(Phoebe goes to babysit a 4 year old little girl, Penelope. The moment Phoebe sees Penelope, Phoebe realizes that Penelope looks like someone she knew. As Phoebe plays with Penelope, Phoebe realizes that Penelope is a lot like Prue. In looks and behavior)
Phoebe: Penny, when I first saw you. You reminded me of someone and now I know who. You remind me of my older sister, Prue.
Penelope: Cool
Phoebe: Your mommy seems really nice, even though I haven't gotten a chance to know her.
Penelope: I'm dopted. She told me, she fiends wid my weal mommy. And she dopted me at birth.
Phoebe: Oh ,maybe someday you can meet your real mommy. (little does Phoebe know the very person that Penelope reminds her of, is this little girl's real mommy)
Penelope: Maybe
(the next day, Phoebe goes to the police station to talk to Andy)
Phoebe: Andy
Andy: (hugs Phoebe) Hey Pheebs, what brings you here?
Phoebe: Last night I babysat a little girl who looked a lot like Prue, but she had your eyes. Her name also began with p, it was Penelope. She also told me she was adopted at birth. Is she yours and Prue's?
Andy: Yes, Prue was only 19 when she was born and so was I. We weren't prepared to be parents, so we gave her up to a friend.
Phoebe: You have to visit this little girl eventually and tell her that you are her daddy.
Andy: I know, I just don't know how she'll react
Phoebe: I'm babysitting her again tonight. Why don't you come with me?
Andy: Ok too bad Prue is dead.
Phoebe: I know, I miss her so much
Andy: Me too
(later that night Phoebe goes to babysit Penelope)
Phoebe: Hi
: Hi Phoebe, Penelope is in her room playing ( notices Andy) Andy! What are you doing her? Where's Prue?
Andy: Hi Janelle, um Prue died two months ago. I'm here because I'm going to tell Penelope the truth
Janelle: Oh ok nice seeing you again and I'm sorry for your loss
Andy: thanks
(Phoebe and Andy walk up to Penelope's room)
Phoebe: Hi Penny
Penelope: (excited) Phee! (looks at Andy confused) Who's this?
Phoebe: This is my friend, Andy. He has something to tell you
Andy: Oh Penelope, you are so beautiful and you look just like your mommy.
Penelope: (shocked) You know my weal mommy?
Andy: Yes, I do because I'm your daddy.
Penelope: Where's my mommy?
Andy: (sighs) She died two months ago
Penelope: (sadly) Oh, I'm sorry
Andy: I bet you are wondering why your mommy and I gave you up.
(Penelope nods)
Andy: Well we were only 19 when you were born and we weren't prepared to be parents to a kid. But now I see that we made a terrible mistake.
Penelope: I love you daddy
Phoebe: Penny, guess what?
Penelope: What Phee?
Phoebe: I'm your mommy's sister so that makes us related.
Penelope: How are we welated?
Phoebe: I'm your Aunt
Penelope: Cool (looks back at Andy) Daddy? Can I live with you?
Andy: Uh, I don't know
Penelope: (looks at Andy with her cute little eyes and bats them a couple of times) Pwease?
Andy: Oh that face is so cute, but I'm not sure. Obviously social services won't take you away, but they might take away Piper, Paige and Charlotte. They are your mommy's other sisters.
Penelope: (sadly) Oh
Phoebe: Piper, can move in with me and my mom.
Andy: What about Paige and Charlotte?
Phoebe: They'll stay with you
Andy: Ok, Penelope you can move in with me. Oh and Pheebs, Piper has been saying it would be a good idea for you to move back to the manor.
Phoebe: I'm not going to
Andy: Ok
(Janelle walks in the front door)
Janelle: I'm home
(Janelle walks up to Penelope's room)
Janelle: Hi baby
Penelope: Hi I'm going to live with daddy.
Janelle: Oh
Andy: Janelle, we talked about this. One day, Prue and I would come for our little girl. The only difference is that Prue is dead.
Janelle: I know (hugs Penelope) bye baby girl, I love you
Andy: (picks up Penelope) We better get going. Bye Janelle
Phoebe: Bye
Janelle: Bye Phoebe, Bye Andy