PJatO || Nicercy || PJatO || Nicercy || All the Percybilities || Nicercy || PJatO || Nicercy || PJatO

Title: All the Percybilities – Meeting Your Other Self

Fandom: Percy Jackson and the Olympians / Heroes of Olympus; kind of Mark of Athena

Disclaimer: All rights reserved to Rick Riordan for he created the awesomeness that is Nico di Angelo. And everything else related to Percy Jackson and the Olympians / Heroes of Olympus. Aside from the Gods, of course. They are all copyright by the old Greeks. This fanfiction on the other hand is entirely mine. No money is made with this, though reviews are more than welcomed.

Warnings: shounen-ai, meeting with AU-worlds, explicit intercourse, anal, oral, child abuse, dark, character death, blood/fighting, threesome(s), shoujo-ai, hetero

Main Pairing: Nico/Percy

Side Pairings: Jason/Reyna, Frank/Hazel/Leo, Piper/Annabeth, Chris/Clarisse, Tyson/Ella, Jake/Will, Malcolm/Katie, Lou/Miranda

Side Pairings of the 4th World: Charles/Silena/Percy, Nico/Annabeth, Jason/Leo

Percy Jackson Canon Characters: Crew of the Argo II: Perseus Jackson, Nico di Angelo, Hazel Levesque, Jason Grace, Thalia Grace, Katie Gardner, Miranda Gardner, Clarisse la Rue, Frank Zhang, Annabeth Chase, Malcolm Cage, Will Solace, Austin Barton, Kayla Hein, Phoebe Burge, Jake Mason, Leo Valdez, Nyssa Black, Drew Tanaka, Piper McLean, Lacy Hunnigan, Mitchell Logan, Travis Stoll, Connor Stoll, Chris Rodriguez, Lou Ellen, Reyna Avila Ramírez-Arellano, Hylla Avila Ramírez-Arellano, Kinzie Cohen, Octavian Simmons, Rachel Elizabeth Dare, Grover Underwood, Tyson, Ella, Mrs. O'Leary, Blackjack, Arion, Scipio, Tempest, Chaos, Nyx, Erebos, Hemera, Aether

4th World: Piper McLean, Leo Valdez, Jason Grace, Perseus Jackson, Charles Beckendorf, Silena Beauregard, Nico di Angelo, Annabeth Chase

Summary: A primeval power decides to show the crew of the Argo II how their reality could be if only little things would have changed. What if the Trio wouldn't have settled so well and Jason didn't get accepted by the Greeks...?

Drifting from one reality to the next, the friends also have to cope with their own feelings. Will this journey teach them an important lesson about themselves?

All the Percybilities

Meeting Your Other Self

Piper's World Part 1: With Piper and Clarisse in Strangeland

We're all a little mad here. That would be the slogan Piper would use to describe her world. She wasn't quite sure what she had imagined her world to be like – maybe one where her dad wasn't a movie star, where she was just a regular kid – but this was the farthest from it.

"They are practically fucking. With their clothes on", commented Clarisse amazed. "Can someone please take a picture for me? I need this! I seriously need this! This is the best blackmail material possible! Di Angelo will be my slave to the day of my death and beyond!"

Piper elbowed the daughter of Ares hard and glared, glad to look anywhere but to the 'main attraction'. Aka Nico di Angelo being all over her girlfriend. It was so disgusting, she was surprised she hadn't thrown up yet. Why was Piper's world so fucked-up? She had only been here for half a day and she was already hating it with a passion. Which may have had something to do with the fact that Nico di 'there is only Percy Jackson for me' Angelo had his tongue down Annabeth's throat.

"You two are very strange", commented Other Percy amused, his head cocked as he stared.

"Says the one sprawled all over my girl's lap", snorted Clarisse, taking a huge sip from her beer.

Her words had a harsh edge to them, but her eyes were soft. Soft with loss and mourn and love, which had surprised Piper immensely at first. But then she remembered the face. Silena Beauregard, they had met her in Percy's World already. Clarisse's dead best friend. The former leader of Piper's cabin, the one with the hero-big footsteps she needed to follow.

There were Beckendorf and Silena, huddled close together so both could reach the Percy Jackson in their midst, who was very busy getting cuddles from them. Which was the sight that had first greeted the two girls upon waking up. Silena and Percy fussing over them.

They had hit their heads on their fall and crash-landing on the ship. Where they got taken care of by the Seven of the Prophecy, or rather this world's definition of the Seven. Piper was still having a headache about it, but she was slowly getting the heck of this world.

Beckendorf, Silena, Percy, Nico, Annabeth, Piper and Leo.

She didn't have to be a brainiac like her girlfriend to know that those were essential too many Greeks. So Piper had silently dubbed this world the No Trusting Romans World.

"I think it's really time to go to bed", suggested Piper hoarsely as Nico and Annabeth started another heated session of making out. "Maybe I'll have a nice, sweet nightmare to distract me from this reality... Hopefully the others will come soon to rescue us..."

Clarisse stood to accompany Piper. So far, these versions seemed nice, but that didn't mean they trusted them enough to stay alone with those Seven. The cozily cuddled-up threesome smiled and waved at them as they retreated and once again, Piper had to think – they're all mad a little here.

"You're glad, right?", whispered Piper softly as the two girls entered a sleeping cabin.

"A bit. Not really. Mostly sad, I guess", mused Clarisse and plunged down on the bed.

"So I take the floor then?", grunted the daughter of Aphrodite displeased.

Then again, she had no plans of sleeping anyway. Nightmares of Nico and Annabeth together would be haunting her in her sleep. Shuddering slightly, she made a move to sit down, but her upper arm was caught by a firm grip. Clarisse glared at her as though she was a total moron.

"Girl, don't be a moron. The bed's roomy enough for both of us", stated Clarisse, raising one unimpressed eyebrow at the younger girl. "I mean, I know I'm hot and you're probably going to have trouble keeping your hands to yourself, but... I trust you."

She threw a playful smile at Piper that managed to loosen the native American up some. Piper relaxed a little and sat down next to Clarisse, kicking her shoes off. If someone would have asked her this morning how she had imagined her evening, the answer would have neither included her thinking about Nico and Annabeth kissing or her climbing into bed with Clarisse la Rue.

"So... What do you think?", asked Piper slowly as she snuggled under the covers.

"About di Angelo humping Chase?", snickered Clarisse teasingly, wiggling her eyebrows.

"Can we talk about anything but this?", groaned Piper disgusted and shuddered.

"I'll go easy on you for now", offered the daughter of Ares amused and folded her arms behind her head, staring up at the ceiling. "I'm not sure. The animosity against Romans is thick in the air and it unsettles me a little. Makes me wonder how they'll react once our crew arrives."

"That's one point", nodded Piper in agreement, frowning. "I mean, Jason is like the stowaway that only got to tag along because of Leo's puppy eyes – and how did Leo end up with Jason anyway?"

"I have no fucking idea", shrugged Clarisse. "But I really didn't want to ask. I mean, have you seen the nasty glare Other Piper threw at him? It was like she wanted to kill him. Creepy."

"And the... threesome", pointed Piper timidly out, blinking her eyes owlishly. "I mean, I'm not judging. I can see that Leo is heading such a way, I just never... Percy?"

"No fucking idea what that's supposed to mean", shrugged Clarisse with a short nod. "But I honestly wasn't feeling like asking my dead best friend why she's screwing Jackson."

"How are you handling that?", whispered Piper softly, turning her head to look at Clarisse. "I mean, she is your best friend. And here, she's alive. And not working with the Titans like the last one."

"I don't... I don't know", whispered Clarisse back and for the first time since Piper knew her, her voice sounded raw and vulnerable. "But she looks so happy. Makes me wonder if this is... what she would look like now if she hadn't died. So... happy."

"Tomorrow, I'll ask some questions", declared Piper and yawned. "But not today."

"No, not today", said Clarisse amused and wrapped a friendly arm around Piper's shoulder. "Night."

/break\

Piper hummed softly as she snuggled up to the comfortable boobs she was laying against. She loved waking up like that. Annabeth poked her cheek. Batting the hand away, Piper grunted.

"Listen, princess, I told you no horny rubbing yourself against me."

That was not Annabeth. Blinking her eyes open, Piper lifted her head to stare at a highly amused Clarisse. Damn. She had hoped yesterday had been a nightmare and nothing else. Groaning annoyed, she combed her fingers through her hair and collapsed back on the bed.

"Well, this world is your quest. So... What's next, princess?", asked Clarisse amused.

"Talking to the weirdos", muttered Piper, not the least bit happy about it. "Okay. We split up. You know Silena, you can tell when she lies. Can you talk to her? I want to have a word with Leo."

"Interesting choices", noted the daughter of Ares curiously, cocking one eyebrow.

"I can't put up with Annabeth while she's having her hands down Nico's pants", grunted Piper and shuddered. "And I... don't trust myself. She really freaks me out."

"Okay, good. Let's do this", grunted Clarisse and sat up. "This is going to be so much fun..."

/break\

Clarisse shifted uncomfortably as she knocked on the door. It was pretty easy to detect this as Silena's room. There were pink and blue hearts painted onto the door. She knocked again.

"Coming!", chimed a voice that was not Silena's.

Seconds later and a half-naked Percy opened her the door. Half-naked as in; only wearing (Silena's) nightdress. Well, she had to hand it to him, he had a pair of pretty legs there. Arching one eyebrow, she looking him up and down with a teasing smirk. He blushed and moved to close the door again. Forgetting that she was the daughter of war and strong as an ox.

"Come back here, babe", whispered Charles and beckoned Percy over.

The blushing Sea Prince went to hide in the broad chest as Beckendorf covered Percy up with the blanket and glared at Clarisse. Wow. How much she had missed that chiding glare.

"Hello, Not-Clarisse", greeted Silena in a soft voice. "Close the door, please. I figured you'd come to us, sooner or later. You and Not-Piper said you're from a parallel world, told us about your world. But you haven't asked a single question about our world. Why not?"

"Too freaked out", confessed Clarisse and pulled a chair up to sit opposite them. "What's the deal with di Angelo and Chase? I mean, they are like... the most unlikely pair ever."

"Ever since Annabeth got Nico and Bianca out of school back then... well, I don't know really", shrugged Percy softly. "Why? Who are they dating in your world, if not each other?"

"Well, normally Nico only shoves his tongue down your throat and Annabeth is all over Piper."

"Oh my, that explains why Not-Piper looked at them so distaste—Wait, what?", grunted Silena, looking wide-eyed. "Why would your Nico have his tongue anywhere near our Percy? Don't your Silena and your Charlie have anything to say about that? This is an outrage!"

"You're dead", whispered Clarisse – and wasn't that something you really shouldn't have to tell someone? "You died. During the Titan war. B—Both of you. But even before that, there wasn't... I mean, you three? I can't even... This is really weird for me to see, to be honest. And not just because you're supposedly dead and because Percy is wearing a dress – which I need confirmed on a photo by the way to blackmail the sea brat later on – but because you're... I don't know."

"I... think I understand", nodded Silena slowly (but her arms were still possessively wrapped around Percy's waist). "It's not what you're used to from us. I would be feeling weird seeing Annabeth and Piper together too, I suppose. Okay, now I understand why you're behaving so squirmy. Anything else you'd like to share – or to know?"

"How are you still alive?", blurted Clarisse out, her nails digging into her jeans. "I mean... Beckendorf died on the Princess Andromeda, giving Percy the chance to dive into the ocean for safety and sacrificing himself... A—And Silena, you... after the fight with the dragon..."

"Percy had made sure that Nico would come along to the quest", answered the son of Hephaestus, caressing Percy's neck tenderly. "The boy shadow-traveled us to safety just in time."

"And when I was wounded during the battle, Percy nearly passed out giving me his strength, through the water. We didn't even know he could heal others too, but he was crying so hard and begging me not to leave him... He just... healed me", continued Silena, her hand resting on Percy's thigh. "I like to say that his love for me saved me. Now, knowing of your world... I think it truly did. You Percy never felt the same love for us as ours did. This world-defying love, the one where you're ready to sacrifice everything for each other."

"Okay. Good", nodded Clarisse.

She knew deep down that nothing about this was 'good', not to her, because now she knew that a completely gods-unrelated thing could have saved her best friend. And she couldn't even hate her own Percy for it, because Percy didn't know about it, had never tried this ability. If Nico would have been wounded like that, maybe he would have tried. But something had shifted his affections, differing between this world and her own world. Shaking her head, she tried to clear her mind.

"Other things", muttered Clarisse to herself. "Other things to ask... Uh, right. Why no Romans?"

"We don't need them", growled Silena with a sharp glare.

"Yeah, but I mean... How did you get Percy back? Did you just snatch him up and leave New Rome again?", asked the daughter of Ares confused.

"Why would we have to get Percy back?", asked Charles, equally confused. "Hera snatched the leader of Camp Half-Blood. In which screwed-up definition of that did Percy end up being the leader? Annabeth had always been that, together with Castellan Chiron's well-trusted girl. Percy had only been around for a couple of years, why should he have become the leader of camp?"

"Uh, never mind that", muttered Clarisse and shook her head. "So you had to get Annabeth back?"

"That was an easy one", chuckled Silena amused. "Nico shadow-traveled to the Romans, snatched his girl and brought her back to us. We don't need Romans. They only screw everything over. Like Thalia's brother. The boy that should not be alive. The only reason we allow him to stay is because Leo is just too adorable and too attached to the boy."

"Well, at least some things never change", snorted Clarisse and rolled her eyes. "The adorable Valdez. He's going to like that one, that's for sure."

"Wait. How did Leo cope without me around?", asked the son of Hephaestus suddenly. "I mean, he's not the social guy and I can't see Jake coaxing Leo out of his shell much. Silena and I had been his parents since he arrived here, so to speak."

"Leo is cabin leader. He's relatively insecure, yeah, but Nyssa and Jake and the others, as well as Piper and Jason of course, did a good job making him... bearable", answered Clarisse with a grin.

/break\

"You two are dating."

"Uh... Y—Yes?", stuttered Leo, staring wide-eyed at the Piper that wasn't his. "You're not going to give us a hard time too, right? Because I'm already getting enough of that from everyone else..."

"No!", exclaimed Piper, lifting her hands in a peaceful manner. "No. I'm just... curious."

"Yes, we're dating", nodded Jason slowly, grabbing Leo's hand in support. "It was a little rough, especially with the fake memories of me dating you – well, our Piper, but I soon found myself drawn to Leo. He was just so... He was the only one accepting me. Everybody else was being so hostile toward me. The Greeks were headless without Annabeth Chase around and they blamed me. Percy, he... he tried to appease to them, but... well, his partners reasoned him down to accepting that I posed a threat and that that was all he should focus on for now."

"Beckendorf and Silena have a lot to say here then?", asked Piper interested.

"They're two of the oldest cabin leaders", nodded Leo and shrugged slightly. "Two of the oldest campers in general. So they do have a certain authority. Besides, with their relationship with Percy, they have quite the control over the strongest Greek too. Not saying they were manipulating him or anything, but they can influence him to lean toward their opinions."

"Which is a couple-thing, I guess. Nothing I hold against them", assured Jason honestly, caressing Leo's hand. "I mean, if we weren't dating, he would probably not be on my side like that either."

"He would", assured Piper softly. "I mean, in our world... You have so many friends. Then again, you did get switched with Percy and not with Annabeth... Things are different."

"We notice", nodded Leo thoughtful. "Wow."

"You can say that loud", snorted Piper and nodded gravely. "I don't like this. You have not enough Romans here. The quest should be more even. I mean, well, our ship is relatively packed, we kind of grabbed everybody who was interested in attending, but still... You only have one Roman."

Piper wasn't sure if the others even got how grave their situation was. They were on the verge of total war between Greeks and Romans, she couldn't come up with any other scenario for this. Jason was still missing, the Greeks never bothered to even visit the Romans. This was at worst going to be a war between the Romans, attacking the rest of Camp Half-Blood. At best it would be a repetition of the Titan War. With Greeks and Romans fighting the same enemy without working together. Which would this time around most likely lead to a disaster.

"I need breakfast", muttered Piper and shook her head.

/break\

Piper regretted wanting breakfast, because Nico and Annabeth were in the dining hall. She coughed a couple of time, interrupting their making-out session. They dove apart and blushed.

"Sorry. Uh, Not-Piper, right?", asked Nico, trying to make sure. "You're a little less creepy than your counter part from our world. Is there something we can do for you?"

"Why are you two together?"

Piper hadn't wanted to say that and she cursed herself for slipping it out. Annabeth and Nico stared at her a little surprised and heavily uncomfortable. Oh, what did she care, really? Once she'd leave this world again, she would – hopefully – never see them in this constellation together again anyway. Still, she was going to make sure that her Percy kept his boyfriend on a short leash around Annabeth for the next couple of... years. Just to be safe.

"Why do you ask?", growled Nico with a dark glare.

"Because you don't love each other. You can't love each other. I know you two have known each other as long as my Annabeth and our Nico. You met under the same circumstances. Why should you two be all over each other while my Annabeth is – mine", grunted Piper stubbornly, crossing her arms over her chest and shifting some. "So, why? Are you really that maddeningly in love?"

"We... learned to love each other", answered Annabeth timidly.

"After the one we both loved got snatched away from either of us, we... settled for each other", added the son of Hades, leisurely leaning back in his chair. "Beckendorf and Beauregard had been very... persistent in their wooing of Percy, always cutting him off from us. We stood no chance. Even before he knew it, we could see it. That his heart was with them. So... Se settled too."

"We're happy", clarified – or insisted, Piper wasn't so sure – Annabeth with hard eyes.

"Right", snorted Piper with a short nod. "I think I need another nap."

She couldn't stand looking at them anymore. This was even more disgusting than seeing them making out. They were cowards. Nico was as gay as a rainbow with a basket full of tiny, pink unicorns. The boy was not in doubt of his sexuality. Even though the rest of the crew liked to tease him that he was less homosexual than he was percysexual. So just because he couldn't have Percy, he tried to bang Percy's best friend? To do what, hurt him? And Annabeth, Piper knew she was more inclined toward the female sex. Not completely gay, but still. But this Annabeth seemed to have just given up on finding someone she could truly love, taking what was convenient.

/break\

"Why does your world feel like a fucking love-drama?"

"I have no idea", muttered Piper as she entered their cabin and kicked her shoes off again. "But I really don't know what kind of value I am supposed to learn here."

"Well, find it soon. I want Chris back and I want to get away from this crazy shit", grunted Clarisse, rolling onto her back and making room for Piper. "I just saw Percy Jackson in a dress."

"I did too. Well, not today anyway, but when we went shopping", shrugged Piper.

"No shit?", laughed the daughter of Ares amused. "But it surely wasn't a pink neglige."

"Oh. Uh. No", grunted Piper wide-eyed. "Wow. Huh. He was fighting me quite well in the store, but now I think that may have only been a cover. Heh. This is going to be an interesting conversation."

"So... That shopping trip...", drawled Clarisse with a nearly wicked smirk. "Are there pictures? Pictures that I may get my hands onto? Because I think a poster of Jackson in a dress would look nice at my wall. Yes, very nice indeed."

"Don't be mean to him", chided Piper fondly, hitting Clarisse's upper arm playfully. "He's... been through a lot. You know that. Hades, we all know that now."

"Are you afraid?", asked Clarisse, her voice nearly gentle. "I mean, that the Old Ones will force you into such a confession-situation too? Soul-striptease in front of everyone?"

"I don't have dark secrets", shrugged Piper and cuddled up to Clarisse. "Aside from this cuddling."


Author's note: Due to the whining when I posted the contest, I wrote new chapters for every story so you'll also have your updates and are not disappointed - I hope I get grateful reviews for that work. ;) - So the CONTEST WINNERS are up!

Next chapter will have fussing Annabeth and a little Nicercy-fight about the fact that Percy had kept his encounter with the deities to himself. But make-up-sex is the best anyway, so no problems there. *grins*