DISCLAIMER: I OWN NOTHING
Please comment and review. This is my first fanfic and I'm excited and nervous but, your comments inspire me.
A/N This chapter got a little long so I decided to break it up into two chapters, first up the Sam/Mike/Brittney/Mercedes. Song in this chapter is "Sorry For The Stupid Things" by Babyface
Thank you to everyone for your comments and suggestions. It truly motivates me to write more. You guys will never truly know how excited I get to see your reviews and comments. You are why I can pump out 2 chapters in a day. Thank you so much.
Much Love.
Baby Please Part 1
The next morning things were still quite tense.
Mercedes was walking around the garden trying to get a grip on what happened last night. She could not believe that Tina and Sam had sex all that time. Not once did they say anything. She was startled when she heard someone coming up behind her. She turned to see Mike standing there.
"Oh Mike you scared me"
"Sorry Cedes I didn't mean to. I just saw you walking around and you look like you might need a friend."
"That would be nice."
They made their way to the gazebo to sit.
"You know this is messed up right?" Mike said.
"Yeah I know" Mercedes replied "I don't know which is more upsetting, the fact that they were together or the fact they lied about it?"
"Yeah I am just so pissed at them for everything" he said "I mean he is-was my best friend and he just lied to me all these years about having sex with my wife."
"Your wife, my best friend, sleeps with my husband for a year and neither one of them feels the need to share that little bit of information with us" Mercedes said "yeah it sucks but if we think about it rationally Mike we weren't together at the time."
"I know" Mike said "I can't stay mad at Tina forever. I mean I was the one who broke things off with her. I hooked up with other people so I shouldn't have expected her not too. It just sucks though."
"That it does" she said "I am just so mad at them right now but you're right I can't stay mad at Sam forever. I put in too many years in this relationship to let some other chick swoop in and get the man I worked so hard to mold into the best man for me, not happening."
Mike laughed "you know for a moment last night, in all my not sleeping, I was tempted to come knock on your door."
"Really"
"Yeah I went through all the emotions last night but I was going to come to your room and suggest we hook up just to get back at them."
"Well two reasons that would not have been a good idea 1. Sam was actually in the room last night, sleeping on the couch, but still there, and 2. Then we would be cheaters, much worse than anything they did because now were married."
"Yeah I know that is why I didn't come up there, but I sure thought about it."
They just sat there in silence.
"I guess we need to talk to them eventually" she said.
"Yeah I hate fighting with Tina. I guess I'll go find her and try not to walk away this time."
"You guys will work this out. She is your end game Mike."
"Sam is yours."
"I know."
Mike and Mercedes stood up and they hugged it out
"I'll go find Tina and talk this out with her. I'll see you later Mercy, and thanks for talking to me."
"Hey that's what friends are for" she said "and Mike"
"Yeah"
"Sam is still your best friend."
"Tina is still yours" he said and turned and walked back towards the house.
Sam was sitting in the sun room looking out the window. Mike walked in and saw him sitting there. He was about to turn and walk out when Sam saw him
"Hey Mike can we please talk"
"I have nothing to say to you" Mike said
"Well then can you listen to what I have to say?"
Mike agreed to listen to Sam "you got 5 minutes"
"I was an asshole that year man and I'm sorry. That incident with Tina was never supposed to happen."
"But it did."
"Yeah it did and again I am really sorry. Tina was really hurt over losing you and so was I about losing Benz. We leaned on each other to get through the hard times but it was just talking at first.
~Flashback~
"Tina what's wrong?" Sam asked
"It's Mike" she said sobbing
"What about him?"
"He came here and just destroyed my world again. Why did he have to do that again Sam? Why did he have to break my heart all over again?"
"Ok Tina what did Mike do?"
"When he helped with Grease he told me that maybe he rushed into breaking up with me, and maybe we could work things out and get back together again. I was so excited and wanted so badly to have him back in my life."
"Ok so where's the bad part?"
"So he's been gone a week and I call him to just talk to him and do you know I hear some girl in his room saying 'come back to bed Mikey I miss you' can you believe that? One week you go from wanting me back to some chick in your bed."
"Wow Tina I don't know what to say."
"You don't have to say anything I just need you to do something for me"
"Ok sure Tina what do you need me to do?"
"ME"
"Wait what"
"I need you to do me Sam. Make me forget about Mike."
Tina jumped on Sam's lap and began to straddle him and kiss him. Sam tried to push her off but Tina was stronger than she looked.
"Tina we can't do this Mike is my best friend and I am still in love with Mercedes your best friend. We can't do this"
"When was the last time you heard from Mercedes?"
"Not since Grease and even then we did not even speak, she would not even look at me."
Sam's heart began to break thinking about that moment he grabbed Tina and began to kiss her. At that moment he saw Mercedes and Tina saw Mike. They needed to feel someone warm against them and they were there for each other. As soon as it was over they felt the guilt.
"That was crazy" Sam said
"Yeah it was but I needed that" Tina said
"Yeah me too" Sam agreed
"Look this was just a moment of weakness and we won't let it happen again" Tina said
"Right" Sam said
~End of Flashback~
"That was not a one-time thing man, it happened all year." Mike snapped
"I know but it always happened either when she would call you or I would try to reach out to Cedes and she would ignore me. It doesn't make it right but that's what happened. I'm sorry man. I can't change the past if I could I would but I don't want to lose my best friend.
Mike knew in his heart that Sam was right and he did not want to lose his best friend either. He had hurt her and she needed a way to cope with the hurt.
"Look Sam I am not saying that things are going to instantly go back to the way things were I need some time to clear my head but I still want to be friends."
"I understand Mike. I'll give you as much time as you need."
"I'm going to go find Tina" Mike said he got up to leave "Mercy is out in the garden, you might want to go talk to her as well."
"I will, thanks Mike"
Mike walked out only to be replaced with Brittney.
"Good morning Sam" she said
"Brittney" Sam sighed.
"Look I know I am not your favorite person in the world right now but we need to talk."
"Actually I was on my way to talk to my wife."
"Well your 'wife' said we needed to clear up the issues you and I had so why don't we do that."
Sam knew she was right and he could not run from her anymore. The fact of the matter was Sam was wrong for what he did to Brittney and it was time he faced her about it.
"Ok Brittney let's talk"
"First of all let me say I HATE you Sam Evans. You have ruined some good moments in my life. You have taken up thoughts in my head in which could have been replaced with other good thoughts, but all I could think about was why this guy hurt me so much when all I did was love him. "I only have two questions to ask you, first question why why did you just leave like that?"
"I got freaked out" Sam said "I came over that night to tell you that I wanted to end it and tell you my plans to go to LA and try to get Cedes back, but things got so heated so quickly I didn't get a chance to say anything. Then you said that you were in love with me and I got scared cause I didn't want to hurt you. I thought we both knew what the relationship between us was, a distraction from missing Santana and Cedes."
"Well that is how it started out" she said "then it became more to me. You were so sweet and nice and not to mention the sex was amazing I just fell for you, hard. I thought it became more to you as well."
"I'm sorry Brittney I never intended it to get this way. Mercedes had my heart, and I always knew that. I was an asshole for even starting anything with you knowing how I felt about Cedes also knowing how you felt and still feel about Santana."
"You know" she said "that is all I ever wanted to hear from you was an apology."
"Yeah I know but like I said I'm an asshole sometimes. It takes me a bit longer to catch on to some things, but eventually I will come around.
"Second question, how could you cheat on me with Tina? Was it the whole time we were together?
"Again I am sorry Brittney I was hurt and confused about my feelings. Just like I was sad about losing Mercedes and you were sad about Santana leaving, Tina was going through the same thing with Mike. I don't know why I felt the need to help her in that way but I did and I am sorry for being dishonest with you.
"You know I came to this reunion to purposely make your life a living hell" Brittney said "I devised a great plan to make Mercedes so mad at you that she might think about leaving you, even though I knew she wouldn't because she loves you so much, but since you apologized I guess I don't need to go through with it.
"Thank you" Sam said "even though Mercedes is still mad but it has nothing to do with you. Look I'm going to go and try to make this right with Cedes you should go talk to Santana. I know you guys still got a connection."
"I don't know about that. It's been so long and we might have just grown apart since high school. I'm a different person now."
"That you are Ms. Pierce, but you're heart hasn't changed that much. Just think about it."
Sam got up and walked outside to go find Mercedes. She was still sitting in the gazebo.
"Benz" Sam said as he walked over to her "can we talk?"
He could tell she had been crying, he hated that once again he had made her cry.
"Sure Sam you want to talk, let's talk. How could you not tell me?" she asked
"I thought I was doing the right thing by not telling you about Tina and Brittney. I mean Tina is your best friend and what we did was-it just was, and I did not know how to tell you. I missed you and you were ignoring me…"
"So now you're blaming me?" Mercedes snapped.
"NO! Dammit I'm just so confused and I don't want to say the wrong thing." Sam replied
"Just tell me the truth Sam" she said "that is all I ever wanted from you was the complete truth."
"Ok fine I did blame you. I blamed you for breaking up with me and not fighting for us. When I came back to Lima I fought for our relationship, even when you were with Shane. I watched you walk away from me time after time and when we finally got back together you say we can't make it work long distance so you want to set me free. How in the HELL was I supposed to accept that."
Tears were pouring out of both their eyes.
"I thought I was doing the right thing Sam. I did not want you to go through your senior year waiting on phone calls, text messages, and Skype calls from me."
"That is what I wanted and I tried to tell you that. I never wanted to break up and you made that decision for me. I was angry, hurt, and confused. Then you would not even take my calls how do you think that made me feel Benz? You even came back for Grease and would not even speak to me I was devastated."
"Sam I'm so sorry. I was so hurt and I just thought you would be better off without me. I could not look at you because I knew if I looked at you I would break down."
"How could you think that? Baby when I gave you my heart it was forever. You are my better half and when you left my other half went crazy. That let me know that I could never be without you."
"Well you never will be without me again because I am not going anywhere, ever I promise."
He leaned in and they kissed with so much passion and fury. They had to pull away to catch their breath.
"Wow babe I really missed those lips" she said "wait I see you brought a guitar out here, were you going to sing to me?"
"I was prepared to pull out all the stops to get you back if I had to" he said.
"I would love to hear what you had planned."
"Ok I'll sing it but then its game on" he said with that lopsided grin of his.
"Game on? Oh I see" Mercedes remembered her punishment. He began to play the song.
Sometimes we wish for the better
When we have it good as it gets
Sometimes the grass isn't greener
Soon as we find out, we forget
Sometimes the fool doesn't know he's a fool
Sometimes a dog he don't know he's a dog
Sometimes I do stupid things to you
When I really don't mean it all
Sometimes a man
Is gonna be a man
It's not an excuse
It's just how it is
Sometimes the wrong
Don't know that they're wrong
Sometimes the strong
Ain't always so strong
Sometimes a girl
Is gonna be a girl
She don't wanna deal with all the drama in your world
God knows I don't mean to give it to you
So girl I'm sorry for the stupid things I wish I didn't do but I do
Oh so sorry, oh no, oh so sorry
Sometimes I wish I was smarter
Wish I was a bit more like you
Not making stupid decisions made at the last minute
You live to regret when it's through
Well, sometimes the fool doesn't know he's a fool
And sometimes a dog he don't know he's a dog
Sometimes I do stupid things to you
When I really didn't mean it all
Sometimes a man
Is gonna be a man
It's not an excuse
It's just how it is
Sometimes the wrong
Don't know that they're wrong
Sometimes the strong
Can't always be strong
Sometimes a girl
Is gonna be a girl
She don't wanna deal with all the drama in your world
God knows I don't mean to give it to you
So girl I'm sorry for the stupid things I wish I didn't do but I do
Sometimes the fool doesn't know he's a fool
Sometimes a dog he don't know he's a dog
Sometimes I do stupid things to you
When I really didn't mean it at all, at all
Sometimes a man
Is gonna be a man
It's not an excuse
It's just how it is
Sometimes the wrong
Don't know that they're wrong
Sometimes the strong
Ain't always so strong
Sometimes a girl
Is gonna be a girl
She don't wanna deal with all the drama in your world
God knows I don't mean to give it to you
So girl I'm sorry for the stupid things I wish I didn't do but I do
"I love you Benz and I'm so sorry" Sam said hugging his wife
"I know boo, and I love you too."
"So can I ask you a question Benz?"
"Sure babe" Mercedes said
"How many guys did you date that year in LA?"
"Really Sam, you are going to ask me that just after I forgave you."
"I am just curious I'm not going to get all crazy jealous or anything, I just want to know."
"Fine Sam if you must know I went out on a few dates while in LA and went out with one particular guy for about two months."
"So you dated this guy"
"Yes Sam I did"
"That's fine, we were broken up and I'm ok with it" Sam said trying to reassure him.
"I'm glad you're ok with everything, so you were saying something about my punishment?" Mercedes smirked
"Yeah I did but…"
"But what Sam come on I need to be punished." Mercedes whined
"Mercy did you sleep with that guy? I just need to know. Not that it will change anything I just need to know."
"No Sam I did not sleep with him or any other guy in LA. You are the only guy I have ever wanted to sleep with. You know I only sleep with guys I love and you are the only man I deemed worthy enough to get with 'all this' is that what you needed to hear babe."
Sam was super excited about what he just heard he could not contain his emotions he did a fist pump in the air "yeah it is thanks babe."
"You are such a dork" Mercedes giggled
"Yeah but I'm you're dork" Sam replied "now about your punishment" he jumped up and grabbed her and they ran to their room.
A/N So I hope you liked this chapter. Up next we will see Mike/Tina/Kurt/Blaine/Brittney/Mercedes Stay tuned.
BTW PLEASE REVIEW!