Unforgettable Love
by WorkingGirl22
Summary
Brittany Pierce and Santana Lopez were finally a couple and not afraid to be open at McKinley High. Everybody knew they had something going on with them and didn't care because they knew that Santana would kick their asses for messing with her girlfriend.
But what happens when Brittany's old childhood best friend/first ever girlfriend, Rachel Berry moves back to Lima after being in California for so long, shows up Brittany's and her Senior year all grown up and not the same girl she was when she was younger,sparking up feelings that Brittany struggled to long forget while also putting a strain on her relationship with Santana Lopez?
Will Brittany and Rachel start their friendship over as just best friends or will they finally admit that they still want each other? Find out what happens.
Season 4 Rachel Berry clothes and hair style in this story. Minor Brittana relationship but Brittberry romance in the end and Quinn and Raevyn romance on the side. I'm making Dani part of this story. She'll be a Senior like the rest of them and apart of the cheerios.
Enjoy.
"Rachel we know it was wrong to keep you away from Shelby but we're your dads and we didn't want you leave us for her." Rachel shook her head so angry with them.
"You had no right to keep me from my mother. I've always talked you about her when I was younger but you just changed the subject. When the rang half of the time on my birthday, it was Shelby wasn't it?" She yelled.
"Baby girl." She got up from her bed.
"No don't call my sweetheart or baby girl. It was her wasn't it?" She yelled.
"Watch your tone with us young lady. We are still your fathers and we didn't raise you to disrespect us." She huffed crossing her arms over her chest.
"Now we know what we did was wrong and hurtful to you but we thought we were doing was was best for you." She scuffed shaking her head. No they were doing what was best for them.
"They want you to spend Christmas and New Years with them in New Haven. We talked to them about having Brittany, Raevyn and Quinn join you and they were perfectly fine with that." She turned to them slowly.
"Are you saying that I think your saying?" She asked hopefully.
"Yes you can spend this Christmas and New Years with Shelby and Naomi." Rachel grins so happy.
"But remember that you belong to us. She might be your mom but we're your dads. You live here." She nodded so excited to be getting to know her birth mother. This has been her dream since she's been alive. That and Broadway of course but spending time with her birth mother was pretty close to the top.
"Do you forgive us now?" She shook her head no.
"I don't know when I'll forgive you two for doing this to her and myself. But thanks for letting me joining them." She said still mad at them.
"You leave tomorrow and they will meet you at the New Haven airport. They left already to catch their flight. So we sent Brittany and Quinn home to pack and Raevyn is packing her stuff too. You might aswell start packing too." She grins saying okay and walks into her walk in closet and grabs her suitcases with a huge smile on her face. This was exciting.
Hiram and Leroy stared at each other knowing that she wasn't going to forgive them any time soon. She was happy to be getting away from them and that hurt.
"Are we doing the right thing?" Leroy whispered to his husband.
"We really don't have a choice anymore. We broke court orders and if we keep breaking them then it's off to jail. It's for the best Leroy." They leave Rachel's room.
At The Connecticut Airport.
Shelby and Naomi stood at bagage claim waiting for Rachel, Brittany, Raevyn and Quinn. They talked to Brittany's parents and Quinn's mom about this trip and they were free to punish them if something happens and they will behave the whole time.
"Shelby calm down, they will be here." Naomi says rubbing her back.
"I hope so Naomi. Hiram and Leroy kept her away from me. I need this time with her before she goes off to college. I want to know everything about her. Her relationship with her fathers, her friends, her exs, her girlfriend, if she's still a virgin. I want to know it all." Naomi smiles.
"I know you do babe and you will when they show up." Naomi tells her before looking around and she smiles when she spots Rachel, Raevyn, Brittany and Quinn talking to each other with their carry on bags.
"There they are." Shelby glanced over at her daughter talking to her friends and her girlfriend with a huge smile on her face.
"Girls over here." They stopped talking and walked over to them. Rachel stared at Shelby for a few minutes unsure if she hug her or not.
"Come give me a hug Rachel. It's been far too long." Brittany smiles nodding her head. Raevyn and Quinn held hands watching her slowly move closer to her mom.
Shelby opened her arms and Rachel fell right into them. The mother and daughter closed their eyes holding onto each other.
Brittany smiles at her girlfriend and Shelby as they held onto each other. She couldn't wait to see how they are with each other on this trip.
Find out what happens next.