You Truly Are The One
By CollegeStar20
Summary
What happens when Mr. Shuester's twin neices have been living with him since the summer aftcer their parent's die in a car crash making them both join McKinley High and joining Glee Club and they become great friends with everybody but what happens when Finn Hudson falls for one of Mr. Shue's neices knowing that he already has a girlfriend. Will Finn remain in his relationship with his girlfriend or will he find his true feelings and try to fight to be with the girl he really loves?
Find out what happens.
Epilogue
Finn Hudson couldn't believe that his glee club actually won nationals and McKinley high still treated them like they were losers but this would be the first in years for them and they were proud of to be in Glee club. They were back in Lima Ohio and it was almost summer break for everybody at McKinley and it was the last day of school! Finn and Rachel have been trying then ever since they got back together and he was staying at Mr. Shue's house for the summer to be more closer to Victorie and Rachel liked that idea alot so now when it's time to go home Finn just goes to her house.
"Finn can we talk for a second?" He froze hearing his old girlfriend's voice and turns around to see Santana Lopez standing there smiling at him slightly.
"Um I can't talk right now Santana, I have to meet Rachel for lunch since she is you know my girlfriend!" Santana frowns.
"Look Finn I still have feelings for you but I'm just going to have to deal with it!" He stopped walking and looked at her sighing.
"Are you being serious Santana because I just got my girl back and I'm not losing her again we have a daughter together!" She rolls her eyes.
"Trust me Finn I had you before little miss Berry came into your life and I could have you again!" She says grinning.
"Why are you doing this Santana I thought you and Rachel were friends!" He said as he kept walking to his locker and opened it when he finally did.
"We are but not best friends and I still have feelings Finn, you were my boyfriend since 7th grade until she showed up!" Santana puts her hand on his shoulder.
"Just stop Santana, I thought we could be friends but your just trying to mess up my relationship with my girlfriend!" He pushed her off.
"When are you going to realize that I will be the girl that puts you on top your last year of high school Finn?" She said not realizing that Rachel is listening to them.
"Why would I go back out with you after you cheated on me with alot of people and treated people like crap!" She glares at him.
"So what Finn, you gave yourself up to that midget and now your thinking your in love with her, what if you get tired of playing daddy?" He sighs.
Rachel always thought about that and she did wonder if Finn would just say to her one day that he can't do it anymore and just break up with her and she didn't know how she felt about that if it ever happened. "Well it's none of your business Santana but I don't plan on leaving her!"
"Well I plan on being Cheerio Caption again next year and I hope we could be together but have your fun for now Finny!" Santana left.
Rachel walked past her and walked up to him frowning. "What if you just leave me one day saying you don't want this?" He grabs her hand.
"Rachel I don't want her or anybody else but you and I love being a dad to Victorie and I promise that I will marry you some day!"
Rachel stares at him sadly and shook her head. "Maybe we shouldn't be together because everybody doesn't seem to want us together Finn!" He shook his head.
"No Rachel don't listen to them alright, we belong together and I love you and Victorie very much and you belong to me forever!" She sighs.
"Sometimes I wish I was back at home in New York with my parents and my little girl but that's never going to happen but I don't regret ever being with you Finn! I just wish we could just be together without any drama and just be one big happy family!" Finn pulls her close and kissed her passionately.
She closed her eyes loving the feeling of his lips on hers and she wrapped her arms around his neck as she stands up on her tip toes then they pull away.
"Were going to spend the whole summer together baby and nothing is going to stop us from being a family and being in love!" She smiles at him slightly before moving out of his way so he could take all the books out of his locker since it was almost at the end of the day.
"Are you worried that I'm going to leave again?" She shrugss slightly standing there.
"Rachel Barbra Berry I made a mistake cheating you with Trista and santana means nothing to be, I just want you to trust me again!"
She nods slightly still unsure and he closed his locker and took his hand out letting her take it. "Just trust me okay?" She nods pecking his lips.
"Let's get to our last class of the day before school ends for the summer and just you, me and our daughter Victorie will spend the summer together!"
She smiles as they walk off holding hands.
Quinn over heard everything and rushed over to Santana and Trista and pulled both of them into the choir room and locked the door.
"What the hell are you doing Fabray?" Trista asked glaring at the ex cheerio caption making Santana nod in agreement.
"You both need to back off Finn big time because he's pretty much checked out on both you and he's focusing on being a father to Victorie who you two know knowing about and he's madly in love with Rachel so stop!" She demanded.
"Why should we leave Finn alone Rachel Berry doesn't belong with him unlike us!" Santana says smirking. Quinn glares at her.
"You two are so stupid, Finn doesn't want you anymore so just give it up and he's planning on marrying Rachel someday and following her everywhere because she's his world Santana, you both need to get it through your head that Finn found his soulmate in high school and all you care about is being on top but it's not going to matter when your done with high school so please just leave them alone!" They stare at her frowning slightly.
"I guess your right and we are being stupid because there are alot more guys hotter then Finn!" Trista says chuckling.
Quinn glares at them. "That's my cousin your talking about and your right you should find other guys." They sigh.
"I don't care for Finn anymore besides after what happened to Rachel in New York I'm letting them be okay?" Trista says and Quinn nods saying she could leave.
When Trista left Quinn waited before turning back to Santana who was looking bored. "Why are you trying to make her feel worthless?" Santana smirks.
"Because I'm hotter, sexy, taller and a girl with a killer body, Finn should be with me not that midget!" Quinn walks up to her staring right at her.
"Leave them alone Santana, Rachel has been so nice to you and you sang them that song and I'm tired of your fakeness!" Santana chuckles.
"What makes you think I'm being fake Quinn?" Quinn glares at her and puts her bag down.
"Who says your being Real Santana ever seen you got that boob job!" Santana glared at her as they just stand there.
"I want Finn and I'm going to get him back no matter what Fabray and Rachel Berry is not going to stop me from getting him!"
"She might after she finds out that the truth about your lying ways and I'm going to stop you aswell, leave them alone!" Santana rolls her eyes and walked out ignoring Quinn calling her back.
With Rachel off campus.
Rachel wanted to be alone for lunch so she told Finn that she would see him at Glee club. She order her meal and waited for her order but she wasn't going to be alone for long because she asked to meet up with somebody. "Rachel Berry?" She heard footsteps and looked up to see the person she was there to meet.
"Shelby Corcoran?" She nods smilling slightly sitting down and Rachel didn't know why she was doing this.
"Why did you give me, Averilyn and Crista up for adoption is the first place Shelby?" She sighs looking at her oldest daughter.
"I had problems when I was 19 years old and I couldn't take care of a child let alone two identical twin girls because I had just started my senior year when I had you two and I wanted to go to New York and follow my dream being on Broadway so I got a call from your parents Leroy and Christina Berry saying that they couldn't have children and I thought great they could take care of my girls the right way knowing that I couldn't!"
"You could of atleast try mom, we needed a mom and you were taking the easy way out and put us up for adoption!" Rachel says fighting her tears.
"I know Rachel trust me I know and I feel like a bad mother for giving you up but it doesn't mean that I never loved you because I did and it was an open adopion aways so I got pictures and letters from them about you girls then I find out that I was pregnant again a year later you girls were born and I was just in my second year of being on Broadway and I couldn't be a mother again so I called your parents and told them and I gave Averilyn and It was still an open adoption but when I heard that your parents died I thought wow my babies are all alone!" Shelby sighs wiping her tears.
Rachel stares at her sadly and gets her food when she's called and she gets it and sits back down!
"Why didn't you contact us then after our parents died?" She grabs Rachel's hand but she pulls away. "Don't touch me!" She demanded.
"I tried to contact you girls really I did but your uncle told me that I wasn't aloud to see you girls ever and I couldn't just back down!"
Rachel frowns staring at her real birth mother wondering if she was telling the truth. "So how did you get my email?" She tells her that ther parents gave it to her a year ago before they died and she nods. "Rachel I want to get to know all three so badly if you would let me!" She nods.
"You mean the four of us because I have a daughter that I adopted last year after I found her in New York sick on a park bench with three suitcases and a teddy bear with her and I brought her home with me and I fed and gave her a bath then we took her to the doctors the next day and she just had a bad cold!"
Shelby stares at her daughter surprised that she as a mother at 17 years old. "Um how did you get to adopt her?" Rachel takes a sip of her drink and talks again.
"I had a lot of up from my parents and we went to go look for her parents and she told that her parents let her there because they didn't want her and I felt so bad for this little 4 year old girl without a home so I got a couple a visits to see how she would be with and I passed so with my parents and the courts permission I got to offically adopt her and I love her so much that I would anything to make her happy but I am also very firm when I have to be and my boyfriend is offically her dad by the courts and he loves her very much and he's a great guy for me and a great dad for daughter Victorie Annabelle Berry!"
"I'm proud of you Rachel really I am and I hope to meet my granddaughter someday!" She was about to say something when the door of the cafe opens and Rachel hears her name being called by her daughter and she turns around to see Finn carrying Victorie on his hip as he walks over to them.
"What are you two doing here and why is Victorie out of school?" Rachel asked giving her daughter a stern look.
"Her teacher called me saying that she wasn't feeling good and she has a slight fever!" Rachel stares at her worried and Finn puts her down and she runs to Rachel.
"Sweetie were you feeling good this morning?" Victorie shook her head no and Rachel feels her head.
"Oh sweetie your warm come sit on my lap then were going to take you to grandma's house then mama and daddy are going to pick you up after were done!"
Shelby stares at her daughter being a great mother to the gorgeous little girl sitting on her lap. "Who is this Rachel?" Finn asked as he sits down with them.
"Um baby this is Shelby Corcoran um mine and my sisters birth mother and she gave all three of us up when she was younger!" Shelby smiles slightly.
"Hi I'm Finn Hudson Rachel's boyfriend and Victorie's father aswell!" Shelby nods awkwardly before staring at her daughter.
"Well Rachel I want to see you and your sisters this summer at some point and hopefully get to know this guy and my granddaughter so please call or email at anytime, I need to run but it was nice meeting you Finn bye guys!" Shelby gets up and waves leaving.
"What was that about Rach?" She sighs looking into his eyes now in tears and Finn stares at her worried.
"That was mine and my sisters birth mom and our parents never told us we were adopted but the second to worst part of this whole thing was that our uncle knew she was trying to contact us after they died and he told her to never try to find us!" He grabs her hand.
"Baby are you sure she's even telling the truth about even contacting you maybe she's just trying to make Mr. Shue look like the bad guy!"
She sighs unsure. "All I know Finn is that my whole life has been a lie and I don't know what to believe anymore!" He wipes her tears away.
"Oh baby I'm sorry you have to go through this but your not alone in this whole thing." She nods and they talk before dropping Victorie off at Finn's mom's house.
After school they leave Victorie there for awhile because they want to talk to Mr. Shue alone. They get there and Crista and Averilyn are in the livingroom talking to each other while Mr. Shue was reading a book. Finn closes the door and Rachel stares at her uncle in tears.
"Rachel why are you crying?" Crista and Averilyn asked concerned. "Baby it's alright just ask!" Finn asked softly rubbing her back.
"How could you tell mine, Crista's and Averilyn's real birth mother to not contact us ever uncle Will?" She asked in tears. Mr. Shue looks at her sighing.
"Rachel did you go see her because if you did you are grounded!" He says firmly. Crista and Averilyn stare at them confused.
"Your not even our real uncle so you have no right to ground me!" She yelled with tears coming down her cheeks.
"Did you tell her to never contact us?" He nods sadly and sighs. "Sis what's going on?" Both girls asked but she ignores them.
"Why would you do that without our parents permission?" He walks closer to her but she backs away.
"Stay away from me uncle will, our parents made a deal with our mother that if something happened to them that we would go back to her and you told her to get lost, what kind of person does that?" He sighs looking at all three girls and Finn and looks down.
"I did it to protect to you girls, she did contact me when it happened and she said that she wanted to atleast get to know girls and I felt it wasn't right because would have been hurt knowing that your parent's lied to you and it was already too late you were living with me!" Crista frowns.
"Wait were adopted all three and you and our parents never bothered to tells us?" Crista asked getting angry.
"I'm sory girls but I didn't want to see you get hurt more after losing your parents and I didn't want to lose you girls again!" They stared at them shaking there head.
"You don't get to say you cared about our feelings because there all lies you and our parents are fake and I-I can't trust you!" Averilyn runs to her room in tears.
Crista and Rachel stare at him. "If you want us to trust you again then let us atleast get to know our mother!" He sighs.
"I can't do that girls what if she just leaves again and you get heartbroken?" They glare at him.
"Then let us deal with it and you owe for lying all these years!" Finn wraps his arms around both girls. "Girls why don't you just cool down and go to your rooms!"
They nod ignoring there uncle and Finn stared at his favorite teacher. "You have alot of work to do to earn there trust back!" He sighs looking away.
"Trust me I know and I'm going to do whatever I can to make sure my girls aren't going to get hurt again and I will make sure of it!"
Finn nods before going to pick up Victorie. Will picks up his cell phone and dials Shelby's number. "Hello?" He glares at the wall.
"It's Will Shuester and if you want to be in Rachel's, Averilyn's and Crista's life then you make a meeting with me first got it?" He demanded.
"Don't worry Will I'm not trying to take them away from you ever but Your fight I will make a meeting with you and I will get to know my daughters and my granddaughter Will!" He sighs angrily. "You better not mess this up Shelby I will be hearing from you!" He demanded.
"Oh Trust me I will not give up on seeing my girls and I promise I won't mess it good bye Will!" He hangs up and turns around to see Rachel.
"Rachel please don't hate me forever!" She nods sadly looking like she was crying.
"I could never hate anybody but I can't trust you right now!" He nods as she walks back to her room and Will sighs feeling stupid for hiding it from the girls.
Well that's the end of my story but don't worry it's not over yet, the Sequel will be out soon watch out for it. Bye.