Haven sat on the steps outside the Police Station waiting for Audrey to finish talking to Nathan about their trip to Colorado. After finding out that the Colorado Kid was James Cogan it gave them a much needed lead. What finding him would lead them to they didn't know, but it was a step in hopefully the right direction.

Haven couldn't stop herself from thinking about what happened on Halloween. She killed Matthew. Her Trouble killed Matthew. It didn't make her high but she felt something completely different...she liked it. The power that surged through her was indescribable. Haven felt unstoppable and it scared the hell out of her – it still does.

Ever since that night she hasn't had to feed off a Trouble. In fact, she's felt more normal than she has in a long time. Haven could still feel the Troubles but it was nothing like the magnetic pull to them like before. Haven felt in control and that worried her as well. If Haven got too comfortable in this state then she'd want to keep it that way. What if she took another life? Haven wouldn't be able to live with herself. Hell, she was barely keeping herself together in that aspect as it was.

Haven was pulled from her multitude of thoughts rushing through her mind when she saw Duke approach. Well, she felt him before she saw him. Duke's Trouble was very distinctive. Then again maybe it was because she knew him so well that she was able to feel him more prominently than the others.

"How you doing, Flipside?" Duke asked as he sat beside her on the steps.

"You really don't want to hear the answer to that," Haven replied as she pulled up her long gloves.

"Yeah, I do," he replied and tried to move some of Haven's hair behind her ear but she pulled away from his almost touch. "You're not going to hurt me, Haven."

"You saw what I did to Matthew," Haven retorted as she got to her feet. "Who's to say that I won't do that again."

Duke stood up and walked over to her. "Matthew forced that on you, Haven. It wasn't something you set out or wanted to do."

Haven crossed her arms and held onto the compass locket around her neck. "It didn't stop what I felt afterwards. I should be locked up, Duke. Everyone who was there knows that."

"Hey, even Tommy could see that you had no control. If that guy doesn't think you should be behind bars then on one else does." Duke has tried to reassure her ever since it happened but he couldn't seem to get her to see his side of things.

When Haven said nothing, he changed the subject. "Flight to Colorado is in a couple hours. You and Audrey almost ready."

Haven was grateful for the subject change. "She's inside talking to Nathan and...Wait, how do you know when our flight is? Are you giving us a ride?"

Duke wasn't expecting to hear any of that come out of her mouth. "Audrey didn't tell you?" Haven's face made it pretty clear that she had no idea what he was talking about, so he explained, "I'm coming with you – all the way to Colorado." Duke made a 'taking off' hand motion to emphasize his words.

Haven didn't like this idea one bit. "Duke, no. You can't come with us. You're going to be the only Trouble person around and what if I can't control myself and –..." Her words grew faster and more frantic with each passing syllable.

Duke put his hands on Haven's shoulders to center her. "Breathe, Flipside. It's going to be fine."

Haven looked into Duke's eyes. "You don't know that."

Duke had complete faith in Haven – even if she didn't have it in herself. "Yeah, I do."

Haven gently placed her gloved hand on the side of Duke's face and was just about to say those three little words that haven't been said and yet shared between them, but Audrey approached before she had the chance to.

"I take it Duke told you he's coming along," Audrey stated then cleared her throat.

Haven took her hand away and crossed her arms. "A little head's up would have been nice."

Duke grinned and opened the passenger door to his vehicle for her. "Now where's the fun in that?"

Haven was grateful that the flight to Colorado was a quick one. At least that's what it felt like. She was also grateful that Duke didn't push her to talk during that time. Haven just needed to be and having him there, well it was appreciated and much needed. Alas, that didn't stop her from worrying about what she could possibly do when she'd inevitably 'snap' and need to feed again.

Once the plane landed, they got the rental car and headed to June Cogan's house. Nothing was really said between any of them until they parked and stood outside the residence. "This is weird," Haven voiced aloud. She remembered it being mentioned that she loved the Colorado Kid too, though not as much as Audrey. That hadn't really sunk in with her until now.

"Tell me about it," Audrey replied, nervously. She was thinking just about the same thing as her sister was.

Duke realized that neither Parker was following him towards the door so he stopped and went back over to them. "What's going on? Why are you so nervous?"

Audrey was the one who put it into words. "We've been what, at least three different people in our, and one of them was in love with the Colorado Kid. Me more than Haven, apparently, and he could be on the other side of that door and all I can think about is, I should worn my other pants."

Duke knew about Haven's apparent past feelings for the Colorado Kid – which was partly why he came along – but seeing Haven's amused face because of what Audrey had said seemed to wipe any worry he had away. Because of this, he looked at Audrey and smiled, "Audrey, you are officially a girl."

"For your sake," Haven chimed in with a bit of a grin, "let's hope he doesn't have a unibrow."

Audrey laughed at the two of them then continued up the walk towards to house. After knocking a couple times, a middle-aged man answered the door, but said nothing. Audrey took the lead in speaking. "Hi, we're looking for the owner of this boarding house – June Cogan."

The guy looked at the trio and asked, "Who's 'we'?"

Duke pointed at Haven and Audrey as they showed off their police badges then gave a thumbs up.

The guy looked at the badges and couldn't help commenting, "You're a long way from Haven, Maine."

As Haven slipped her badge back into her pocket, she said, "June Cogan has a son named James Cogan, where are they?"

The guy shrugged. "Don't know. Never heard of them. I just pay my rent. Well, good day, officers." Leaving it at that, the guy went back inside and closed the door behind him.

Haven was about to point out how weird that was but gasped when she saw a wooding carving hanging on the porch post.

Duke heard this and instantly asked, "What?" When a gaped mouth Haven pointed to the post, he and Audrey both turned to look and both saw the carving of the Guard symbol. "What the hell is that death omen doing in Colorado?"

"I knew that guy was sketchy," Haven said just before knocking on the door. When the guy answered, Duke pulled him from the doorway and pinned him against the outside wall. Haven pulled up her gloves as she said, "How about we have an honest little chat about why that's hanging at your front door." She pointed to the symbol so he'd know what she was talking about.

"Calm down you two," Audrey said to them as she guided Duke away from the guy. Once Duke backed off, she said, "My name is Audrey Parker, and this is my sister Haven Parker. We know that symbol means you work for the Guard."

The guy knew there was no reason to lie now, so he nodded. "I put that up for folks who are special. So they know this is a safe house. They can rest here."

"Where are the Cogans, really?" Duke asked and Haven added in, "James Cogan, specifically."

The guy didn't know. "I don't know anything about a James Cogan. Paul Cogan, he died. Months ago. He was old. We moved June to a home."

Haven stepped forward and sweetly yet slightly menacing tone, "How about you give us the rest of that information and we'll be on our way."

"She has scary sweet voice on, dude," Duke said to the guy and leaned closer as he added in a quieter tone, "I'd listen to her."

Audrey just rolled her eyes a bit at this display. "Always so dramatic."

When the trio arrived at the Geriatric Home, Haven looked up at the place with crossed arms. "Aside from asking her where James is...does anyone have an idea of what to expect?"

"Why?" Audrey asked, moving next to her sister. "Do you feel something? Is it a Trouble?"

"No, the only Trouble I feel is Duke's, which is pretty powerful now without all the others around." Haven adjusted her gloves as she continued speaking. "It's the same...goosebumps feeling I've had since we decided to come here."

"Maybe a past Trouble is kicking in giving you ESP." Duke was joking lightly in an attempt to make her smile, but Haven took it seriously.

"Hmm, maybe," she replied and headed inside with the others.

After going inside, they found Mrs Cogan's room. June was sitting in her chair by the window focused on the knitting in her hands. Audrey took the lead saying, "Mrs Cogan? We're friends of you son, James."

"James is such a good boy," June replied with a smile as she knitted. "He drew a picture for me in school today.

When Duke heard that, he was trying to find an explanation that didn't mean she was senile. "Maybe James is an art teacher at an elementary school."

June scoffed, "Don't be silly. James is only nine years old. Little boys can't be teachers."

Haven looked at Duke and responded to what he said before, "Or not."

Audrey sat on the sofa across from June and Haven followed suit. "Mrs Cogan," Audrey said to her, "We have a lot of important questions to ask you. Could you please look at us?"

June put down her knitting and looked at the woman across from them. She took their hands and gasped. "Haven, Sarah, why did you change your hair? Haven, your raven locks were stunning. And Sarah, you were so pretty as a redhead." Suddenly terror filled her as she pulled back. "You said you'd never come back! You both swore you'd never come back!"

At that moment, a nurse came in. "Who are you? This is a private facility. No unauthorized visitors. This woman has Alzheimer's."

Duke tried to get the nurse to give them a little while longer. While Haven said to June, "Please, we just need to ask you a few more questions. Where is James? How do you know us?"

"I don't know you," June cried. "Why are you in my room?"

The nurse had enough of this. "That's it, I'm getting security."

Duke went over to the sisters as the nurse left. "Parkers, I think this lady's gone."

Audrey couldn't accept that. "No, she can't be."

Haven didn't want to accept that either, but it's not like they had much of a choice. "We'll come back, Audrey. She might be better then."

"If not," Duke added, "we'll find another way."

Haven smiled in a 'yeah' way to her sister, but that was just for Audrey's benefit. Honestly, Haven wasn't sure if they would.

There was nothing much else they could do after hitting that dead end, so they went to an Inn to get a room. Audrey and Haven both agreed that they'd need a few more days in Colorado.

Haven was sitting on the sofa while Audrey was filling in Nathan and Duke was going to check and see if there were any other rooms available. This 'room' was more like a small apartment than anything else. It had a little living room and two small bedrooms attached to it with a bathroom. It was tiny, but calling it just a room at an inn would be an understatement.

Haven was still worried that she'd crack and end up feeding from Duke or worse, so she thought it'd be better if he got a room of his own. She was flipping through a magazine when Duke came in. "Any luck?"

Duke out a deep exhale. "Uh, no. There's a lumberjack tournament in town and no, I'm not making that up. That's an actual thing here."

Haven set the magazine down as she said, "It's okay. I'll see if there's enough room with Audrey and you can take my room."

When Haven got up to make those arrangements, he stopped her saying, "We could always share the room." Duke grinned then saw the serious look on her face so he changed his tune a little bit. "I'm good with the couch." He knew how worried she was about hurting him but he wasn't concerned. Duke just knew that she wouldn't hurt him.

Haven was grateful for Audrey's interruption at that moment. "How's Nathan?"

"Fine," Audrey replied, "there's a Trouble thing going on with blackmail but he and Tommy can handle it." She didn't have all the details on that adventure, so she sat on the couch and got to the matter at hand. "So, I was Sarah in the fifties, Lucy in the eighties, and you're Haven every time."

Haven picked up from there saying, "When you were Lucy you were in love with the Colorado Kid, where I as Haley apparently loved him. And as Sarah and that Haven, we...what? Helped relocate Troubled people?"

Audrey was having a hard time wrapping her head around all this and something else, "But why did June think we were Sarah and that Haven instead of Lucy and Haley?"

Duke sat in the chair and gave his own input. "Maybe Sarah, that Haven, and Old Lady Cogan knew each other from way back."

Audrey sighed. "Yeah, well, there's only one person who can help with that and that's June Cogan."

"And her memory is about as cooperative as ours is," Haven replied as she gestured between herself and Audrey.

Duke took that moment to show then what he picked up from June's room. "Her memories, maybe. But not her mementos." He pulled out a little photo album from his back pocket and handed it over to the Parkers. "Uh...I lifted this off June Cogan's night table."

Audrey couldn't believe he did that. "You stole a photo album from an old woman?"

Duke chuckled a bit. "It sounds much worse when you say it like that. You can scold me later."

"Nonsense," Haven said with a smile as she took it from him, "you're the sweetest thief ever." She sat on the sofa in the middle of Duke and Audrey then opened up the album. "Baby photos...school pictures..."

Duke looked at the Parkers and asked, "Any of this ringing a bell for either of you? I mean, does he seem familiar?"

Haven paused at a picture of James Cogan as an adult and handed it over to Audrey. "I got nothing."

Audrey took the album and looked at it for herself. "I know that I loved him, but I just – I don't – I don't know."

"Didn't see any Lucy or Sarah in there." Duke thought if either one of them were prominent in James' life then they'd probably be in the album.

Audrey was about to flip the page but something caught Haven's eye. "Wait, what's that picture from?" She took the album back so she could show Duke what she saw – James Cogan in a wedding picture.

Duke looked at it and scoffed in a 'wow' sort of way. "The Colorado Kid got married. Is there a date?"

Haven took the picture out and turned it around to see. "1983. And the wife's name is Arla."

Audrey was trying to make sense of all of this. "So if the Colorado Kid got married then where does Lucy fit in, or Sarah, or the Havens for that matter?"

"Why don't we focus on one past life set at a time," Duke suggested. The fact that they were starting to get confusing was just the tip of his suggestion.

Haven looked at the picture in her hand as she said, "Marriages have records, right? We should see what we can find out about Arla Cogan." She looked at her sister and smiled a bit impishly. "Don't worry, sis. Maybe you weren't the 'other woman'."

Audrey playfully shoved her sister for saying that then got up to get a drink with a sigh.

Haven asked to stay back while Duke and Audrey went to get the records about Arla Cogan. It wasn't that she didn't want to be a part of it, it was just that she wanted some time alone. She didn't want Duke or Audrey to see what she was experimenting.

Haven sat cross-legged on her bed in the motel and held her hand up in front of her. She still felt at 'full power' and wanted to find out what else she was capable of thanks to the Troubles she's fed from in the past. A little while ago she fed off a Trouble from someone who could move things with their mind. Haven thought that'd be the safest one to try.

After focusing on the Trouble she wanted, hand started to glow with a red aura. She could feel it starting to 'tap into her reserves' but she didn't stop. Haven had to know if she could do it. She held up her hand in an attempt to move the lamp but when she heard Audrey's key in the door her attention turned there and the aura glowed even more as the door flew open.

Haven gasped and quickly hid her hand behind her. She didn't realize how long they'd been gone.

Audrey stood at the open door with a 'wtf' expression on her face. "Haven?" she called out, hoping everything was alright.

"In here," Haven replied as she moved off her bed and went into the little living room. "Everything go okay?"

"Things didn't get weird until we got back," Duke replied as he closed the door behind them. "Either this place is haunted or you managed to tap into in absorbed Trouble."

Haven neither confirmed or denied this and took the file from Audrey saying "We don't have time to figure out what I may or may not have done. Let's do this."

Duke and Audrey shared a look with each other but neither of them said a word about it and just followed Haven into her room so they could go over their findings.

After going through the papers for a little bit, Audrey found a pretty important one. "Arla Cogan killed herself after the Colorado kid went missing. So there wasn't a big love affair between him and Lucy." She sighed and put the papers aside. "This whole thing is ridiculous. When we first showed up in Haven, I was an FBI agent looking into a case with my tag along sister to make sure she didn't get into any trouble."

"No pun intended," Haven interjected with a grin before taking a sip of her soda.

Audrey just gave her a 'seriously' look before saying, "My point is, we knew who we were. Life was good. It was. And then what, we find out that we not only have one but two past lives."

"That we know of," Haven added in because who knew how far their lives went back.

"Nothing is what we thought it was," Audrey sighed, looking to her sister. "The past lives we were so wrong about, and the other ones are still a mystery. What are we doing, Haven? We find out about the Hunter Meteor Storm and that we only have a month before we disappear and we do what? Chase around a mystery that we may never solve."

"I think your sister's screws are getting loose," Duke said to Haven softly because Audrey seriously seemed to be on the verge of a little breakdown.

Haven didn't say anything to that and got up to go over to her sister. "Audrey, we solved the Colorado Kid mystery. And we'll solve anything else that comes our way – including the Hunter."

Audrey moved some hair out of Haven's face with a soft smile. "I never should have pulled you into any of this. You deserve to live your life the way you want to." With another sigh she pointed out the door saying, "I'm going to bed. Goodnight."

"Night, sis," Haven replied then ran a hand through her hair before gathering up the papers. Finally she said to Duke, "I lied to her."

"About what?" Duke asked as he helped her with the papers.

"When I told her we'd figure out the Hunter – I lied," Haven tossed the file on the chair in the corner before sitting on the edge of the bed. "Whether we like it or not we're going away in, what, twenty days? Audrey's right, I should live my life."

Duke could easily understand this. He softly asked her, "How do you want to do that?"

Haven looked at him with pure love in her eyes. "I want to live it with you but I have no idea how to do it, Duke. If I touch you I could kill you and I would die if I ever hurt you."

"You won't." Duke tried to reach out and assure her, but she moved out of his reach.

"Did you not see what I did to Matthew? And I didn't even mean to!" Haven crossed her arms and took in a trembling breath. "You should go, now."

Duke wasn't going to let her push him away that easily. He stood up and walked right over to her. "You won't hurt me, Flipside. You have to believe that." Duke couldn't explain how he knew but he did.

Before she could put up a fight about it, he cupped her face and kissed her deeply.

Haven's first instinct was to push him away but she didn't feel her Trouble kicking in so she allowed herself to fall into the kiss.

When their lips parted Duke smiled at her. "See?"

"Shut up," Haven replied and pulled him in for another kiss. She had no idea how long they'd have like this so she wasn't going to waste a minute of it.

Duke scooped Haven up in his arms and carried her over to the bed. After laying her back he pulled off her gloves and laced with fingers with hers as he moved over her.

They hadn't been able to be intimate like this for a long time so they were going to savor every minute of it...And they did.

The next morning, Haven woke up in Duke's arms. "I missed this," she said softly as she moved closer to him.

Duke smiled and kissed her softly before tracing the tattoo on her chest. "I don't remember this."

Haven placed her hand over his that was on the tattoo. "I got it soon after I found out I couldn't touch anyone. Good thing the artist wore gloves because they were indeed Troubled."

Duke kissed her hand and looked at the tattoo again. It was of a compass that looked exactly like the one on the locket he'd given Haven, with the words 'Never Forget' encircling it. "It suits you."

Haven gave him one last kiss before getting out of bed to get dressed. Deciding to be cautious, she said, "We shouldn't risk this again, Duke. Not until we figure out why my Trouble didn't work with you. Especially since we know I've taken from you before."

Duke had a completely different idea. "How about we not look a gift horse in the mouth and enjoy it?" Going on with his idea, he took her hand and pulled her back into bed with him.

Haven laughed when did this and moved some hair behind her ear before kissing him deeply. "What if I hurt you next time?" she whispered.

"If your Trouble was going to hurt me then it would have already." Duke wished he knew how he was so sure her Trouble wasn't going to hurt him anymore, but he had no idea. Perhaps it was a subconscious thing.

Neither of them knew that it was because of Matthew's sacrifice that her Trouble wouldn't work on Duke. Matthew loved Haven, truly did, and because of that act of love her Trouble would never activate on those she loved. And Duke was absolutely one of those people.

Haven wished she was as sure as he was but perhaps he was sure enough for the both of them.

Haven went outside to meet her sister with two cups of coffee in her hands. "Here," she offered then leaned against the car next to her.

Audrey took a sip before awkwardly, yet casually asking "So...how many times did you have to injure yourself last night?"

Haven stopped mid-sip and didn't move the cup away from her mouth as she turned to look at her sister in question.

"You guys weren't exactly quiet," Audrey replied, trying her best not to cringe or shudder because the last thing she ever wanted to think about was her little sister having sex.

"Oh my god!" Haven exclaimed, feeling humiliated enough for the both of them. "I – uh – nope, I have no segue."

Audrey laughed and drank some more of her coffee. "But seriously though, you're not high or going through withdrawal so are you okay?"

"My Trouble didn't kick in," Haven explained and upon seeing Audrey's 'whoa, seriously' face, she said, "I know, right. Your face right now was my mental expression when I realized it. Somehow Duke just knew I wasn't going to take any Trouble from him and while neither of us know how, he was right."

"You think it's temporary? I just want you to be careful here." Audrey didn't want Haven getting too attached to this discovery in case it didn't last.

Haven looked down at her cup of coffee with a sigh. "I don't know, Audrey. But what I do know is last night I was able to actually touch the man I love. If it's temporary, so be it, because I will always be grateful for the time I had." She sipped her beverage and gave Audrey a suggesting look. "Maybe you should take this as inspiration to go after someone you'll be grateful for."

"Whose being taken for granted?" Duke asked as he joined the Parkers, thinking that was what he had heard.

"Grateful," Haven laughed, "Not granted."

Duke 'finger-pointed snapped' her way then said, "I confirmed our flight back to Maine."

"It's beautiful here," Audrey thought aloud with a sigh as she leaned back against the car next to Haven.

"Hey," Haven jokingly suggested, "maybe that's why Lucy and Sarah came here."

Audrey was picking up where her sister was going with this joke. "But of course," and the Parkers each waved a hand out in front of them as if they were presenting something and said "The scenery," in unison.

Duke shook his head as he looked at them then started imagining something in his mind.

"What?" Audrey asked because it looked like he was studying them. "Why are you looking at us like that?"

"I'm just imagining you as a red-head and Haven with black hair. I have to admit, Haven, you look pretty hot." Duke smiled at his Flipside.

After the Parkers got a chuckle out of that, they looked at each other when the same idea came to their mind. Turning back to Duke, Audrey said, "Duke, you're a genius."

"I know," he answered with pride then realized he didn't know why she said that. "Uh – why?"

Duke's question was answered during a trip to a thrift store then a costume shop for a couple of wigs. Haven and Audrey were going to pose themselves as Sarah and Sarah's Haven to see if that would jog June Cogan's memory.

"You ready for this?" Haven asked as she adjusted the black wig on her head. "Because honestly, I feel a bit like Morticia Addams and not in a good way."

Audrey just chuckled, mainly because she didn't know what Haven meant by that, and took a breath to compose herself. "Let's go," she said softly then they walked into June's room together. "June, we're here."

June looked over and gasped when she saw them. "Sarah, Haven! You said you'd never come back!" She sounded as if she was on the verge of tears. June stood up from her bed and pleaded, "Oh, give me another chance, please!"

The sisters went over to her and Audrey took June's hands as she assured. "Don't be scared, okay? We're not angry."

June looked right at the sisters. "The day you girls brought him was like a miracle. We're a family now."

Haven was hoping they'd get some answers so she kinda baited, "We helped you, didn't we?"

June looked at Haven and nodded with a smile. "We named him James," she then turned to who she believed was Sarah, "Do you like that name?"

Audrey nodded slowly. "James. Did we – did we bring you your son from the town Haven?"

June looked at Haven and pleaded, "Oh please, please don't take him away. We've kept him safe, I swear."

"Was James Troubled?" Audrey asked, "Is that why you had to keep him safe?"

June looked from Haven to Audrey, saying, "I already love him so much. I know it must have hurt to give him up, Sarah, but I can take care of him. I can protect your baby."

Haven gasped a little bit when she heard this. "James – James Cogan he's – he's Sarah's son?" Looking away from June and right at Audrey she said, "He's your son?"

Audrey was just as shocked to hear this, if not more.

When they arrived back to Haven, Maine, the first thing they hit on the way into town one a pot-hole. One that just had to pop one of Duke's tires. While he was changing it, Haven went over to her sister. "We going to talk about what June said?"

"You mean how the Colorado Kid is my son and you helped me give him away? Nope, not really." Audrey replied with a sigh.

"You make it sound like I shipped him away without your knowledge," Haven retorted with crossed arms.

Audrey looked at her sister apologetically. "I didn't mean that. It's just a lot to take in."

"I can't even imagine." Haven leaned against Duke's vehicle as she said, "Too bad we couldn't get more info out of her."

"I doubt she'd remember where the Colorado Kid is anyway." Audrey was just trying to focus on the information they did have and not what they might have had.

"How do you feel, sis? I mean, knowing that you have a son." If Haven was in Audrey's shoes, she'd probably be losing it.

Audrey stammered out her reply. "I – I don't even know how to really process that information yet."

"It'll be our secret," Haven said with a smile then called out to Duke, "Right?"

"I know nothing!" Duke called back as he finished putting on the tire. His way of telling them that he would keep Audrey's secret.

Audrey heard her cell ring and saw it was Nathan. "I should take this."

Haven gave her a thumbs up as she walked away.

At this time, Duke went over to Haven and asked, "How are you doing?"

"That's kind of a loaded question," she replied with a half chuckle as she adjusted her gloves.

Duke reached out to touch her face but she recoiled a little. "It's okay," he said softly then gently moved some hair out of her eyes, his fingers lightly brushing her skin.

"I shouldn't let myself get used to this," she sighed after his gentle touch felt like it sent electricity through her.

Their moment was broken when Audrey came over and said, "Nathan needs our help with the Troubled girl."

"What kind of Trouble are we looking at?" Haven asked as they started getting into the car.

Audrey looked at her in a 'you're not going to believe this way' and said, "She can bring people back from the dead."

"What is going on?" Haven thought aloud as they pulled up to the cabin because Tommy was outside shooting at something. She was the first to get out of the car when they stopped. "Tommy, what's going on?" she called out then saw what he gestured to. "Oh god, Audrey," she said to her sister then Audrey too saw what she did.

"Nathan!" Audrey called out and ran over to him. Nathan was dead on the ground with two bullet wounds in his chest and torso. "No, no, no!" she repeated.

Haven looked at Tommy and demanded to know, "What the hell happened!" Tears were in her eyes and her tone was heated.

"It – it was the Troubled girl, Noelle," Tommy just about stammered. "She – she just started shooting and by the time I got out here..." he finished his sentence by gesturing at Nathan's body.

A big part of Haven didn't believe his story but she didn't say anything about that yet and went over to her sister. Haven and Duke shared a bit of a look because it seemed that he didn't buy his story either. But if what Tommy said wasn't the truth then one question remained...what the hell happened?

End Season 3 Episode 7