pineapplegrl77: That makes me happy. :)
litafan82: You write the best OC smut ever! You never sent me part 2. Oh and I'm glad you liked the AS part.
AnywhereElse: Thanks for the review! I'm glad you liked the chapter. What you said about it's not always perfect but it doesn't matter as long as you love each other is exactly what I was going for. :)
Casey pinned Alex down on the couch and started to kiss her. It had been over a week since they lost their virginity to each other and since then Casey wanted her girlfriend all to herself. She was thrilled that Mrs. Cabot let her spend the night with Alex, especially since it was their four-year anniversary. What Casey didn't know is that Alex had invited a couple of guests over to join them.
"Happy anniversary, babe!" Casey told her as she kissed her again. "I can't believe we have the whole night alone."
"Casey, about that," Alex said hesitantly.
"Oh, no," Casey groaned. "They're coming, aren't they?"
"Not for awhile," Alex responded and Casey pulled away from her.
"You always do this, Alex."
"I'm sorry, babe," Alex said and unsuccessfully tried to get close to Casey. "But it's our last year together before college and the last Cabenmichael Halloween."
"You're forgetting, Alex, that this is our last year together, too," Casey reminded her. "And it's just as hard on me as it is on them. I know they're your best friends, but you're my girlfriend and, even though it's your last Halloween with them, it's also your last anniversary with me. We're going to be in different states next year and it's like you don't even care. When this school year started, we were inseparable and now all you want to do is spend time with Abbie and Olivia. I'm not the only one who is noticing this either. Connie and Serena feel the same way about their girls. Face it, you three are co-dependent."
Alex was speechless. She had wanted to spend the night with Casey, but Abbie and Olivia insisted on having a sleepover to celebrate their last Halloween together before they started college. Abbie and Olivia assumed it was going to be a typical Cabenmichael sleepover complete with Hellraiser, strawberry ice cream, and Metroid. They had no idea Casey would be there and Alex knew they wouldn't exactly be pleased about that. Alex did the only thing she felt she could do in order to spend Halloween with her girlfriend and her best friends: she lied to all of them.
"Open up!" Olivia said as she pounded on the door. Alex sprang from the couch so she could open the door for Olivia. Even though it was Halloween Olivia was wearing her Cabenmichael sleepover attire: purple flannel pajamas, a purple hair ribbon, and fuzzy slippers. Her favorite stuffed animal was sticking out from her overnight bag and she had absolutely no make-up on.
"Liv!" Alex said excitedly and gave her a hug. It suddenly made sense to Casey why Alex insisted on wearing her pink flannel pajamas and pink hair ribbon instead of something sexy.
"It's our last Cabenmichael Halloween! To celebrate, I brought Hellraiser, of course, The Exorcist, and Texas Chain Saw Massacre. Little Jared's not going to know what hit him," Olivia told her.
"He'll never want to watch scary movies with us again," Alex said and started laughing.
Olivia became nervous when she saw Casey sitting on the couch. "Alex, I didn't know I was supposed to bring my girlfriend," Olivia whispered. "I'm not dressed for Connie. She doesn't even know about Mr. Cuddles yet. You know I can't sleep without him, not even when I'm with Connie. He has to hide when I sleep with her and all I do is lie there for hours and feel bad for hiding him."
"Get a grip," Alex told her. "Your girlfriend won't be here, just mine."
Olivia suddenly felt relieved. She had never considered Casey to be 'one of the girlfriends.' She had always felt as if Casey was on the same level as Abbie, Alex, and herself. Sure, she wasn't a Cabenmichael, but maybe there was an upside to having Casey around. Then again, she realized they would have to watch what they said around Casey for fear that she'd tell the other girls.
"Happy anniversary!" Olivia said to break the ice, but neither Alex nor Casey looked too happy about their situation.
Olivia ran to the door the moment she heard the doorbell ring. Alex and Casey kept eyeing each other and the last thing she wanted was to be the third wheel.
"I'm so glad you're here," Olivia said as she hugged Abbie. She was pleased to see Abbie wearing her yellow flannel pajamas and yellow hair ribbon. Abbie also had her Chucky doll in her arms and Olivia was glad to see that there would be at least some normalcy at this sleepover. Even though he freaked everybody out, Abbie loved her Chucky doll and she slept with him every night, including the nights she spent with Serena. Serena got so used to him that she considered Chucky to be their illegitimate son.
"What's going on?" Abbie asked.
"Girlfriend alert," Olivia told her. "Casey's here."
"Why?" Abbie groaned.
"It's their anniversary," Olivia told her. "Mr. and Mrs. Cabot are at a Halloween party and you know if we weren't here, Alex and Casey would be having sex right now. They keep eyeing each other."
"Let them," Abbie suggested. "We'll hang out in the rec room with Jared and they can go up to Alex's room. Besides, there's something I have to show you."
Alex and Casey wasted no time going up to Alex's room once Abbie and Olivia told them they wouldn't mind if the girls sneak away for awhile. "Go enjoy your anniversary sex," Abbie told them. Both girls gave her a hug and left Abbie and Olivia to entertain themselves.
Jared was still trick-or-treating with his friends, so Abbie felt this was the perfect opportunity to show Olivia her big surprise. She went to her overnight bag and pulled out the sonogram photo she was given by her doctor that afternoon. She began crying the moment her doctor gave it to her. In the top left corner it said, "Carmichael, Abigail" and today's date "10-31-1991." In the center of the photo was her baby. Even though he or she was only the size of a peanut, Abbie already loved her baby. Her doctor said her baby was healthy and Abbie was doing a great job of taking care of herself. When Abbie saw the bottom of the photo, she began crying even more. Her doctor had printed a message that was "from the baby." It read, "Hi, Mommy! I can't wait to meet you." She wanted to tell her little one that she couldn't wait to meet him or her either.
As soon as they got in the car after her appointment, she showed Serena the sonogram photo and Serena had the same reaction.
"That's our baby?" Serena asked excitedly and Abbie nodded. Serena was speechless after that. All she wanted to do was hold Abbie as close as she could, for as long as she could.
Abbie became lost in thought as she was remembering everything that had happened to her earlier. With a gentle toss of her pillow at Abbie's back, Olivia was able to snap her out of it.
"Jerk!" Abbie told her and then gave her the photo. "Check this out."
"It's our Cabenmichael baby!" Olivia said excitedly. Abbie then got on her lap and Olivia held her close to her as they looked at the photo together. "Abbie, this is so exciting. It's his or her first photo."
"Serena already made copies," Abbie informed her. "She's just as excited as I am. Isn't this great, Liv? It's like we're re-defining what a family is. In seven months, I'll have my baby and Serena by my side."
"What about college?" Olivia asked even though she already knew the answer to that question.
"What about it?" Abbie responded. "I'll go eventually, but I'd rather spend time with my baby."
Abbie rested her head on Olivia's shoulder and Olivia could sense how scared Abbie really was even if she didn't want to tell anybody. Serena and the Cabenmichael family accepted the baby, but everyone knew Abbie's parents would be less than thrilled about their 17-year-old being pregnant, especially when she had no intentions of marrying the baby's biological father.
Abbie quickly got off of Olivia's lap when they heard the doorbell ring. They were surprised to hear it until they remembered it was Halloween and Alex's neighborhood got its fair share of trick-or-treaters. Abbie got the candy dish from on top of the coffee table and took it to the door.
"Give me some damn Twix!" shouted a familiar voice.
"And a Milky Way!" added another.
Abbie had an idea who it was, but to make sure, she looked out of the peep hole. Standing on the other side of the door were two scantily clad girls they happened to be acquainted with.
"It's Connie and Serena," Abbie told Olivia.
"I'm not dressed for Connie," Olivia said worriedly. "I can't let her see me like this. I'm wearing flannel PJs and I have no make-up whatsoever. You're pregnant so you have an excuse. I have nothing!"
Abbie ran back to Olivia and unbuttoned her pajama shirt. The loose flannel fell to the ground and Olivia was left with nothing but her pajama pants and her push-up bra.
"I'm supposed to greet her like this?" Olivia asked.
"You look sexy," Abbie reminded her. "So, stop your bitching and let's answer the door."
"Trick or treat," both girls said in unison when Abbie answered the door. She had intended to play along and give them candy, but she had forgotten all about it when she saw Serena dressed in nothing but a white bra, panties, and matching thigh highs and garter belt. She knew Olivia was going to cream when she saw that Connie was dressed the same way.
"What are you supposed to be?" Abbie finally managed to ask them.
"High-price call girls," Connie responded.
"Most girls dress skimpy for Halloween anyway," Serena added. "Connie and I just decided to outdo them. Now, where's my Twix?"
"You're going to have to earn it," Abbie teased and pulled Serena in for a kiss.
"I have a gift for you," Serena told Olivia as she led Connie to her.
"More like you have a gift for me," Connie corrected her. "Olivia in that bra? It's like Christmas came early."
Olivia started smiling and pulled her girlfriend toward her. "You look beautiful," she told Connie.
"You do," Connie responded. "Even without make-up, you're still the most beautiful girl I've ever laid eyes on."
"You two are disgusting," Abbie told them, but Olivia and Connie were already too busy making out to pay any attention to them.
"Why are you still wearing pants?" Serena asked as she gently pushed Abbie down on the couch and got on top of her. Serena pulled Abbie's pants down but kept her underwear on in case Alex and Casey were to walk in.
Once Serena commented on how wet Abbie was, Connie and Olivia stopped what they were doing.
"Are you two really going to have sex in front of us?" Olivia asked in disgust.
"No, I was just going to finger her," Serena responded and Abbie started to kiss her neck.
Connie rolled her eyes at them. "There's so many things I would love to do to Olivia right now, but I would never do anything in front of you and I think you should show us the same courtesy."
"Unlike some people, I actually know how to satisfy my woman," Serena said and glared at Connie. "Maybe it would do you some good to watch me and Abbie. You might learn a thing or two."
"You mean I could learn how to be a slut like you," Connie replied sarcastically and Serena looked like she wanted to slap her.
"Girls!" Olivia said to snap them out of it.
"I'm sorry, Rena," Connie told her and gave her a hug.
"I'm sorry, too," Serena responded.
"Maybe you should kiss her?" Abbie suggested.
"I'll kiss Connie if you kiss Olivia," Serena bargained with her. "Maybe we'll even do more," she said as she held Connie close and started to play with the front clasp of her bra.
Once she saw that, Abbie wasted no time making her way over to Olivia. She started kissing Olivia's neck and then made her way up to her lips. Connie and Serena were enjoying the show their girls were putting on until Alex and Casey walked into the rec room.
"What the hell is going on here?" Casey asked.
"I don't even want to know," Alex told Casey.
"We were just playing," Abbie informed them. "It was good, clean, wholesome fun."
Alex started laughing. "How about no more fooling around for the rest of the night? Please? Jared is staying at his friend's house after all, but still, the last thing I want are my parents to walk in on us when they get home from the party. And Connie and Serena, you two better cover up. My parents don't even know you're here and if they see you dressed like that, we'll never be able to have another sleepover again."
"Easy for you to say. You've already had sex tonight," Abbie told Alex. "If it's okay, Serena and I can do it in the shower."
Serena loved the idea, but the other four girls just looked at Abbie in disbelief.
"…or not," Abbie said hesitantly.
To take their mind off of sex, the girls decided to put on The Exorcist. It was a favorite of everyone's except for Connie, who was paranoid to watch that movie.
"I'll protect you, cuddlebug," Olivia told her girlfriend as she held her close.
"No offense, Olivia," Casey began. "I'm sure you could protect her from Jason Vorhees, Leatherface, and maybe even Freddy Kruegger, but Satan is whole different story."
"Livvie can protect me from anything," Connie said and Serena started making gagging noises.
"See, I'm realistic," Serena told her. "Abbie weighs two pounds. I know she can't protect me from anything."
"I love you, too, babe," Abbie said sarcastically.
"This is where you girls are going wrong," Alex informed them. "You keep talking about how one of you can or cannot protect the other instead of talking about protecting each other. Casey and I have an egalitarian relationship. We'd work as a team."
"Yeah," Casey agreed. "Alex would use her powers of persuasion and I'd come from behind and knock the bastard out with my baseball bat."
"I'm going to let your arrogance slide because it's your anniversary," Serena told them.
When the movie became too much for Connie to handle, Alex shut it off, and Olivia decided to tell her a story.
"When we were 15, the three of us watched The Exorcist almost every day," Olivia began. "Our favorite scene was when she spits out the pea soup. Well, Abbie thought it would be fun to scare her sister Addie by doing that. So, one night, when we stayed over at her house, she ate a bunch of pea soup and started making herself throw it up while her sister watched. Addie had watched the movie with us, so when she saw Abbie throwing up, she thought she was possessed. Addie started screaming bloody murder and when Mr. and Mrs. Carmichael found out what she did, she was grounded for two weeks."
"It was so worth it," Abbie told her. "That was hilarious!"
"And what about this summer with the pop rocks and soda?" Olivia told her and Abbie started laughing.
"That was the best!" Alex said. "I love the way you made your body convulse and the pop rocks and soda started oozing out of your mouth. Addie actually thought your insides had exploded."
"Maybe this is why she hates you, babe," Serena told her.
"I'm a horrible person," Abbie said jokingly. "My sister already has my headstone designed. It says, "Abigail Jean Carmichael Dec. 5, 1973-July 4, 1992. I always knew her childish pranks would backfire on her."
"You're so bad, Abbie," Connie told her.
"I know she is and I love it," Serena responded and started to kiss Abbie. "I've always had a soft spot for bad girls."
"Just think, in a few years, a little version of Abbie will be running around and making Addie's life a living hell," Alex told them.
"Speaking of," Abbie said to them as she hands the picture to Alex to pass around. "This is the first picture of mine and Serena's baby."
"I hope it's a girl," Serena said. "Abbie already has her name picked out."
"Lillian Serena Carmichael," Abbie informed them. "Serena and I both love the name Lily and, well, it's obvious why I want her middle name to be Serena."
"And if it's a boy?" Olivia asked.
"We're doing the same thing your mom did with your name," Abbie told her. "I love how she named you Olivia Lorraine after her two best friends, so I've decided to name him Alexander Olivier Carmichael, that way it's like he has all three of our names."
"Alexander Olivier? It sounds so distinguished," Olivia told her.
"I love it," Alex added. "This baby is going to be spoiled rotten by all of us."
The girls spent the rest of their Halloween talking about the baby and everything they have planned for him or her. As they were getting ready for bed, Abbie took a look around at the five girls she was fortunate enough to be spending her night with. Serena was holding on to the Chucky doll as she was lying in their sleeping bag, Casey and Alex were cuddling with each other, and Olivia put her pajama shirt on her girlfriend and tried to convince her that The Exorcist was just a movie and she had nothing to worry about. Abbie loved these girls and she knew that her baby was going to have four loving aunts and two crazy, yet lovable mommies. Only seven more months until they'd finally get to meet little Lillian or Alexander.