A/N: Okay, I don't know if I made this clear or not, but I quite obviously have a bit of a kink for BDSM. However, this is the aspect that I think about the most. I haven't acted on anything with bdsm yet because I'm still in high school, so I wouldn't know for sure, but if I had to pick one thing to be my overall kink it would be this.
Forgive any OOCness. Some of it is essential to the story.
TW: Bondage, BDSM, humiliation, rules, exhibitionism
When the game ended and a new world was created, everyone who had died had returned on the meteor. Nobody just appeared on earth, instead they woke up in a random room on the meteor, wandering around until finding the others. The meteor was heading towards the new world, and Jade said that she would direct it away as soon as all of you were close enough for her to bring you down to the Earth's surface. This took about 3 years. Now, by this time, everyone was about 17 or 18 (in human years), so of course there's gonna be a lot of hooking up.
Almost everyone was paired up. Rose and Kanaya, Dave and Terezi, Jade and Davesprite, Equius and Aradia, Tavros and Gamzee, Eridan and Sollux, hell, even Nepeta and Vriska (they decided to just be kismeses). All except for John and Karkat.
Now, it was obvious to everyone except John, that Karkat liked John. It was obvious that John felt the same way, almost as obvious as the fact that he didn't even realize it himself. He kept calling Karkat some variation of friend, bringing movies, and engaging in 'platonic cuddles'. Everyone could see Karkat was slowly losing it, and one day would snap. So, Vriska shoved her moirail in a pile, and slapped some sense into him. She dragged him to Karkat's door, knocked, and ran like hell. John was about to yell at her when Karkat opened the door.
Karkat decided to open with something about why the fuck John was waking him up right now and John was mentally trying to decide how to say that he liked him when he just decided, to hell with it, and kissed him.
Needless to say, Karkat was very confused.
After much sorting it out, they ended up in a relationship. During the honeymoon phase it was very happy, but after that phase ended, Karkat seemed like he was happy, but not satisfied.
Now, while this is all happening, let it be noted that the meteor was very open about sex. As stated, hormones were raging. People and trolls did not really care what happened. There were threeways, fourways, and that one night that Gamzee snuck slime into the food that everybody pretended to forget, but everyone remembered everything.
Anyway, back to John and Karkat. They had a great sex life, once John became a bit more open minded, and once Karkat started making excuses to avoid it, John sat him down and asked him what was up. Karkat was very closed off about it, but John wouldn't shut up, and eventually Karkat caved.
Karkat wanted to be taken charge of. He wanted someone to govern his daily life. He wanted someone to tell him when he could wear clothes and when he could speak and when he could come. John agreed to give it a try.
John thought it was the best thing in this new universe.
So, after an extremely awkward conversation with Jade about codes for collars, and messing around with the alchemiter, for Karkat's birthday later on in the year, John gave him a collar. It was silver, with a latch that he somehow used his wind powers to open and close, with a ring on the front and a ring on the back. It had a single tag hanging down from the front with John's wind symbol on it. Karkat was thrilled
It took them months to figure everything out, come up with limits and rules, learn what each other was and was not okay with, but eventually they knew each other well enough that they decided to transition into this lifestyle.
The next day, Karkat followed John out to breakfast with the collar on.
John had given Karkat permission to speak freely and move freely when they were with their friends, only a few restrictions. He wasn't allowed to be in a different room than John and if John asked something of him, he had to excuse himself and do it immediately.
When people noticed the collar, questions were asked. Karkat sat next to John, holding his hand, carefully explaining everything about how they would be from now on, leaving out some of the more personal details. He told them he would be allowed to talk to them normally whenever he was with them, so nothing would really change, he would just have a different priority above everything else. It was a big deal for all of ten minutes.
A few months later, they moved into what was not essentially a human-troll inhabited earth. The hemospectrum was more of a formality, less enforced but still there, and the young adults heard stories about the gods who had saved them. Luckily, nobody recognized them as long as they didn't wear their god tier clothing.
Over the past year or so, Karkat and John's relationship blossomed. They grew into the routine more, and their bond grew to the point where both of them depended on each other equally. Then something happened.
John had been video chatting with Dave when Karkat got home one day, and forgot to close the chat window. He left his laptop open while he went down to greet Karkat. Dave decided this would be a great opportunity for blackmail, so he set the window to record and muted it while doing other work on his laptop.
Later that night, when John and Karkat moved their activities to the bedroom, Karkat caught a glimpse of Dave in the webcam. While it was obvious he wasn't paying attention, he was turned to the side just messing with his turntables, Karkat found it extremely arousing. So when he looked directly at the webcam as he came, he assumed Dave wouldn't see it.
The next day, Dave skimmed through the video, seeing if there was anything good on it. He came to the point where John and Karkat were making out, John grabbing Karkat's collar, while they entered the bedroom. He thought for a moment about closing it, but he didn't really know what was up between them, so he decided on a whim to watch it. The fact that John was there kept him from being turned on, but what surprised him, was when Karkat's eyes looked right at the webcam as he came. Wow, John pranked him back good.
He congratulated said prankster and when John didn't know what he was talking about, Dave snorted.
TG: come on
TG: karkles stared into the camera at the last second
TG: remember when we were video chatting
TG: and you forgot to close it
John promptly told him to hold on and found his boyfriend. He asked about it, and Karkat turned more shades of red than John could count, and said he didn't think Dave was watching. John asked why he would even look and Karkat said something quietly. He was told to repeat it louder, so he did.
"I don't know, I think I just liked the fact that he could watch me." Oh, wow, John could do a lot with this information.
John went back to Dave and explained. Then, he told Dave his idea.
EB: ok so this is gonna sound crazy but
EB: karkat likes being watched
EB: i know thats a kink but i dont know what its called
TG: im pretty sure thats exhibitionism man
EB: no not like that hes embarrassed but
EB: he likes being embarrassed?
EB: i guess
TG: hold on let me wikipedia that shit
TG: yep
TG: erotic humiliation
EB: humiliation
EB: thats it
EB: anyway
EB: would it be sick and disgusting for me to ask you if you would be willing for me to use you as
EB: like an onlooker
EB: you wouldnt even have to watch
EB: just mute it and minimize it
TG: idk man
TG: id have to ask rezi about it i mean i got no problem but
EB: if it helps with terezi ill probably be using it as punishment
EB: but you could phrase it as justice
Terezi agreed immediately.
Over the next few months, John convinced a few other people to be in the same position as Dave. It was usually Rose, Kanaya, Dave or Terezi, but he'd gotten a few other people to try it as well. They didn't enjoy it as much though, so he didn't ask them about it again.
It was never in person though. Sometimes it was video chat, sometimes it was voice, or even type. But never in person.
Now whenever their friends had parties, John would let Karkat be generally free as long as he followed those two rules. But then there was this one day where Dave and Terezi were having a movie night with Rose, Kanaya, John, and Karkat...
"Master, I'm sorry!" He screamed, tear running down his face. "I couldn't help it I'm so sorry." You don't hit him. Instead, you don't even look at him. You don't touch him, you don't comfort him, you just let him cry at your feet.
"You're not sorry yet." You lock him in the room. The special room you two had dedicated to this purpose in your house. You go into your bedroom, sitting on the edge of your bed. You put your hands in your hair and you let out a sigh.
You need a good punishment for this. But a punishment has to fit the crime.
He came without your permission. While you weren't even home.
You looked around the room, trying to think of something that he would enjoy so much that it would be torture not to let him come. Then you saw your computer.
If it was okay with them, you had a plan.
- ectoBiologist [EB] began pestering turntechGodhead [TG] at 17:03 -
EB: dave
EB: can i talk to you about something
EB: its totally cool if you say no
EB: i dont even know why im asking
EB: youll definitely say no but i have to ask anyway
EB: plus you have to talk to kanaya and rose anyway
EB: i bet theyre already there
EB: yeah sorry were not
TG: dude calm down
TG: what is it
EB: ok so
EB: you know how i let karkat act normal around everyone in person
TG: yeah
EB: well he did something super bad today
EB: and i was wondering
EB: is there any way that i can take that away for tonight or would it be too weird
TG: what do you mean
EB: its not gonna be like a sex party
EB: well who knows it doesnt matter that much to me
EB: but like
EB: i dont let him wear clothes and he cant talk or leave my side and has to have the leash on
EB: i dont let him act normal
TG: woah what the hell did he even do
EB: do you actually want to know or are you just asking for irony
TG: naw
TG: youre usually pretty lenient as long as he doesnt break any important rules or whatever
EB: well the rule he broke was pretty important...
TG: spill
EB: ...
EB: he touched himself while i wasnt home and finished
EB: without my permission
TG: is that like super bad in the world of chains and whips
EB: i wish youd stop calling it that
EB: but yeah
EB: thats like
EB: the number one rule
TG: damn
TG: lemme put rezi on and you can see with her i dont really give a shit
EB: wait dave!
TG: H3Y JOHN :]
EB: oh hey terezi
TG: D4V3 1S S4Y1NG SOM3TH1NG 4BOUT YOU W4NT1NG TO PUN1SH K4RKL3S 4T OUR MOV13 N1GHT
EB: uh
EB: yeah
TG: WHY
EB: well its kind of weird if you dont really know the rules
TG: 1TS MY MOV13 N1GHT
TG: 1 G3T TO KNOW
EB: well
EB: when i was at work
EB: he touched himself and let himself come
EB: without my permission
TG: HOW 1MPORT4NT 1S TH4T RULE? :?
EB: its like
EB: the most important one
TG: ...
EB: its totally up to you
EB: i really understand if its too weird for you
EB: just let me know soon
EB: ...
EB: terezi?
TG: dude
EB: what
TG: she just ran towards rose and kanaya screaming
TG: and i quote
TG: "TH3 ONLY TH1NG W3R3 S3RV1NG TON1GHT 1S JUST1C3"
EB: so
TG: thats a yes dude
TG: bring all the s&m your little heart desires
EB: ok
EB: thanks dave
TG: no problem man
TG: even though we all kind of help out a tiny bit
TG: im pretty sure none of us know exactly how the whole slave thing works
TG: rose probably doesnt even understand it
TG: i dont know about everyone else but
TG: im pretty curious
EB: well tonight will probably help a lot
EB: it depends on how the night turns out
EB: okay i gotta go get karkat ready
EB: ill see you in like a half hour
- ectoBiologist [EB] ceased pestering turntechGodhead [TG] at 17:32 -
Perfect.
Why the fuck did you do that. It was only 20 minutes before he got home. You could have made it that long.
Your heat cycles are a bitch.
This was the first time you ever slipped up on this rule, and you never would again. Never mind any way he punished you, the look on his face when he realized made you break down crying the moment you saw it.
You're not bringing that much, because you don't know exactly how far tonight will go, but you bring enough just in case. You bring enough rope to be able to keep him from moving, a light flogger, a blindfold, a spider gag, a leash, and a bulge ring. You take out the leash and the bulge ring, holding them while you captchalogue the other pieces of equipment. Leaving it by the door and grabbing a pair of shoes and a hoodie, you walk back to the room he's in.
You unlock the door, seeing him curled up in the corner of the bed, slightly shaking. You clear your throat and he turns toward you, so much hope in his eyes that you almost break down.
Almost. You need to reiterate that this is not okay. You by the edge of his bed, facing the middle of it.
"Come here." He almost trips over himself but kneels in front of you. You drop the leash, seeing that he hadn't noticed it yet, and use your hand to push his shoulder until he falls backwards. Unwilling to be slow and sweet, you pry his legs open and begin to brush your hand against his sheath. He sighs lightly, not making a sound for fear of upsetting you further, and allows himself to relax. Moments later, his bulge comes out of his sheath. He gasps at the contact with the air, but doesn't have time to revel in the sensation because moments later, the ring is around the base of his bulge. He makes a choked moan, but you let that slide this one time. "Sit up." He obeys, wincing slightly at the feeling. You don't use the bulge ring often, trusting him to hold off his own climax until you've permitted him, but you plan on torturing him tonight.
"Close your eyes." He listens to you, and you lean down to get the leash. You clip it to the back of his neck before tugging him to the floor. "You may open them now." His eyes open again and he looks up to you. He opens his mouth for a moment, and you nod almost imperceptibly, giving him permission to speak.
"Where are we going Master?"
"Did you forget about tonight? We have Dave and Terezi's movie night." His eyes widen considerably and his face turns bright red before he speaks again.
"B-but Ma-"
"Quiet, pet." You stroke his hair gently. He leans into your touch, still uneasy but wanting to repay you for disobeying. "It's just to make sure you'll never do it again. Understand?" He looks at the ground, obviously still upset, but willing to trust you.
"Yes Master." He says. You smile.
"Good." You bring him down into your closed garage and you put him in the backseat of the car, unwilling to let other people see your toy.
This is going to be interesting.
When you arrive at Dave and Terezi's, you tell Karkat to wait in the car. You walk up to the front door and walk inside without even knocking. Hearing voices in the kitchen, you head over there.
"Oh hello John." Rose's voice greets you first and you smile, giving her a quick hug before doing the same to Kanaya. You and Dave exchange a fist bump while Terezi just kind of smiles that terrifying smile she has. It's endearing, to a point, but terrifying just the same.
"Hey guys! I trust that Dave told you what's kind of, uh, going on tonight?" You blush and avoid eye contact.
"Yes, he has. Where is Karkat, anyway?" Kanaya asks.
"I told him to wait in the car. First of all, I need Dave to open the garage because he's not comfortable walking to the door without wearing anything. But that's not the only reason why I'm in here." Rose raises an eyebrow without responding, so you just continue.
"I felt like I should tell you a bit more about our dynamic and some of the rules. We've never acted that way too much around you, and what you have seen was just heat of the moment stuff, so you don't know too much of the way we act towards each other.
"Basically, I need him just as much as he needs me, and we love each other, but he also has a certain loyalty to me. There's no other way to say it other than, he lives to make me happy. It sounds bad and not nearly as deep as it is like that, but that's the basis. On the flip side, I'm here to better him, except better him in a different way than people normally better each other. Basically, I show him how to be obedient, and once he's completely obedient to me, it's beautiful because he still has an air of independence but with a submissive side shown as well. I don't expect you guys to understand it, but it'll make more sense when we're around each other.
"I also tend to get a lot more...malicious. I'll be just as nice towards you guys, and I'll act all smiley, but its with an intent in the background that makes it different. Again, you'll understand it more when you see it.
"Lastly, though, I just wanted to brief you guys on the basic rules that we go by when we're alone, but the same set that we'll go by today. One, he's not allowed to touch himself or finish without permission, that's kind of why he's here. Two, he can't speak or do anything without my permission, and he can't leave the room I'm in. Three, when there are other people in the room he must stay kneeled by me unless I ask him otherwise. Four, anything that I let others do, he has to take it as if it were an order from me." By the time you're done with your speech, you're out of breath and everyone is looking at you. Nobody speaks for about 30 seconds, but this time it's Kanaya again.
"So, he has no limits, only what you say?" She looks confused.
"No, no no no. Him and I know each others' limits. I can't tell you because that's incredibly personal, but he does have a safeword to use around other people. If he has a gag in, I'll be watching him and I can tell if it's too hard for him, and I'll say the safeword. It's Skaia, so if he ever says that, stop what you're doing immediately or I will hurt you." You probably look scary, but you're not letting anyone push Karkat.
"We can still watch the movie right?" Dave asks, before getting shushed by Terezi.
"Yeah, we can act normal, he's just going to be there. Feel free to ask about doing anything to him though, I brought a little bit of equipment, but not much. If we do end up doing something though, it may be a good idea to put out an old blanket or something."
"There's no way I'm watching that movie when I have this opportunity." There's that smile again. Terezi cackles and you just kind of make a mental note to watch her and Karkat together. You know how he's sometimes on edge around her.
"Okay, one last thing, no matter what ends up happening, he has a bulge ring on." You flush red from saying those words without Karkat around, he makes you so much more confident with these things. "It's kind of his punishment because he finished without my permission, now I get to essentially torture him and he can't react the way he wants to." Rose nods at this, still seeming to process all the information. "Dave, can you show me how to open the garage?" Dave starts to go, but Rose interjects.
"I'll show you John." Oh god, what is she going to say. When you two walk into the garage, she shows you the button but before you press it she puts a hand on your arm.
"John, as a psychologist, I'm not sure that this sort of thing is normal. I haven't had any patients that were in as devout of a BDSM lifestyle as you two are, but I know that some psychologists think that these practices are harmful to one or both of the participants." You shake your head at her.
"Rose, I'm sorry but, you don't get it. I love him more than life. I'd never hurt him. The reason we do this is because he enjoys being taken control of, and I enjoy controlling. We do it in a safe, consensual way. We took it slow. We didn't use any sort of gag until I could read his eyes like a book, and we take care of any small bruises that end up happening. I know I said this a lot in there, but trust me. It makes a lot more sense once you see it. A lot of people do this kind of stuff in bed anyway, even lightly. We just add more of the everyday stuff in. Who knows, you might just enjoy it a bit." You love her, you do, but if she starts doubting this, you're not sure you'll be able to take it. When Jade discovered exactly how everything worked, she got so angry at you until you showed her how you two acted around each other. She was skeptical but when she saw how, at the end of the night, you gave him a back massage while he told you anything he was kind of iffy on that happened that day, she realized that you were right.
"Alright John. I trust you." She goes back inside, and you press the button, only now realizing you had been gone for almost 20 minutes. When you walk to the car, you see Karkat exactly how you left him, having only turned his head to look out the window. When he sees you he smiles. You walk into the front seat and move the car a little bit closer to the garage. Once it's as close as it's going to get, you turn off the car and walk to his door. You open it, pulling him out and rushing him into the garage, making sure nobody saw him. Once he's there you lock the car, close the garage, and go to stand in front of the door opening into the house.
"Hey," you put your hand underneath his chin, bringing his face towards yours. "This is okay, right?"
"Yes, Master." You put your arms around him.
"Shh, no Master right now, just John." You hear him let out a sigh and put his arms around you. You can feel the outline of his wrist cuffs on your back and you can see the edge of the ones around his ankle, but you don't pay attention to that right now.
"Yeah, John, I'm just nervous."
"I know. It must be scary."
"It is."
"If it helps, I just went in there and kind of gave them a brief so you don't have to sit there while I explain much." You hear him sigh.
"Thanks." You kiss his cheek.
"No problem. If it gets too scary, they know the safe word too, so don't be nervous to say it. Whenever you can't speak, I'll be looking at you. And if it ever gets too bad, close your eyes and pretend its just video chatting, okay?" You can feel him nodding into your shoulder.
"Okay." You give him one last kiss on his forehead before unwrapping your arms from him and grabbing the leash. "Get down Karkat."
"Yes Master." He gets onto his knees, and you open the door. You walk slowly down the hallway, hearing his breathing get a bit heavier. He seems to be staring daggers into the floor rather than look up, but this must be nerve wracking. Finally, you reach the kitchen, and you bring him in there. His shoulders are flushing red which means his face must be so red that the grey in his skin is nearly unnoticeable. You say hello to everyone and lean against the island, smiling when he kneels beside you as he's supposed to, even if he's facing a wooden wall. You tap him on the shoulder and when he looks up at you you gesture for him to stand up, making sure the gesture is above the table so it's obvious to everyone what you're doing. He may not want them to, but it'd be better for him if you didn't have to explain every little thing. He stands up slowly, keeping his arms crossed in front of him, looking straight down at the island. You finish re-saying your hellos when Kanaya does something surprising.
"Hello Karkat." Oh this will be interesting.
He doesn't even look up when he replies. "Hey Kanaya." Wrong.
"Karkat." The hand that was stroking his hair tightens slightly. He breathes a deep breath in before he corrects himself.
"I'm sorry. Hello Ma'am." Kanaya raises an eyebrow at you questioningly.
"Rules." You explain, hoping she'd understand. She seems to get the message quick enough, and you make small talk with Dave in order to keep the complete silence out of the room. After a few minutes, it looks like Karkat is about to pass out, so you decide to take a bit of pity on him. "Hey guys, why don't we move into the TV room and start the movie?" Everyone agrees and they walk there. Karkat makes to get on his hands and knees again, but you grab his arm. "You can walk." Normally, he'd be glad to walk rather than crawl, but his bulge is out and he can't retract it because of the ring so walking is a blatant 'oh look I'm naked with a collar on' gesture. After a few seconds, though, he gives in.
"Yes Master." You smile and grab his leash, starting to walk towards the TV room. He follows behind you, obviously trying to stay close enough that people can't look at him that much. You sit on one of the couches, next to Dave and Terezi. He kneels down, trying to keep his bulge between his legs rather than above them. Terezi puts on the movie and everyone settles down, getting ready to watch.
Even with the movie on, it's still horribly awkward. Everyone can tell. Didn't they seem excited for this?
Eventually, everyone relaxes. Dave starts cracking more jokes and even Karkat chuckles under his breath a couple times. Your hand is over the arm of the couch, stroking his hair.
To your surprise, it's Kanaya, again, that makes the first comment about something other than the movie. Thank god for Kanaya.
"John?" You look over towards her, to find her looking towards Karkat with a bit of an interested look on her face.
"Yeah?"
"What are those on his wrists?" You look over at his wrists crossed on his legs. Normally he'd be in a lot of trouble for that, but at this point you're willing to let one or two things go.
"Oh, those are his cuffs. He has them on his ankles too, they're really just used when I need to secure him to places."
"Did you sew them yourself?"
"Haha, no. I did a bit of the softer layer, but theres no way I can work with leather. One of the other people in our group showed them to me when he started to get marks on his wrists." She's quiet for a few seconds, biting her lip. She seems to be considering something. After about a minute, you give up, assuming that she didn't want to, when she speaks again.
"May I see them?" Oh finally. You give her a big smile, hoping she'll see the grateful look on your face.
"Sure! Karkat?" You gesture over towards her and he looks up at you, letting you see his eyes for the first time since you came in. To your surprise, you don't see any sort of apprehension. You see quite a bit of nervousness, even a bit of fear, but he's determined to do this for you.
"Yes Master." He leans forward onto his hands and knees and crawls over towards her, going back to resting on his knees when he's in front of her. He's more in the stream of light coming from the TV, so his bulge is more noticeable, and he can tell, attempting to keep his face down but he doesn't hesitate when he holds up one of his arms to her.
"The bottom layer of fabric is cotton and the top is leather, as I said." You love those. They look beautiful against his skin, the leather black for him but the fabric a navy blue. The ones on his ankles are exactly the same, each of the four cuffs holding a single ring to attach things to.
"Is the leather secured to the fabric or is it just tight enough on top to keep the bottom layer down?"
"I actually asked that myself. The woman who made these threaded the thread through the leather so you can't see it on the top, but it is indeed attached the cups."
"I never would have thought of that." She takes a bit of a closer look, and when she sees that it's true she makes a noise of surprise but then simply gives him control of his wrist again. She smiles to Rose for a moment and Karkat looks awkwardly between her and then to you. He looks at you like he wants you to give him an order, but you just raise an eyebrow. If he wants something, he needs to ask. He looks at her, biting his lip before speaking.
"May I...?" She looks at him and he looks back at you.
"Oh, yes." He looks relieved and he simply crawls back to you, but you look at him with a bit of a frown on your face.
"Karkat."
"Yes Master?"
"You didn't address her correctly." He looks up at you with a bit of regret. He really wants to please you tonight, doesn't he?
"I'm sorry Master, I'm sorry Ma'am as well." He adds looking at Kanaya, enough so she can see his face but he doesn't meet her eyes. You really need to do something to break the ice.
"Karkat? Would you leave us alone for a few minutes? Maybe go in the garage and wait, please?" You look at him and hope he gets the message that you're going to try and fix this. He must get something because he looks at you with no sadness or anger, and just replies with a simple 'yes Master' and gets up and walks away. You grab the remote from Dave and pause the movie.
"Okay, listen. This is not going to get any less awkward if nobody tries. If you've changed your mind about this being okay, tell me now. I can take Karkat home, and never involve you guys in anything like this again. But for fucks sake, either do something, ask us to leave, or just relax. You don't have to interact with him in order to relax, but it's making him extremely uncomfortable for everyone to be silent, and honesty it's not that much fun for me either." You don't glare at them, you just give them a matter of fact look. "You can talk directly to him, he's allowed to speak, just not without getting spoken to first. Just tell me which of those three routes you'd like to take."
"John, I'm not sure about Dave and Terezi, but Kanaya and I aren't opposed to this, we just don't know where to start." That's understandable, you're having a bit of trouble with that too. But first, you need to know what Dave and Terezi's standings are on this. You look to Terezi first.
"I'd prefer not to start anything but once it's already happening I'll definitely take part in it." She shrugs, looking towards Dave just as the rest of you do.
"I have absolutely no fucking clue what to do." Ah thats the Dave you know. Says it like it is.
"Well before we can figure out what to do, I need to know which of those three you'd be most comfortable with." You hope he isn't against the first. Everyone else agreed, and it'd be such a great punishment.
"I'm not really opposed to any of them, I just don't get what exactly one is supposed to do in these situations." Okay. Good. You can work with that.
"Ask him to do anything. You can tell him to get you a drink of water, grab a different movie, anything. If you make each one getting dirtier bit by bit then you can get it to the point where it flows naturally. Or, if you'd like to do something quote unquote ironic, someone can ask him to grab something and you can wolf whistle at him when he comes back in. Frankly, anything. Just remember, I really do not mind sharing because I know that he's mine, and even if he looks terrified, he really really enjoys this. That's why its such a great punishment; something he's going to love but he still can't come." Dave looks a bit less confused so you decide to change this to something he might understand more. "Okay, Dave, have you ever seen bondage porn?"
"Psh, what porn haven't I seen."
"Treat it like that. Because, in all honesty, when it comes to the sex parts, that's essentially what it is. If you guys want to see what I brought with me you can, maybe it'll give you more ideas." Kanaya and Rose look to each other and nod before Rose speaks.
"I can't speak for everyone but Kanaya and I support that."
"Sure man." Dave speaks up, looking a bit more interested in it. Better.
"Okay, let's see." You open up your captchalogue and look inside. "Okay so here's a blindfold, it's pretty simple but always fun." You show them the black mask. "Next here's a spider gag. I'm sure the one you've always seen in porn is the ball gag, but this one's so much more useful."
"Why?" Terezi chimes in.
"Well, it holds his mouth open." You chuckle, showing them how it would work on your hand. "Next, and I swear to god Dave if you reference 'land of whips and chains', is a flogger." You take out the device. "I normally use something different with him, but these are very unlikely to harm him more than a bruise or two, and you guys have no practice with the others." You take out the rope. "Finally, what every BDSM scene needs, rope. It can be cut up, this isn't some of the highest quality rope I have. It's actually mainly used to take places." You have a pretty good amount of rope. "Any ideas?" Surprisingly, Terezi is the first to speak.
"Well, isn't one of the staples of the whole humiliation thing just teasing?"
"Yeah, pretty much."
"What if two people made a bet on how well he could pour something with his wrists tied together and make it like a difficult task. Once he screws it up doesn't that make it easier to justify the rest of the scene?" Five stars to Terezi.
"That's actually really perfect. What do you guys have to pour that wouldn't mess up the floor?"
"Why not just water." Dave says. "If it's just a segway, it doesn't really have to be a big deal? I have some cheap wine glasses we can use, and we can get one of those annoying pitchers that's difficult if you don't have two hands."
"Awesome. I do not know your house that well, so could you grab that?"
"Sure, but first I'm getting a goddamn blanket. I don't want red staining these wood floors." Dave walks up the stairs to presumably get the blanket and you turn towards the other three.
"So, who wants to make a bet? If it's against me, then I can bet something to do with Karkat."
"I'll do it." Rose chimes in. "Old rivalries, eh?" She winks. They're all getting a lot more comfortable which is great.
"Hehe, definitely. So I'll make a bet that he can, and you say he can't. Just bet something, it doesn't really matter." You think for a moment. "Actually, make it money. I don't have my wallet on me so I can say that I have to bet with Karkat."
"Alright." She nods. "What are you going to have him do when you lose?"
"Hmm... it depends if we want to get the ball rolling fast, or slow."
"Let's do slow, but not too slow." She replies after thinking for a moment.
"Would you like to try and use the flogger?" You grin. "I'm thinking 10 strokes?"
"It's a bet." She grins and Kanaya smiles at the two of you. A few minutes later, Dave comes back in with the blanket, laying it down on the floor so that it covers the entire thing.
"Pitcher, tray, and glasses are in the kitchen."
"Let's do this." You get up and go to the garage. You see Karkat, sitting on the steps up the door and when he turns around he smiles at you sadly.
"Hey, hey, are you okay?" You sit down besides him, rubbing his back.
"I'm so sorry about today, I didn't want to, I just, I couldn't-" He starts to cry a little bit.
"Shush, shush. It's okay. Tonight, even though it's a punishment, is going to be fun, okay?" You wipe the tears off his face, smiling.
"Okay." He gives you a little smile back. You kiss his nose quickly before standing up again.
"Let's go back in." He follows you back and when he goes to kneel by the couch, you pull him onto your lap instead. He smiles and snuggles into you a bit. For now, you just watch the movie.
After about 20 minutes, you and Rose exchange a look. Looks like it's time to begin.
"This movie is boooorrrriiiiiinnnngggggg." You groan.
"John, be quiet. I happen to like this movie." Thank god Rose can play along. You wait about two more minutes.
"Rose." She ignores you. "Rose." Another minute goes by. "Roseeee." She finally acknowledges you.
"Yes, John?"
"Wanna make a bet?" That got Karkat's attention. He knows scenarios like these. Rose turns away from Kanaya a bit and faces you a bit more, resting her elbows on her knees.
"What kind of bet?"
"I bet that Karkat can pour a glass of water with his wrists tied together." Now that you think about it, it was kind of a shitty way to start this out, but hey they're new at it. Rose raises an eyebrow at you.
"No. There's no way he can do that."
"I bet you he can." Karkat's starting to squirm in your lap.
"Fine. I'll take that bet."
"What do I get if I win?"
"I'll give you $50."
"Ughhhh but I don't have moneyyyy." Karkat SO knows where this is going.
"I guess you'll have to find some other way." You glance sideways at Karkat. You're certain he knows what's going to happen, but you're determined not to break character.
"Would you take ten strokes to Karkat with the flogger?" You waggle your eyebrows at her for extra effect. She appears to think about this for a second.
"Deal."
"Yessssss." You turn off the movie, dimming the lights a bit less but still keeping them fairly dark. "Dave, can you show Karkat where to grab everything."
"Sure." You unclip Karkat's leash and he stands up, quietly following Dave into the kitchen. You quickly go over to rose and whisper in her ear.
"A tip: make him count them and/or thank you for them." You sit back in your seat, taking out the rope you have. Soon Karkat is back, carrying the pitcher in two hands. He puts it down and then goes back to get the cups. Dave's back on the couch, and you're excited to get into this. He comes back with said cups and puts them down on the carpet, looking to you for what to do next. Luckily, he seems to have gotten over his shyness, because he's standing there, not trying to hide his bulge. You gesture for him to come to you, so he does and kneels in front of you. "Hold out your wrists." He does so, and you pass the rope between the cuffs before wrapping it around, twisting to make them as stiff as you can in a shorter length of rope. You tie it off and cut the rope, captchaloguing the rest of it.
"Go on Karkat, win me $50." You laugh. Your friends are probably starting to see the crueler side of you, but soon it'll come out of them too. He starts to crawl over and kneels in front of the cups, looking to you. You nod and watch as he puts the cups on top of the tray, the blanket keeping it a bit unbalanced, before he turns to the pitcher. He looks at it for a moment, seemingly formulating how he's going to accomplish this. Eventually, he attempts something a lot smarter than you had planned for.
He hooks the handle of it behind the ropes of his cuffs, using his hands to grab the sides of it. Once he attempts lifting it up, and its held fairly stable, he goes to pour it into the cup. He gets about 1/3 of the way through before the handle slips, causing the pitcher to fall. He curses under his breath and looks up at you with wide eyes, but you just let out an over dramatic sigh and pout.
"I was gonna buy a new video game." You say dreamily.
"Well, you better cough up." Rose says expectantly. You make a slight scoffing noise but put the pitcher and cups towards the side of the room.
"Karkat, get on your hands and knees in the center."
"Yes Master." While you see nervousness in his eyes, you see a bit of anticipation as well. He moves into the place you asked, his hands still tied together, causing his balance to be slightly off. You captchalogue the flogger and hand it to Rose.
"It works like this, right?" She cracks it forward onto his ass, a lot quicker than you thought. See, you knew they'd enjoy this. Karkat lets out a noise and flinches forward a bit. Ignoring him, you chuckle.
"Yes, Rose, it works like that." She laughs a bit in return.
"Karkat, why don't you count these?" She says to him. He turns his head to you, and you a see a look of contempt that looked so fake you just tried not to laugh. "Well?" He seemed to forget what she had said.
"Yes Ma'am." She grins.
She does the first next one, right on top of his ass just as before. She does quite a few on his ass, adding one on his upper thighs for good measure. He somehow counts each one, even the particularly hard last one she lands on his ass.
"Well that was fun." She hands you back the flogger. "What else can we use him for?" By now Dave, Terezi, and Kanaya are standing around him as well.
"I have an idea." Terezi walks towards you and giggles, whispering an idea into your ear. By the end, you're grinning widely.
"Perfect." You uncaptchalogue the blindfold, instructing Karkat to kneel before putting it around his eyes. Then you get the spider gag, forcing his mouth open before adjusting it to the highest setting and fastening it behind his back. You hand Rose back the flogger. "Here, Rose, you can do that again." She grins. "Not this second though. Karkat, Terezi suggested we play a game. You like games, don't you?" He can't speak so he just nods. "Someone's going to fuck your face and after they've finished all over your pretty features, you're gonna guess who they are. If you get it wrong, you get another ten strokes." He's shaking slightly, but you notice his bulge is starting to get a bit wet. "Understand?" He nods again, and this time you point your finger around the four of you with bulges, an eyebrow raised as to seemingly question who wants to go first. Nobody volunteers so you point to yourself and nod at them. They all nod and you move in front of Karkat's mouth.
You should probably be a bit shy about your dick, but those years on the meteor made everyone except Karkat extremely un-shy. Karkat would always be shy about his bulge, because it matches his blood color. You unzip your jeans, pulling your half hard dick out, putting it into Karkat's forced-open mouth. It soon starts to harden from the warmth, and once it's completely hard, you tangle your fingers in his hair and start fucking his face. You shove your dick as far down his throat as you can, feeling him gag on it slightly. You pull out slightly, before repeating the action. This continues until you're extremely close to finishing, so you push inside of him fully, and the moment you come, you pull out and shoot it over his face. You zip up your jeans, tucking your dick inside of them completely, before Rose makes an appearance.
"Exactly who was that Karkat?" She asks, unfastening the gag just enough that he can speak.
"Master." He doesn't have any trace of hesitation in his voice. You laugh and squat down in front of him, shoving two of your fingers in his mouth.
"Of course you'd know exactly what my dick tasted like, wouldn't you?" Everyone laughs, including you, and Karkat just blushes as you replace the gag.
This time, Terezi volunteers. She steps forward, pulling her bulge out of her pants before putting it inside of Karkat's mouth. Doing the actions that you just did, she gets into a steady rhythm. It takes her a bit longer than you to come, it's just how trolls are built, but when she does his face gets drenched in teal, and he's forced to swallow quite a bit of it too. You unfasten the gag, and wait for his answer.
"Kanaya?" He sounds unsure, and it's only reinforced when Rose smacks the flogger against his ass. After five, Terezi asks to try, so she gets to give him the last five strokes.
"And that's for not recognizing me Karkles." She gives him an eleventh, right beneath his ass on the sensitive part of his thighs.
After that's done, Kanaya and Dave go, him guessing them easily. You decide that this would be a good time to end the night, as they're not super used to this. You captchalogue all the equipment, removing the rope, gag, and blindfold from Karkat easily. You carry the blanket to Dave's washer, and you walk back into the living room. Karkat is just kind of sitting there with his head down, while the other four are laughing to each other and talking quietly.
"Hey, guys? I think we're going to head out." You say to them. You've been here for a while. "We should do this again sometime!" To your ultimate surprise, it's Dave that agrees.
"Definitely man." He fist bumps you and you laugh when you return it. You clip the leash on Karkat, and make him crawl out of the house. When you're in the garage, instead of going straight for the door, you squat in front of him.
"When we get home, do you want to come?" You ask him, stroking his cheek lightly.
"Yes, Master." He's not allowed to lie to you. At this, you give him a light slap.
"Next time, don't you dare touch yourself before I give you permission, much less come. Understand?" You grab his face in your hand, your expression hard.
"Yes, Master, I'm so sorry." He looks regretful.
"It's okay, tonight made up for it don't worry. Now, let's go home and get you cleaned up."
A/N: I know I half assed this near the end, but oh my lord that took for fucking ever. I got my kink out though, and I like the way this turned out. I hope you guys enjoy it too because I'm getting my ass to bed now. Goodnight guys!
-Dara