Ever since vanquishing Jasper, Mara had been having nightmares about him. It was as if every other possible scenario of what could have happened haunted her dreams each night. They had gotten so bad that she'd cry out in her sleep so the Sisters would take turns being with her along with Felix and Eva. Making sure that Mara would be alright in the end was their priority.

That night she had yet another nightmare only it wasn't one of Jasper but of Andy. Mara had a dream that Andy had died in the Manor and it felt so real that she bolted upright in bed in fear. That dream wasn't like the others she'd had before – that time it felt real and that made it all the more petrifying for her.

"It was just a dream," she said to herself with a bit of a rasp to her voice from trying to catch her breath. Once her breathing settled down a little bit, she repeated, "It was just a dream."

At that moment Mara jumped about fifty feet when Sebastian Orbed into her room and stood at the foot of her bed. "Good god, knock or something before you do that. What if I had been naked or something?"

"I would have come anyway," Bash answered like he was stating the obvious. "I sensed your fear. Are you alright?"

Mara was about to question him on that but remembered. "Oh, right, it's one of your Protector tricks." Now she answered what he wanted to know, "I had a nightmare. I'm fine."

Bash gestured to the window seat and asked, "Would you like me to stay until you fall asleep?" When Mara narrowed her eyes at him in a suspicious manner, he sighed heavily, "I'm not trying to get you to fall in love with me, Sweetheart."

Mara nodded in an 'okay then' manner. "Thank you."

Bash sat down at the window seat and waited a moment or two before telling her, "They'll start to fade – the nightmares. Just give it time."

Mara was laying down facing away from Sebastian and didn't move when she answered him. "Apparently I've got all the time in the world."

When Mara woke up that Wednesday morning something just felt off. She couldn't explain it, but there was almost like a tension in the air; A tension that made her feel like something was trying to happen but it hadn't happened yet.

"Morning," Mara greeted as she went downstairs and found Prue and Phoebe in the sitting room. They both looked like someone had just died and Mara, fearing the worst, asked them, "Did something happen to Andy?"

Both sisters looked right at her when she asked them that. "What made you ask that?" Phoebe wanted to know.

Mara felt like she'd just shoved her foot in her mouth or something. "Sorry, it's nothing. I just had a nightmare about Andy dying last night." She looked between Phoebe and Prue when they shared an odd look with each other. "You guys are starting to freak me out here. What's going on?"

Prue was the one who answered, all while trying to make sense of the coincidence. "Phoebe just had a premonition of Andy dying. How did you dream the same thing?"

"It could be an extension of Mara's psychic divination power," Phoebe suggested then realized something, "She has one power that's adjacent to yours and another that's adjacent to mine. Who knows, maybe Mara will get one adjacent to Piper's next."

Mara didn't care about any of that right then and voiced it. "None of that matters, Phoebe. All that matters is making sure that your premonition doesn't come true. What – what happened?"

Phoebe went on to explain to them what she saw; That in the room they were presently standing in Andy had been thrown in a manner that could only be from a Demon or a Warlock, and that he had died.

Mara didn't interject in there that what Phoebe was describing was exactly like she had dreamt. What she did say was, "We're gonna have to be extra careful since we don't what kind of Demon we're dealing with."

"Phoebe, fill in Piper and I'm going to warn Andy." Prue couldn't let anything happen to him and was going to do everything in her power to make sure that nothing did.

"I thought he said it was too risky to be seen together?" Phoebe instantly replied, hoping that Prue wasn't just acting off emotion but also thought. "What if IA figures out that we're Witches?"

"Let them find out," Prue shot back, not caring about any of that. "This is Andy we're talking about here."

Phoebe accepted that and nodded slightly. "Alright, but please be careful. Mara's right, we need to be extra careful since we don't know what we're dealing with."

"I will, promise." Prue left the room without another word.

It wasn't until Prue had gone that Mara asked Phoebe, "Uh, what does an Internal Affairs investigation have to do with us?"

Phoebe realized in that moment that Mara hadn't been caught up with the information about how IA was investigating Andy and all his unsolved cases that all involved Magic. "Come with me while I get a new dress for Piper and I'll give you the cliff-notes version"

Mara – who hadn't been present for the conversation about Piper needing a new dress for the Food Network thing at Quake because she spilled marinara sauce on herself – followed after Phoebe, asking, "Wait…where is Piper and why does she need a new dress?"

Felix came out of the newly added guest room in Eva's loft and found his sister in the kitchen. "That was some pretty Harry Potter magic you were casting last night." He said this because until the previous night that guest room didn't exist. Eva cast a spell to make an addition onto her loft.

"I was going more for Halloweentown," Eva replied as she handed Felix a glass of milk.

Felix took a long drink from the glass before sitting down at the kitchen island. "You know, if you work some of that magic at the Manor you wouldn't have to live here. You could live there with your daughter."

"I need to stay here," Eva countered. "You know who's living right across the hall. Someone needs to keep an eye on her. I'm pretty sure we've been over this."

"Alright, fine, I'll let it go." He moved his glass to swirl the milk around in it. "Are we going to talk about Mara's power? It's only a matter of time before she conjures up something like that again."

Eva braces herself against the island with a heavy sigh. "I've been considering stripping her powers." Of course it wouldn't strip Mara of her immortality, but all others would be gone.

Felix looked at her like she was insane. "You can't do that to her."

"Would you rather she find out the truth?" Eva shot back before bringing her forehead as she paced. "It's the only thing I can think of to make sure that monster doesn't find her."

Felix finally convinced Eva to share the secret with him that she'd been carrying for a long time. That's how he knew what Mara's energy fireball meant and how he knew who the monster she was referring to now was. "Perhaps it's for the best, Eva. At least that way she will be prepared for what could be coming for her."

"That would destroy her." Eva shook her head – There was no way in hell she'd ever tell Mara what she confided in her brother.

"It didn't destroy Lincoln," Felix countered. "Mara's strength is growing and clearly so is her magic. You can't hide this forever, especially is Mara returns her sights back on killing Belthazor. That will open up a whole huge can of worms that could be better avoided if you talk to her now."

"We just got Mara back. If I tell her what happened do you really think that won't drive her back to the dark? Out of everything that's being kept from her this is something that she can never find out." Eva couldn't even begin the imagine the ramifications if Mara ever found out the truth.

"And what if Bash tells her? What's stopping him from telling Mara everything he knows?"

"He won't." Eva was quite certain of that. "He knows what that would do to her. Bash wouldn't hurt her like that. He may not be falling in love with her but that doesn't mean he does not care."

Felix wasn't as confident as Eva was with all of this. He lifted his glass in a 'cheers' manner, "We'll see."

Prue was out talking with Andy about Phoebe's premonition, Phoebe was at Quake with Piper, so that left Mara at the Manor. She sat up in the Attic with the crystal ball in front of her. It'd been awhile since she called upon it but the dream was getting to her so she needed to see for herself.

Mara held her hand over the crystal ball and asked, "What happens to Andy?" After feeling the familiar static shock sensation in her palm, smoky swirls moved around within the ball before an image started to form. The image was the exact same thing in her dream which was still the same as Phoebe's premonition. "Who kills him?" Mara wanted to know, but instead of the ball revealing an image it started to shake and tremor before returning to its normal state.

"Thanks for nothing," Mara scoffed as she returned the ball to the Infinity Chest. She'd been calling it the Infinity Box for awhile now, but changed her terminology when the Box literally grew to the size of a large treasure chest. Eva told her that happened because everything that needed to be found had been and was now accessible since the spell had done its job. Mara even knew where all of Eva's cash caches were if they were ever needed for a rainy day.

Mara closed up the lid and heard Prue's voice call out asking if she was home. It sounded pretty important, so she called out, "Coming!" and went downstairs to find out what had happened. It surprised her a little to find all the Sisters discussing something in the conservatory. Looking to Prue, she asked, "What did I miss?"

"Andy thinks Rodriguez, the IA officer looking into him, is the Demon. Rodriguez knows we're Witches despite not having any concrete evidence and wants a meeting with me. Andy is going to give him a message to come here at six and we'll all deal with him then."

"This sounds like a setup." At least that's what it sounded like to Mara.

Phoebe was curious about where Mara's head was at. "Why do you say that?"

"If this IA guy is a Demon then why did he request a meeting with Prue? Why not just go after her when she's alone? It's fishy, is what it is. The Demon would have to know we wouldn't let her meet alone. He wants us all together." Mara was going pretty far with her gut feeling on that one but would stand by it nevertheless.

Mara's words didn't change anything where Prue was concerned. "If that's his plan then we'll be ready for him." Prue was going to vanquish that Demon no matter what; Nothing was going to happen to Andy if she could help it.

The game plan was set – Mara would be the one to answer the door because, duh, she was Immortal so if Rodriguez did anything right off then Mara would survive it. Okay, so she'd answer the door, Piper would come out and freeze the guy, then Prue would come down the stairs and send him flying, which would bring Phoebe into the room to join them and kick his ass with some Power of Three Magic.

The plan didn't seem to have any flaws, but they didn't account on Rodriguez showing up early and taking Mara out of the equation when she went outside to get something out of Prue's car. Rodriguez incapacitated Mara by snapping her neck, killing her, and dumping her in some nearby bushes until she awoke.

Now that Mara wasn't there to answer the door and give the Sisters time to use their Powers on Rodriguez, he was able to kill Phoebe before Piper and Prue could retaliate and Vanquish him in turn. Little did Mara or the Sisters know, this would not be permanent because Rodriguez was working with the Demon Tempus who would turn back the clock until Rodriguez got it right.

Mara woke up that Wednesday morning feeling…off. What made it worse was that she felt like she had woken up the previous day and felt the same way but hadn't because it was Wednesday and she didn't feel like that on Tuesday and things were just weird.

After getting dressed, Mara went down to the sitting room where Prue and Phoebe stood and asked something based off what her gut was telling her. "Phoebe, did you have a premonition of Andy getting killed by a Demon?"

Phoebe held up the newspaper in her hand. "I just had it and you had a dream the same as my vision, didn't you?"

Mara opened her mouth to say something but changed her words mid thought. "Okay, so I'm not the only one who feels like we've lived through this before?"

A moment later, the front door opened and Eva came into the sitting room with Felix. Before exchanging any greetings, Eva asked them with a tone conveying the importance of knowing what happened, "Okay, who cast a time spell?"

Prue, who was still reeling over hearing about what Phoebe saw happen to Andy, asked, "A time spell?"

"This day has already happened," Felix explained. "Older Immortal Witches are, you could say, in tune with time. We can sense when something has been altered."

"Think Déjà vu times a thousand." Eva figured that would be the quickest way to get to the point.

Phoebe gestured between herself and Mara. "We're getting major Déjà vu today, but we didn't cast any spell."

Eva believed them because if they were the one who cast it then they'd remember. "Well someone did. Some Demon did."

"Okay, uhm, if this is really happening you guys figure that out and I'm going to warn Andy about Phoebe's premonition." Prue left the room without another word.

"I better go get Piper and fill her in on all this," Phoebe added in before also taking her leave.

When it was just the Sibley Witches present, Mara asked, "How come you can't remember what happened in the other day of the time loop but I can? Is this because my Divination power is adjacent to Phoebe's premonitions?"

Felix thought about it for a moment and when Eva didn't say anything to counter, he said, "Makes sense. Not all Immortal Witches, or even Witches in our family have the exact same powers. So it's not surprising that you're able to do things we cannot."

Remembering a conversation about powers in the other day of the time loop, Mara asked, "Am I going to have a power that's adjacent to Piper's, too? And why are my powers similar to the Charmed Ones?"

Eva sat on the sofa and patted the spot beside her for Mara to sit. When she did, Eva answered her questions in order. "You already have a power adjacent to Piper's, in a way. All Immortal Witches do. We can…freeze ourselves, so to speak."

Felix could see the confusion on Mara's face. "We can pretty much put ourselves in stasis – freeze ourselves in that moment until we want to awaken. We can do that for a million years and yet not even age a day if we want to."

"Okay that's just…weird." Mara would definitely want to ask more about that later but this wasn't the time. She turned to her mother for the second answer she was looking for.

Eva didn't think she was going to get away with not answering and chose her words wisely. "Melinda Warren predicted it. You're Charmed Adjacent in more ways than you realize, Mara. I can't go into details because…"

"Let me guess, time travel is a finicky thing and this is something I'll discover during one of my trips to the past?" Mara rolled her eyes when Eva nodded.

"We can discuss all this another time. Right now you need to check the Book and the Tome to see what you can find." Eva shooed Mara for her to get a move on.

"You're not going to stay and help?" Mara couldn't believe they were bailing.

"If time resets again then yes, right now you and the Sisters try and figure it out." Eva kissed Mara's forehead. "Love you, Dove."

"Love you," Mara replied before going up the Attic to see what she could find out.

"What are you thinking?" Felix asked Eva once Mara was out of earshot.

"I'm thinking that either a Demon is resetting time or the new leader of the Infinity Coven is." Honestly, Eva would prefer the Demon.

"You think Gwen is behind this? Why?" Felix couldn't make sense of it.

Eva left the Manor with him saying, "I don't know, but if she is the one doing this then we're going to find out."

Mara and Phoebe when she returned home, both looked at their respective family spellbooks but didn't find anything yet about a Demon that could alter time. Phoebe found a spell to advance it and Mara found reference to the Immortal Witch 'stasis' she'd been told about, but they didn't have enough time to find anything else.

Now it was almost time for the plan to be put into action and this time Mara didn't go outside like she felt she had before. Unfortunately her presence didn't change anything for the better, despite her hopes that it would.

Rodriguez killed Mara with an energy ball as soon as she answered the door then proceeded to kill Piper and then Phoebe. When Prue came down the stairs he tried to go after her next but she deflected the energy ball back to him, thus causing him to vanquish.

Just as time had been reset before, it had been again. Tempus was giving Rodriguez another chance to learn from his mistakes and kill the Charmed Ones.

Mara woke up that morning already knowing what was wrong. "We're living in a Witchy Groundhog day!" she cried out before getting out of bed and going downstairs in her pajamas without getting dressed into her clothes for the day.

Once again, Mara found Prue and Phoebe in the sitting room and came right out with it like a crazy person, "Phoebe had a premonition about Andy dying, I had the same exact dream, since time reboot again my mom and Felix are going to show up to help right about now."

Eva and Felix came into the Manor right at the moment with Eva asking, "Alright, who cast the time spell?"

Mara snapped and pointed at them in an 'I told you so' manner.

Phoebe picked up from there saying, "Immortal Witches are in tune to time so you can sense when it's being messed with. Mara and I can tell because I have premonitions and Mara's power is adjacent to that."

Mara turned to Prue saying, "You need to go warn Andy and keep him the hell away from this house no matter what. Phoebe and I are going to hit the spellbooks to find out how to kill this time demon thing." Now she turned to her mom and uncle. "And you two aren't going anywhere. We need all the Immortals we can get to make sure no one dies this time."

Completely new plan was made this time around. P3 was kept out of the foyer leaving the Sibley Witches as the first line of defense. This time around they knew that the Demon behind the time loop was Tempus and the only way to vanquish him was to remove him from the time he was in. They'd figure out what that meant later, presently they had to deal with the attack to come.

"So much for not interfering in the lives of the Charmed Ones," Felix mildly teased Eva.

Eva swatted him with a scoff. "Apparently the other times we did nothing and the time loop happened. Perhaps this time well me different."

They'd soon find out because Rodriguez burst through the Manor doors and instantly threw an energy ball, not quite realizing who he was up against yet.

Eva shot her hand out in front of Mara and caught the energy ball with ease. She closed her hand tightly which diffused it.

Rodriguez conjured another ball and was about to throw it but Andy came into the Manor calling out Prue's name before firing upon Rodriguez. This Demon in turn threw the energy ball at Andy a second before Mara used her power to throw him away.

P3 ran into the foyer after hearing Andy's voice and found Mara was using her power to firmly hold Rodriguez in place against the wall.

"Andy!" Prue gasped and ran to him with her sisters to find that Phoebe's premonition wasn't one they could stop. Despite everything, despite all the changes they made, Andy still died in the end. She leaned over Andy's body and cried while Andy communicated with her, in a way, from the afterlife telling her to end the time loop or else his death would be in vain.

Rodriguez laughed at Mara because he could see the rage in her eyes. "Go ahead. Kill me."

"No," Prue sniffled as she got to her feet and went over to Mara. "If you kill him time will reset."

"Damn right it will and Andy will be alive." Mara was more than willing to kill this Demon scum for that to happen.

"And who will die if he's saved?" Eva asked as she went over to Mara and gently placed a hand on her shoulder. "You should know better than anyone how the balance between life and death needs to be maintained. The Demon we need to vanquish is Tempus, Dove."

Mara closed her eyes tightly as tears started to well in them. "It's not fair." She turned her head to look at Prue. "You don't deserve to lose Andy."

"And Andy doesn't deserve to have his death be in vain." Prue took a deep shaky breath and went over to the Book of Shadows for the spell to accelerate time since the Book said in order to vanquish Tempus that they had to remove him from the time he was in, so that's what she did.

Prue cast the spell to make tomorrow today and thus successfully broke the time loop. With that done, she said to Mara. "Release him. Just let him go."

"You can't be serious, Prue." Phoebe couldn't believe this. "After all that he's done."

"That's what makes him the monster, not us," Prue replied and repeated to Mara. "Release him."

"He'll just try to kill you again." Mara wasn't going to let him go that easiy.

"He doesn't have the power to. If he did then he wouldn't have needed to work with Tempus." Prue was confident about that.

Mara released him with a disgruntled mutter and joined P3 where they stood.

Rodriguez scoffed, "Stupid Witches," before going to the door. He paused there and turned around, revealing his blood red eyes. With a cry of rage, he conjured up two energy balls and threw them at the Charmed Ones.

Both Mara and Prue deflected them back to Rodriguez causing his vanquish.

This made Prue say, "We may not be monsters but we're not angels either." She gave Mara's shoulder a gentle squeeze before going back to where Andy's body laid, allowing herself time to grieve before next steps had to be made.

The following day after the time loop had been broken, Felix came out of the newly added guest room in Eva's loft and found his sister in the kitchen. "That was some pretty Harry Potter magic you casted there."

"I was going more for Halloweentown," Eva replied as she handed Felix a glass of milk.

They both paused in that moment because they each felt a strong sense of déjà vu, but since they didn't feel any alterations in time they proceeded with their morning along with a conversation they didn't remember previously having. However this time it had a different ending;

"And what if Bash tells her? What's stopping him from telling Mara everything he knows?"

"He won't." Eva was quite certain of that. "He knows what that would do to her. Bash wouldn't hurt her like that. He may not be falling in love with her but that doesn't mean he does not care."

Felix wasn't as confident as Eva was with all of this. He lifted his glass in a 'cheers' manner, "We'll see."

"There is no 'we'll see'. If I even get a sense that Bash will tell Mara anything I will silence him forever." At Felix's speechless expression, Eva tweaked Prue's words to suit herself. "I may not be a fulltime monster, but I'm not a fulltime angel either."

End Season 1 Episode 22 – Season 1 Finale