Unforgettable Love
by WorkingGirl22
Summary
Brittany Pierce and Santana Lopez were finally a couple and not to be open at McKinley High. Everybody knew they had something going with them and didn't care because they knew that Santana would kick their asses for messing with her girlfriend.
But what happens when Brittany's old childhood best friend/first ever girlfriend, Rachel Berry moves back to Lima after being in California for so long, shows up Brittany's and her Senior year all grown up and not the same girl she was when she was younger,sparking up feelings that Brittany struggled to long forget while also putting a strain on her relationship with Santana Lopez?
Will Brittany and Rachel start their friendship over as just best friends or will they finally admit that they still want each other? Find out what happens.
Season 4 Rachel Berry clothes and hair style in this story. Minor Brittana relationship but Brittberry and Quinntana romance hopefully in the end.
Enjoy.
A Week Later.
Rachel Berry was at her locker, staring at the pictures of her and her friends back in California wishing all of them were with her and the twins. She still felt nervous around here after the shooting. That guy could have killed her girlfriend last week and her best friends while they were in the bathroom. She could be without the love of her life right now but she wasn't which she was grateful forand it still scared her.
"Rachel can we talk?" She jumped a little, hearing Santana's voice.
"Not really Santana." Rachel says checking her notes.
"Why not midget?" Rachel spun around glaring at her.
"That's why not, your bitchy attitude makes me not want to be around you or even talk to you. I get that you hate for me for showing up at your school, sort of stealing Brittany from you while you two were together and talking back to you when most people are too scared to even do that but I'm not most people Santana." Santana stared at her.
"Are you done now hobbit?" Rachel scuffed rolling her eyes.
"Yes I'm done and my name is Rachel, good bye Lopez." She grabbed her books, picked up her bag and closed her locker walking off.
Santana stood there watching Rachel walking off down the crowded hallway. Oh this was going to be a long year for the both of them.
Brittany was walking past her when she stopped her.
"Brittany wait up." Britt stopped walking and looked back at Santana.
"Are you following in your girlfriend's footsteps and ignoring me too?" Brittany just stares at her.
"I know what I did at Quinn's house was wrong, I shouldn't have tricked you into cheating on Rachel." She nods.
"Santana I get that having Rachel here isn't easy for you since we broke up but you had no right to play me like that. We're supposed to be best friends who are always there for each other no matter what, what happened to my best friend?" Santana stared at her confused.
"I'm still here Britt." She shook her head.
"No your not, my best friend would have never hurt the way you did. You made me feel stupid by tricking me into hanging out with you guys when it was all about you trying to get me back as your girlfriend." She frowns.
"I did?" Brittany just nods then turns around and walked off to her next class.
"Brittany I never meant to make you feel that way, you have to believe me, I just don't think she's right for you." San yells trying to get her stop.
She stops and walked back to her. "That's not your choice to make Santana. What I do with my love life is none of your concern anymore." Santana stares at her sadly.
"It use to be Brittany until she came here, I use to be all you cared about besides our friends, I use to be the main focus in your life as your lover and best friend, we were perfect together, I get that you need a break but when is this break going to be over? when are we going to get back together and spend the rest of our lives together like we promised?"
Brittany stares into her eyes then looked behind her, seeing Quinn standing there and sighs shaking her head.
"Never because I don't want to spend the rest of my life with you. You can't even be fully committed to your new relationship with Quinn, I'm sorry Santana but we're done for good. As for our friendship? We'll be best friends for life but if you keep insulting my girlfriend then I don't know if I want to be friends with you."
Britt left after that. Santana sighs feeling somebody walking past her and saw Quinn now standing infront of her.
"Hey babe." She says half heartly leaning in to kiss her but Quinn just turned her head.
"Okay why are you acting like that?" Santana asked confused.
"You still like Brittany and I'm kidding myself." She starts to protest but Quinn puts her hand up.
"Don't lie to me Santana, everybody in this whole school knows how deep your relationship with Brittany was. Don't play me like a fool." Quinn sighs looking down.
"Until you figure out what the hell you want, we're done." Quinn says sadly then walks off.
Puck was having a party at his house tonight since it was friday and they had just won Sectional's two days ago and close friends of his was invited so that meant that the whole Glee club would be there. Santana walked in looking hot in a skintight black and pink mini dress, wearing a pair of black high heeled boots. Her hair was down in curls and her makeup was just right.
She looked around and spotted Kurt and Mercedes talking to Blaine and Mercedes new man Shane. She smiled at them then made her way around. She sees Brittany talking to Quinn while wearing a very cute but still sexy floral print halter mini dress with some red heels. Her hair was down pulled back a little in a clip. She had on red lipstick and her makeup looked really good. San looks around wondering where Rachel was.
She hears Brittany call Rachel's name and glanced over at her taking in her look. She had a short flowy black shirt that was up a little showing her waist a bit but her top was also black and it was tied in the back like a halter top. On her feet are black heels. Her hair was down flowing down her back in wavy curls and her makeup was dark but not too dark.
Rachel looked really good tonight. Santana watched her walk over to Brittany and frowns seeing her ex put her hand on Rachel's ass holding her close.
"I use to do that with Brittany and now I have to watch her do that to her? I need a fucking drink." Santana mutters walking over to the table where the drinks were.
"You plan on getting trashed tonight Lopez?" Santana turns her head to see one of the goth twins staring at her.
"Yup my girl broke up with two days ago, my other ex girl rather be with Rachel so here I am ready to party." Ariella nods knowing how she feels.
"Well I'll join you since I rather be with Rachel and she's all up on Brittany." Santana stared at the girls as they laughed with some random people, taking a swing of her beer.
San watched Brittany run her fingers through Rachel's hair before bending down to kiss her on the lips. They really looked like the cutest couple.
"It makes you sick huh?" Arielle whispered in her ear.
"Have they been like that all night?" She whispered back.
"Who really knows, I just know that they don't plan on leaving each others all night or for the rest of their lives." Ariella spoke then left.
Santana watched the couple go to the make shift danced floor and begin dancing with each other. Brittany held Rachel by the hips swaying her hips. Rachel had one hand around her neck as they swayed their hips together.
In Brittany's POV.
I'm enjoying my night with my friends and my lover when I felt eyes on us. I turned my head to see Santana watching us with beer in her hands. She was going to head up crying all night because when she drinks, she cries. I whispered in Rachel's ear that I'll be right back and she nods pulling away and dances with Kurt.
I made my way over to her and sighs. "Santana don't get drunk all night, I know how you get." She just glared at me.
"Fine don't listen to me. Get drunk all you want but I'm just trying to be your friend here." She just ignores me and keeps on drinking.
"Whatever Santana." I finally walk away and wrapped my arms around my girl from behind and we kept on dancing like this for awhile then made out in a corner of Puck's house. I wasn't going to let Santana ruin my night because of how bitter and jealous she is.
Find out what happens next.