A/N: Thank you Sam for wishing me a happy anniversary, and thanks to the rest who reviewed. I'm making up this chapter as it goes so bear with me. Reviews are love.

Emily's P.o.V

Last night was amazing. Spencer was so polite and charming, and knowing that it was all for me just made it much more meaningful. Throughout dinner her family was constantly asking questions about how my swimming and school work were doing, but that wasn't anything new. Her dad was impressed when I had told him I had broken yet another record.

My mom had called this morning to let me know that she would be coming from Texas tomorrow, so Hanna's mom said that it was ok for me to go back home. I decided to take Spencer's advice and as soon as I got home I called Samara. I have no idea how this is going to turn out. I just finished sending out a text to Aria when there's a knock on my door. "Hi Emily." She says when I open the door.

"Hi Samara." I say, as I move over a bit to let her in.

"So what did you need to talk about?" She says, taking a seat on the couch.

I take a deep breath. "Where were you Tuesday night?"

"I was out with the girls." She says cautiously.

"All of them?"

"Yeah me, Quinn, Zoey, an-" I cut her off immediately.

"Quinn was with you?" I ask her.

"Yeah, wh-, oh." She says a look of acknowledgement crossing her features.

"Quinn would've told you about me then. You lied to me didn't you?" I say with no anger in my words. I sit next to her and she immediately looked down. "Why?"

"I didn't mean to. We started talking last Thursday and then she asked me to go out as friends. I tried telling myself that I felt nothing but the girls couldn't make it and we ended up alone at my house making out. I'm so-so sorry Em I di-." I cut her of because she's crying her heart out in front of me.

"Wait a second, calm down. What are you talking about?" I say as I take her in my arms.

She takes in a few deep breaths before saying, "I cheated on you. I didn't mean hurt you I swear, but I couldn't stop myself." Her body is trembling in my arms, so I hold her tighter.

"Who was she?" I say as calmly as possible.

She looks up at me with her red rimmed eyes. She takes in a shaky breath and says, "Paige McCullers."

I look at her with wide eyes. I hear my phone vibrate and I pick it up.

"Didn't see that coming did you? Not everything is what it seems-A"

I was about to call Spencer when Samara's sobbing began again. I decide to help her crying subside before I did anything that involved 'A'.