"Hey Ali." The girls all say as Alison walks into Spencer's house. Emily walks over to Alison and kisses her. Alison doesn't kiss her back and Emily notices. Alison's mind is stuck back to her dream with Sarah or whatever she thought it was. Emily pulls Alison aside into the kitchen, away from the girls. "Hey babe. Are you okay?" Emily asks Alison. Alison drops her head in silence. "Yeah I'm fine. Just tired." Alison replies. Emily drops her head too. "I know when you're lying Alison." Emily confesses. She cups Alison's face and lifts her face up to meet hers. "What are you hiding from me?" She asks. Alison rubs her face up against Emily's hand. "I just had a weird dream." Alison explains. "About what? I mean obviously it's on your mind." Emily questions. There is a silence for a minute before Alison speaks. "I had a dream about Sarah, only it didn't feel like a dream. I don't know I just have this urge that she is still alive." Alison admits. Emily pulls her hand back in shock. "Really? What happened in the dream? Between you and Sarah." Emily continues. Alison shrugs her shoulders. "We were talking more than anything, she said something about being at the wedding but we…" Alison couldn't say the words. If it were true that Sarah was alive than she would have cheated on Emily again. "You what?" Emily asks confused. Alison drops her head again. "We kissed. Like really kissed." Alison whispers just loud enough for Emily to hear. The embarrassment in her words are noticeable but Emily's jealousy over powered her reasoning. "Oh, okay well I guess that means that you still have feelings for her." Emily's anger and jealously rise in the words. Alison cowers back a little. "Em, I don't know how to explain it but I have this love and affection for Sarah but I will always be in love with you, you are and always will be the one for me. I'm marrying you remember." Alison tries to explain her actions but Emily turns and walks for the door interrupting Hanna's, Aria's and Spencer's conversation. Emily walks out the door and heads to her car, raindrops start to paint the drive way. The only light that emerges comes from the moon and the artificial light of the floodlights attached to the house. "Em!" Alison calls out as she runs after Emily. Spencer, Aria and Hanna follow Alison out the door and stand on the porch to watch the scene unfold between them. The rain starts to get heavier as Alison reaches Emily and pulls her arm, spinning her around to face Alison again. "Em, the kiss meant nothing and besides Sarah is dead, it was just a dream. Please! I'm sorry." Alison pleads with Emily to return back into the house. Emily looks at Alison, her eyes flashing shades of jealously, anger and hate. "I had a dream to and it was similar to yours, I saw her too and it felt real. Sarah could be alive! It wouldn't be a first time someone broke me by pretending to die. Last I checked there is still a tombstone with your name on it in Rosewood Cemetery!" Emily turns away again and leaves Alison standing in the rain. Her hair clinging to her face as she listens to Emily's door slam shut and the car ignition start. Within seconds, Emily was gone.
"Hey. So I know about the kiss and I don't know what I'm doing here but I guess I just needed to see you." Emily speaks as she kneels down in front of Sarah's tombstone. She runs her fingers over the name carved into the stone SARAH MOONEY. "I need to know. Are you really alive or are you just haunting us in our dreams? You tell me to forgive Spencer when she accused me of being A, you kiss my girlfriend and now I guess you expect me to forgive her and you." Emily continues. "You know if you are alive, the first thing I am going to do is punch you for kissing her but I know you love her too." Emily explains. "So what valuable advice do you have for me now? Go forgive her. Tell her how much I love her and I do love her with 100% of my heart but her love is split between you and me and I'm scared that I'm not going to come out on top compared to you. You are beautiful, brave, loyal and protective. All amazing qualities but why did you fall in love with my girlfriend?" Emily asks the questions swimming through her mind. Emily waits for the answers but they don't come. She sits at the grave for hours, talking with her former best friend. Emily's fingers touch the tombstone again, this time along the quote that is carved beneath the name. 'TIS A FEARFUL THING, TO LOVE WHAT DEATH CAN TOUCH.' Emily remembers back to Sarah's burial and the speech she made. "Uh hello, well Sarah was a friend, a really good friend and a hero to many of you who are here today. I know a lot of you are hurting from the tragedy that happened and it hurts thinking that someone died in this event. It hurts more for my friends and I that it was our friend. Sarah was kind and selfless but most importantly, she was brave and she stood up when others couldn't and did what no one else could. Sarah may not be here with us physically but in our hearts and our minds and our memories, she will always be here. I know because I can feel her right now. I can feel her arms around me, hugging me, telling me that it's all going to be okay and just hearing that makes everything okay. We love you Sarah, rest peacefully." Emily sighs as she gets up and rubs the grass off of her pants. She feels her phone vibrate in her pocket. She opens her phone and reads the text. 'May want to start digging a grave next to hers. – A." Emily's head spins around as she looks for someone who is watching her. There is no one to be seen. Emily carefully walks back to her car and drives home.
"So you are saying that Sarah might be alive?" Spencer asks Alison. "I don't know but it just felt so real. It could have been a dream and Sarah is really dead but I don't know." Alison replies. "So wait, Sarah as in the Sarah that ran into a burning building and was skewed. The one's whose body the firefighters found." Hanna says. "She wasn't skewed, a beam fell on her and what if it wasn't her body. I had you guys convinced I was dead for a year and nine months." Alison explains. "Either way, Emily will never forgive me." Alison continues as she drops her head. "How strong are your feelings for Sarah?" Aria asks Alison. "Strong but Emily is the one and I know that. Emily and I are in love and its epic and Sarah one told me that we a like the yin and yang, we connect perfectly but Sarah and I… we just blend and its different." Alison attempts to explain her emotions. "I feel drawn to her, as much as Emily has made me a better person, Sarah has made me a stronger person." Alison says. All the girls jump as they hear knocking at the front door.