My number one: There could never be no one like you
How come I feel this way again
My number two: Never tried to tell me what to say or do
I'm so in love with two
Jenna ran her hand up Groves chest as she looked up at him.
"How...how can you love me and Gillette at the same time?" he asked.
"You make me feel good", she answered. "Gillette is handsome, yes. But he has never done what we just did with me."
I don't want to push it
I don't want to fight
But this feeling keeps me up all night
"Can you decide which one of us is the better man?" he asked.
"What do you mean?"
"Which one do you like better?"
"Why does it matter?" Jenna asked. "We're just having an affair, nothing more."
"Is that all you want me for? An affair?"
If I only could decide
But I can't make up my mind
I'm breakin' all my rules because of you
You tell me it's not right
And it tears me up inside
But the problem is I'm so in love with two
"How can I choose between the two of you?" Jenna asked. "I love both of you, I can't decide!"
Hey, hey, hey
I don't know what to do
Hey, hey, hey
I choose the both of you
"Can't we just stay like this?" she asked curling up next to Groves. "We can keep this affair going that way I don't have to choose between you and Fluffy. I can't love either of you more than the other. I love you both the same way. Fluffy's handsome and he gives me a home. He gives me what I need. But you give me what I want."
My number one: You give me everything I need
But some thinks two I'm better with
My number two: He's the one that really makes me feel so good
I'm so in love with two
I don't want to push it
I don't want to fight
But this feeling keeps me up all night
Groves stayed silent.
"Please, Happy? For me."
He wrapped his arms around Jenna and kissed her. She smiled as she kissed him back.
"Will you tell me when you decide?" he asked.
"Mm...just shut up and love me."
If I only could decide
But I can't make up my mind
I'm breakin' all my rules because of you
You tell me it's not right
And it tears me up inside
But the problem is I'm so in love with two
Hey, hey, hey
I don't know what to do
Hey, hey, hey
I choose the both of you
