This is a HUGE chapter. We find out what really happened that summer and what will happen to the girls...

Spencer's POV:

2 days later Aria was released from the hospital. I had told Toby about the Jenna incident and he wasn't nearly as forgiving as Ezra was to Aria. He had gone on our honeymoon alone.

"Ready to do this Aria?" She nods as Ezra leads us into the police station.

"As ready as I will ever be." We reach the front desk and they lead us to the chief officer.

"How can I help you?" The chief looks up. "Wait what are you two doing here? I've had enough of all your drama." He gets up and starts to walk away.

"We know about Jenna." I yell to make him stay. He turns around and gestures to interrogation room 1.

It's dark and cold. Aria and I sit down and wait. I know he's on the other side. Ever since Ali died Officer Wilden has hated us. He's always been after us. All of us.

"What do you know about Jenna?" He sits down across from us.

"We know it wasn't an accident." His face changes drastically.

"You didn't…push her did you?"

"NO. We were camping, Aria and I, and we heard someone. Jenna wanted to scare us and punish us for her blindness. We ran and there was a cliff and it was slippery." I started crying so Aria picks up where I left off.

"She lunged at us and we fought until she fell. We tried to find her, but it was dark so we left and didn't disagree when it was ruled a suicide."

"How do I know you're not lying? How do I know you didn't just push her off?"

"We didn't!" We're both crying now. "Look we should have come forward and confessed we were there, but we were scared."

"It has been nearly five years since this happened. So why come forward now?" We look at each other before Aria speaks up.

"I had a vision when I was in the hospital. Ali came to me and said I deserved to be in jail for what I did. We kept the truth, but we didn't commit a crime. Jenna kept running even though she knew there was a cliff. She didn't stop running. Maybe she wanted to fall?"

"She had just gotten her sight back why would she want to die?" Aria shrugs and wipes her tears.

"Wait wasn't that the same summer Garrett went missing. And Toby was with me and their parents had left town. She must have been alone."

"Wait didn't she say something before she fell?"

FLASHBACK

"Spencer and Aria. Only two pretty little liars. Darn I wanted all of them here. I wanted to see all four of you to rot in hell and pay for what you did to me. You took my eyesight and now you've taken my boyfriend."

"We didn't do anything to Garrett!"

"I doubt that. He just left. In the middle of the night without a word." She steps closer to us.

"We didn't do anything to him!"

"I have my eyesight back. You can't run from me anymore." Aria and I look at each other. "When you're blind you're other senses kick in better. All the longings and the touches between you and Fitz were clear to me. And Toby can't hide anything from me. I could tell he was dating you from the start. I've known everything all along and now I'm finally going to be avenged. You can run, but you can't hide."

Aria and I start to run. It's wet from the rain earlier. Aria slips and falls.

"Spence!" I run back and grab her off the ground.

"I see you!" I turn around and see Jenna not far behind us. We run and run until we reach the cliff.

"ARIA!" I grab Aria before she falls over. It starts to rain and it's hard to see. I make out a figure and run away from the cliff. Jenna runs toward Aria and tackles her.

"Get the hell off me."

"You're going to pay for what you did to me." They roll around until I grab Jenna. I whack her with a branch and she grabs my leg pulling me down. Aria pushes her, but Jenna whacks her with a stick knocking her out.

"It's just you and me Spencer. You're friends can't save you." I run over to Aria to make sure she's alright. Jenna runs to me and tackles me, but I push her off. I run to the cliff and grab my branch. Jenna grabs my arm and whacks me her stick ripping my shirt. It's slippery and wet so I fall, but Jenna slides off the cliff.

"JENNA!" I run over to look over the cliff, but the rain is pouring and it's dark. "JENNA?" I start crying. I run over to Aria whose awake now.

"What happened Spence?" She looks to me and looks around for Jenna. "Where's Jenna?" I'm crying so hard, but I manage to get the words out.

"She fell." Aria grabs me and we hug. "We have to get away from here."

END OF FLASHBACK

"Why was there no evidence of you two camping there?"

"We didn't tell anyone because we didn't want to be interrupted." Officer Wilden gets up and walks out of the room.

"What do you think he's going to do to us?" Aria is still in tears. I wipe mine away. I couldn't go to jail. This was our senior year of college. Office Wilden walks back in.

"What's going to happen to us? Are we going to go to jail?"

Officer Wilden doesn't answer right away. "No."

"Wait we're not going to go to jail?"

"No, not only do we have no proof you killed her, her case is closed and we don't want to cause more grief on her family. But we aren't letting you off the hook. Even if you didn't kill her you didn't help save her. You both must rack up 190 hours of community service and your record will stay clear of it."

Spencer and I look to each other.

"Do we have to do the community service here because I go to Harvard?"
"You can't leave until you complete the hours. I suggest you make the switch to Hollis University because 190 hours of community service takes a long time."

Looks like Spencer is moving back home! And Hardy will be making a special appearance for Ezria's wedding soon...Let's just say Toby and Spencer may be getting their marriage annulled...