LEMON ALERT! I do not own Yugioh, enjoy!
Chapter 25
Atem opened the door and Yami stumbled in kissing Yugi hungrily, like a man that hadn't eaten in days. Yami worked his jacket off, and let it fall to the ground. Yugi wrapped his arms up and around Yami's neck, tangling his fingers into his hair. He hitched his legs up around Yami's waist to kiss him at a better angle. Yugi ground their hips together as he felt his back hit a wall, making Yami groan into his mouth with pleasure.
"Yami no, not against a wall. Come on, this way." Atem said grabbing Yugi's arm and pulling them both in a random direction.
Yugi felt his back hit a soft bed a moment later, opening his eyes; he noticed that it was the black bed he'd been admiring earlier. His bow tie came undone and off, and the top three buttons of his shirt were undone again. Yugi felt something wet on both sides of his neck, and squirmed trying to figure out what it was.
"Calm down, we're just taking off the perfume." Yami whispered in his ear. Yugi nodded as one of the washcloths came up to his face and took off the makeup too. Once he was deemed clean by their standards they finished unbuttoning his shirt and vest, opening them but not removing them.
"Are you sure about this?" Atem asked him. Yugi responded by leaning up to kiss him softly.
"I do have one request though." Yugi said pulling away.
"What's that?" Yami asked.
"That Yami takes me first, so that way it's easier when you take me Atem." Yugi explained quickly noticing the affronted look on Atem's face.
"Makes sense, this way I can stretch him out better for you." Yami said.
"Okay." Atem agreed loosening his tie.
Yugi sighed in relief before grabbing Atem by his tie and dragging him down to his mouth. While Atem was kissing Yugi into the mattress, Yami was working on relieving Yugi of his shirt and vest. A task that was kind of difficult because Yugi had tangled his fingers into Atem's hair, like he'd been doing to Yami earlier. Yami had gotten as far as to take them off of Yugi's shoulders but his progress stopped there. Atem reached up and worked Yugi's fingers out of his hair. His shirt was gone in seconds, making Yugi shiver and pull closer to Atem, seeking warmth.
"Atem, I think he's cold. Perhaps we should warm him up." Yami suggested earning a chuckle out of Atem.
"Show me how you'd warm up a human." Atem said huskily pulling away from Yugi.
Yami smirked sliding his body over Yugi's; he attached his lips to his throat. Yugi moaned as Yami sucked at his skin, and grazed his teeth over it as well without breaking the skin. Yugi reached with tentative hands up to Yami's tie loosening it before pulling it off in one slick quick movement. He worked on the buttons of his shirt and vest, fumbling a couple of times due to nerves. Eventually he got them all undone, and pushed Yami's shirt and vest off his shoulders, down his arms, and off his body all together.
"Yugi you do realize that just because we're doing this, we aren't going to become mates, right?" Atem asked running a hand through his hair. Yami pulled away from his throat to look at him.
"Yeah, I understand. If you both drank from me now, you'd kill me." Yugi said back looking away.
"Good, I'm glad you understand." Atem said moving closer to the two of them.
"Besides I don't think I'm ready to take you two yet." Yugi mumbled blushing and suddenly becoming interested in the blankets.
"As long as we get to love you, that doesn't really matter to us." Yami said turning his head to look at them.
"Love me?" Yugi asked confused.
"Make love to you." Atem clarified trailing a hand down his bare side.
"Um, but I don't think that I-." Yugi said starting to panic.
"Shh, we know. Take your time with the emotion, there's no rush. For now, just enjoy everything we're about to do to you." Yami said placing a finger on his lips silencing him with his words.
Yami lowered his head back towards Yugi's throat and starting to kiss the skin softly moving his head down to his shoulder. He trailed his lips over his collar bone kissing the indentation between them at the base of his throat. Yugi tilted his head back, tangling his fingers into Yami's hair, massaging the scalp. Yami moaned against his skin, as he kissed around one of Yugi's nipples, before taking it into his mouth and carefully biting down on it. Yugi arched his back letting out his own moan of pleasure. Yami licked over the nipple before releasing it and moving not to the other one, but down to his stomach, where he dipped his tongue into Yugi's navel, swirling it around a little bit.
Yugi opened his eyes, and looked over to Atem who was watching them with amusement. Yugi reached out his arms to him, and beckoned him closer. Atem moved even closer to him, and Yugi reached up undoing his tie and watching in fascination as it slipped like a silky river from his neck to pool at his knees. Yugi slowly undid each button on his shirt and vest with a careful ease. Atem shrugged out of the clothing, and put his hands on Yami's waist, undoing his belt and slipping him out of his pants. Yugi was shocked to find he wasn't wearing anything underneath them. He looked away from cock embarrassed that he'd been staring.
Maybe this wasn't a good idea. Maybe his decision was made in the heat of the moment, and it was a hasty one. Now that Yami and Atem were stripping themselves of their pants he was starting to get nervous and second guessing it. What if he wasn't any good? Would they want to do this again? Or would they just toss him aside? As these thoughts were going through his head, he was lifted up into a sitting position.
"Yugi, relax. We're going to take this nice, easy, and slow. Whatever it is you're worrying about, let it go. The only thing I want you to focus on is what I'm doing right now." Atem said softly massaging his shoulders and moving down his back, trying to get all the stress knots out of Yugi's back and to get him to relax. It actually worked as the tension left Yugi's body, as if Atem's hands were soaking it up, and taking it away.
"Do you feel better?" Yami asked rubbing circles with his thumbs into Yugi's abdomen.
"Mmmm." Yugi hummed letting his head fall back onto Atem's shoulder.
"Yugi, we have a question." Yami said. He felt Atem tense behind him.
"Yami, don't." Atem said warningly.
"Did you and Sarugaki ever…" Yami continued ignoring Atem but trailing off at the end. Yugi lifted his head off of Atem's shoulder to look at Yami, his eyes sparkling with amusement. He leaned forward to rest his forehead against Yami's sighing softly.
"No Yami, we never had sex." He said moving his head down to touch his lips to Yami's jaw line.
"It was disgusting, he said, to have sex with a human. I'm starting to think it was just him though, that was truly disgusting." Yugi said trailing kisses down his throat before biting harshly in the juncture between his neck and throat. Payback was sweet, slightly salty, with a tang of clovers and cinnamon. Yami cried out but Yugi couldn't tell if it was with pleasure, so he licked over the mark, trying to appease him.
"He bit me!" Yami said to whatever it was that Atem had asked.
"Just returning a favor." Yugi said twisting in Atem's lap, and kissing his throat before biting him in the spot opposite of Yami's. Atem growled at him, but Yugi ignored it as he licked over the spot in the same way that he had Yami's. Atem tasted slightly salty, of exotic spices and a little spicy. They both were very arousing tastes.
"You're getting brave." Atem accused sliding Yugi off his lap so he could take off his pants.
Now they were both nude, all that was left of Yugi were his two defenses, his pants and briefs. Not wanting to appear timid, he undid his pants, and slid them and his briefs off together. Now all three of them were naked. Yugi fell back against the pillows on the bed, and waited for one of them to prep him. Neither one of them moved towards him, instead they sat back on their heels, taking him in. Yugi had the urge to cover himself up, but fought it just barely winning his internal struggle. He did squirm though under their gazes, becoming a little uncomfortable with all the staring.
"I know I've said this before Yugi, but you truly are beautiful." Atem whispered.
"Yeah, well you guys are just…gorgeous." Yugi said blushing.
"Heh, thanks, hand me that bottle on the bedside table, Yami." Atem said grinning down at him along with Yami before pointing to a small bottle on the bedside table.
"What's that?" Yugi asked as Yami handed him the bottle and he flipped it open squirting it into his hand.
"Lubricant, it'll make everything slide in easier." Atem explained rubbing it along three fingers.
"Um, o-okay." Yugi stuttered spreading his legs already knowing where they were going. Just because he was a virgin didn't mean he was that stupidly naïve, he knew how sex between males worked.
"Distract him, Yami." Atem said positioning his fingers at his entrance.
"Why? When you're so great at multitasking?" Yami asked smirking. Atem rolled his eyes before slipping a finger into Yugi, and capturing his mouth in the same movement. Yugi squirmed at the intrusion; it wasn't that it hurt it was just that it was weird, uncomfortable even.
Atem sucked on Yugi's bottom lip while he thrust his finger in and out of him, adding a second one as he licked his bottom lip, asking for entrance. Yugi opened his mouth, allowing him entrance as he started to scissor his fingers while thrusting him. Atem slipped his tongue in, immediately trying to get Yugi to play with him. Yugi complied by snapping his tongue up trapping Atem's against the roof of his mouth. As Atem wiggled his tongue trying to get it free, Yugi's accidently brushed against one of Atem's fangs and broke the skin. Atem yanked his tongue out of Yugi's mouth, and pulled away.
"Show me." He said. Yugi stuck his tongue out, and Atem licked the side of it healing the cut. Yugi saw Yami tilt his head frowning. Atem shook his head, as Yami moved closer lowering his head towards Yugi's and capturing his lips.
Atem inserted the third finger, and made scissor movements with all three, making Yugi cry out into Yami's mouth at the slight pain it caused. His painful cry soon turned into pleasure though, as Yami started to thrust his tongue in and out of Yugi's mouth in time with Atem's finger thrusts. Kami, that mind link of theirs was going to be his undoing, he was sure of it. Yugi could feel himself growing hard.
Atem suddenly took his fingers out, making Yugi whine at the loss. Atem just chuckled as he pulled Yami away and flipped him onto his back. Squirting more lubricant onto his hands, he lathered Yami up.
"You just can't keep your hands off me, can you?" Yami teased.
"Never." Atem said back kissing him, before letting him up.
Yami moved and settled in between Yugi's legs. He stroked the inside of his thighs, as he moved his legs slightly more apart. Yami massaged the inside of Yugi's thighs right on the sides of his cock, before gripping his hips firmly and positioning himself at Yugi's entrance.
"Alright, here's how we're going to do this; I'm just going to-." Yami broke himself off as he snapped his hips forward embedding himself within Yugi. Yugi gasped clutching the blankets in pain, as a couple of tears leaked from his eyes. Yami leaned forward licking them up, before leaning his forehead against Yugi's.
"Sorry, but Atem and I discovered a long time ago that it's better to just get it all in at once rather than trying to push in slowly, less pain that way." Yami explained softly. Yugi just nodded as he panted slightly trying to get used to Yami in his body.
"Take your time Yugi, there's no rush." Atem said moving behind Yami.
"Atem what are you doing?" Yami asked looking over his shoulder.
"This." He said slamming into Yami pushing Yami deeper into Yugi.
"Oh, he does not need us to double up on him." Yami said groaning his eyes closed with pleasure at the double assault.
"Don't worry, I'll allow you to return the favor." Atem said kissing his shoulder.
"I don't need permission to have sex with my mate." Yami said opening his eyes and glaring at Atem over his shoulder who just smirked at him.
"So how tight is he?" Atem asked as they both waited for Yugi to give some sign that they were able to move.
"Tighter than you were that first time. Which is saying something considering you were pretty tight." Yami said leaning back into him.
While they were talking the pain started to ebb away, and Yugi rolled his hips experimentally as he tried to see if all the pain was indeed gone. Finding it to be so, he pushed slightly against Yami, gaining the vampire's instant attention. Yami stared at him for a few seconds before pushing back against Atem, who pulled out allowing Yami to do the same.
"Remember he's no vampire, so we have to go slow or risk breaking or ripping him." Yami reminded Atem behind him.
"I know habibi." Atem said kissing the back of his neck as he thrust back into him making Yami thrust into Yugi, who let out a light groan.
They started up a slow process of thrusting into him, wanting to take it slow so they didn't hurt him. Yugi was okay with that at first, but it started to grow tiresome after awhile. Yugi growled as he pushed back against Yami, meeting his thrust head on. This was supposed to be pleasurable, not irksome. When did that euphoria pleasure start?
"Find it yet?" Atem asked.
"No." Yami said in frustration.
"Yeah, I couldn't either." Atem said back.
"I'm going to find it though." Yami said back angling a different way into Yugi.
Just as Yugi was about to ask what it was they were looking for Yami brushed something that sent waves of pleasure through his body. He cried out throwing his head back, his body arching up at the simple brush against whatever it was. He saw a surprised look on Yami's face, as he thrust into him again, but the same reaction wasn't present. He'd missed whatever target he had barely brushed before.
"Damn it, I had it too." Yami growled out in frustration stopping in his thrusts.
"Yeah, I saw that." Atem said appreciatively.
"Don't stop! Do it again, that felt really good!" Yugi demanded rolling his hips sharply making Yami moan.
"So demanding." Atem teased. Yami got a look of determination on his face as he pulled out, angled his cock again and thrust in a little harshly hitting that one spot dead on. Yugi's back arched further than he thought it could as fire pooled in his belly. His head tossed back in pure ecstasy, a loud needy moan escaping past his lips.
"So damn beautiful." Atem whispered looking at Yugi's form.
"Do that again." Yugi ordered as his back started to come out of its arch.
"As you wish." Yami whispered in his ear before gently biting down on his ear lobe.
"I don't want pierced ears, Yami. I want you to fuck me, and fuck me hard." Yugi said pushing down on him a couple of times to get his point across.
"We can go hard for a human, just not a vampire; we have to stay in control." Atem reminded as he pulled out of Yami, and Yami did the same to him. Together as one they thrust back into Yugi.
Yami hit his sweet spot as he had started to call it in his mind dead on over and over again. Wave upon wave of pleasure tore through him. His back almost seeming to be held in a permanent arch, and the fire in his belly grew excruciatingly hot, almost licking the sides of whatever container held it in place. His body felt as if it was dripping with sweat as he held onto his sanity, unwilling for the moment of Yami pounding relentlessly into him to be over. He knew it must be though, he could feel that fire almost at its breaking point. A thought he felt he needed to share.
"The fire is growing too hot; it's going to break free of the container containing it." Yugi said in gasping breaths moaning in between his words.
"Mmm, is it now?" Yami asked amused.
"Yes, I can feel it." Yugi said back.
"Let it come, I want to feel this fire too." Yami said back in a deep husky voice.
That was all it took, well that and another thrust from Yami, for him to come over the edge, for him to release his white seed all over both of their chests. Like a jet of water from a hose, and it had Yugi blushing crimson that it came from him. Yami chuckled, bending down to whisper in his ear.
"That fire was amazing, and Atem says he's just dying to get his share of it." Yami said coming in Yugi. It felt weird to him, feeling Yami's own white seed shooting up inside him, though it was probably something he was going to have to get used to. He doubted he would be on top very much with these two. Yami moaned leaning against Atem, and Yugi could only figure that Atem had released inside of him.
"Now we switch." Atem said.
"Um, can't we get cleaned up first?" Yugi asked looking down at the white seed still all over his chest.
"No. If we wait too long, we'll have to prep you again." Atem said shaking his head at Yugi.
"O-okay." Yugi said nodding as Atem pulled out of Yami and Yami pulled out of him.
Atem lathered himself up again, as Yami did the same, and waited for Atem to enter him. Yugi stared at the monster attached to Atem's hips with apprehension, sure that it still wasn't going to fit in him. Atem sighed and did the same thing that Yami had done, massaged his inner thighs right around his cock. Unbeknownst to Yugi, he relaxed slightly giving Atem all the time he needed to snap his hips forward and embed himself in him. Atem moaned loudly at the feeling of being in Yugi, while Yugi clutched at the blankets breathing heavily. Atem was bigger than Yami, he had known this, but he just hadn't accounted for how much bigger than Yami he really was until now. More tears leaked from his eyes as he willed for the pain to go away.
"Get your head out of the clouds and attend to Yugi." Yami growled as he slammed into Atem. Yugi cried out in pain as Atem was pushed further into him. Atem snapped his attention to Yugi at the cry and Yami's words.
"Oh, Yugi, don't cry, the pain will go away, I promise, it'll go away." Atem said kissing his tears away.
"It hurts." Yugi whimpered.
"Just relax, and it'll go away faster. Come on Yugi, relax, relax for me." Atem urged rubbing circles with his thumbs into Yugi's abdomen. Yugi willed himself to relax, finding it to be easier if he focused on Atem massaging his abdomen. Soon he found himself completely relaxed and the pain ebbing away, as Atem continued to massage his abdomen.
"Maybe you should've mounted him." Yami suggested.
"No, I don't doubt that he wouldn't be able to keep himself up if I did that." Atem said back continuing to massage his abdomen. Yugi forgot about giving them a sign that he was ready as he just enjoyed his free massage. He was utterly content just like this.
"You know Atem; he looks a little too relaxed." Yami commented placing his chin on his shoulder to look down at Yugi.
"He does, doesn't he?" Atem asked stopping his free massage of Yugi's abdomen. Yugi frowned, and opened his eyes to stare up at Atem, not sure when he had closed them.
."Why'd you stop? I was enjoying that." Yugi complained.
"Because we are supposed to be doing other activities right now, I'll give you another massage later." Atem explained amused.
"Can we move?" Yami asked. Yugi rolled his hips and felt not even a twinge of pain.
"Yeah, you can move." Yugi said.
"And how long have we been able to move for?" Atem asked annoyed.
"I don't know. I was enjoying my free massage." Yugi said shrugging. Atem rolled his eyes as Yami laughed pulling out of him and allowing Atem to do the same.
They started up an even slower pace than the one before. Yugi knew it was for his benefit, but that didn't mean he found it any less annoying. Yugi pushed down on Atem as he thrust up into him. Atem shook his head at Yugi's impatience, not giving him what he wanted.
"Where is it Yami?" he demanded.
"Sort of hidden on the right side. You have to angle just right or you're not going to hit it." Yami said explaining where his sweet spot was as best he could, as Yugi pushed on Atem again.
"No Yugi, not until I find your small bundle of nerves." Atem said frustrated that he was having a hard time locating it. He re-angled himself turning his cock more to the right inside Yugi, desperate to find his sweet spot. His efforts were rewarded after his third thrust in that direction as he hit it head on, making Yugi arch and cry out, louder than he did for Yami.
"Got it." he said victoriously as he started to slam into that one spot making Yugi spasm with every hit of pleasure.
It was better than when Yami had done it, and Yugi didn't know if that was because Atem was bigger or because he was older. He had more experience with getting his partners to enjoy every second of the sexual experience. Now this wasn't to say that Yami was inexperienced, because he wasn't, it was just that Atem had more.
Yugi reached up with his hands to grab Atem's biceps, needing to hold onto something sturdier than the blankets and bed rocking beneath him. With all the force he was putting into it, Yugi felt the fire pool in his belly faster than it did for Yami. He felt the end coming sooner, and he gave no warning this time, because he barely had a warning himself as he came like a jet of water from a hose all over their chests. Atem sighed and released into Yugi, almost collapsing on him, as Yami came into him.
"Is there a reason you made quick work of that?" Yami asked Atem as he pulled out, allowing Atem to do the same. Yugi felt strangely empty after being so full for so long, but mostly he felt very stretched.
"I guess I wanted him to be able to walk in the morning." Atem said back lifting Yugi's hips to look at his wider hole.
"Yeah, right, he won't be able to stand on his own tomorrow, Atem." Yami scoffed back.
"Yeah, you're probably right. No blood, that's good." Atem said lowering his hips again.
"Come on, we need to get him and ourselves cleaned up." Yami said moving off the bed.
"You're not actually suggesting that we should move him?" Atem asked in disbelief.
"It doesn't matter, he's falling asleep anyway." Yami said pointing to him. It was true, that Yugi's eyes were drooping, but he was still sort of awake. Well, he was awake enough to hear them talking like he wasn't lying right here in front of him.
"Can't we just use those washcloths again?" He asked in a tired voice.
"Works for me." Yami said shrugging and getting up as Atem remained sitting on the bed with him.
Yami came back with wet washcloths and handed one to Atem, together they worked to get him cleaned up. Once he was completely clean, they cleaned themselves up, and then lifted him from the bed. Atem cradled him to his chest as they walked to the other bedroom, the golden one. Yami lifted the covers, and Atem slid Yugi gently into the middle of the bed. Both Atem and Yami slid in beside him, wrapping their arms around his waist and hips. That was how Yugi fell asleep, in pure bliss between the two vampires, for once not worried about a single thing. He was happy as he thought he would never be in the presence of a vampire, let alone two. He just wished that there was a way for them to stay this way for forever.
[Time skip]
Yugi awoke to immense pain in his backside. He opened his eyes as he tried to move into a fetal position to lessen the pain. He felt as if he had just got the worst beating of his life, only to be beaten again twice over. He was seriously in that much pain. There were two pairs of arms around him though, preventing him from getting into his desired position. The pair of arms around his hips left and Yugi was able to move his legs up further to his chest. That's when he felt something break or snap inside of him, and the next he felt a wet liquid trailing down his thighs.
"Hey beautiful, how're you…feeling?" Atem asked trailing off as he whipped the covers back his eyes widening in horror as Yami sat straight up.
"Huh? What's going on?" he asked.
"Get some hot water going now!" Atem ordered as he scooped Yugi up making him cry out in pain at the sudden movement.
"Shit! He's bleeding!" Yami exclaimed and was gone, the blankets on his side fluttering to the bed. Next moment Yugi heard water running somewhere.
"Atem it hurts." Yugi whined feeling the tears leaking from his eyes.
"I know, I know." Atem said moving slowly towards the bathroom trying not to jostle him too much. Yugi appreciated the thought, but it didn't make his back hurt any less.
Atem walked into the bathroom with Yugi to see a tub fit for four people only a quarter ways full of water. He groaned; he must have wanted to put him in it right away. It looked as if he was going to have to wait though.
"What do you think happened?" Yami asked coming over with a wet cloth to wipe up the excess blood on Yugi's legs.
"I don't know." Atem said shaking his head.
"It felt as if something broke or snapped." Yugi supplied.
"We need to get him to Isis." Yami said.
"Or get Isis to come to us." Atem suggested. Yami sighed, and glanced at the water in the tub.
"Let's lessen the pain in his back first before we talk about anything else." He said.
"Right, Yugi this is going to sting a little but will feel wonderful for your back." Atem explained lowering him into the tub half full of water. He hissed in pain, but found it relaxing at the same time. Atem and Yami climbed in as well, making the water rise even more. He let his head rest against the side of the tub, remembering last night events. He smiled to himself, he had enjoyed himself, and the pain he was feeling now, couldn't take that away from him.
"Yugi, what are you thinking about?" Yami asked.
"Last night." He replied.
"Did you enjoy yourself last night? Both on the date and afterwards?" Atem asked.
"Mm-hmm, immensely so." He responded back.
"Would it be something you would want to do again?" Yami asked.
"Yes, I would." Yugi said back.
"Wonderful." Atem whispered wrapping his arms around Yugi's shoulders and leaning down to kiss him. Yugi let him enjoying the simple touch. He was still tired though, and found himself falling asleep slightly on Atem.
"Do I really bore you that much?" Atem whispered in his ear. Yugi didn't answer he just yawned resting his head against Atem's chest.
"I don't think boredom is the problem, I think he's still tired." Yami said smiling while moving closer to them.
"Go to sleep, Yugi, we'll keep you afloat." Atem whispered in his ear. Yugi was out like a light instantly.
Now wasn't that sweet? Thanks to everyone who are/have following/favorited this story. Also, thanks to everyone who have reviewed Guest and User alike. Please review. Midnight ;p