DISCLAIMER: I DO NOT OWN ANY OF THE FOLLOWING CHARACTERS EXCEPT FOR ALEXA AND KALEIGH AND MELISSA.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

They were 4 hours into the drive and Randy was sleeping in the backseat, Alexa was in the passenger seat and John was driving. Alexa and John avoided talking to each other for the whole ride so far.

John pulled up to a stop light and looked over at Alexa who was looking out the window. As the light turned green and John looked away from Alexa he caught a glimpse of the ring on Alexa finger. He shook his head, "So I guess you two made up?"

Alexa looked at John, "Yeah, we did."

John was quiet for a few minutes before saying, "So when's the wedding?"

Alexa was confused until she looked down at her hand and saw the ring, "Oh…um…I don't know yet. We just got engaged last night."

John laughed sarcastically, "So he cheats on you and you get engaged to him. Yeah, good thinking Alexa, he'll make a great husband."

"It was a mistake John; he didn't cheat on me on purpose. And why do you care anyway?"

"I don't," John said.

"Then shut up about it," Alexa said.

John rolled his eyes and continued driving.

About an hour later John got pulled into a little diner. He parked the car and turned it off and opened his door.

"Wake up your 'fiancé', we're eating dinner before we rent a hotel for the night," John said as he got out of the car and headed inside.

Alexa rolled her eyes before taking off her seat belt and getting out of the car, "What did I do to you John?" Alexa said as she shut the car door. The sounds of the doors shutting woke Randy up. He looked out the window and saw Alexa and John yelling at each other.

"Nothing Alexa," John said. "You did nothing. I just find it funny how you can be with someone who cheats on you but yet you can't be with me just because of some stupid reason."

Alexa looked at John, "That's what this is about?" She got in John's face, "I'm going to say this one time, I love that man in there John, more than anything, more than you. So you let us be happy, stay the hell out of our relationship. Besides, you got your little Melissa anyway."

"Yeah, I do," John said. "And she is a hundred times better than you." John went to walk away before turning to Alexa, "One more thing, I am praying to god that the baby you're carrying is not mine. I don't want to be around anymore than completely necessary." John walked into the diner.

Randy opened the car door and got out, "What was all that about?"

"Nothing, we just had a little disagreement. Let's just go eat," Alexa said.

Randy took Alexa's hand, he believed her because he couldn't really make out what was being said between the two, and he figured that she would tell him later. Alexa and Randy walked into the diner, found John, and sat down at the table.

"So you wanna just get a hotel here for the night?" John asked Randy.

"Yeah," Randy said. "We can find one here and then finish driving tomorrow."

The waiter came and everyone placed their orders. The food came shortly after, John and Randy talked while they ate, Alexa stayed quiet and didn't really eat anything. She just sat there picking at her food with her fork.

"Are you OK baby?" Randy asked.

Alexa looked up at Randy and gave him a fake smile, "Yeah, I'm fine."

Randy kissed her and then went back to his conversation with John.

They finished up at the diner and left and rented a hotel. All that was available was one room with two beds. They paid for it and made their way to the room. When they got in Randy and John turned the game on and went and watched that.

"I'm going for a walk," Alexa said.

"Ok baby," Randy said.

Alexa grabbed her phone and left the room. She went out to the pool and sat on the edge of it with her feet in the water.

Alexa flipped open her phone and dialed her best friend's number.

"Hello?" Ashley said, answering the phone.

"Hey," Alexa said.

"Oh look, it's my quote un quote best friend," Ashley said. "What have you been up to? I hear you're pregnant again, and it's either John or Randy's. When did Randy become part of your love life?"

"Well I see you've been keeping in touch with Dave," Alexa said. "Randy's been in my love life for a while. And he's gonna be in it…forever."

"What?" Ashley said. "The baby is his?"

"I don't know. But him and I are engaged," Alexa said.

"Oh," Ashley said. "You don't sound too excited."

"Oh, I am," Alexa said. "Don't get me wrong, I love him and I want to be with him."

"But…"

"John, he…just…I don't know."

Ashley took a deep breath, "If only you could have them both."

"Things would be easier."

"Yeah, but you can't have them both so my friendly advice to you is to go with the one who is better for you."

"Yeah, that's the problem; I don't know which one is best. I am completely in love with Randy, but John is the father of my baby. Randy could be the father of this one, John is being a jerk. John is in love with me, Randy cheated on me. Randy is my fiancé, John has a girlfriend. It's like every bad thing one does the other one does something good. I can't decide who's worse, or better."

"Well, John's has a girlfriend which means he must not love you too much. He would have left her for you a long time ago to prove you're the only one he wants. And Randy, he cheated on you but yet you still said yes to his purposal, which means you trust him not to do it again which means you want your relationship with him to work."

"So Randy's the one," Alexa said.

"From what I hear, yes he is," Ashley said. "But with your life, you never know."

Alexa laughed, "Yeah."

"Well Sean is crying," Ashley said. "Call me tomorrow?"

"OK," Alexa said. "Thanks Ashley."

"No problem, that's what I'm here for. I'll talk to you tomorrow."

"Ok bye," Alexa said before they both hung up. 'Ashley's right,' she thought. 'Randy's the one.' Alexa got up and made her way back to the room. When she opened the door she saw both of the guys asleep on their beds. Alexa changed her clothes and then climbed into bed next to Randy. "I love you," she whispered before kissing him.