Ok. So it seems that some people have skipped over a part of the story and it's caused some confusion. In Chapter 34…..this was written.
"Hello Rumple." Cora greeted with a small smile. Right beside her Queen Cora looked worriedly at him.
It was the first time in a long time Rumpelstiltskin felt fear.
Two Cora's...could ruin all of his plans.
"Well well well...I must say this isn't a pleasure to see you again. Especially since I'm seeing double." Rumpelstiltskin tried to keep his cool and calm exterior from showing how edgy he was.
"We need a few answers from you...as I'm sure you can understand we're both a bit confused with what's going on." Queen Cora said without preamble.
Trying to keep his cool he smirked, "And what makes you so sure that I know exactly what's going on?"
Cora's smiling face turned cold as she responded. "Because I just had to tell David that he was my son."
Rumplestiltskin lowered his head as he couldn't stifle the laugh.
Both Cora's looked at each other before looking back at him.
"What's so funny?" Queen Cora asked with a glare.
"That you would need to do something as foolish as that. I know it's not true." Rumpelstiltskin responded.
"I did give birth to him." Cora responded on the verge of anger.
"That may be...but we...three...know that he's not really yours." Rumpelstiltskin said with an evil smirk.
To Spell Things Out:
In this story David and James' biological mother is also a huge twist. Cora gave birth to David and James' but she's not their biological mother. She was unable to give birth after Regina…and found a way to 'get' Rumplestiltskin to "procure" a child for her. But Regina and Emma think that David and James are biologically Regina's siblings. That's why Emma agreed not to tell her mother, and why Regina never wants Snow to find out.
PLEASE ALLOW ME TIME TO REVEAL WHO HIS REAL MOTHER IS!
When I do, I don't thing anyone will see it coming!