AN: WARNING: Lemons.

Chapter 21: Trouble In Paradise

Evelyn was rushing towards her class. She was already late. The beginning of her senior was fantastic. Well her summer was better since she got to spend it with Kai. They never went to New York for any concert. Instead Kai and Evelyn were on a road trip. They went to places and had a lot of fun together. Since Kai and Evelyn were amongst strangers, they got to be boyfriend and girlfriend the entire journey. At a small town restaurant Kai even proposed to Evelyn to marry him. Evelyn of course said yes and they kissed each other while everyone surrounding them applauded and congratulated them. Of course when they came back home, Evelyn and Kai were back to being siblings and secret lovers.

"Oops sorry!" Evelyn apologized because when she turned a corner she bumped into someone. Before Evelyn could realize anything, she was whisked into the coach's office across the corridor. Evelyn looked up and obviously found Kai there. Smirking down at her obnoxiously.

"Kai what are you doing here?" asked Evelyn in a playful scolding tone of voice. She was already getting late for her class.

"I missed you" said Kai innocently. With a playful smile on his lips. Evelyn rolled her eyes at him.

"Kai, I just arrived at school. We ate breakfast together less than an hour ago" said Evelyn. Kai only wrapped his arms around Evelyn in reply.

"47 minutes, 22 seconds ago. I can't stay away from you for that long" said Kai nuzzling his nose against the curve of Evelyn's neck. It made her tickle a little bit. A giggle escaped Evelyn's breath. Kai could be so cheesy when he wanted to be.

"Kai, I've to attend the class" said Evelyn trying to untangle herself from Kai in a futile attempt. Truthfully she didn't mind staying in Kai's arms all day either.

"No, what you have to do is kiss me and let me take you right now, right here."

"Kai don't be crazy. Coach could walk in here anytime" said Evelyn trying to make Kai stop as he already started kissing her neck.

"Let him. We have magic to save our asses" said Kai biting Evelyn's earlobe lightly and sucking on it.

"But Kai, my class-" Evelyn couldn't say anything else as Kai captured her lips with his. Silencing her with a heated kiss. He pushed her up against the wall. Evelyn resisted for a while but couldn't help but give into the temptation in the end. She wrapped her arms around Kai's neck and pulled him closer to her. All the while, Kai ravishing her lips. Their tongues passionately meeting each other. Kai lifted Evelyn up and she wrapped her long legs around his waist. Their hips pushed against each other. Evelyn moaned as tingly feeling happened in her core due to the movements between them.

Kai was thankful that Evelyn was wearing a floral print dress and not jeans and tops. He could easily roam his hand over her thigh. Evelyn pulled away from the kiss as she ran out of air. She grabbed onto Kai's hair and guided him to her neck. Kai obediently started devouring her skin there. Both Evelyn and Kai were very aroused by then. Kai already got an erection and Evelyn was dripping out of her core.

Kai kissed Evelyn down to her breasts. He reached behind her back and opened up the dress zipper. The dress loosened and Kai pulled it down to reveal her bras. He immediately attacked her mounds. Kai bit onto her buds one at a time over the bras. He revealed her breasts and sucked on them for a while. He also unbuckled himself during this time and freed his hard erection. Evelyn was completely lost in pleasure and ecstasy when Kai suddenly thrust into her. She gasped out loud in surprise. It took her breath away. Kai told her by this action that he wasn't going to be gentle with her.

Evelyn strongly held onto Kai as he rapidly thrust into her. Both of them were sweating like hell and breathing heavily. Moans and groans filled the room.

"Oh god." Evelyn almost screamed out loud. Kai was continuously tearing through her and she felt like falling apart in his arms every time. It was getting hard for Evelyn to keep herself together with the amount of pleasure she was getting.

"Come on, come for me baby" Kai said into her ear breathlessly. They were both on the peak of their intercourse. Suddenly the door knob turned and the coach walked inside. Evelyn gasped out loud. She panicked but Kai took some magic from her which made Evelyn flinch a little and cast a cloaking spell on them quickly. He didn't stop though. The coach entered the office without having any clue that two people were present in the room. And engaged in a very intimate affair. It was wrong on so many levels. Getting hot and heavy in the presence of another person even though he couldn't see anything.

Evelyn wasn't feeling the pleasure anymore. She wanted Kai to stop but Kai only stopped after achieving his release. He pulled out of Evelyn and the first thing that Kai said was-

"I'm gonna kill him." Kai was obviously talking about the coach. How dare he invade their private moment. Like a sociopath Kai failed to see it was wrong of them to come into the coach's office in the first place. Evelyn however rolled her eyes at Kai.

"Shut up Kai and lets get out of here." The coach was sitting in his desk chair and looking through some paper work. Evelyn and Kai fixed their clothes and she dragged Kai out of the coach's office.

"Go home now. I'll see you in the evening" said Evelyn. Kissing Kai one last time, she sent him home. Once Kai left the cloaking spell revoked and Evelyn was visible again. She sighed out heavily. Evelyn was feeling exhausted and her muscles arched a little bit but she had to at least attend the rest of the classes of the day. She definitely missed the first one. Evelyn thought about waiting in the library till the second class.

The library was in another building. Evelyn was walking towards that direction. Suddenly her eyes fell on a boy standing under a tree. Evelyn recognized that boy right away. It was Sam. She met him the other day at the hospital. Sam was looking right at her. Evelyn started approaching him but Sam just walked away. It confused Evelyn. What was Sam doing at her school? Joey had already graduated. He must know that.

Being curious Evelyn kept walking in the direction Sam went. Hoping to catch him up. Sam kept walking at a steady pace. "Sam" Evelyn called him. He turned around to look at her. Their eyes met. Then he turned back around and kept walking.

"What's the matter with him?" Evelyn asked herself. It encouraged her to follow him further. They walked for quite sometime like that. Evelyn following Sam. At one point Sam stopped. He was being very weird. Evelyn wanted to know why? What got into him?

"Sam" Evelyn called him with careful tone of voice.

"Are you alright?"

This time Sam turned around to face Evelyn. His face was void of any emotions. "Ronny's dead." Sam said at once. He tried to keep his voice steady and controlled.

"What?" Evelyn's eyes widened hearing that. It obviously shocked her. She thought Ronny would wake up from coma and eventually get well. She would wipe out his memories and everything will be alright.

"When did he-?" Evelyn couldn't speak. Ronny dead meant someone died at Kai's hand. Evelyn started feeling suffocated at the thought. She kept telling herself that Kai didn't mean for Ronny to die. That he was a changed person now. Kai wouldn't want anyone to die. He wouldn't kill anyone intentionally.

"In the beginning of the summer" replied Sam. Evelyn let out a small gasp. She ran a hand through her hair. Evelyn was struggling with herself. She was convincing herself that Ronny's death didn't make Kai a killer. But a part of her knew that indirectly Kai did kill Ronny. It made Evelyn feel hollow from inside.

"Why do you look shocked Evelyn?" asked Sam with a little bitterness in his voice. It snapped Evelyn out of her own thoughts. "You should be happy right now."

"What? Why would you say that?" asked Evelyn completely taken aback.

"Am I wrong? Now that Ronny's never gonna wake up, your psycho brother wouldn't have to kill him now. But then again, he might regret not having the pleasure of stabbing Ronny to death." Sam said the last part more to himself than to Evelyn. Evelyn however felt like getting hit by a speeding train. How did Sam know?

"Yes, Ronny told me who's responsible for his death just before he died" said Sam seeing the bewildered expression on Evelyn's face. Before Evelyn could say anything Sam spoke up again.

"I guess now you're gonna kill me too, huh?"

"Sam, listen to me-" Sam interrupted Evelyn before she could say more.

"No, you won't kill me. You're not the killer here. After all you can take care of me in various other ways, can't you Evelyn? Since you're a witch and all-" said Sam shocking Evelyn even more. How the hell did he know that? Did Joey tell him anything? No, he wouldn't break the coven rules. Then how did Sam know? How? Before Evelyn could register this in her mind, Sam spoke up again.

"And before you do something to me to save your dear brother, I wanna show you something. Come with me" saying that Sam turned around and walked over to a car. It was his car. Sam opened the door and got inside. Evelyn stood still for a moment. Should she really go with him? If she didn't then she would never find out what Sam had to say. And Evelyn better find out what else he knew. Inhaling a deep breath Evelyn walked over to the car and got inside. Sam started driving the car. Evelyn was flickering her eyes over to Sam now and then. He already knew she is a witch and Kai killed Ronny and yet he came to talk to her. Why? He didn't seem scared at all.

"You don't look afraid of me" stated Evelyn.

"I'm not" said Sam at once.

"Why not? You obviously know what I am."

"Exactly" said Sam making Evelyn frown in confusion at him.

"What do you mean?"

"I know you're a witch. Not a killer. Even though you've plenty of flaws yourself but you're not evil. Unlike you're brother Kai" said Sam.

"Kai's not evil." Evelyn defended Kai immediately. "He's misunderstood and our parents mistreated him a lot. Our father is the worst. He was going dark but now he's changed. I'm sorry about your friend Ronny. But Kai wouldn't harm anyone now. Believe me." Sam only shook his head at that.

"It's so true what they say. Love is indeed blind." Evelyn glared at Sam for saying that.

"Where are we going?" she asked with angry tone of voice.

"You'll see."

It was a long drive. Sam was taking Evelyn to another town. Why? Evelyn had no idea. The entire drive Evelyn tried to convince Sam that Kai wasn't evil and to some level herself as well. That he wasn't a sociopath anymore. How can Kai be when he loves her so much. Sociopaths can't love anyone. But Sam wasn't listening to anything. Thankfully he didn't say anything to Joey. Evelyn found out that Sam was spying on their coven the entire summer. He even knew about their invisible mansion. About the merge ceremony. Not to mention about Evelyn and Kai's romantic relationship. Evelyn couldn't understand, why Sam wasn't running the other way after learning about everything. He wasn't suppose to come anywhere near them. Sam pulled over in front of a mental asylum.

"What's in there?" asked Evelyn curiously.

"Your past" replied Sam. Making Evelyn furrow her brows. They walked inside together. Sam took permission to see someone there. "Come." Sam said to Evelyn. They went to a room. Evelyn looked inside and she was very shocked.

"Mrs. Garcia" whispered out Evelyn.

"Your ex-boyfriend Andrew's mother" said Sam out loud. The woman was just sitting there. Looking lifeless while she stared outside the window with unblinking eyes. She was nothing but a corpse except with a beating heart. Evelyn looked at Sam with confusion and curiosity.

"What happened to her?" Evelyn asked. Sam looked right into her eyes.

"She watched her son getting brutally murdered." Evelyn stopped breathing that moment as Sam said that. Her heart threatened to give up beating.

"No" gasped out Evelyn with horror in her voice. She shook her head, denying to accept the reality that Andrew, the first person she loved is no more. She had her first kiss with Andrew. He was the first person Evelyn made love with. She really really loved Andrew if not in love with him. And when Andrew left without a goodbye, it broke Evelyn's heart into pieces. She was mad at Andrew in the beginning but time healed her wounds. However, Evelyn never ever wanted anything bad happen to Andrew. But now she was hearing that he's dead.

"Andrew never left town Evelyn. He was killed" said Sam with confirmed tone of voice.

"No" Evelyn said again. Tears threatened to fall from her eyes. It wasn't possible. Andrew was dead all along and she had no idea.

"No, Andrew can't be dead. You're lying." Evelyn accused Sam.

"You wanna know who killed him Evelyn?" asked Sam. Evelyn's heart started beating faster. Suddenly she started getting a very nasty sick feeling.

"Who?" asked Evelyn fearfully. For some reason she didn't want to know the answer. Cause in the back of her mind, she already had a guess. But still Evelyn felt like throwing up when Sam said the name out loud to her.

"Malachai Parker."