She's Your Sister?
By CollegeStar20!
Summary.
16 year old Santana Lopez born and raised in boring Lima Ohio, gorgeous badass latina, has black eyes, smoking hot body, Co. Captain of the McKinley High cheerios, is a Junior this year and part of the New Directions Glee club. She's a closeted Lesbian and isnt ready to come out yet and the only people that know are her parents who are supportive, her two best friends Brittany Pierce and Quinn Fabray who she's the most closest to. What happens when Santana finds out that her best friend since middle school has a fraternal twin named Rachel who has been at a Musical Arts Boarding school in Paris France? What happens when Quinn finds out that Santana likes her twin sister/best friend? Will Quinn keep them apart or will she set them up?
Oh Quinn's and Rachel's parents are Leroy and Judy Fabray just letting you know. I didn't like Russel so I'm using one of Rachel's dads.
At The Fabray House With Rachel and Angelica.
Rachel was in her daughters room sitting on the ground watching her daughter play with her toys fighting her tears because of the pain she was feeling in her hand from physical therapy but also because she doesn't know who she wants between Cecilia and Santana and she hated that she had to pick one because they both seemed like great girls but she was stressing out and she just wanted so peace in life.
Santana and Brittany got the okay to visit their family so Quinn drove them and her parents are downstairs making dinner.
Angelica turned around from playing and saw her mommy in tears and crawled over to her pouting.
"Mommy I'm sowwy." Rachel stared at her daughter confused sniffling and wiped her tears with her good hand.
"Sweetie what are you sorry about?" Angelica points to her hand and moves closer to her and Rachel sighs picking her up placing in her arms.
"You didn't do anything to my hand baby,mommy is just tired and in a little pain and you can't help me." Angelica frowns and kissed her mommy's cast hand and Rachel laughs sniffling a little and kisses her daughter's forehead.
"Better mommy?" Rachel nods smiling lovingly at her daughter.
"Yes baby, mommy is better with you around." Angelica smiles wiping her mommy's tears and Rachel held her close.
"You want to take a nap in mommy's room?" Angelica nods clapping her hands and Rachel gets up and takes Angel with her and they go in her room.
Rachel already changed into some sweatpants and a t shirt and her daughter was changed aswell for the evening. Rach placed her daughter on her chest and she snuggled up to her and Angel instantly closed her eyes and Rachel could feel her breathing smoothly and knew she was tired.
"Mommy loves you Angel, I'm trying to be the best mother for you and make sure you have such a great life and mommy is just tired." She whispered and closed her eyes falling into a comfortable sleep.
Later That Night.
Santana and Brittany are back from visiting their family and they had dinner there aswell and changed out of their cheerios before they left so they were ready for bed and Santana looked around for Rachel and Angelica and she didn't them anywhere.
"Where is Rachel and Angel?" Both girls asked wondering.
"Angelica is in her crib for the night and Rachel is asleep for the night awell, she was in pain before and took her pills and just needs sleep." Leroy says.
Both girls nod and say that their going to bed and they go upstairs and Santana checks on Rachel and opened the door to see Rachel sleeping in her bed peacefully and smiled really glad that she got to share a kiss with Rachel but she saw Cecilia kiss her aswell and it did break her heart seeing Rae kiss another person but she understood that she was going to see if she had sparks with Cecilia and it looked like she did but she hoped that she had stronger sparks with herself.
"I really hope you give me a chance Rae because I can't see my life without you in my arms, giving you sweet lady kisses and being a second mother to Angelica even if I'm only 16 years old, I don't care I want to be with you and hopefully I can call you my girlfriend." Santana whispered before closing the door and going to her room.
Rachel stared at Cecilia and Santana at different times durning the day at school trying to think about who she wanted to be with and she knows that her daughter loves both girls differently but lately she's seen the way Angelica as been looking at Santana as a second mother and it doesn't surprise her at all because sure Cecilia is great with her daughter because Elisa is her best friend but Santana has been around Angel alot more and if her daughter call her mama she wouldn't be shocked.
Santana walked up to Rachel at her locker and smiled clearing her throat and Rachel stared at her.
"Are you ready to sing our song in Glee club today Rae?" Rachel smiled at her nicely nodding saying sure and Santana sighs.
"Look Rae I'm not pressuring you to pick me but it still doesn't mean you have to push me away, can't you just be my friend while your thinking?" Rachel sighs.
"I'm sorry you and Cecilia are thinking that I'm pushing you away but it's not easy being around you girls without being stressed out at who to choose and I just need alone time but I promise that I will tell you girls very soon who I want to be with! please just let me think and I'll see you at Glee club."
She walked off still thinking and ignored Cecilia calling her and Santana sighs watching her leave but also stared at Cecilia to see her looking back at her knowing she's feeling the same and walked over to her.
"Why don't you just give it up now Jackson, sure I hurt her in the beginning but your just boring and she doesn't want somebody that's boring." Cecilia glared at her.
"Really? well what makes you think she wants somebody that tried to kill her over jealousy of losing your best friend? we'll see who she picks." She walked off.
At Glee club practice.
Rachel was sitting next to Sam and Santana was sitting next to Matt as the music starts and everybody was watching them.
Both.
Girl, girl, girl...
Santana was looking at Matt sitting in her seat and starts singing to him as everybody watched her and Rachel danced in her seat smirking.
Santana.
I see you've fallen, fallen for me
That's not the thing to do
I'll tell you straight up now
Listen while I'm saying now
I'll play you like a fool
You think I'm pretty
Such a pity, don't know what you've got
And wife material is something that I'm really not
Don't even think about,
Taking me to momma's house
Taking me to momma's house
Oooh Ooooh
Santana and Rachel get up from their seats and dance on the steps doing the same dance they came up with and sing together.
Both.
I warned you from the start
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl (kinda girl, kinda girl)
Oooh Ooooh
I'm gonna break your heart,
Tear it up cause that's the way I work (way I work, way I work)
Oooh Ooooh
Rachel shakes her hips smiling at the group and she walked over to Santana and they dance together still singing.
Both.
No, I'm that woman, I'm free to roam
Won't blow you kisses, down the telephone
I warned you from the start
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl...
Everybody is liking the song and Brittany and Quinn are clapping to the beat and Kurt and Mercedes are getting nervous because their both so good! Rachel walks over to Sam and sings to him and smirks at him and Santana keeps dancing to the beat getting a little jealous as she sings to Sam.
Rachel.
I won't pretend I'll be the girl on your arm
Don't need no Mr Right
Forget the fancy things
I ain't looking for no strings
You got me dressed for tonight
You think I'm pretty
Such a pity don't know what you've got
Your little sweetening sugar is something that I'm really not
Don't even think about
Taking me to momma's house
Taking me to momma's house, oooh...
Rachel dances over to Santana and they do the same dance they did before smiling at each other while singing the main part again.
Both.
I warned you from the start
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl (kinda girl, kinda girl)
Oooh Ooooh
I'm gonna break your heart,
Tear it up cause that's the way I work (way I work, way I work)
Oooh Ooooh
Quinn stares at her sister and Santana together and liked the two together as they had fun dancing and singing together but knows that Rach doesn't know who she wants yet but she was hoping for Santana and Rachel together even if Cecilia is beautiful and has been so nice from the beginning.
Both.
No, I'm that woman, I'm free to roam
Won't blow you kisses, down the telephone
I warned you from the start
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl...
Santana.
Being good's not my thing
I like to walk on the dark side
Rachel.
Love's a stranger to me
But we can ride
Santana and Rachel.
Yeah, we can ride tonight (tonight...)
Santana and Rachel clapped their hands dancing to the beat and everybody joins in clapping as the girls finish up their song.
Both.
I warned you from the start
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl
Santana.
I'm not that kinda girl
Both.
Oooh Ooooh
I'm gonna break your heart,
Tear it up cause that's the way I work
Rachel.
That's the way I work.
Both.
Oooh Ooooh
No, I'm that woman, I'm free to roam
Won't blow you kisses, down the telephone
I warned you from the start
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl
Rachel.
I'm not that kinda girl
Santana.
That boy, I'm not that kinda girl...
They ended the song smiling and everybody cheered for them and Santana grins hugging Rachel carefully and Rachel pulled back uncomfortably and smiles at her before taking her seat and Santana hugs Brittany staring at Rachel awkwardly but puts on a fake smile for Britts and sits down next to her.
With Rachel After School.
Rachel was standing outside waiting for Quinn to hurry up when her phone rang and she saw her great friend Lexi from France calling her and picks up.
"Oh my god have I missed you so much." Rachel said smiling and Lexi smiles on the other line.
"I miss you too Rachel how is the life in Lima?" Rachel tells her what's been happening and Lexi feels bad for her.
"I think you need to follow your heart and if your heart believes that you should be with both of them or one of them, then figure it out darling, I love you girlie but I need to go but I will call you tomorrow." Rachel said okay and says that she loves her too and they hang up.
Rachel thought about what Lexi said and maybe she should talk to them about maybe being in a 3 way relationship, she's been in one before but it got a little too hard for the other people she was with after Frankie died.
"I really don't know anymore, god why am I having trouble breathing, and why is the world spinning." Rachel thought staring at her cast breathing really hard and starts shaking and she can't breathe and drops to the ground and didn't hear the voices calling her worried before everything goes black.
Find out what happens next and the song was Not That Kinda Girl by The Saturdays.