Lincoln was headed back to his house when he realized something. "Isn't Lily a little young to drink chocolate milk, let alone eat solid food?" Lincoln then ran inside the house and back in his room and wondered, "If she drinks the chocolate milk, there's a high chance she will become an Oshawott. If I don't, I'll never be able to explain this mystery! The good thing is that it only lasts 30 seconds! The really bad part is taking the picture! If I don't take that picture within time, who knows what would happen if they give her chocolate milk!?" Then Lincoln got an idea. He said, "Maybe, I could dress her up, first. Then give her the chocolate milk. Then take the picture quickly. Oh, the anticipation is killing me!"
Lincoln was interrupted when Leni burst through the room. Leni said, " I need some type of antidote! My skin's turned blue again! Where's the antidote?" Lincoln said, "I got it." After Leni was turned back to normal, she said, "Thanks, Lincoln!" Lincoln told Leni about an unexplained mystery he was going to explain, then Leni said, "Really? That could happen?" Lincoln said, "well, yes." Leni said, "You do realize Lily would refuse to drink the chocolate milk, right?" Lincoln then became shocked. "Then what do I do? She needs chocolate milk to turn into Oshawott!" Leni then poured some of the milk into a syringe, and then handed the syringe to Lincoln. Leni said, "It's dangerous for chocolate milk to spill, take this!" Lincoln said, "Why, thanks, Leni!" Leni said, "That's what older sisters are for!"
Lincoln headed back to Clyde's house and said, "Leni filled a syringe full of chocolate milk!" Clyde said, "Yeah, I know. Lily would refuse to drink chocolate milk." Lincoln turned to Clyde and said, "You know about an unexplained mystery?" Clyde said, "I was calling Lori, and then you talked with Leni, and I eavesdropped on the whole conversation!" Lincoln said, "Why did Lori leave her phone on?" Clyde said, "She leaves it on for Bobby. I dunno why, but she does." Lincoln says, "She always talks to Bobby." Clyde said, "But I have feelings for Lori!" Lincoln said, "Wait, why was the phone in my room?" Clyde said, "She threw it on your bed while you weren't in there, and you apparently didn't notice it. She's so thoughtful."
Lincoln then ran out of Clyde's house and said to the audience, "Well, Lori has her phone on my bed. And Clyde knows about the next mystery I'll explain: Lily turning into an Oshawott."