Unforgettable Love
by CollegeStar21
Summary
Brittany Pierce and Santana Lopez were finally a couple and not to be open at McKinley High. Everybody knew they had something going with them and didn't care because they knew that Santana would kick their asses for messing with her girlfriend.
But what happens when Brittany's old childhood best friend/first ever girlfriend, Rachel Berry moves back to Lima after being in California for so long, shows up Brittany's and her Senior year all grown up and not the same girl she was when she was younger,sparking up feelings that Brittany struggled to long forget while also putting a strain on her relationship with Santana Lopez?
Will Brittany and Rachel start their friendship over as just best friends or will they finally admit that they still want each other? Find out what happens.
Season 4 Rachel Berry clothes and hair style in this story. Minor Brittana relationship but Brittberry and Quinntana romance hopefully in the end.
Enjoy.
On Friday.
It was time for Mike's and Rachel's duet since the others but Finn and Quinn and Mike and Rachel have gone and Brittany was excited to see what her girlfriend was doing.
Mike/Rachel/Both.
"Alright Mike and Rachel will go first then Quinn and Finn will go last then I'll decide who win the coupons to Breadstixs." Mr. Shue tells them before taking his seat.
Mike walks into the room first wearing black jeans, a black and white shirt, a black hat with converses on his feet and he looks down posing.
Rachel struts into the room after him wearing sexy black tights, a black leotard over the tights with a sexy maroon top that was half off her shoulder. She has on black heels, Her makeup was dark and her hair was down in wilded curls. She gets behind not facing the group and pose.
The music starts and the band starts as they whisle as Mike dances while doing short breathes and snapping.
1! 2! 3!
Rachel spins around now facing the room snapping her own fingers doing a few dances steps then posed as Mike sang.
When I look into your eyes, I'm a Trouble Maker
Rachel turns to the group and does a sexy dance move while singing then faced Mike.
When I stand next to you, I'm a Trouble Maker
He danced his way closer to her wrapping one of his arms around her waist and another one is placed on her cheek singing to her which Tina, Ariella and Brittany weren;t happy about.
Little by little, more more more
Rachel gives Mike a sexy look singing, sliding her fingers up his shoulder.
As we go on, more more more
They sing together while doing the steps they came up with that Brittany and Tina finally got what they were talking about in the hallway because they Mike was behind Rachel as she shakes her hips dancing and he placed his on on her hips almost holding her and then they turned their bodys and Rachel sticks her hand out and he holds it looking like he was about to kiss her but she turns her head then they have their backs against each other moving their arms.
Now I can't help my heart either
I'll keep being in front of you so you can't forget me
I'll keep shaking your heart so you can't escape me
I will steal your lips and run far away
I'm a Tro ble! Trouble! Trou! Trouble Maker!
Rachel turns around and slowly shakes her hips in a sexy way while Mike placed his hand on her ass a little as she shakes her hips then he pushes her to the other side of him.
Trouble Maker!
She spins around moving closer to him, wrapping her arm around his neck smirking at the group singing her part while his back faced the group.
Trouble Maker!
Rachel pushes him away going a little back away from him while he danced singing his part which made the group cheer and clap their hands to the beat.
Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
Rachel struts back to the front and starts singing/rapping her solo which shocks the group and she danced around Mike while doing this.
I will bite your heart and run away like a cat
You will keep getting irritated, so come to me and get mad
My sexy walk ignites the inside of your head
Brittany couldn't take her eyes off her girlfriend as she stands off to the side swaying her hips while Mike does his solo.
The slight skinship - your eyes on your face say you can't take it anymore
As I go on, you'll fall even deeper - I like you the more I get to know you baby
I think I am drunk with thoughts of you Lady
I never never never stop!
Mike walked over to his duet partner and grabbed her hand and they go back to singing the part of the song doing the same same dance steps then they do different ones.
I'll keep being in front of you so you can't forget me
I'll keep shaking your heart so you can't escape me
I will steal your lips and run far away
I'm a Tro ble! Trouble! Trou! Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
Mr. Shue stared at Mike and Rachel surprised at how good of singers and dancers they are together and was really impressed with Mike's voice because he hardly ever sings.
How can I put you in my heart (Trouble Maker)
Now I will go wherever my heart takes me
I never never stop!
I can't stop
Mike does a dance solo then Rachel joins him and everybody is cheering for them loving it. Brittany had a huge loving smile on her face watching her girlfriend dance like this. This was something that surprised her.
I'll keep being in front of you so you can't forget me
I'll keep shaking your heart so you can't escape me
I will steal your lips and run far away
I'm a Tro ble! Trouble! Trou! Trouble Maker!
Rachel stayed with Mike and danced with him with her arms around his neck as they faced the group singing and everybody was loving it.
Santana,Quinn and Finn had a scolded looks on their faces because they didn't think that Mike and Rachel were going to be this good.
Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
Trouble Maker!
They dance together and at the end Mike has his arm around her waist facing the group while Rachel isn't facing the group with her arm around his neck and they both pose like that when it was over then everybody cheered clapping. Both Brittany and Tina were glad the dance was over. Mr. Shue stood up clapping his hands.
"That was fantastic Mike and Rachel. I've never heard that song before but I loved it and the dancing was amazing." They tell him that it was a song in a different langage but they did it English.
"Well it was amazing, right guys?" They all nodded clapping in jealousy because they knew that Mike and Rachel were really good.
Mike and Rachel sat down together and Brittany frowns not liking that her girlfriend wasn't sitting with her but wasn't going to make a big deal about it.
Quinn/Finn/Both.
"Alright last is Quinn and Finn." The group clapped and both of them stand in the front and the music starts.
Uh
Eh
Another shot of whiskey please bartender
Keep it coming til I don't remember at all
How bad it hurts when you're gone (no no no no)
Turn the music up a little bit louder Who am I kidding?
Just gotta get past the midnight hour (uh huh)
Maybe tomorrow it won't be this hard
I know what I'm missing
Santana stared at Quinn as she sings and felt like this was song was towards her and sighs sadly listening.
Oh, I had my heart set on you
But nothing else hurts like you do
Who knew that love was so cruel (yeah, yeah, yeah)
And I waited and waited so long
For someone who'll never come home
It's my fault to think you'd be true (yeah, yeah)
I'm just a fool
(Yeah)
Finn sang next while Quinn stays quiet until her next part comes.
I say that I don't care
And walk away whatever
And I tell myself we were bad together (uh huh)
But that's just me trying to move on without you
Both of them stare at each other singing together.
But who am I kidding?
I know what I'm missing
I, I had my heart set on you
But nothing else hurts like you do
Who knew that love was so cruel (yeah, yeah, yeah)
And I waited and waited so long
For someone who'll never come home
It's my fault to think you'd be true (yeah, yeah)
Santana felt eyes on her and looked up to see Quinn staring at her strongly.
I'm just a fool
For holding onto something that's
Is never ever gonna come back
I can't accept that it's lost
I should've have let it go
Held my tongue
Kept my big mouth shut
'Cause now everything is just wrong, wrong, wrong
Quinn looks away from Santana, fighting her tears and sang to Finn finishing up the song.
I'm just a fool
A fool for you
I'm just a fool
I, I had my heart set on you
But nothing else hurts like you do
Who knew that love was so cruel (yeah, yeah, yeah)
And I waited and waited so long
For someone who'll never come home
It's my fault to think you'd be true (yeah, yeah)
I'm just a fool
I'm just a fool
I'm just a fool
It's my fault to think you'd be true (yeah, yeah, yeah)
I'm just a fool
They end the song and everybody cheered and clapped for them as they took their seats. The whole group was waiting for Mr. Shue to pick the winners.
"Okay I've heard everybody sing and watched you all danced and you didn't make it easy for me to pick. The winners are Mike and Rachel and Quinn and Finn with a tie."
Santana glared at the two groups not believing she wasn't part of that tie and everybody clapped for them.
Rachel and Mike hugged each other then got up and got the one set of couppns from Mr. Shue then Mike picks Rachel up making her laugh.
"I told you were so going to win this Rach." Mike whispered in Rachel's ear smiling. Rachel giggles nodding.
"We tied Mike but were still winners and that's fine by me." Rachel whispers back hugging him. Quinn and Finn take the other set of coupons and thank him before taking their seats to pick a day when they should
Brittany cleared her throat loudly seeing that Mike's hand was still on her girlfriend's waist. Mike pulls back putting her back down and smiles awkwardly before whispering into Rachel's ear and she nods grinning before walking out of the room to change her clothes.
"Alright guys that's it for our duets. Next week were going to start working on songs for Sectionals, have a great weekend." Mr. Shue tells them before the bell rings.
Rachel comes back a few minutes later wearing the same top but she has a black bra under it with a pair of black skinny jeans on and she's still wearing the same black heels,her clothes are in her bag and walked over to Mike talking to him for a second about what day they should go and then he goes over to Tina and they walk out with some of the others.
Ariella and Kalaeia walked out saying that they will see her at home. Brittany grabs her bag and walked over to her girlfriend.
"That was amazingly sexy Rachy, I had no idea it was going to be that hot of a number you two were doing." Brittany says winking at her and slipped her fingers into Rachel's hand.
"Didn't I tell you that that it was going to be a number that you couldn't take your eyes off me baby?" Brittany nods remebering her say that and pecks her lips.
Santana stared at them sighing softly then glanced at Quinn who was softly talking to Lori and didn't like how close they were getting to know each other.
She decided that Brittany was no longer what she wanted in a relationship, sure friendship is fine but that was it.
She wanted Quinn Fabray to give her a chance and hopefully she could have her. Santana watched Brittany and Rachel hold hands as they walked out of the room.
"Quinn can I talk to you for a second?" Lori glanced at Quinn talking to her softly and she nods before Lori walks out.
Santana glanced at Lori as she leaves then turns back to her and sighs awkwardly.
"So are you and Lori starting something or whatever?" Quinn sighs.
"Not that it's any of your business but were just friends because she knows that I have feelings for somebody else." Santana frowns.
"Oh never mind then." She starts to leave when Quinn grabs her hand.
"Are you that clueless Santana? you know it's you." Santana sighs feeling confused.
"Would you like to go to breadstixs with me right now so we can talk?" She asked hopefully. Quinn smiles slightly.
"I would like that alot." Santana looks back at her and grins as they both walk out and get ready to leave school for the day.
Find out what happens next songs were Troublemaker by Hyuna & Jang hyun seung but I did the lyrics in English and Just A Fool by Christina Aguilera and Blake Shelton.