In Zach's bedroom, Grey was woken up by some moans and groans. "Psst… Zach. Zach wake up," Grey said, rubbing his brother's chest. Zach woke up, still a little sleepy. Zach rubbed his eyes and looked at Grey.
"What is it Grey… it's 5 in the morning," Zach said, checking his clock. "Did you hear moaning?" Grey asked. Zach started hearing it. "That! That moaning," Grey said, looking into the dark room. Suddenly, they both remembered.
They looked at each other. "Tanner," Zach and Grey said in unison. Zach got out of the bed, his flaccid cock swaying with a string of precum leaking out. Grey stood up, his flaccid penis flapping down. They walked towards Grey's room and opened the door, turning on the diming lights. Grey turned down the light so they wouldn't be blinded.
Laying on the floor, Tanner moaned. "It hurts," Tanner moaned, "Badly."
Grey ran down next to Tanner. "Tanner, it's Grey. You're at my house remember," Grey said, looking at his friend. Tanner could still taste the cum in his mouth, still wet. His butt had some cum pouring out. This was the cum that was in the way back of his butt. Most of it was on the floor or splattered on his butt and legs.
"Grey. Hey man," Tanner said, reaching his hand out to stroke his cheek. Grey let him. "You okay?" Grey asked, rubbing Tanner's head and playing with his hair. "Why did you guys let me talk you into pounding my ass. It feels like I stuffed it with a bunch of butt plugs," Tanner said, giving Grey a little smile.
"Well… we kinda stuffed you with our cocks," Zach said, bending down. "Oh yeah… I remember your huge cock Zach," Tanner said, "Look… it's growing."
Grey turned to Zach's cock. It was growing. Zach looked at Grey. "What. There's a completely naked boy on the ground covered in cum and piss who begged us to fuck his brains out," Zach said. Just hearing that made Grey a little hard.
"See," Zach said, looking at Grey's cock.
"What should we do with him? The pee has hardened kind of on him," Grey said. "So that what that smell was," Tanner said. "Yeah… sorry about that man," Grey said, standing up.
"Let's get him in the shower. I'm not going to go back to sleep. It's almost day time anyways," Zach said, picking up Tanner. Tanner was a lot lighter then Zach imagined him to be. Zach picked him up with ease and walked him over to their bathroom.
Grey walked behind them as cum dripped from Tanner's butt. Grey could see the color of the cum. It looked weird. He saw a color difference in it. Suddenly, Grey remembered that he and Zach both cummed inside of Tanner so Grey's cum was mixed with his brother's. Zach's was the more white one and Grey's was more clear.
"Zach, our cum has mixed from Tanner's butt," Grey said, picking some off the ground and licking it, "Taste good. Especially with that nice inside taste," Grey said. "Tell me about it," Zach said, "When I ate his ass out, his insides tasted so good."
"Yeah and his cum is sweet," Grey said, walking closer to Tanner. Zach and Grey approached the bathroom and they set down Tanner. Zach decided to try some butt cum so he fingered Tanner. Tanner groaned before Zach pulled out to taste. "Tastes good," Zach said. "Exactly," Grey replied. Zach laughed.
"Hey Grey. Zach… thanks for everything. I really had fun. Sorry about me fainting… I… It was so great," Tanner explained. "No problem Tanner," Grey said, "We had fun as well and you feel nice inside and out. Great kisser and nice cum taste right Zach?"
"Definitely," Zach said, bending down to turn on the water. Tanner looked into Zach's ass cheeks to see his hole and Tanner drooled.
"The water is starting up Tanner. I'll make it a bath," Zach said. "Thanks," Tanner replied.
"Hey Tanner. Do you taste my cum still?" Grey asked. "Yeah. It's sweet and sour. Wanna taste?" Tanner asked, winking. "Alright," Grey said but he stopped. Zach turned to Grey and nodded and put his thumb up. Grey smiled. Grey went in for the kiss and made out with Tanner. Grey could taste Tanner's mouth which tasted like cum. Grey explored his friend's mouth, tasting everything he can. When Grey pulled out, he smiled.
"Yup… I still can taste it," Grey said. Tanner smiled. "You guys really didn't show any mercy," Tanner said, rubbing his butt, "And thank you Zach for those slaps. Man that was sexy. You being big and dominate… oh yeah."
"Grey… who knew you were so cute," Tanner added. Grey blushed. Zach gave out a chuckle.
After Zach got the bath ready, Tanner got in. Tanner looked at the bathtub. "Sure you guys don't want to get in?" Tanner asked, watching Grey and Zach look at him. "No. We're good," Zach said.
"Do you want breakfast Tanner?" Grey asked. "Uh… sure. Just one request," Tanner started. "Sure. What is it?" Zach asked. "Can I make out with you guys some more?" Tanner asked.
Grey looked at Zach. "Zach's big and strong with big body parts…," Tanner winked, "…but Grey is cute in every way. Both of you are amazing."
Zach felt himself getting hard as well as himself start blushing. Zach laughed, "Thanks Tanner but I think we should slow down a little bit," Zach said. "Yeah. I agree with Zach," Grey said, watching Tanner bathe.
"Aww okay. I guess I'll have to earn those luscious lips," Tanner said, smirking. Grey smiled back. "We'll see you downstairs," Grey said.
Zach and Grey left the room.
Downstairs, Grey sat at the table with all the food in front of him. "Tanner should be finishing," Zach said. "Yeah. Hey Zach… is it just me or is Tanner more needy then before?" Grey asked.
"Well… you seem to have no problem with making out with him," Zach said, a little snappy. Grey looked at Zach. "What is that supposed to mean? Why are you getting mad at me?" Grey asked.
"Well… I don't know… it's just… you seem to not even hesitate when it comes to kissing him... like that crush is suddenly coming out," Zach said, looking away. "Zach… I didn't realize…" Grey started to say. "Well… it's kinda heart breaking… just saying," Zach said.
Grey's eyes started to tear up. "I'm sorry. I really am. I didn't know that I was kissing him a lot. It just seemed like… well… you were literally pounding him and dominating over him…" Grey started.
"In which you did say that I had no limits," Zach cut in. "Yes but… I just thought that I could get something out of it. I love you and you know that," Grey said.
Zach thought about Grey's last sentence. He smiled. "I know… I'm sorry. I'm being paranoid and thinking the wrong things. Would you forgive me?" Zach asked. "Only if I get a kiss from those nice wet lips," Grey said.
"Wet? They're not wet," Zach said. "Not yet," Grey replied, coming in to kiss Zach. They're naked bodies pressed against each other as they shared this passionate kiss.
They're tongues battled together for a little bit as they made smacking sounds as they came connected and unconnected from each other's lips. Zach overpowered Grey when he felt that Grey was taking over. Grey loved this and he let Zach do his thing. Grey grabbed onto Zach's biceps, which were flexing. Grey felt his butt being held and squeezed. They're cocks rubbed against each other, putting precum onto each other's shafts. They're balls slapped against each other, creating a shockwave of love.
Grey could feel Zach's abs running over his stomach. The hair above Zach's penis was tickling Grey as they kissed. Suddenly, they heard a gasp. Both of the brother's eyes shot open as they turned to the stairs. Standing there was Tanner.
"Oh shit," Grey said. "Language," Zach replied.
Zach looked at the clock. They had been making out for a while, giving time for the naked Tanner to hear them.
"Was I interrupting…" Tanner started. "No… uh," Grey said, thinking of ways to explain this.
"We were… uh… just…" Zach said, thinking the same was as Grey.
"Let's just talk about this when we eat," Grey finally said. Tanner walked down, his cock as hard as a rock from seeing the brothers make out.
Tanner sat down at the table and made his plate, still not believing that the boys that were sitting right across from him were in love.
Zach and Grey exchanged glances, trying not to look away. Tanner sighed to break the silence.
"Go ahead. You guys can make out already," Tanner said. "Tanner… it's not like that…" Grey said.
"Well… it kinda is…" Zach replied. Grey looked at Zach. "Not helping," Grey said, teeth closed.
"Sorry," Zach replied.
"How did this all even happen?" Tanner asked. "Well…" Grey started.
After some long explanation about everything that has happened, Grey finished with the help of Zach.
"And that's the whole history," Grey replied. "So… it just started after you made a bold move of making out with Zach?" Tanner asked.
"Making out is such a strong word judging by the circumstances that we were in when he kissed me," Zach said.
"And Grey… you liked your brother when you both were on the island?" Tanner asked. "Yeah… he showed a lot to me. Opened my eyes. I guess I found it attractive," Grey replied.
Tanner looked at the naked boys. He looked down at his cock. He looked back at Zach and Grey.
"This is a lot to process," Tanner replied. Zach sighed. "I'm sorry that you had to find out but we tried to keep it a secret," Zach said.
"Yeah… I can't believe your mom hasn't pieced the pieces together after the loud smacking that you two made with your lips," Tanner said. "Usually we do that when we're alone… we haven't done that in a while so we just did it," Zach said, "Kinda slipped our minds that you might hear."
Grey nodded.
"Also Tanner… you're like one of the first people to know about this so could you please keep it secret. I love Grey and he loves me and we don't need people finding out about us. I'm sorry that you had to find out but I hope we can trust you to keep it secret and safe. People don't know anyways so please don't let people know," Zach said.
"Well… besides a few people. To name a few… the store lady and the movie guy that beat us up," Grey replied. "Ok… besides some people who really don't matter. You're our first big person that has found out… and you found out on accident," Zach replied.
"I know how you guys feel. I won't even tell my parents that I like dick let alone tell them that I was fucked by two, which felt amazing by the way so thanks for that. It's scary to me," Tanner said.
Grey laughed. "Yeah… our mom has gotten close to finding out but I don't need her knowing… we don't need her knowing," Grey replied.
"Got it. You're secret is safe with me," Tanner said. "Tanner… I'm trusting in you," Grey replied. "Don't worry Grey. Man… you are cute when you are scared. Sorry… got off track. I won't tell anyone. I promise," Tanner said.
Grey saw a certain look in Tanner's eyes that told him everything that he needed to know.
"He won't tell anyone," Grey said to Zach.
"Wait… how do you know?" Zach replied. "I've been with Tanner for my entire life. I know this cute boy," Grey blushed.
Tanner smiled. "Too bad I can't date you guys. Grey… you have an amazing boyfriend who I have felt first hand. Literally. His hand hit my face a lot," Tanner laughed. Zach laughed as well.
"But seriously. He's a good brother and an even better boyfriend. Treat him well because I know he would do the same. Zach… you better not mess with my best friend because I'll beat your ass… just kidding. You'd probably beat mine, pound me, and make me not walk for a week," Tanner replied.
Zach laughed. "That seems accurate," Zach said. "He's not kidding. He can pound the living daylight out of you. I know from experience," Grey replied.
Tanner laughed. "Am I really that huge?" Zach asked.
Tanner and Grey nodded in unison.
"Oh… it had to feel good right?" Zach asked. "Best feeling in the world," Tanner said. "I can second that," Grey replied.
"Alright good," Zach laughed.
"But Zach… make sure you treat him well. Please don't hurt my bff. I love him more than you know… if you know what I mean," Tanner said, adding a little wink. Grey blushed.
"Don't worry. I know… but you don't love him as much as I do," Zach smiled.
Tanner laughed, "Sucks that I can't be one of your boyfriends. Sure you don't want to reconsider?"
Everyone laughed. "Don't worry Tanner. We'll leave some room for you," Grey said.
"Definitely," Zach said. Tanner smiled. "Yes! Second time maybe?" Tanner said. Grey shrugged his shoulders and winked. "Second time," Zach said, smiling.
Everyone started eating. Tanner would take glances at Zach and Grey's flaccid cocks. Zach was maintaining his size around 5 inches while Grey was around 3. Zach caught Tanner looking at his cock.
"You like what you see?" Zach asked. "Yeah. You have some nice foreskin. Can I stroke you for a little bit. Just to see it go back an forth," Tanner asked, "If it's fine with Grey."
"It's okay. It fascinated me as well… to this day actually," Grey smiled.
Tanner did a silent yes before he bent down in his chair to play with Zach's cock. Zach twitched as he felt the hand reach for his semi-hard cock. Tanner stroked the shaft, watching the foreskin peel back and forth. He got his other hand to lay on top of the head before he let the foreskin go back up, capturing his finger. Tanner pulled on it, trying to take it out. It was kinda stuck. "He's got me! The monster cock has me!" Tanner yelled out. Grey laughed. Tanner pulled out, seeing precum follow his finger out as it spilled onto Zach. "Whoops," Zach said.
"Nice," Tanner replied, licking the precum off his fingers. He gathered more on his fingers and licked it. "Tasty," Tanner replied.
"Damn Grey. I can't believe that Zach took your virginity… well… after your complications," Tanner said, remembering the camping story. "Yeah... it was amazing," Grey replied.
"You played it off really well. You would have fooled me about you guys being a couple," Tanner said. "Yeah. We've gotten good at it. Hiding from the public a lot," Zach said.
"It shows. I can't believe that Grey got his virginity taken before me," Tanner said, "How did it feel?"
"It hurt. A lot," Grey said, looking at Zach and laughing, "But I had trouble getting the monster cock down my throat and up my butt."
"At least it wasn't forced into you. You took your time," Tanner said. "Yeah. Zach wanted to play with you like a toy. He loves me too much to hurt me," Grey said, looking at Zach and smiling. "He's too cute. How do you hurt him?" Zach said.
"True. He's pretty cute. That's why I didn't like fighting with him," Tanner said. Grey smiled.
"But… being forced into sex was pretty sexy," Tanner said, rubbing Zach's leg.
"We're you as stretched as me?" Tanner asked. "I don't think so… I'm still kinda tight but I'm getting there," Grey said. "You should see this," Tanner said, getting up.
Tanner turned around and bent down to touch his toes. When he bent down, Zach and Grey could see his butthole opening. It was red inside and more stretched out than the beginning. Zach and Grey could still smell cum coming out, which would probably stay there forever. Tanner let the boys stare as they saw his insides.
"Dang. You're not tight anymore," Grey said. Tanner laughed. "Holy shit Tanner. It's red inside," Zach said. "Yeah. It hurts but it was worth it for my first time," Tanner said.
Grey took a deep breath. "I can still smell the cum. It's probably going to smell like that for a while," Grey said, "After all… we filled you to the max. Well… Zach did most of it. Shooting 26 thick huge loads and all."
"26… damn Zach. You had a lot in there," Tanner said, looking at Zach's balls as he sat down.
"Yeah. I was saving up," Zach said. "Also Grey… you tasted amazing. Your lips, cock, cum… holy shit it was great," Tanner said, "Same to you Zach. You are like the king."
The Mitchell brothers smiled.
"So… will you ever tell your mom?" Tanner asked. "We're not sure yet. That may ruin things for us," Zach said.
"Yeah… I don't do well in bad situations," Grey replied. "That's true," Zach and Tanner said in unison.
"We're taking it slow. You?" Zach asked. "I'm too scared. I don't know what my mom or sister will think. My dad might kick me out," Tanner said, looking down as tears formed in his eyes.
"Aww Tanner. Don't think like that," Grey said, getting up and hugging Tanner.
"I don't even know. I want to tell them. Tell them what I like and all but it might end up to be horrible," Tanner said. "Just… just take it slow Tanner," Grey said.
"Yeah," Tanner said.
Grey, Tanner, and Zach talked through their meal, talking about various subjects in the main subject of sex.
After they finished, Zach, Tanner, and Grey hung out on the couch. "So… what next?" Grey replied. "Well… I have to leave soon. It's twelve thirty and I'm leaving at one," Tanner replied.
"What! That sucks. I don't want you to leave," Grey said. "It's fine. I don't want to get in the way of you two anyways. When I leave, you might have sex," Tanner said.
Zach looked at Grey and laughed. "Having it with you got all the cum sucked out of me. I need to refill. Breakfast should take care of that," Zach said.
Tanner laughed. "Alright then. But… I really had fun. Like… really really had fun," Tanner replied.
"Same here. That was hot Tanner," Zach said. "Hope we can do it again sometimes because we could probably work something out right Zach?" Grey replied.
"Yep. It'll happen soon," Zach said.
Tanner smiled. "Can I get a hug?" Tanner asked.
Grey nodded and Tanner hugged Grey, taking it all in. They stood up while hugging and Tanner held on. Tanner's fingers dug into Grey and he pressed himself against his friend. Tanner's left hand rose up some of Grey's hair to smell it. Grey felt his friend doing this and he looked at Zach. Zach just laughed. Grey looked down to Tanner's butt and smiled. Zach nodded.
Grey waited as Tanner grinded their cocks together. Suddenly, Grey rose up his hand and slapped Tanner's ass. Tanner let go, rubbing his butt, laughing.
"Alright… I deserved that," Tanner said. "No it was nice. Thanks," Grey smiled. He looked down to his stomach to see some precum from his taller friend. Grey tasted it, smiling. "Sweet," Grey said.
Tanner smiled and he turned to Zach. Zach stood up, leading the hug. Tanner grinded with Zach, getting passionate with Grey's brother. Tanner's face landed in Zach's chest as his stomach grinded with his abs and cock. Zach's cock spit out some precum as Tanner grinded. Tanner squeezed Zach's butt before letting go of the hug, fearing another smack.
"Thanks you guys," Tanner said, gathering some more of Zach's sweet and sour precum. It tasted just right.
"Tanner. I really wanted to say something. I know you like me and Grey but I have a strong feeling that you're going to find someone. Who wouldn't like you?" Zach said, patting Tanner's hair.
"Yeah. You have straight teeth, sexy pink nipples, dirty blonde perfect hair, nice body textures, and a nice cock and butt. You're perfect in my eyes and I will always love you. I think Zach and I will be like… friends with big benefits," Grey said, smiling.
Tanner smiled and blushed. "Guys, you're going to make me cry. Thanks," Tanner said, "I'll be seeing you guys soon right? Another hang out soon right?" Tanner asked.
"Of fucking course," Zach said, laughing. Tanner laughed.
"Alright. Wait… Grey… I just realized something. Did you used to have a crush on me?" Tanner asked. Grey breathed in and exhaled. He nodded.
"Yes! I knew it! Fuck yeah!" Tanner yelled, dancing as his cock and balls bounced around, slapping together. Grey laughed. Zach shrugged while smiling.
"What can I say… you're irresistible," Grey said, "Like me."
Zach and Tanner look at Grey. "Am I really wrong?" Grey asked. "Not really," Tanner and Zach said.
Before they knew it, Tanner got a text. He could hear it from upstairs. "Oh… my mom's outside probably. Let me get dressed and I'll go," Tanner said, walking up the stairs. Zach and Grey followed so they could be dressed appropriately.
After the boys got dressed, they walked downstairs. Tanner had everything that he brought with him. "See you guys soon I guess," Tanner smiled, "Thanks for everything. Really."
Grey and Zach looked to each other and smiled. They both leaned down to kiss Tanner on his cheeks. Tanner felt both of them as a smile grew on his face. When the boys pulled back, his cheeks were red as he was blushing.
"You two just know how to make people happy," Tanner smiled. "We try," Zach said, rubbing Tanner's hair.
"I'll miss you pounding buddy," Zach said. "I'll miss that big cock down there," Tanner said, groping Zach's bulge in his pants. His hand shot away after feeling it as he looked at Grey.
"Sorry. It's going to take time to get used to you two being a thing," Tanner said. "It's fine," Grey said. "I didn't mind it," Zach replied. "Cool," Tanner said. "Well… see you guys later," Tanner said.
Tanner opened the door and he walked out. Grey and Zach could see Tanner's mom in the car. She waved to Zach and Grey as Tanner got closer to the car. "BYE TANNER!" Grey called out. Tanner turned around and smiled, teeth showing. Grey smirked.
Tanner got in the car and drove away, waving.
Zach shut the door.
"You have some pretty nice friends Grey," Zach said, playfully pushing Grey a little bit. Grey laughed. "I guess he was good after all. I was worried that you wouldn't like him," Grey said.
"He's great but you're better," Zach said, kissing Grey lightly.
Grey and Zach talked the rest of the day, teasing each other. They talked about Tanner and being with each other. It went smoothly.
Author's Note: Hey everyone! I know I skimmed over the whole injured thing with the boys but I didn't want all this fun to be ruin because of the casts. They will be healing and the casts will be taken off in the next chapter. (I know it's not accurate with time and all but some time passages will not appear in this series fully because it will take too long). Hopefully you all understand. Thanks for reading :D