Disclaimer: don't own glee or any characters
Rachel POV
"Okay so what's the game plan?" Finn asked me as we sat on the subway
"I'm thinking that you should go in first, get a drink at the bar and then Sophia will see you. Then when I arrive she will probably freak out!" I told him
"Well I should probably be talking to a girl if you want it to be convincing" Finn said
I rolled my eyes "You can talk to whoever you want; but I mean TALK"
"A few kisses would really sell the prank though" Finn grinned
"Please tell me you're joking before I hit you" I stated
"Of course im joking babe" He started laughing at himself "I mean look at you, im not tryung to mess this up"
We walked hand in hand down the cold New York streets, it was moments like these that made all the hard ones worth it. The bright lights of the city, my unbelievably hot boyfriend and this new life of freedom was everything I needed. I got goose bumps every time I had him on my arm; even all these years later. I loved him when he was a boy; and now I feel like I get to fall in love with him all over again as he becomes a man.
"Hey" I said breaking my thoughts "I really, really like you"
"I really like you too" He smiled down at me
"Lets go pull an awesome prank!" I grinned "Okay you go in, and ill wait out here for a few minutes"
I watched Finn walk into the bar and I stood outside the building for a few minutes. After about 15 minutes I decided to call Sophia.
"Soph!" I said when she picked up "Im almost to the bar, is my date there?"
"Not yet! But mine is! Were sitting in a back booth come find us!" She said before hanging up
I walked in and found my way through the loud, dark bar. The decorating was very modern and the set up kind of confusing. You couldn't see the bar (where Finn was siting) from the back tables, so I knew she hadn't seen him.
"Hey girl!" I said approaching the table where the Blonde hair beauty was sitting next to this tall guy.
"You made it!" She stood up and examined my outfit as I did the same to hers "You look hot!"
"Thanks! Whose this?" I asked as her date stood up
"Rachel, this is Jack!" She introduced us
"Hi, Its nice to meet you!" I replied. Jack was very attractive, tall, dark hair, dark eyes. Pretty much my type. I looked over at Sophia giving her a knowing look
"I think Davis will be here soon Rachel!" Sophia assured me "In the meantime do you want a drink?"
I used this as a perfect opportunity to send her to the bar "Yeah just grab me my usual and I'll get to know Jack" I smiled
I watched her walk away from the table and towards the bar where Finn was talking to another girl. I turned to Jack and smiled.
"I like the outfit you've got going on!" He said touching my knee
The gesture kind of freaked me out, but I wanted to play it cool.
"Have you been in the city long?" I changed the subject
"Since August, im a student at pace!" He smiled back to me
"Oh my boyfriend goes to pace!" I blurted out before I had realized what I said "I mean ex-boyfriend, we broke up in November but its still kinda weird"
"That's funny because I though you looked familiar. I think I might follow your ex on instagram I remember your face from somewhere!" Jack said
"Oh yeah that's funny" I laughed awkwardly trying to save myself "I unfollowed him months ago, he started posting about a new girl and I couldn't take it"
Sophia re approached the table, her face white. "Rachel….."
"Yeah" I looked up from Jack "What's wrong?"
"Finns here" she said trying to be discreet
"Finn! That was his name! I totally follow him on instagram!" Jack said not realizing the seriousness of the situation
"No way he cant be here!" I said trying my most convincing acting "When I left the apartment and told him we were seeing a movie he said that Kurt and him were gonna go bowling or something"
"Well he's most defiantly doing the "or something" and flirting with a girl at the bar!" Sophia said pacing
"He wouldn't cheat on me, he loves me. Maybe he's just getting a drink and making conversation!" I trued to justify
"Well even so, what if he sees you on your date with Davis!" Sophia freaked out even more
"Oh my god! I forgot about Davis! What if Finn catches me cheating on him!" I began to freak out with her
"I'm so confused" Jack said "I thought you were single, why are you on a tinder date if you have a boyfriend?"
"Because I'm stupid!" I replied
"Well what are you gonna do?" Sophia looked at me
"If I go over their and yell at him for lying to me and flirting with a girl then he's gonna know I'm here on a date; which is way worse!" I complained "But I'm so mad at him, I mean last night he was telling me all this stuff about how were gonna get married in 3 years and he was gonna build me my dream home after college"
"And you still decided to go on another date tonight?" Jack rolled his eyes
"Sophia made me! Don't worry she's cheating on you too" I laughed
"RACHEL!" Sophia yelled
"Oh come on its not like he wouldn't have found out" I rolled my eyes
"I thought I heard you yell Rachel's name over here" Finn approached our table
Sophia looked at me, Jack stared into my soul and Finn hovered over the table. I wanted to bust out laughing but I knew I needed to continue.
"What are you doing here Finn?" I nervously fiddled with my hair
"I came out for a drink, what about you? Movie night got cancelled?" Finn said sternly looking at me
"Don't play dumb I saw you flirting with that girl over at the bar!" Sophia yelled at Finn
"And aren't you dating Jesse?" He laughed and then looked at Jack "Hey I know you from Pace, Man!"
"Brother I'm gonna be straight with you, these girls seem a little crazy and I think your girlfriend is cheating on you" Jack said with a serious face
"JACK!" I hit his arm
"Rachel!" Finn shouted the same time I yelled Jack
"Baby I'm sorry please don't be mad! Its all Sophia's idea" I pleaded
"I cant believe you would do this to me" He yelled
"Well you were over there flirty with a girl!" I replied standing up looking into his eyes
"Oh man Rachel I am so mad I could just….could just, rip your damn clothes off" He said fiercely taking my face into his hands and kissing me hard
"Wait what" Sophia spit out her drink
"Dude don't do it, she's damn cheating on you! No matter how hot she is" Jack added
Just then Finn and I both broke off into tears of laughter. "I cant believe you thought I would go on a date with a guy from tinder and cheat on Finn" I said to Sophia crying laughing
"What?" She said confused
"Finn knew the whole time and is playing along! I would never cheat on my baby, not when he's this hot!" I said looking up and kissing him
"Wow I feel like I just got played" Jack said also confused
"So Davis isn't coming?" She looked at me
"There is no Davis, I made it up!" I laughed "Sit down baby, have a drink with us"
"Dude I felt so bad when I recognized Rachel from your instagram" Jack laughed
"Yeah man I get it! Rachel wouldn't do that though" Finn laughed "Sophia just doesn't know her that well" he winked
"Hey I know her plenty!" She defended herself
"Sophia you thought I would seriously cheat on Finn? Come on girl" I laughed
"He's not that cute" She smiled at him
"Oh Finns perfect" I smiled into a kiss
"Dude we should totally hangout sometime!" Jack said making conversation with Finn
I turned away from him while they talked and look at Sophia. "he's cute" I whispered
"I know right! I might just take him home" she winked back
"Im defiantly taking my boy home" I looked at Finn
"He lives there" she rolled her eyes
"I know isn't that great?" I laughed back at her
"You guys are so gross together" She laughed
"I know but that's why you love us! Hey maybe you and Jack can have this Finchel kinda love"
"Maybe" She smiled at the cute boy with hopeful eyes
We stayed for a couple of drinks and had fun on the double date. Finn and I never really went on double dates with people outside of our roommates.
"Ready to head back" Finn said to me "Its midnight"
"Yeah lets head back and give them some time" I smiled "Call me tomorrow Sophia!"
"Good seeing you again Jack, text me about that party next weekend!" Finn said giving Jack a handshake
"I had a lot of fun tonight" I said as Finn and I walked back to the apartment
"Me too! But I'm ready to get home and take these clothes off" He looked at me
"Finn" I blushed "I'll have to admit I was kind of jealous when you were pretend flirting with the girl at the bar"
"I didn't say that it was pretend?" He winked at me
"Shut up" I laughed "What were you guys talking about?"
"You" He replied
"Really?" I squeezed his hand
"No" He laughed, "We were just talking about living in the city I guess"
Finn pulled out his apartment key and then opened the door, talking off his shoes and then sat on the couch. I quickly scanned the apartment to see Kurt's keys were gone. I slid off my shoes and straddled his lap.
"What are you doing?" He looked confused as I removed my top "Rachel!"
"No ones home, Kurt's gone" I fidgeted with his pant buckle
"On the couch?" He looked at me
"Yeah lets change things up" I blushed
"Say no more" He said grabbing my back and then flipping me around so I was the one against the couch.
"Oh you got moves?" I said laughing
"I can show you some more" He puckered his lips
"I dare you" I grabbed his neck and pulled him tightly to my body "Lets see who can last longer"
"I don't like that game, I always lose" he said in-between kisses
"Yeah you probably wouldn't win tonight" I said before taking charge of the situation