In Love With A Super Star

By CollegeStar20

With Finn and Santana.

Santana was in her room looking at her picture books when there was a knock on the door. She stared at the door knowing it's Finn and walked to the door and opened it.

"You said you wanted to talk?" Finn said with a hoarsly voice. Santana felt guilty hearing how his voice was. She knew he was crying about the things she thought about him.

"Yes come in Finn." She said walking back to her bed sitting down and Finn stared at her before walking over to her and sits on her bed.

"Wow you actually called me by my name and not Frankenteen,Double-Stuffed-Fatty-Gassy-McGravy-Pants, Bacon-Wrapped-Bug-Eyed Hypocrite, Finnocence, Pastry Bag, Doorknob, Tubs, The Knuckle-Dragger, Soft Serve, Pillsbury Dough Turd, Orca, Lumps The Clown, Grimace, Hamburglar, Fetus Face,Finessa,Finnupt,Gigantor or whatever names you came up with." He said sarcastically.

Santana stared at him as he said the names that she's called him and she sighs sadly.

"I'm sorry for calling you those things, I hate everybody but Brittany and I push them away." Finn stared at her before placing his hand on hers.

"Santana people aren't perfect and I know I'm not perfect but atleast I try to understand people and not judge them! I'm not a coldhearted person that your acting like! I know your covering up your anger and hurt from your family and being a Lesbian by taking it out on others but that's not the way to live Santana!" She stared at him knowing he's right.

"Why do you care so much anyways Finn, I've been a bitch to you the longest and just smile at me and try not to get angry." Finn stared at her.

"Because when Quinn and I were having problems with our relationship! you came up to me in the hallway one day and said Look Orca I know you and Q are dealing with shit right but she's the best thing you will ever have as a girlfriend and she's my best friend and your kind of alright yourself so try not to screw up both of you! You walked off glaring at me with a slight smile and I knew you were okay with me."

Santana forgot all about that day because she was too busy hiding her feelings for Brittany but she was comfortable now with her now girlfriend.

"Are you sure it has nothing to do with the fact that when you were Quinn and you were fighting that we had sex?" She asked him raising an eyebrow.

With Rachel.

Rachel was walking upstairs after cleaning the dishes and cleaning up the dinning room table when she heard Finn and Santana talking and she listened a little.

"Are you sure it has nothing to do with the fact that when you were Quinn and you were fighting that we had sex?" She heard Santana say and she frowns hoping it wasn't true.

"Look we promised we would never bring that up again! It was my first time and like you said me and Quinn were on a break and fighting." She heard her boyfriend say and she felt hurt and walked downstairs and went to her music room trying not to cry because Finn told her that he and Quinn never did anything while they were together but he never told her Santana took his virginity. What was she supposed to think now knowing that she will never be his first already knowing that he wasn't hers but she told him all about her exs and her relationship with them but he couldn't tell her? She needed to think.

With Finn and Rachel.

He and Santana said that they would try to become friends and she said that she was sorry and they hugged then he leaves because she says that she was going to talk to Brittany. He walked to Rachel's room and saw that she wasn't there so he goes he goes downstairs and heard music coming from down the hall and he walked to the music room and saw Rachel sitting at the piano.

"Hey baby are you coming to bed now?" Rachel wiped her tears and nodded getting up and walked up to him and he saw that she was crying and placed his hand on her face.

"Baby what's wrong?" She placed her hand on the one holding her face and closed her eyes fighting her tears.

"I think it's best if you sleep in the other guest room that's a room over to Santana's! I need to be alone tonight in my bed." She moved away from him and starts to leave when he grabs her hand.

"Rach what did I do that's got you wanting to be away from me?" She didn't turn to him but she didn't let go because she loved his touch.

"You slept with Santana and never told me, I thought we told each other everything but I guess not! Good night Finn." She pulled away and walked off to her home room taking Finn's bag out of her room before closing the door.

Finn stood in her music room feeling like the wind got knocked out of him. Rachel knew about his one time with Santana and it sucks. He turned the light off and walked upstairs and saw that his bag was outside of her room and he picked it up and stared to go to the guest room when he stopped and walked back to Rachel's room opening the door and closed it behind him and saw her sitting on the ground crying.

He put his bag down and sat down on the ground with her and she crawled over to him and straddled his lap and he held her close as she cried resting her head on his chest.

"I'm so sorry baby! I should have told you after you told me about the guys you've been with and it was wrong of me to keep it a secret." She calmed down a little.

"Why didn't you tell me?" She murmured against his chest sniffling a little. He sighs hating himself for not telling his baby about him and Santana.

"I was scared that you might break up with me! I know you told me about your past but I just really love you and I didn't want to lose you." He replied sadly running his hand down her back.

"You were never going to lose me unless one of us cheated or died but still you would still have my heart. I love you too but you have to be honest with me." She said looking into his eyes.

"I promise baby, damn it I promise you Rachel Barbra Berry that I will be honest and faithful to you aslong as you promise to do the same." She stared at him wiping her tears nodding.

"I promise baby I really promise that as long as were together that we won't get hurt." She whispered before pressing her lips against his and he quickly deepens it.

Find out what happens next.