Unforgettable Love

by CollegeStar21

Summary

Brittany Pierce and Santana Lopez were finally a couple and not to be open at McKinley High. Everybody knew they had something going with them and didn't care because they knew that Santana would kick their asses for messing with her girlfriend.

But what happens when Brittany's old childhood best friend/first ever girlfriend, Rachel Berry moves back to Lima after being in California for so long, shows up Brittany's and her Senior year all grown up and not the same girl she was when she was younger,sparking up feelings that Brittany struggled to long forget while also putting a strain on her relationship with Santana Lopez?

Will Brittany and Rachel start their friendship over as just best friends or will they finally admit that they still want each other? Find out what happens.

Season 4 Rachel Berry clothes and hair style in this story. Minor Brittana relationship but Brittberry and Quinntana romance hopefully in the end.

I'm adding two girls to this story who are part of New Directions and good friends with the group. I'll be adding some of Rachel's California friends into this story aswell and two just happen to show up in this chapter and will be staying with Rachel and her family for the whole year.

Enjoy.


With Rachel and Brittany.

Rachel was straddling Brittany's lap making out with her on Brittany's bed after school but Brittany wasn't as into it as she was. Rachel frowned when she felt Brittany just laying there not really responding to her kisses and pulled back offended.

"Wow I guess your not into making out as much as I am." Rachel starts climbing off her lap but Brittany stops her.

"Don't leave Rachie I'm sorry. I guess I something on my mind, come back baby and kiss me." Rachel shook her head fixing her shirt.

"Forgot I have to go home and change for Mike coming over." Brittany frowns clearing her throat.

"Why do you have to change clothes just because Mike is coming over your house?" Rachel stared at her confused.

"Because I don't feel like dancing in skinny jeans Britt. Were working on dance and song for the duets in Glee club next friday, are you okay baby?" Brittany shook her head.

"Wait that's what you two were talking about with the sweating and his arms around you?" Rachel raised an eyebrow wondering what she was talking about.

"Huh? baby what are you talking about?" Brittany tells her about what she heard them talking about and Rachel frowned.

"Oh my god you thought me and Mike were having sex last night?" She exclaimed angrily.

"I'm sor-" She stopped her from saying sorry because she was tired of the sorry crap.

"Nice to know that my girlfriend trusts me. Nothing is going on between me and Mike Chang. Were just friends who are dancing and singing for Glee club." She tells her.

"Fluffy I do trust you but I don't trust other people." Rachel put on her shoes and sighs staring at her.

"Were you this jealous with Santana or Artie?" She shook her head feeling bad.

"I'll see you at school tomorrow." She grabs her school bag and car keys about to leave when Brittany gets up and grabs her hand.

"No kiss good bye? please Rachel I know I'm acting like this super jealous girlfriend but your sexy and beautiful and I'm just worried that I'll lose you." Rachel stares at her.

"Okay were two girls worried girls scared of losing each other but we should really just talk about this another time alright?" Brittany nodded sadly.

"Good I need to get home fast and change before Mike comes over and I'll call you after he leaves." Rachel tells her smiling then leans in and pecks her lips a few times.

"I love you Fluffy." Rachel knows but sometimes she needs Brittany to understand that it goes both ways.

"I love you too Bunny remember that. I promise to call you as soon as he leaves." Rachel said before kissing her cheek and left saying good bye to Brittany's cat.

Brittany grabs her phone when she heard it ringing and saw Tina calling her and answered it.

"Hey are we still up for spying?" Brittany bit her lip wondering if it was the right thing to do.

"I don't think so Tina we should trust our lovers, You know Mike would never cheat on you and Rachel isn't the kind of girl that would cheat on me." Brittany says sighing.

"Fine I guess your right but I want to know what that was all about." Brittany tells her what's going on and Tina feels stupid.

Like Rachel promised she called Brittany and they both talked for awhile before saying I love you and good night and went to sleep with a smile on their faces.


At Glee Club.

Kurt and Blaine sang their song first and now it was Brittany's and Santana's turn. Rachel sat next to Quinn and smiled at her girlfriend. Quinn was also smiling differently at Santana and Rachel noticed because her and Brittany have been talking about how those two should be together.

Both/Santana/Brittany.

The music starts and the girls start singing looking at the group who were smiling at them.

We were born to break the doors down
Fightin' till the end
It's something that's inside of us
It's how we've always been (Yeah)
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior...
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior...

Santana danced to the beat singing her solo first making the group clap liking the song.

We are the misfits
We are the bad kids
The degenerates
We ain't perfect but that's alright
Love us or hate us
Nothin' can break us
Better believe us
Times, they are changing tonight

We don't want to flirt with disaster
On your ass we'll pounce like a panther
Cut the bullshit out with a dagger
With a dagger(x2)
Do or die we all gonna stay young
Shoot the lights out with a machine gun
Think it's time for a revolution
Revolution(x2)

Rachel smiled lovingly watching her girlfriend sing a song from her favorite artist.

We were born to break the doors down
Fightin' till the end
It's something that's inside of us
It's how we've always been (Yeah)
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior...
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior...

Rachel clapped her hands dancing with Quinn and both girls had smiles on their faces watching the girls do their things and Brittany sings her part alone.

Now this is our time
Our generation
And we're impatient4
Animals you ready to fight?!
Fight for the fuck ups
Stand up for true love
We'll never give up
Live like it's our last night alive

We don't want to flirt with disaster
On your ass we'll pounce like a panther
Cut the bullshit out with a dagger
With a dagger(x2)
Do or die we all gonna stay young
Shoot the lights out with a machine gun
Think it's time for a revolution
Revolution(x2)

Brittany and Santana smirked at each other dancing to the beat while singing and Mr. Shue was liking it alot even thought there were some words in there.

We were born to break the doors down
Fightin' till the end
It's something that's inside of us
It's how we've always been (Yeah)
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior...
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior...

Brittany and Santana do a different dance without singing and the group was cheering for them then they finish the song standing beside each other.

We were born to break the doors down
Fightin' till the end
It's something that's inside of us
It's how we've always been (Yeah)
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior
Warrior-ior-ior
Warrior-ior

They finished the song and everybody clapped and cheered for them. Both girls hugged each other and Brittany grabbed Rachel and brought her over to her seat while Santana sat down next to Quinn.

"That was great girls, that was pretty good and I hope you guys who are still working on their songs, work really hard to beat these two girls." Santana and Brittany smirk at each other knowing they are going to win.

Just then there was a knock on the door and the group looked at the person.

"Hi sorry to just stop your practice but is Rachel Berry here?" The girl with short jet black hair with blonde and blue highlights in her hair, she had her lip pierced, her body was slim and slightly curvy. Her breast were Santana Lopez big but hers were real, She had grayish blue eyes, she was a little taller then Rachel and she was wearing dark skinny jeans with a black and green halter top showing off a sliver of her tan slim stomach.

Rachel's eyes widen squealing getting off her girlfriend's lap and rushed over to the person.

"Oh my god Kalaeia Parker what are you doing here?" Rachel squealed wrapping her arms around her best friend from California.

"I'm staying with you for the rest for the year due to my dad getting shipped to another state once again. I hate being an army kid." Rachel frowned pulling back.

"I forgot that he was getting shipped off but where is Ariella did she come with you?" Rachel asked her then they heard other footsteps walking in.

"Kalaeia when I say to wait while I go to the bathroom, you better wait or esle." Ariella said angrily with the strong Irish accent that matched her twin sister's.

Ariella Parker had the same eye color, body tyle, skintone but she had light brown hair that was still short with purple and blue highlights in it. Ariella finally noticed Rachel standing in front of her and squealed pushing her sister out of the way and hugged her and she smiles brightly hugging her back.

"There is my Rachykins that I love and missed so much." Brittany glared at the girl who was giving her girlfriend that stupid pet name.

"Ariella Parker, my have I missed your corny nick name for me." Rachel joked laughing then the girls heard clearing of the throat.

"Oh sorry Mr. Shue these are my best friends from California Kalaeia and Ariella Parker. They are going to be joining me at McKinley for now on." Both girls waved at the group then Ariella whispered in Rachel's ear making her laugh nodding and stared at her with a huge smile.

Brittany frowns seeing the way Ariella is staring at Rachel like she wanted to kiss her and she had to stop it before she beats the girl up.

"Can they sing and if so maybe they should try out for Glee club?" Brittany spoke up glancing at Ariella strongly. Both twins nodded and Rachel sat down next to Brittany who grabs her hand and kept her close. Both girls talked to the band and they nodded and started the song.

Kalaeia/Ariella/Both.

Kalaeia starts singing first and Puck couldn't take his eyes off her seeing how hot she looked because it was a total badass look.

You were unaware that diamonds came with debt.
Ironic sure but that's the way it is, got my vows off the internet.

Ariella sang next glancing at Rachel dancing to the beat and Kalaeia rolled her eyes dancing to the beat knowing all about her sister's major crush on their best friend.

You say, "Crying weakens my immune system."
But don't forget that if you pray for me,
I'll pray for you, and cash flow too, why not.
I said, "If you pray for me,
I'll pray for you, and cash flow too, why not?"

Both twins sang together dancing to the beat and Rachel glanced at them surprised that they picked this song to sing but liked it sort of.

It was a black wedding you could hear the organs,
Not the violins or the words the Pope was saying.
Was a black wedding,
You could hear the organs but,
no drunken snoring or real hallelujahs.
Dumb people swore they saw the devil.
While most prayed they wouldn't last a winter.
It was a black wedding, throw those blessings all around.

Kalaeia starts again and glanced over at the people smiling at them dancing to the beat.

So, you're finally viewing this at 5 foot 6.
It's not all "roses" like your momma said,
We're not spoon fed anymore.
So you gonna tell, all our kids I was an "accident,"
Ironic, sure, but that's the way you act when you're upset,
so let's take this outside.

We see our mirrors from outside.
And he said, "We are only pride.
We stay hidden all our lives."

It was a black wedding you could hear the organs,
Not the violins or the words the Pope was saying, was a black wedding,
You could hear the organs but, no drunken snoring or real hallelujahs.
Dumb people swore they saw the devil.
While most prayed they wouldn't last a winter.
It was a black wedding,
throw those blessings all around.

Brittany was freaked out by their song choice but they sounded pretty good.

What else is there to know when our Bible's here?
What else is there to know when your Bible's here?

There are no lies to find when the page is bare.
What else is there to know when your tax is shared?

They stared at each other smiling at each other while finishing up their song and everybody was impressed and a little spooked out by their song.

Outside.
We see our mirrors from outside.

And he said, "We are only pride.
We stay hidden all our lives."

Rachel wasn't surprised at their song choice because her best friends were into that kind of dark music but they were still her best friends.

"You have friends who listen to music like this baby?" Brittany whispered glancing at her. Rachel looked at her nodding.

"Yes I know it's odd but they are very nice girls and they don't always listen to this kind of music." Brittany nods still unsure about them and kissed her cheek.

It was a black wedding you could hear the organs play,
(But not the) words the Pope was saying.
Was a black wedding you could hear the organs not,
no drunken snoring or real Hallelujahs.
The Grave digger said, "It's this cathedral."
They drank holy water like it was the last supper.
It was a black wedding, throw those blessings all around.

Ariella glanced back at Rachel and frowned slightly seeing her whispering in some blonde haired girl's ear and she looked so in love as the girl kissed her cheek.

(What else is there to know when your Bible's here?)
It was a black wedding, throw those blessing all around.
(What else is there to know when your tax is shared?)
It was a black wedding, throw those blessings all around.

They finished and everybody clapped for them. "Wow girls that was a very interesting song and your voices were great. Weclome to Glee club." Mr. Shue tells them.

Santana glanced over at Brittany to see her looking angry at that Ariella girl who seems to have eyes for Rachel Berry. She wasn't going to let this girl mess up her best friend's relationship with her girlfriend Rachel and she was going to make sure Ariella stayed just friends with Rachel.

Find out what happens next and the songs were Warrior by Kesha and Black Wedding by Meg and Dia.