True Love Conquers All

By WorkingGirl22

Summary

It's the Sequel to With True Love Anything Can Happen. It will focus on the rest of Santana's and Rachel's Senior year as a married couple. then during college and the rest of their lives together. It will also focus on Jasper's and Aqua's relationship, Arilyn's and Finn's relationship, also Rossi and Puck's relationship that won't be lasting much longer. It will also focus on how Santana and Rachel will be like when they are old enough to be mothers.

Shelby, Hiram, Leroy and the rest of the New Directions will still be in the story. Jake, Marley, Unique, Ryder and Kitty will also be in this story.

Quinn will also work on her friendship with Santana and Rachel at some point.

I'm adding two new girls to the story, One's name will be London Castillo. She's latina, sassy, bitchy, outspoken and she's going to be a childhood best friend of Santana's who will finish up her Senior year at McKinley.

The other one is Misty Ellington. She's black, also sassy, bitchy, outspoken and she causes drama alot but she was Santana's and London's best friend and likes to steal others boyfriends. She also moved with London's family and her own family to Lima and will be going to McKinley to finish up her Senior year.

Just you know that Santana's other old friends have been going to Carmel but not Emilio since he's 21 and lives alone with his sister. You will see them in this story from now on from time to time and they will also be in New York with the girls.

Enjoy.

At Breadstixs.

Puck walked into Breadstixs nervously. Today was the day he's been waiting for. Mr. Cooper called him a few days ago telling him that Nigal and Kallie Rogers were up for having the first face to face visit with him and Beth.

"Noah we're over here." The voice of Kallie Rogers called out from one of the booths. He looked around and saw her waving him over. He took a deep breath before joining them. He smiled shaking their hands.

"Have a seat, we're nervous ourselves." He nods calming down a little while sitting down.

The waitress walks over to them and asked him what he wanted to drink. He tells her what he wants then she leaves.

"Are you ready to hold her?" Nigal asked young high school student. Puck shook his head for a second staring at the little 1 year old that was laying her head against Kallie's chest.

"We have all the time in the world so take your time Noah." Kallie says with a assuring smile. He stared at Beth taking in her beauty. She was a copy of him and Quinn all together. She had her mother's blonde hair, her skintone but she had his eyes and ears. She the most gorgeous baby he's ever seen and he created her with Quinn.

"I'm ready now, can I hold her?" Kallie smiles nodding. She gently hands Beth over him and they told him how to hold her.

Beth her mommy and Daddy confused then looked at the guy holding her, she saw that she had the same eyes as him.

"Hi Beth I know this is very confusing to you but I'm Noah Puckerman." He said softly.

"Do you want me say that I'm her biological father or should I just stick to being Noah for now?" They looked at each other then back at him.

"We talked over and we want you in Beth's life as she grows up. For now we should just stick to you being just Noah, when she's older we'll bring it up again."

"I'm perfectly fine with that. Can we take a few pictures together?" He asked hopefully.

"Of course we were planning on doing this tomorrow before we headed back to California. It's fine to take them today." He smiles very grateful.

"Bethy do you want to take pictures with Noah?" They both cooed. She placed her hand on his face still unsure but she was warming up to him.

"Wow I'm impressed. She's not like that with most people that meet her for the first time." Puck felt blessed that Beth was calm with him.

He hands them his phone and Beth lays her head against his chest looking away from the camera as they took a picture together.

"Bethy look at the camera for mommy and Daddy." Puck was jealous of Nigal. Beth was his daughter but she was also Nigal's. He did the right thing because he wants to get out of Lima and hopefully go to college in California so he can be close to Beth more.

"She likes you alot. Now what's going on with Quinn?" He sighs not wanting to get into it at the moment. He's just going to make it short.

"Well something happened between her and my childhood best which ended with Quinn being jail for a few days and my best friend in the hospital. Quinn went to a health center to get her mind straight and now she's out. I think it's best that she keeps getting her life together and hopefully when she's ready then she might be up for seeing Beth." They nod understanding where he was coming from. They wanted Quinn be in good health when she got to know Beth.

They talk more and enjoy dinner together before it was time to end the day. Nigal starts to take Beth from her birth father but she was clinging onto him.

"Do you want to take her to our car since she doesn't want to let go of you, I guess she really likes you." He nods loving that Beth was warming up to more.

They walk out with Beth all dressed for the still chilly weather. Rossi and Bryson, Emillio and London bumped into them.

"I'm so sorry, I should have watched where I was going." Rossi said feeling bad when she noticed that there was a little baby in the person's arms.

"It's fine Rossi, have a good evening." Puck said nicely about to leave when Rossi spoke.

"Noah is that-" He looked back at her and nods.

"Yes Rossi this is my daughter Beth." He tells her before walking over to Nigal's and Kallie's car with Beth still in his arms.

Rossi stared at the little baby in her ex boyfriend's arms shocked, this is what Rachel was talking about. He was getting ready to meet his daughter since she's been born? She felt like a bitch for forbidding her sister from speaking to him.

"Are we going to go in or not?" London spoke wanting to get warm.

Rossi ignored London's queston as she watched Noah kiss his daughter's forehead. She saw the older couple take her from him and they talk for a little bit then he waves at them before glancing at her before going to his car.

"You ready now?" Bryson whispered. Rossi looked at them saying sorry and opened the door walking in with the other couple that was joining them for a double date.

At The Puckerman House.

When Puck pulled up to his driveway he saw Santana's car in his driveway. He knew that Rachel was with her. He turned the car off and get out after taking his keys out. He closed the door locking it then walked to the front door, opening the door.

"Santana, Rachel are you here?" He yelled.

"We're in the kitchen." He closed the front door then walked into the kitchen to see his best friends sitting down with his mom and sister.

"So how did it go?" He sits down and starts telling them everything.

"Wow this is a great start Noah." Rachel said so happy for him.

"We took pictures, do you want to see them?" They all yelled yes. He chuckles showing them the pictures on his phone.

"Woah she looks just like you and Quinn." Santana said taking a longer look at the picture of Beth.

"We're going to be meet up tomorrow before they head back to California. Thank you girls for being in my corner during this time." The married couple smiled.

"Of course Noah, you need somebody besides your mom and sister on your side." Rachel said looking at the picture of him and Beth together.

"My woman is right, you might do some messed up things but your not a bad person and we're best friends for life." He believed her.

They talk more looking at the pictures then Santana and Rachel go home.

Find Out what happens next.