I've got my own little ideas for the pretender now! :) I have always thought about this happening... So I decided to bring the idea to life!

She wanted to plead to him. It was obvious he knew a lot, but nobody could see if he was A or not. He knew a lot of facts that the girls didn't, and he had already figured out who Alison's killer was. Instead of begging, Emily asked him this: "If you know who's hurting us, and if you know who killed Alison, why don't you just be a man, step forward, and say it already?" Garrett nodded, giving out a menacing chuckle.

"It isn't that easy," He began. "Why would I even bother to help you after you all got me framed?" Garrett gave her a small smirk from the corners of his mouth. Emily was ready to slap his face now... He was trying to ask for something, but what would he want?

Emily frowned. "If you want something from me, just tell me. For this information, I'd give you anything you want."

"You know that I have the whole story with me, but I won't tell it, because it just won't help me. I'd rather let you get tortured." Garrett stretched his arms behind his back and then pulled them to the front, interlocking his fingers and cracking his knuckles. "You want life to be easy, but it isn't. Emily, you can't force everyone to do what they don't want to do."

She gave him a strong look and squinted her eyes. "Don't lie, Garrett. You want something from me- Not just me, my friends, too. What do you want? If I have it, I'll give it to you. Anything is worth this information! I'll do anything to find out who murdered Ali, and I'll do anything to find out who 'A' is. I know you know who A is, and I know you play your own part in this game. There's nothing to hide. What do you want?"

Garrett laughed again. "I don't play as big of a part in this as you think I do. And I do want something. I want that video-tape of Jenna and Toby."

"You sicko!" Emily screamed, shoving him in the chest. He stumbled backwards, slamming into a table.

"What the hell?" He snapped.

"You want Jenna and Toby's video? The video of your ex-girlfriend having sex with her brother?" Emily's eyes widened. She wanted to shove him again. He deserved it for that perverted desire! What else could he use that video for? Just his own perverted enjoyment!

Garrett picked himself up from the table he slammed into. His arm was sore as he got up. "That's so like you, Emily... It's so like you to just jump to conclusions. You assume whatever you want, and this is another reason why you can't trust people in Rosewood. They make very impractical assumptions, and life goes on! I don't want to watch that video. Jenna's a twisted bitch, I'm not watching that! If I watched that whole video, I'd never be able to look at Toby again. Which is already something you won't be able to do."

Emily pretended like she didn't know what he was talking about. But he knew a lot about the A-Team, and Emily could see someone on the team had hurt Garret, too. "Don't pretended like you're stupid," Garrett continued. "You know about Toby. You know he's the betrayer. But does Spencer know?"

She nodded and said, "Yes."

Garret smirked again. "She was crushed, wasn't she?"

Emily bit her lip and nodded.

"If he explained anything to you, it's most likely a lie. Toby's a dirty-ass liar." Garrett was glaring at the ground now.

Why would Garrett say that Toby can't be trusted? He knew about everything, and he knew who killed Ali. Tears were about to form in Emily's eyes. Toby did try to explain himself. Garrett knew the most. Then what made her tear up: It hit her, it really did! The killer had to be Toby... Who else? He hated Alison all along! The Liars framed him for "The Jenna Thing" in order to keep his secret with Jenna even though that wasn't his fault.

She felt so bad. There were days that Toby was all alone. He would cry himself away in the halls, and people would bully him. They'd call him Alison's killer, and "the one that murdered the hottest girl in school". She couldn't even think of what he felt!

"Why do you want the video?" Emily stood up to ask.

"Because," Garrett began. "Because... Jenna's done enough to me, and it's time she learns a lesson. With that video, I'm her boss."

"That's so sick!" Emily cried. "Why would you hurt her? Revenge isn't the answer."

"In this town, revenge is the answer." Garrett smirked.

"You're not... You're not going to turn this into the police, right?" Emily asked, biting her lip. She didn't know if Toby was A, but she couldn't let him be turned in for that. That video clearly showed him sinning. Spencer would be furious if Garrett turned him in and Toby ended up being innocent. "You can't turn Toby in, it wasn't his fault! And you'd hurt Spencer... Please,"

"That's exactly what I want. Toby, Spencer, and Jenna need to be hurt. They need someone to show them that it isn't their own little game." Garrett snapped. "Toby's lied to me so many times, Spencer turned me in to the police, and Jenna... Well, she has her own little betrayal story with me." Emily could see the anger building up in Garrett's eyes.

Emily felt a little sympathetic for him, but not enough to allow him to hurt Spencer and Toby! Emily believed Toby was innocent. He was in love with Spencer, any eyes in Rosewood could see it! Spencer was just as in love as he was, and there was hope for them. Yes, she was thinking about Toby being 'A' at first, but not anymore. He tried explaining, but she just didn't want to be a part of his life. If Toby wasn't lying then, Emily could see that Spencer would not be able to resist him. Everything on their track would be fine... Unless Garrett turned that tape in. She bit her lip and then spoke, "Garrett, please! She's one of my closest friends, and Toby's the guy she's in love with! Can you just leave them alone?"

Garrett laughed. "Why would Spencer give a damn about Toby? She knows. She knows that Toby isn't the honest good-guy she thought he was. Don't you think that she'd be happy to hear about Toby's arrest for sinning?"

She softly said, "I know he hurt her, but Spencer... She's forgiving, and she loves him. I know he'll come through."

"You keep thinking that," Garrett sarcastically spoke. "I'll tell you what; meet me at The Brew tomorrow with the video footage of Jenna and I'll have the true answers waiting for your ears. How's that sound?"

"I'll do what I can." Emily nodded.