With True Love Anything Can Happen

By CollegeStar20

Summary

17 year old Santana Lopez was in a relationship with her best friend Brittany Pierce since they were in middle until Brittany cheated on her with Quinn Fabray now they are Juniors at McKinley and Santana hates that Quinn is all over Brittany but what happens when the new girls Rachel, Rossi and Arilyn Berry who are all triplets but there fraternal triplets, move to Lima Ohio from London England with there famous dad Hiram Berry who is a big time Famous Lawyer from England but travels around alot while their daddy Leroy Berry is a famous Fashion Designer and everybody knows there names in the world.

Santana asks Rachel Berry to fake date her to make Brittany jealous even if she's with Quinn but what happens when San figures out that she's in love with Rachel, will she let Rachel know about her feelings or will it show that Brittany wants her. Find out what happens.

Oh you all know that Rachel and Santana are in a fake relationship so I'm not going to keep saying fake girlfriend anymore every time. They are still bests. Oh Rachel, Rossi, Arilyn and there dads can speak Spanish, French, Germin, Hebrew, and a little bit of Japanese, Oh Hiram is half French, Germin and Black while Leroy is half Spanish,Japanese and white so the girls are all mixed race. Santana can speak Spanish and a little bit of French.

In Shelby's POV.

I was out at with my good friends Tracie and Nina enjoying my friday night after a long work day at Carmel. I did set up a time with Hiram and Leroy to get to my daughters for the first time and they said that they would call me back when they came back. Were at this karaoke Bar in Lima. Were enjoying our time talking about work and what are the plans for the weekend when I noticed that some girl is getting onto the stage and both Tracie and Nina gasp staring at her and I see that the girl was my oldest daughter Rachel BErry.

"Oh my god that girl is so pretty and she looks like you Shelby, I bet she has your singing voice." Nina says making me stare at Rachel wondering what she was doing her alone and I look around wondering if her girlfriend or her friends are here but I don't see them anywhere so I look back at the stage. Noticing what she's wearing. Rachel's wearing a red ruffle mini skirt with a black top with a gray blazer over it and black high heeled boots. Her dark locks are in curls and she has a headband on. Her bangs are in face a little.

"Alright guys I'm going to sing a song that my girlfriend dared me to sing and I don't like her right now but here it goes." I heard Rachel say into the mic and I wonder what song it is then it starts and I chuckle because I don't blame her for not liking her friends right now.

Oh baby, baby, Oh baby, baby

Oh baby, baby How was I supposed to know That somethin' wasn't right? yeah
Oh baby, baby I shouldn't have let you go And now you're outta sight, yeah.

I froze hearing her voice and I felt Tracie's and Nina's eyes on me as I stared at my daughter.

Show me how you want it to be Tell me baby 'cause I need to know now Oh because
My loneliness is killin' me and I, I must confess I still believe, still believe, When I'm not with you I lose my mind Give me a sign, hit me baby one more time.

I see some girl staring at Rachel with a lustful sparkle in her eyes like she wants to take my baby girl home and have sex with her all night and I frown slightly before looking right at Rachel.

Oh baby, baby The reason I breathe is you Yeah, boy you've got me blinded
Oh pretty baby There's nothing that I wouldn't do It's not the way I planned it.

She says her hips smirking at her friends while singing and I can't believe I'm hearing Rachel's broadway's voice for the first time.

Show me how you want it to be Tell me baby 'cause I need to know now Oh because
My loneliness is killin' me, And I, I must confess I still believe When I'm not with you I lose my mind Give me a sign, hit me baby one more time.

Rachel smirks at the crowd swaying her hips as she sings and looks over my way for the first time tonight and her eyes widen when they meet mine.

Oh baby baby, yeah hey, oh baby baby yeah hey yeah.

She stares at me shocked and I nod giving her a hint to finish up the song.

Oh baby, baby How was I supposed to know, Oh pretty baby I shouldn't have let you go..

She keeps looking at me as she sings and I clap with the crowd and I smile at her so proud of her.

I must confess that my lonliness is killing me now Don't you know I still believe? That you will be here and give me a sign Hit me baby one more time.

She gets into it finally looking away from me as she finishes up the song.

My loneliness is killin' me,And I, I must confess I still believe When I'm not with you I lose my mind Give me a sign, hit me baby one more time
My loneliness is killin' me,And I, I must confess I still believe When I'm not with you I lose my mind Give me a sign, hit me baby one more time.

Everybody cheers and claps for her as she sings and she's asked to sing another one but she gets off and I get up saying that I need to do this and take the mic saying my name and the music starts.

Rachel/Shelby/Both.

The music starts and I look at the group and Rachel turns around staring at me shocked.

I dreamed a dream in days gone by When hope was high and life worth living I dreamed that love would never die I dreamed that God would be forgiving.

I glance at Tracie and Nina and they smile at me brightly pointing to Rachel who has a mic in her hand walking closer to me and she gets back on the stage and sings looking right at me.

Then I was young and unafraid And dreams were made and used and wasted There was no ransom to be paid No song unsung no wine untasted

I stare at her wanting to hug her so badly but I couldn't because she looked so scared of me.

But the tigers come at night

But the tigers come at night.

With their voices soft as thunder As they tear your hope apart

As they tear your hope apart.

As they turn your dream to shame

Rachel looks at me with tears in her eyes as she sings and there were tears in my eyes aswell not believing I'm getting the chance to sing with my daughter.

And still I dreamed she'll come to me That we would live the years together But there are dreams that cannot be And there are storms we cannot weather

We grab each others hand as we sing together with tears in our eyes and I can see Tracie and Nina staring at me with tears in their eyes.

I had a dream my life would be So diff'rent from this hell I'm living So diff'rent now from what it seemed Now life has killed the dream I dreamed.

Everybody stares at us not saying a word then burst out cheering so loud that I think they busted my eardrum. Rachel looks at me unsure what to say and gets off the stage.

"Rachel please wait so we can talk." I get off the stage and follow her and she runs outside and I grab her hand to stop making her sob.

"Let me go, it's bad enough that my dads lied to me and my sisters but then you come back here after you gave us up for adoption like we meant nothing you." She begged and I let go sadly.

"Rachel Barbra Berry please listen to me when I say that I never wanted to give you and your sisters up, I loved you and still do, please give me a chance." I said sadly.

She stares at me with more tears in her perfect brown eyes shaking her head and I just want to hold her.

"Did you ever think to fight for us, we needed our mom and you just stayed away until now, why the fuck now?" I never thought she would swear.

"Can you please not talk like that in front of me, I'm still your mother." I said sternly but she just scuffs looking away then she wipes her tears and looks at me.

"Are you trying to take us from our dads?" I shook my head no.

"No Rachel I would never try to take you away from your dads I gave you to them for a reason so you could have a better life! Sweetie I just want to get to know you." She wipes her tears.

"Get away from her Shelby, Baby are you alright?" The familiar voiced asked making me turn around to see a very angry Santana Lopez staring at me holding onto a coat before walking past me to check and see if Rachel is alright.

"Look Rachel please understand that I really do want to get to know you and your sisters, I know me coming into your lives isn't easy but I really want to get to know you, even you Santana I know your dating Rachel and I'm not telling you to stay away from her because I want to get to know the girl that has her heart." She nods.

"Good because even if you did Shelby, we wouldn't have listened to you because I love Rachel very much." Rachel sighs looking at me sadly then Santana pulled her face to hers to peck my daughters lips.

I saw the tears falling down Rachel's face as she kissed Santana and I knew she wasn't into kissing her girlfriend at the moment. Santana pulls back glaring at me with her arms wrapped around Rachel's waist.

"Why couldn't you just leave my baby and her family alone, they were doing fine until you showed up, come on Rach we could join the others." Santana said annoyed.

"Sanny please just take me home, I can't be here any longer." She nods slipping her arm around her waist. "Please call me if you want to get to know me." Rachel looks at me with sadness in her eyes.

"Can I think about it first before agreeing to this?" Rachel asked still in Santana's arms. I sigh hating that their dads told them that I died.

"Sure whatever you want, just give me a call, your dads have my number, hope you girls have a good night." They both nod as I turn around sadly walking back in glancing back at them to see Rachel crying in Santana's arms and Santana comforting her as they walk down the street to their car.

Santana Lopez held her girlfriend in her arms as they layed in on Santana's bed changed out of their clothes and were wearing shorts and tank tops.

"Are you going to see her babe?" Rachel wasn't sure anymore because she didn't know how she felt getting to know her birth mom, she told Rossi and Arilyn and they were unsure aswell.

"I really don't know Sanny, I want to but I'm scared she might walk out on us." Santana nods kissing her forehead and they fall a sleep holding each other.

The Next Day.

Arilyn Berry walked into the Lima Bean to meet up with her boyfriend Finn Hudson! She walked over to him and sat down pecking her boyfriend's lips.

"Hey baby you sounded upset when I called, what's going on?" Finn asked giving her a concern look taking her hand.

"My birth mom is suddently make into mine and my sisters life and I'm not sure I'm ready to see her, her and Rachel got into a fight last night and Rachel is really upset, I hate for my sisters to be upset."

Finn grabs her hand and sighs. "Listen to me alright, you have your dads who love you very much and I have my mom, I never got the chance to get to know my dad because he died when I was a baby! Arillyn you, Rossi and Rachel have a chance to get to know your birth mom, I would give anything to get to my father but I can't! Do this for me because I know if you don't then your going to regret it."

Arilyn nods sadly and noticed somebody walking in and she stares at them with tears in her eyes. "I can't believe she's stocking me and my sisters." Arilyn whispered.

Finn turns around and saw a woman that looks just his girlfriend in some way walking over to them. "Arilyn hi." Arilyn glared at her wiping her tears and got up.

"I thought my sister made it clear that she needed some time, that same rule goes for me and Rossi Shelby, just let us think about it." She snapped before leaving.

Finn stared at Shelby awkwardly before grabbing his coat and walks past her but not before whispering"Give them sometime or your going to lose them." He moves away and leaves.

Shelby stood there knowing who that boy that knew her second oldest daughter was right but she hates waiting but if she wanted her daughters to talk to her, then she's going to wait.

Find Out what happens next and the songs were Baby One More Time from Glee and I Dream A Dream from Glee.