Chapter 21: That Fateful Day

(A/N: This is the day when it all started, thus it is in the past; but it is set about a week after the Valentine's Day Dance)

It was about a week after Sam was outed by Kurt to the entire school about Sam being together with Blaine. Ever since then Baine had seen Kitty looking at Sam with some kind of look that he couldn't quite place his finger on. He would have asked Sam if Santana could keep an eye out on Kitty, but unfortunately Santana and Rachel had left to head back to New York together the day after Kurt had left. But Blaine had this uneasy feeling that something bad was going to happen to him and Sam. But Blaine had pushed it to the back of his mind until it was too late.

After Glee Club was over and Blaine went back home, he had noticed that there was a letter hanging outside of his house which was sent from an address that Blaine recognized the handwriting as Kurt's. The feeling he had been having all week was immediately ten times worse. He walked inside and went up to his bedroom only to find that the door was open. He knew he always closed his door when he left the house, so he immediately was worried who was in the house. Especially because he knew he was the first one in the house. He had opened the door all the way and discovered a giant red heart that said the words "Sam & Blaine" in white. He opened up the letter and started reading it.

Dear Blaine,

I know I acted inappropriate on Valentine's day, I hope you can forgive me. I hope you liked the gift I left in your bedroom, I hope we can put all this behind us and just be friends. I was hoping that you could meet me at the Lima Bean today. Yes I know everyone thought I left before Santana and Rachel, but the slushies you guys did to me and the bitch slaps were a wake- up call to be a better friend to all of you guys, and to be happy for you and Sam, I will be at the Lima Bean from 6:00pm-8:00pm tonight, so come by so that I can personally apologize to you. Sorry for everything I did.

Sincerely,

Kurt

There was a tear of happiness in Blaine's eye from how heartfelt the letter was. He decided to go over to the Lima Bean tonight to get the apology in person from Kurt, little did he know that Kurt had something much different planned for Blaine.

XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

6:30PM at the Lima Bean

XOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOXOX

Blaine walked into the Lima Bean expecting to sit down and meet with just Kurt, but he got something totally different. "Kitty what are you doing here with Kurt?" Blaine asked warily. "Oh don't worry Blaine she isn't going to do anything…yet." Kurt replied with a sly smirk. "Kurt what is going on here?!" Blaine demanded of him. "Here is how this is going to play out Blaine. Kitty has a video of you and Sam kissing in the choir room on Valentine's Day, she isn't going to show it to Mr. and Mrs. Evans. But there is a catch…you come to New York with me and you give me another shot at convincing you that I will be better for you in the long run than that stupid blonde Evans. Refuse, and Kitty here sends the video to Sam's parents, and you know how Sam comes from a Christian family; they will probably kick him out of the house and really will be homeless and pathetic. So which do you choose Blaine?" Kurt explained.

"…Why are you doing this to me Kurt?" Blaine asked. "Because you will never be happy with Sam. I want you to be happy, and I know that only you can be happy with me. So who is it? Give a second chance or force Sam out onto the streets?" Kurt asked, smirking while waiting for an answer. "Fine, you win Kurt. But I am only doing this to protect Sam." Blaine said with defeat in his voice. "Goodie!" Kurt said. I'll be expecting you to be in New York by Wenesday of next week. If you aren't in New York by then; then Kitty will know what to do." Kurt said satisfied with himself as he and Kitty made their way out of the Lima Bean leaving Blaine to silently cry for what he was about to do to Sam.

A/N: Let me know what you guys think of this chapter and the story so far, please don't be afraid to PM me or Review the story and tell me what you liked and didn't like and what you will want to see more of and less of, and anything else. I appreciate feedback. Thank you for reading this.