Dean-
Lexi walked into the living room and hugged Scott.
"How are you Lexi?", he asked.
She came to stand beside me and I placed my hand on her back.
"I've been good, pregnant", she said.
"Congrats", he said.
We sat. We explained everything to him, about Cat showing up and everything I knew about Madison.
"I knew she was a twin, it was in her paper work. I didn't say anything because I assumed you knew", he said.
I nodded. Cat walked in.
"Cat, this is detective Scott", I said.
She smiled at him and he stood to shake her hand.
"This is our daughter, Cat", Lexi said.
Cat looked at her and smiled.
"I've heard a lot about you Cat. How about you tell me about your aunt?", he said.
She nodded and sat beside Lexi. She told him everything Madison did and said.
"You told me over the phone, Madison liked to protect Penny. If she's anything like her sister, I think it's best if we give her a restraining order", he said.
"That didn't work for Penny, she still came after us", Lexi said.
"Also", Cat started.
We looked at Cat, she stood and left to the kitchen. She came back with Lexi's laptop. Setting it on the coffee table.
"Madison made that bashing website about Lexi", she said.
Detective Scott looked it over and then looked at Cat.
"You hacked into it", he said.
Cat nodded.
"I took it down, only I can see it and make changes", Cat said.
He nodded.
"I'll make a call to a friend of mine in Ohio. I'll have him check on Madison", Scott said.
We nodded.
"She might have changed her hair color as well, before I left she had made an appointment with the hairdresser", Cat said.
Scott nodded.
"But she does have a tattoo on her wrist, says Madison", Cat said.
I stood.
"No", I said.
Cat looked at me and so did Scott.
"Baby what's wrong?", Lexi asked.
I swallowed. I didn't want to scare Lexi, she would have a panic attack. I placed my hand gently on her head.
"Nothing, it's just, the show I was taking the girls too, the first show is tonight", I said.
She nodded. Detective Scott gave me a look.
"I'm going to step outside and make that call to my friend", he said.
We nodded.
"I need some air. Tell the girls to get ready and Cat you too", I said.
She nodded, I stepped out after Scott. He faced me.
"Something was wrong. You lied to your wife. Why?", he asked.
"Madison doesn't have her name tattooed on her wrist. Penny does", I said.
He seemed surprised by this.
"I was there when they each got those tattoos. Madison has Penny's name and Penny has", I couldn't believe it.
"Madison's name", he finished.
I nodded.
"After Cat said that, I put two and two together. Its like I said, Madison would have done anything for Penny. Madison wanted to get rid of Lexi for Penny", I said.
He nodded.
"The only way we could prove this is by a DNA test", he said.
"We know Cat is Penny's daughter and if they match", he nodded, catching on.
This was all too much to take in.
"Then it really is Penny pretending to be Madison and you killed Madison that night", I said.
He rubbed his chin and nodded.
"Let me make that call. I'll have him take her in and question her. Maybe she'll slip", he said.
I nodded.
"Do me a favor, don't tell Lex", I said.
He nodded, understanding everything we've been through. I walked back in and the girls were putting on their shoes. I didn't know if I wanted to go to this show after all. Leaving Lexi alone wasn't an option anymore, but if I cancelled she would know something was wrong.
"Ready girls?", I asked.
They nodded, Lexi was holding Elijah.
"Have fun", she said.
I went over to her and kissed her.
"I love you, I'll be back as soon as I can", I said.
She nodded. I kissed the top of Elijah's head.
"Oh hey", she said, pulling me in.
Her lips near my ear, I felt her smile.
"Get ready for some one on one time when you get home", she whispered.
I groaned, kissing her cheek before moving over to her ear.
"Don't tease me", I whispered.
She giggled.
"Ew mom, dad really", Gracie said, covering her eyes.
The girls laughed.
"Hey, this is my woman. I can do with her as I please. This is how you two were made, you're welcome", I said.
"Gross dad", Amelia said, turning away.
"Leave them alone", Lexi said.
I kissed her once more before walking out with the girls. Detective Scott was getting off the phone.
"Wait for me in the car", I said.
The girls did as I asked.
"Would you mind sticking around a bit? At least till I get back?", I asked.
"I don't mind, have fun", he said.
"Hi uncle Scott", Amelia waved.
He waved back.
Penny-
I checked my new dark brown hair in the mirror, I had the girl put in extensions.
"I've always been so much better than her. I'm prettier and smarter", I told my reflection.
Someone knocked at my front door. I was about to yell for Catherine when I remembered that she had snuck out on me, no one had seen her. I opened the door, a man dressed in a suit stood there with a woman.
He lifted his hand and flashed me his badge.
"I'm detective Mark Henderson and this is my partner detective Claire Evans. We are looking for Madison Reeding", he said.
What did they want with Madison? Wait, I am Madison.
"That's me", I said.
He raised a brow.
"May we come in miss Reeding?", he asked.
I nodded and opened the door wider, they walked in and looked around. The woman was looking at the photos I had placed over my fireplace.
"Beautiful little girl", she said, pointing at a photo of Catherine.
"Yes, she is, thank you", I said.
She lifted a photo of me and Madison.
"Identical?", she asked.
I shook my head no.
"Usually when someone first meets us, they confuse us but after a while they could tell us apart", I said.
She nodded.
"Miss Reeding, do you know a Mr. Jonathan Good?", he asked.
I quickly looked at him.
"What about Jon? Is he okay? Did she hurt him?", I quickly asked.
They looked between each other. I could hear the voices in my head tell me.
"Shut up, don't give it away. Madison didn't care about Jon"
"Shut up", I mumbled.
The detectives looked at me and then each other.
"Are you okay Miss Reeding?", she asked.
I took a deep breath.
"They are going to lock you up again, stop it."
Madison's voice said.
"I'm fine", I said.
They nodded.
"He's fine. It's just a young woman turned up at his door a few days ago. She claims he's her father and her mother is Penelope Reeding, your sister. Since you are the closest person to Penelope, we would like to swab for DNA.", he said.
I nodded. The woman came over to me and opened a small case. She took out what she needed and I opened my mouth. Once done, she placed it in the bag and closed it.
"How is Catherine? Is she safe? Is Jon's whore treating her right?", I asked.
"She's his wife. Miss Reeding, are you sure you're okay?", she asked.
"She is not his wife, she took what belonged to you Penny. She killed me, she killed Burt, you need to finish what we couldn't", Madison said.
"She's not his wife, she took him from me. He was mine", I said.
They looked between each other again.
"I think we've got everything we need. Thank you for your time Miss Reeding", he said.
"Can you tell Jon something for me?", I asked.
He nodded.
"Tell him to be careful, Cat isn't a good person. She's a liar", I said.
I knew that little bitch was going to tell him everything and since he hated me, he was going to believe it all. It's a good thing she didn't know I wasn't Madison.
"We can do that", he said.
I nodded and walked them to the door. I watched them get into their car and drive off.
"She's going to ruin this for us Penny, we need to go to California", Madison said.
"I know, don't you think I know that", I said.
Hearing a baby cry, I made my way up to the baby room. This was suppose to be my baby's room, but she took that from me.
"She made you get an abortion then she took Jon from you. She took your baby from you Penny", Madison said.
"Its not fair, she got everything I was suppose to have", I said.
I buried my fingers in my hair and tugged hard on it.
"He belongs with me", I yelled.
"He does Penny and you'll get him back. We just have to get her out of the way", Madison said.
I nodded.
"I'm going to kill her, but first I'm going to tie her up and kill each of those brats right in front of her. She's going to hate him for it and then I can get him back. He'll come back to me Mads", I said.
"He will Penny, he's always loved you", Madison said.
I nodded.
