Ella and Chris finally left for their honeymoon in the Bahamas. Luckily, Castiel and Gabriel get to spend two weeks without their parents.
When the nighttime came, Cas washed his sheets that reminded him of his night with Dean. He didn't exactly what to do now that Dean knows the truth. How will their friendship even survive?
"Hey, bro," Gabe stops him by the staircase. "I'm going over to Penny's for a few hours."
"Well that's great even though she has 34D silicones," smirked Cas.
"Look, Cas, I'm sorry about you and Winchester. Don't worry. There'll be plenty of more for you."
"Well I did have a date today." Cas informs him.
"Guy or girl?" Gabe asks him. "I just have to know."
"His name is Balthazar. He's pretty cool and funny."
"At least you got someone other than Deanno. I hope you could get a girlfriend or boyfriend, dude."
"I am actually surprised that you're still being nice to me after everything that's happen."
"Yeah, well appreciate it while it lasts because I'm gonna go back to Trickster Gabe when I meet the next guy who sleeps in your bed. See you later, Cassie!" Gabe grabs his keys and leaves he house.
All alone in his house, Cas had nothing else to do but stay home. Once his sheets were dry, he walked into his room and noticed something. Next to his bed on the floor was a pair of dark green boxers. They weren't even his. They were Dean's.
"Great," Cas says to himself. "I have his underpants and he has my virginity. Story of my life."
Ring, ring, ring! His phone began to ring. Cas grabs it and answers, "Hello?"
"What's up, Cas?" said a familiar voice.
"Charlie? Hey, how's it going?"
"Sorry I haven't texted you all weekend. I've been doing the video game marathon all weekend."
"Well that's exciting. I need to tell you something."
"Oh, no, Cas, it wasn't my fault. Lisa told Dean or I don't know who told him. I guess he just figured it out."
"Yeah, well after the reception, I told that I love him. Then, we slept together."
"WHAT?!" Charlie screams through the phone.
"Ouch." Cas calmly says. "You might've broken my eardrums."
"You two had sex? So what does that mean?"
"I was just an experiment." He shamefully confesses to her. "Dean just had sex with me so that I would get over him."
"Really? Ugh! That no good son of a bitch! How could he do that?"
"The worst part was that I went on a date with Balthazar. Dean was there and…he yelled at us because I kissed Balthazar."
"Wait he yelled at y'all for kissing? What did he say?"
"He yelled, 'Get the hell off him.' It was like he was jealous."
"Did you talk to him after what happened? What did he say?"
"He left when I stopped kissing Balthazar. That really confused me. First, he doesn't want to be my boyfriend. Now he gets pissed off if I kiss a guy I was on a date with."
"You're in a real pickle there, Castiel. When I thought you two would get together, I thought it would be more like…When Harry met Sally."
"I'm not Meg Ryan and I figured that's what really was gonna happen."
"So what now? Are you still best friends with Dean?"
"I'm not sure. Whatever happens…Dean will always be a big part of my life. He's my best friend, my home."
"Don't you realize how awkward it's gonna be now that he knows that you love him and you know that he doesn't love you?" Cas didn't answer her. "Oh, fuck, I am so sorry I said that."
"No, no, it's fine." Castiel assures her. "I'll be alright. I might actually have a shot with Balthazar."
"I do hope you move on. Honestly, Cas, after everything you've been through, you deserve to be happy."
"Thank you, Charlie. You've been one of my greatest friends."
"That's that nicest thing anyone's ever said to me. I gotta go. These goblins are kicking my ass. I'll talk to you later. Bye."
"Bye, Charlie." Cas hangs up the phone and tosses it on the bed.
It was true. Castiel believes that he deserves happiness out of everyone else. He has been humiliated enough for the rest of his life. If only the memories of his fake relationship with Dean would disappear from his mind.
Beep! A text message appears on Cas's phone. He check it and shocked to find out that it was from Dean. Look outside, read the text.
Cas looks out his window and finds Dean in his backyard with a black acoustic guitar in his arms.
"Dean?" Cas says his name.
"This is for you," Dean tells him. He starts strumming the guitar and sang the song.
Earth angel,
Earth angel
Will you be mine
My darling dear
Love you all the time
I'm just a fool,
A fool in love, with you
Earth Angel
Earth angel
The one I adore
Love you forever
And ever more
I'm just a fool,
A fool in-love with you
I fell for you
And I knew
The vision of your loveliness
I hope and I pray,
That someday,
I'll be the vision of your
Happiness
Earth angel,
Earth angel
Please you be mine
My darling dear
Love you all the time
I'm just a fool,
A fool in love, with you
Before he knew it, Cas ran out of his room and nearly falls down the staircase. Finally, he opens his back door and sees Dean right there still singing the song.
I fell for you
And I knew
The vision of your loveliness
I hope and I pray,
That someday,
I'll be the vision of your
Happiness
Earth angel,
Earth angel
Please you be mine
My darling dear
Love you all the time
I'm just a fool,
A fool in love, with you
At last, Dean finishes the song. He and Castiel stand in the backyard in awkward silence. "That song is from your favorite movie, Back to the Future," Dean says. "I know how much you hated the sequels."
"You know that it's a love song," Cas informs him. "It perfectly describes George and Lorraine McFly."
"I know it's a love song. It reminded me of you." Dean admits.
Cas crosses his arms. "So what? You think that you're just gonna sing me a song and I'm ultimately going to forgive you."
After a long quiet moment, Dean answers, "Yes—I mean no. Or is it yes? Definitely no."
"What is this about, Dean? You're confusing me and I'm worried about you. Plus, why are you singing me a love song?"
"Isn't that why music was invented? Words aren't always enough. I just want to let you know how I feel about you."
At that moment, Cas's heart almost stopped beating. "How you feel about me? W-What about the other night?"
"Cas, if I tell you nothing but the truth, promise me you won't leave until I'm done."
"Okay, I'm listening."
"That night we had sex…I was only doing it so that you would get over me. I thought you just had a little crush on me and I thought it was a phase. Then, I started to like it."
"You liked it? I thought you were just experimenting on me."
"You never were an experiment, Cas. When I woke up, I realized that I just had sex with my best friend in the entire world. That's why I left. I felt like I ruined our entire friendship."
"How do you think I felt when I woke up and you were gone? I felt like a loser."
"Cas, I had no idea that you weren't faking it. It must've been difficult for you. I'm such a dumbass. I am so sorry for everything I've done."
"Don't apologize. I knew that eventually you were going to find out."
"Why didn't you tell me the truth? Instead of that, I had to hear it from Charlie, Sam, Lisa, and Gabe."
"Dean, you know why. You were gonna get grossed out and disgusted and you wouldn't wanna be friends with me anymore. You were just gonna remember me as your ex-best friend who was in love with you."
"I'm not grossed out." Dean confesses to him. "At the movies, I got jealous because of that British blonde guy kissing you. He made me see red. I just want you to know that…I'm started to fall for you."
Everything in Castiel's body bursts like fireworks. "You are? Are you sure?"
"Yeah, I tried so hard to deny too. I just can't help it anymore."
"What about Lisa?" Cas mentions.
"She dumped me when she found out the truth. Cas, I really wanna give this a shot. It's alright if you don't want to. We can still be friends."
In an instant, Cas leans over and presses his lips against Dean's lips. After a few seconds, he pulls back. Both of them couldn't help but smile and blush. "How about let's not fake it anymore?" Cas suggested. "I'm up for it if you are."
"Cas, this is actually the best news that I've heard in a long time." Dean sighed.
He puts the guitar down on the ground and embraces Cas into his arms. Once again they shared a passionate kiss that filled them both with waves of excitement. When they pulled back, both of them smiled and pressed their foreheads against one another.
"There's always the big kiss at the end of that stupid chick flicks," chuckles Dean. "What do we do now?"
"Dad and Ella left for the Bahamas," Cas informs him. "Gabe is at a friend's house. I'm all alone so we can start our actual relationship by watching the Hangover movies, cuddling, and kissing."
"I would so love that." Dean says.
For the rest of the night, Dean and Castiel stayed in bed watching movies and eating food. When Cas would snuggle up next to him, Dean took a quick sniff of him. His scent just made Dean's heart skip a beat. He loved that feeling and never wanted it to go away.
Dean didn't go home at all. He and Cas fell asleep in Cas's bed in a spooning position. Both of them knew how much it felt right and wonderful.
In the middle of the night, Gabriel returned home and caught a glimpse of his step-brother in bed with Dean. He walks in and looks down at them. They were apart from each other no longer in a spooning position.
"Nice Gabe is gone." Gabe whispers to himself. He grabs a big permanent marker from his pocket. "Trickster is back. What shall I write? Property of Dean."
Gabe leans over ready to mark Cas's forehead. All of a sudden, Cas opens his eyes and lets out a short yelp. In a split second, he throws his fist at his stepbrother's face. Gabe falls to the ground waking up Dean.
"You fuckin' hit me!" Gabe yells as he held his nose. "Holy fuck! I'm bleeding!" He runs out of the bedroom.
"What the hell just happened?" yawned Dean.
"I just punched Gabe in the nose." Cas tells him. He lays his head on Dean's chest.
"That's my man," Dean chuckles. He wraps his arms around Castiel and kisses his head.
First of all, I'm asking if someone could make a supernatural faking it trailer. I don't know how to do it and it seems like it fits the story.