Samoan drop on him. Everyone in the arena was going crazy. Libby could even hear JBL, Michael Cole and King from the announce table say, "WHAT!" Libby covered Adam for the pin. 1-2-3! Libby's music played throughout the arena and the ref started helping her up. Libby was almost standing straight up when Roman walked up behind her and lifted her in the air. Libby was exhausted but it didn't stop her from smiling. She stood there hugging Roman and then turned to her fans. Libby held her fist up to them and looked back at Adam leaving the ring. She smiled at Roman as he lifted her up into his arms again and kissed him.
Libby's music was cut off and Paige's started filling the ring. Libby and Roman stopped what they were doing and looked up towards the Titantron with confused expression on their faces. Paige walked out from behind the curtain wearing her Divas championship around her waist. She had a smile on her face and a mic in her hand. Paige stood at the top of the ramp and waited for her music to stop before speaking. "Libby! I am so happy for you," Paige said in a not so convincing tone. "No really I am. I'm glad you finally got the revenge you been wanting. Now to celebrate, I have put together a little tribute video for you." Roman and Libby exchanged looks and stood there in the middle of the ring.
On the Titantron played what seemed to be a slideshow. "Oh look Libby it's our first match against each other. Remember our NXT days?" Paige said. "See Libby was once a groupie of Adam Rose." Photos of Libby as a Rosebud were shown. "But Libby didn't want to be just another ex girlfriend of Adam's. She wanted to steal his spot light." Photos of Libby's debut were shown. Libby didn't know what was going on. "That just wasn't enough for you Libby, was it? Adam just wasn't satisfying your needs was he? Because Libby here started going after Roman Reigns." Several photos were shown of Redacted coming to aid Roman in his matches. "You tried to hide your identity but Roman wasn't having it," A photo of Roman spearing Redacted appeared. Roman face palmed but Libby let him know it was okay. "Then, like a fairy tale, a love blossomed between the two of you." Rare photos of Libby and Roman from Live Events were shown. "But Roman, does Libby really love you?" Paige asked.
"What kind of question is that?" Roman asked as he stepped forward.
"No, really. Does she? Does Libby really love Roman Reigns?" Libby didn't understand what Paige was trying to do. "I have evidence that says otherwise."
"What?" Libby said. Roman looked at Libby, who shrugged her shoulders. "I have no idea what she's talking about."
"Let's have a look shall we." Footage from the match of Roman teaming with John Cena against Seth Rollins, Kane and Randy Orton started to play. Only this footage was shot from a different camera angle where we see Libby accidently getting hit when Roman clothesline Seth Rollins over the top rope and Libby going to Seth's aid. The video paused, "What's up with that Libby?" Libby now saw what Paige was trying to do and would not have any of it. Libby asked for a mic and started to speak into it.
"Look Paige, I know what you're trying to"-
"Oh do you Libby, do you really? I'm just showing Roman the truth. Like with this next clip." Roman was not liking this situation at all and started to look coldly at Libby before looking back up at the Titantron. Then to Libby's horror, a video started playing of Seth training with Libby and teaching her new moves. Libby's stomach dropped and she stood there frozen. The video showed Libby laughing and messing around with Seth and Libby knew Roman was not okay with it. Roman was now feet ahead of Libby in the ring, watching the footage. The clip stopped and Paige started to talk again, "Well this is a little awkward, but Roman just know, that I did the right thing. See this is what Libby did," Paige pointed to the Titantron. A photo of Seth Rollins kissing Libby appeared on screen. "Instead of coming to you, she went to Seth," Paige laughed and blew a kiss before walking back behind the curtain.
Roman was stiffened and Libby stood there frozen as her emotions started building inside of her. Libby felt like she had just gotten shot in her abdomen. Roman slowly turned around to face Libby. He was glaring at her and fury burned through his eyes. Beneath all the anger, Libby could see that he was deeply hurt. Tears started to fill Libby's eye. Roman took small steps towards Libby. Libby had seen Roman like this to many of his opponents but never wanted to be one of them. It scared her. "Roman please," Libby whispered as her tears started rolling down her face.
"Is it real?" Roman asked, referring to the photo that was still on the Titantron. Libby tried so hard to talk but she couldn't because of all the tears. Libby collapsed on her knees and covered her face. That answered Roman's question. Roman threw his head back and started running his fingers through his hair. He turned facing the Titantron and stared at the photo. Everyone could feel Roman's anger boiling inside him. His facial expression proved it as he grunted harder and harder. Roman looked back at Libby and saw her looking up at him, her face covered in tears.
"Roman please," Libby pleaded, but Roman ignored her as climbed out of the ring. He walked backstage with his head down and clinching his fist. Libby was left all alone in the ring. She full of embarrassment, heartbreak, betrayal, and couldn't stop the anxiety from taking over her. What was she going to do now?