Unforgettable Love

by WorkingGirl22

Summary

Brittany Pierce and Santana Lopez were finally a couple and not afraid to be open at McKinley High. Everybody knew they had something going on with them and didn't care because they knew that Santana would kick their asses for messing with her girlfriend.

But what happens when Brittany's old childhood best friend/first ever girlfriend, Rachel Berry moves back to Lima after being in California for so long, shows up Brittany's and her Senior year all grown up and not the same girl she was when she was younger,sparking up feelings that Brittany struggled to long forget while also putting a strain on her relationship with Santana Lopez?

Will Brittany and Rachel start their friendship over as just best friends or will they finally admit that they still want each other? Find out what happens.

Season 4 Rachel Berry clothes and hair style in this story. Minor Brittana relationship but Brittberry and Quinntana romance hopefully in the end.

I'm spelling Ariella's sister name differently since it's hard for any of you to figure it out. It's now going to be spelled Kaliyah.

Enjoy.


"Can we talk please?" Kaliyah pleaded with hope.

"I already said that us being friends wasn't in the cards for us, you made it clear yesterday." Britt whispers trying to get past her.

"Stop Brittany. I'm sorry for hurting your feelings but I felt you were trying to ruin mine and my sister's surprise for Rachel. I get you want to be her everything and do things for her but you haven't been in her life for the past few years, she's not the same Rachel was as a little girl." Britt stares at her.

"I know that Kaliyah, I'm not stupid like everybody thinks and I'm tired of people dumbing down for me, stop treating me like a fucking baby. I'm 17 years old."

She screamed pushing past her. Kaliyah felt bad hurting her feelings. She doesn't know that much about Britt and she seems upset.

Ariella walked up to her sister.

"How did it go?" Kaliyah stared at her sister.

"Not good, I think she hates me." Ariella just shrugged not really caring. She's not a fan of Brittany's anyways.

Kaliyah rolls her eyes and goes to her room to call her boyfriend.

With Brittberry.

Rachel heard her bedroom door open then close. She stayed quiet as the bed moves a little. She felt an arm around her waist. Rach knew it was her girlfriend. She heard her screaming to Kal.

"I don't think your stupid, I never thought that and I never will." Britt just sighs tiredly and just lies next to her. Rach shifts her body and looks at her.

"You believe me right Bunny? " She whispers getting close to her and rests her head against her chest.

Brittany just nods looking into her eyes. This was the girl she wanted to marry someday. Her life was better with Rachel in her life. Santana use to be that girl until her true love came back.

"I'll always believe anything you say. Do you think I was pushing it a little yesterday?"

She looks into her blue eyes.

"Kaliyah crossed the line with the insults because you're my girlfriend and she shouldn't had said that. But if her and her sister wanted to do something for me? I don't think you have to be apart of it unless they asked you to be apart of it. Do you understand where I'm coming from?" Britt frowns.

"Yeah I understand. I guess I just want to be part of something when it comes to you, your everything to me and I love you Rasberry." Rachel smiles at her, placing her hand on her cheek.

"That's very sweet Bunny. I love you too. Let's go back to sleep for a few hours then we'll do something."

Brittany whispers okay then kisses her cheek before pulling her girlfriend close before closing her eyes, Rachel closed her eyes the moment she got close.

A few hours later, the couple were watching TV downstairs. Rachel was going to be act school on Monday. The door bell rings and Ariella comes downstairs answering it and smirked letting the person in. Rach and Britt looked up to see Santana walking upstairs with Ariella with a smirk on her face and knew this wasn't good.

"What is Santana Lopez doing here in my house?" Britt was tired of dealing with Santana's mix signals.

"I really don't know but the more time she screws things up, the more she's breaking Quinn's heart."

"I agree with you baby. She's playing with her emotions and it's not right." Brittany shook her head.

"Let's not worry about them right now and get back to our relaxing day." Rachel loved that idea but she still felt bad for Quinn.

Find out what happens next.