Karli, Sam and Dean were walking around the small town, searching for Andy and Dean's car.
"I swear, if we find him, I'll kill him." Karli said, looking around.
"No you won't." Dean told her.
"Yes I will. First he took the impala and then he wanted to take me." Karli complained.
"Yeah, I don't understand. He asked Dean for the car and he gave it up, no questions asked. But when he asked for you, you wouldn't go." Sam spoke up.
"So?" Karli asked, confused.
"How come the mind control worked on Dean but not you?" Sam asked.
"I don't know, I'm special I guess." Karli said as they walked across the street and spotted the Impala parked out on the street.
"Thank god." Dean said, running across the street to the car, "I'm sorry baby, I'll never leave you again."
"Again I'm replaced by the car." Karli said, rolling her eyes.
"At least he left the keys in it." Dean said, looking inside the car.
"Yeah, that was nice of him." Sam rolled his eyes.
"So it looks like this guy can't work his mojo just by twitchin his nose, he needs to use verbal commands." Dean stated.
"The doctor had just gotten off his cell phone when he stepped in front of that bus." Sam said, sighing. "He must've called him or something."
"Yeah, maybe." Dean said.
"What was that?" Sam asked.
"I just don't know if he's our guy Sam." Dean said, looking up.
"Dean, you had O.J. convicted before he got out of his white Bronco and you have doubts about this?" Sam asked.
"He doesn't seem like the stone cold killer type, that's all, you know. And O.J. was guilty." Dean said, adding the last part as an afterthought.
"Either way, how are we gonna track this guy down?" Sam asked.
"Not a problem." Karli spoke up from behind them and told them to get into the car. "I can spot a stoner's car a mile away, especially his."
"Why is everyone a stoner to you?" Dean asked her.
"Twenty bucks says he is." Karli said smiling.
"Deal." Dean said.
"How bout you Sammy?" Karli asked, turning to look at Sam.
"Fine." Sam sighed and got into the car as Dean took off down the street searching for the van.
"Not exactly an inconspicuous ride." Dean said as they found the van and walked over to it. "Lets have a look." Dean pulled something out of his jacket and broke open the door. They opened them and looked in the back.
"I told you he was so a stoner." Karli told them.
"This…this is magnificent, that's what this is." Dean told them, smirking, "Not exactly a serial killer's lair though." The three of them began looking inside the van. "There's no clown painting on the walls or scissors stuck in victims photos. I like the tiger." Karli rolled her eyes.
"Hegel, Kant, Wittgenstein, it's pretty heavy reading, Dean." Sam told him as looked through the books.
"Yeah." Karli laughed as Dean pulled something long from the back, "And Moby Dick's bong." Sam rolled his eyes and Karli laughed and smirked.
"So, I believe you two owe me twenty bucks." Karli told them. They both sighed and slipped her twenty each before they closed the doors while Karli still smiled. They turned around and saw Andy standing there.
"Who are you and why are you following me?" Andy asked them.
"Well, we're lawyers. See, a relative of yours has passed…" Sam started.
"Tell the truth!" Andy half yelled.
"That's what we're…" Karli started but was cut off by Dean.
"We hunt demons." Dean told him.
"What?" Andy asked, a confused look on his face.
"Demons, spirits, things your worst nightmares wouldn't even touch. Sam here, this is my brother…"
"Dean, shut up!" Both Karli and Sam hissed at him.
"I'm trying!" Dean started through gritted teeth, "He's psychic. Kinda like you, well not really like you, but see, he thinks you're a murderer, and he's afraid that he's gonna become one himself, cause you're all part of something that's terrible, and I hope to hell that he's wrong, but I'm starting to get a little scared that he might be right." Karli put her hand over his mouth so anything else he would say wouldn't be clear.
"Dean, just stop." Karli told him.
"You three are crazy, you know that." Andy told them.
"So you can't control other people using verbal commands?" Karli shot back at him. He just looked down. "Yeah, that's what I thought." Karli pulled her hand away from Dean when she was sure he was done talking. Sam and Andy walked away, Karli guessed that Andy was trying to convince Andy that all of this was true.
"I didn't want to say any of that, that stupid…" Dean started.
"Dean, it's okay. We know. But what I don't get is why it doesn't effect me and Sam." Karli told him. They heard something come into contact with the van and rushed over to the other side, where Sam was holding his head and leaning against the car.
"Sam, What is it?" Karli asked, placing her hand on his arm.
"Come on Sammy." Dean said. Sam eyes shot open and he looked around.
"A woman got a call on her phone and poured gas on herself before lighting herself on fire." Sam told them. "We gotta stop it before it happens." They looked shocked for a moment as a fire truck started to fly by them.
"Sam, stay here. Me and Karli will go check it out." Dean said as he ran with Karli back to the Impala and took off after the fire truck.
"This isn't gonna be good." Karli said as the fire truck pulled into a gas station where a figure was covered by flames. "Oh my god." Karli said, placing her hand over her mouth in shock.
"Guess we're too late." Dean told her as he turned around to go back to Sam. Karli sat back in her seat, too shocked to say anything. They pulled up right behind Andy's van and got out of the car.
"We were too late." Dean told him.
"So I guess you're off the hook." Karli spoke up, looking at Andy.
"What do you mean?" Andy asked.
"We thought it was you because of the power and they were both on their phones so someone told them to do the things we did. We figured it was you." Karli explained, "But since you were with us, it couldn't have been you."
"I wouldn't do that anyway, I can't kill anyone." Andy told them.
"We know now." Karli told him. "What do we do now?" Karli turned her attention to Sam and Dean. Sam looked exhausted.
"We should check on the woman who just died. See if we can find anything out." Dean told her and looked over at Sam. "And you should get some sleep."
"I'm fine Dean." Sam told him, moving to the car.
"No you're not Sammy. Now you're going back to the motel and you're going to rest." Karli told him.
"Wow, that's a change." Dean said, looking surprised.
"What?" Karli asked.
"You telling people what to do." Dean told her, smiling.
"Well he looks tired. It looked like the vision took a lot out of him." Karli told him as she got into the car and they took off for the motel.
"You guys are not leaving me here." Sam told them.
"Your right." Dean said and Karli looked at him confused, "I'm leaving you two behind. Sammy, you need to rest and Karli's stayin here to make sure you get that rest." Dean said, leaving quickly and pulling out of the parking lot, Karli running out to catch him but he was gone. Karli sighed and rolled her eyes.
"Wait till he gets back, the next time he leaves me, I'm gonna kill him." Karli said, walking back into the room. She looked over at Sam who was standing in the middle of the room, "You need to lay down."
"I'm fine, how many times do I have to say it?" Sam complained, still looking exhausted.
"Yeah, of course now lay down. You don't have to go to sleep but you need to relax so we can figure out what's goin on." Karli said, trying to lead him to the bed.
"Karli, I'm fine." Sam said as Karli pushed him over to the bed. He sat down and Karli pushed him down so he was laying on it. Sam closed his eyes and fell asleep almost immediately. Karli smiled and walked over to her phone and began going through it, waiting for Dean to get back so she could yell at him for leaving.
An hour later Karli looked over at Sam who was still sleeping soundlessly. The door opened and Dean walked in. Karli jumped out of the bed and hit him in his arm.
"Ow, what was that for?" Dean asked.
"Leaving me." Karli told him.
"I'm sorry." Dean told her, "But we got a little problem."
"What is it?" Karli asked.
"Andy was adopted. The woman in the gas station was his birthmother. Doctor Jennings was the doctor present at his birth." Dean told her.
"So Andy did do it."
"I don't think so. I looked at the birth certificate. Holly Beckett, the woman who died, gave birth to twins." Dean said.
"So Andy has a twin?" Karli asked.
"Yeah and I've got a picture. Does he look familiar to you?" Dean handed Karli a picture and she gasped in shock.
"The bus boy from the diner." Dean nodded at her. They both snapped around when Sam fell to the floor, holding his head.
"Shit, not again. Sammy, what is it?" Karli asked, kneeling beside him and wrapping her arms around him. "Sammy, what's going on?"
"The girl from the diner jumped off a dam." Sam told them.
"Well lets get going before it happens." Dean said as Karli helped Sam up and they ran to the car.
"I-I have a brother?" Andy asked from the backseat. It was Karli's idea to pick him up and tell him what was going on.
"Yes, his name is Anson Williams but you probably know him as Webber." Karli told him.
"The bus boy? He came around eight months ago and ever since he tried to be my best friend." Andy told them.
"Well at least you know the truth." Karli told him.
"Yeah, your brother's a psychotic murderer." Dean said from the driver's seat. Karli hit him in the back of the head.
"Don't say it like that." Karli told him.
"And he's gonna kill someone else?" Andy asked.
"Yeah, the girl from the diner." Karli nodded.
"Tracy?!" Andy asked, raising his voice.
"Don't worry, we're gonna get her before he does something bad, I promise." The car came to a stop a good distance away from the dam to be sure that Webber didn't know they were there.
"What the hell are we gonna do?" Karli whispered.
"Sam's going to try and stop Webber with Andy. I'm going into the forest with my friend here just in case Sam and Andy can't stop them." Karli nodded and grabbed another gun from the trunk.
"Then I'm goin with you." Karli told him.
"No, you're immune to his commands, you're going with them to help." Dean told her.
"But what if something happens and you need help. You shouldn't go by yourself." Karli argued.
"I'll be fine Karli, go with them." Karli sighed and nodded slightly. She tucked the gun into her jeans and followed Sam and Andy while Dean walked away and disappeared in the trees. When they reached the dam they saw Tracy standing on the ledge and Webber was still sitting in the car. Tracy was about to jump when Andy told her to stop and Sam broke the window of the car and pulled Webber out. He tried to say something but Sam held him down and Karli taped his mouth shut. Andy was over by Tracy and was trying to help her down but she wouldn't move.
"Why won't she move?" Andy asked them. They both turned to him and didn't realize what a bad idea that was until Karli heard Sam fall to the ground beside her. She turned around just in time for Webber to knock her down beside Sam. She tried to get up but her head was spinning. She looked up and saw an outline of Webber and Andy talking to each other.
"Are you really this stupid?" She heard Andy, "You, you learn you got a twin, you call them up! You go out for a drink. You don't start killing people!"
"I wanted to tell you for so long, bro, but he didn't let me. He said I had to wait until the time was right." Webber said in a calm voice.
"Who?" Andy asked him. Karli was able to see clearer and tried to pull out her gun from the back of her jeans.
"The man with the yellow eyes." Karli looked up at and started to aim the gun at him when he turned around and grabbed it from her, throwing it on the ground somewhere behind him. "You really don't want to do that." He said, still holding her wrist.
"Why is that?" Karli asked him. He just smirked and punched her. Her head started spinning again.
"What the hell are you doing? What are you talking about?" Andy asked.
"He came to me. In my dream." Karli looked over at Sam and saw he was struggling to move. "He said I was special. He told me he's got big plans for me. Wait till you see what's in store for both of us. See, he's the who told me I had a brother. A twin." Webber told him.
"Why did you kill our mother?" Andy asked. "And doctor Jennings?"
"Because they split us up!" Webber yelled, "They ruined our lives Andy." his voice softened, "We could've been together this whole time. Instead of alone. I-I couldn't let them get away with that."
"Oh yeah, so killing them was such a smart thing to do." Karli said sarcastically from her spot beside Sam. 'Great, why do you always gotta piss them off Karli?'
"How about you think about it from my point of view. You have a sister and your parents split you up and you didn't find out for twenty years." Webber said, looking over at her.
"Yeah, I'd be pissed as hell but I wouldn't go all psycho killer on them." Karli told him. He just walked over to her and hit her again. Karli looked up at him and even though everything was spinning, she saw him looking over to where Dean was hiding.
"I see you." Webber said, smirking "Bye-Bye."
"Shit, Dean!" Karli yelled and Webber hit her one more time before backing up. Karli heard a gunshot and tried to get up. "Dean!" She yelled again. Sam had managed to get up and was shushing her.
"Karli, it wasn't Dean." Karli looked up at Sam who motioned over to his right. Karli looked and saw that Webber was on the ground and Andy was holding Karli's gun. Karli heard Tracy crying from her spot on the dam ledge and saw Andy run over to him. Karli was still scared, thinking for another second that it was Dean who had been killed. Sam was beside her, comforting her, telling her it wasn't true and she eventually fell asleep.
Karli woke up early the next morning with Dean sitting beside her, playing with her hair. She immediately smiled when she saw him and wrapped her arms around his neck.
"Dean, you're okay." Karli smiled and hugged him tighter.
"Yeah, and so are you. Not that you helped the case." Dean said, pulling back and looking at her face which had bruises everywhere.
"You know I don't know when to shut up. That's something we have in common." Karli said, giving a weak smile. Karli looked outside and saw there were cops and an ambulance. "Do we need to go talk to them?" Karli asked.
"Yeah, it'll just take a few minutes. We have to tell them why it was necessary to shoot Webber." Dean told her. Karli nodded and got out of the car with Dean and walked over to Sam, who was already talking to the cops. When Karli first got there, the cops were all over her, asking what had happened. She said that she was trying to help the girl Tracy and Webber had punched her a few times. They asked if that was true and looked over at Sam and Dean. She said yes, that they could ask Andy. They nodded and asked about what had happened. They told him everything, leaving out the part about the mind control. Half an hour later, they walked back toward the Impala when Sam spoke up.
"It looks like I was right." Sam told them.
"About what?" Dean and Karli asked.
"Andy." He answered, "He's a killer after all."
"No he's a hero. Saved his girlfriends life, Saved my life." Dean told him.
"Bottom line, last night he wasted somebody." Sam told him.
"But he's not a foaming at the mouth Psycho. He was pushed into that." Dean said.
"Webber was pushed too in his own way. Max was pushed. Hell, I was pushed by Jessica's death." Sam argued.
"What's your point Sam?" Dean asked, stopping. Karli stood beside them.
"Under the right circumstances, everyone's capable of murder Dean, everyone. Maybe that's what the demon's doing. Pushing us. Finding ways to break us." Sam said.
"Sam we don't know what the demon wants. Okay, quit worrying about it." Dean said, walking over to the car. Karli walked behind him and Sam followed.
"You know, I heard you before Dean when Andy made you tell the truth. You're just as scared of this as I am." Sam told him.
"Man, that was mind control, It's like being roffied man, it doesn't count." Dean said, opening his door.
"What?" Sam asked.
"No, I-I'm callin do-over." Dean told him.
"What are you, seven?" Sam asked and Karli rolled her eyes.
"Look, we just gotta keep doin what we're doin. Find that evil son of a bitch and kill it." Dean said, getting into the car. Sam followed and Karli jumped in behind them. Dean's phone started to ring and he answered it.
"Hello." Dean paused. "Ellen." Another pause. "Sure, we'll be right there." Dean hung up the phone and put it back in his jacket. "Ellen said she needs to talk to us."
"So we're goin back to the Roadhouse?" Karli asked, crossing her arms.
"Yeah, don't say anything to Jo, just ignore her." Dean said, turning around and giving her a look.
"I will, as long as she keeps her mouth shut." Karli said as Dean turned back around and drove toward the Roadhouse.
Two hours later, they walked into the Roadhouse and took seats at the bar, Dean on the right, Karli in the middle, and Sam on the left. Ellen came over and gave Sam and Dean both beers and handed Karli the Malibu without Karli needing to put up a fight. She smiled and started drinking. Jo was walking around the bar but Karli tried not to pay attention.
"Jo, go pull up another case of beer." Ellen told her.
"Mom." Jo started, sounding like a childish whine that made Karli roll her eyes.
"Now." Ellen said sternly, "Please." Jo sighed and walked away. Karli looked up and noticed she was glaring at her. After Jo was gone, Ellen walked over to them and sighed.
"You three want to tell me about that last hunt of yours?" Ellen asked them.
"No, not really." Dean said quickly, taking a sip of his beer. Karli and Sam both gave him a look and he spoke up again. "No offense, it's just kind of a family thing." Ellen pulled a folder from under the bar and dropped it onto the bar between Dean and Karli.
"Not anymore. I got this stuff from Ash." Ellen looked between the three of them but they all avoided her gaze. "Andrew Gallagher's house burnt down on his six month birthday, just like your house." She said, looking over at Karli and Sam, "You think it was the demon both times, you think it went after Gallagher's family."
"Yeah, we think so." Sam spoke up.
"Sam." Dean said.
"Go on." Ellen told him.
"It's none of your business." Dean said rudely. Karli hit him in the back of the head and Ellen shot him a look.
"You mind your tongue with me boy." Ellen told him, "This isn't just your war, this is war. There's something coming big and fast and their side holds all the cards. Now at best all we got is us. Together." Karli looked between Dean and Ellen, who never broke eye contact, "No secrets or half truths." Dean looked away first and sighed.
"There are people out there." Sam started, "Like Andy Gallagher. Like Karli. Like me. And we all have some kind of ability."
"Ability?" Ellen asked.
"Psychic abilities. Me, I have visions. Premonitions." Karli looked over at Dean who was looking down the whole time. Karli grabbed his hand and gave him a small smile. "It's different for everybody." Sam told her.
"What about you?" Ellen asked, turning to Karli.
"None of your…" Dean started.
"It's kind of like Sam. When I'm asleep, I see stuff. Kind of like premonitions, but not as strong as Sammy. And I can feel when something bad is near." Karli told her, cutting Dean off.
"The demon said he had plans for people like us." Sam told her.
"What kind of plans?" Ellen asked.
"We really don't know for sure." Karli told her.
"These people out there, these psychics, They dangerous?" Ellen asked.
"No." Dean spoke up, "Not all of them."
"But some are." Sam told her, "Some are very dangerous."
"How many are we lookin at?" Ellen asked them.
"We've been able to track a clear pattern so far." Dean started, "They all had house fires on the night of the six month birthday."
"That's not true." Sam spoke. Karli and Dean both looked at him confused.
"What?" They asked at the same time.
"Webber, or Anson Williams, or whatever his name is, I looked at his files and there was no house fire." Sam explained, "There's nothing out of the ordinary."
"Which breaks the pattern." Ellen said. "So if there are any others like him, they wouldn't be in the system." Jo came back up with the beer and tried to listen to the conversation. "No way to track them all down."
"And so who knows how many of them are really out there." Dean said, looking over at Karli and then down at the bar.
"There could be thousands more than we expect." Karli said.
"Jo honey." Ellen called over her shoulder.
"Yeah mom." Jo answered.
"You better break out the whiskey instead." Dean was still looking down at the bar and Karli leaned her head on his shoulder. 'This so can't be good.'
