"What is going on?" Haven thought aloud as they pulled up to the cabin because Tommy was outside shooting at something. She was the first to get out of the car when they stopped. "Tommy, what's going on?" she called out then saw what he gestured to. "Oh god, Audrey," she said to her sister then Audrey too saw what she did.

"Nathan!" Audrey called out and ran over to him. Nathan was dead on the ground with two bullet wounds in his chest and torso. "No, no, no!" she repeated.

Haven looked at Tommy and demanded to know, "What the hell happened!" Tears were in her eyes and her tone was heated.

"It – it was the Troubled girl, Noelle," Tommy just about stammered. "She – she just started shooting and by the time I got out here..." he finished his sentence by gesturing at Nathan's body.

A big part of Haven didn't believe his story but she didn't say anything about that yet and went over to her sister. Haven and Duke shared a bit of a look because it seemed that he didn't buy his story either. But if what Tommy said wasn't the truth then one question remained...what the hell happened?

Audrey pushed down her grief and looked at Tommy, desperately asking, "Where the girl who can bring people back from the dead? Where's Noelle?"

Tommy more or less stammered his reply, "She – she's the one that shot him."

Audrey didn't care, she just needed her Trouble. "Where is she, Tommy!"

Tommy waved his hand off towards the woods to direct where Noelle had gone.

Haven got to her feet and went over to him, saying, "You were shooting at her, weren't you?"

"Why would you do that?" Audrey asked then took off for the woods. "Get an APB out on her!" she shouted to Tommy as she went.

"There already is," Tommy called back as Haven and Duke joined Audrey in the chase.

"We might not need one," Haven said to Audrey as she caught up with her. "If I concentrate hard enough, I might be able to zero in on her location."

"Fine, do it," Audrey replied and didn't stop when Haven did.

"What are you doing?" Duke asked when he realized Haven stopped.

"Help Audrey," she replied, "I have an idea. Trust me."

Duke didn't like just leaving her behind but he did what she asked and went off with Audrey.

Haven was about to do her thing when Tommy appeared, "They went that way. You better hope she's still alive."

Tommy just glared at her a bit and went to catch up with the others.

Haven went back to the cabin where Noelle was hiding out, hoping that being close to her things would help her focus in on the Trouble. The last time Haven did this, it worked, but she had a direct link to said Trouble. Haven was basically going off of thin air this time.

Haven shook herself out to try and relax then sat down in the middle of the floor. "Okay, you can do this." She closed her eyes and continued to speak to herself. "Okay, Noelle, you're a paramedic. You're Troubled. You bring people back from the dead...where are you?"

She tried to concentrate on the Trouble itself and not just on Noelle. The more she concentrated the stranger she felt. It was almost like Haven was zooming through the town going through each and every Trouble present until she found the one she was looking for.

Haven gasped then her eyes opened. She couldn't see but their color was not red. As if in a trance, Haven got to her feet and walked out of the cabin. She felt tethered to the Trouble now and her entire focus was making her way to it because in that moment – in her trance-like state – Noelle's Trouble was the thing she wanted more than anything else in the world.

Haven made it all the way to the house Noelle was hiding in before anyone else got there. Her head tilted to the side as she looked around, trying to pinpoint exactly where the Trouble was coming from. She soon felt the more distinctive pull and went downstairs into the cellar.

Noelle was laying on the floor covered up in a blanket. She was just about to fall asleep when she heard footsteps. Noelle looked up and saw the red-eyed Haven walking towards her. "Who are you? What do you want?" She tried to move back but she was too weak from the blood loss.

Haven, still in the trance-like state, brought her finger to her lips and shushed her. "I want to feed," she replied then went over to Noelle and clasped her bare hands on Noelle's face.

Noelle gasped loudly as the black vein-like lines moved from her face into Haven's hands that soon turned red and disappeared before Noelle's last breath.

Haven removed her hands just before Noelle's death and she didn't even realize what she had done until it was too late. Her eyes returned to normal as she looked down at Noelle's body with shuddering breaths. "No...no!"

Just then Tommy came down the stairs and drew his gun. He looked at Noelle then to Haven, asking, "What the hell did you do?"

"I – I didn't mean to!" she exclaimed through tears. "It was an accident!"

Audrey and Duke hurried down the stairs at this point and tried to understand that scene that was unfolding before them. Audrey saw Tommy's gun drawn and cautiously asked, "Tommy, what are you doing?"

"Your sister just killed Noelle," Tommy replied, keeping his gun aimed at her.

"It was an accident, Audrey, I swear. I had no control!" Haven was falling apart with every other word.

Audrey couldn't believe this was happening but tried her best to keep herself composed. "Put the gun away, Tommy."

Tommy looked at her incredulously. "Are you kidding me right now? She just killed the girl and confessed to it!"

"Put the gun away, Tommy!" Audrey shouted as she started to lose her composure a bit. "You should know by now that not all Troubled people can control what they can do." Audrey turned to Duke and said, "Get Haven out of here, please."

Duke didn't have to be asked twice. He quickly went over to Haven and guided her out of the house.

"I didn't mean to," Haven cried as they went, "I didn't mean to."

Haven was left at the house with Noelle's boyfriend. He didn't know that she was the one responsible for Noelle's death - All he knew was that she was dead when they found her. Haven didn't know what was going on with Audrey and the others, hell she didn't even know when they left. It wasn't until Dwight showed up that she knew they'd gone.

Haven, now with gloves present, pulled Dwight to the side to quietly ask, "Do you have Jordan's number? I need it."

Dwight wasn't expecting that. "Jordan? Why?"

Haven crossed her arms and took a breath before replying, "Because she gave me the feeling that she knows about my Trouble and I need to know if that's the truth."

Dwight was starting to get a little concerned. "Haven, what happened?"

Haven made sure they were out of earshot before answering with the truth. "I somehow managed to track Noelle's Trouble, but when I was out of my fugue state or whatever it was...I found that I drained her completely of her Trouble. I killed her, Dwight."

Dwight looked at her with compassion before bringing her in for a hug. "It's not your fault, Haven."

"And yet it happened." She cried as she leaned into her friend's embrace. "I don't know what to do."

Dwight looked at her when their hug ended and said, "You keep going. You'll figure this out and you'll survive it." He didn't think this was a good idea but he held out his hand, "Give me your phone."

Haven handed it over and watched as Dwight entered a number into it.

"Tell her I gave you this number and hope she's not too pissed." Dwight handed the phone back with a little smile.

Haven gratefully accepted it and said, "Dwight, I could kiss you."

"I don't think Duke would appreciate that very much," he answered with a wry chuckle.

Haven smiled a 'thank you' before going outside to call Jordan. After a few rings she was greeted by Jordan's voice on the other end of the line asking, "Who is this?"

"Haven Parker," she answered. "Dwight gave me this number."

"I'm going to kill him," Jordan muttered.

"Please don't," Haven pleaded. "Look, I need your help with something. It's about my Trouble."

"I don't see how I can help you with that."

"You seemed to know about me when we first met," Haven shot back.

Jordan sighed. "This isn't something to be discussed over the phone. I will meet up with you on one condition: You tell me where Nathan is."

Haven ran a hand through her hair with a sigh. "You're going to want to pick me up first."

Jordan didn't understand. "Why?"

Haven used Jordan's words against her. "Because this isn't something to be discussed over the phone."

A little bit later, Jordan pulled into the driveway and got out of the car. "I'm here, now where's Nathan?"

"If I tell you that now you'll get pissed and probably won't help me," Haven replied, wanting the help first.

"I'm not playing games here," Jordan stated firmly. "I've been trying to call him all day and suddenly your sister picks up his phone? Where the hell is he?"

Haven sighed heavily. "Look, I don't know where he is right at this moment, but I do know what happened to him."

Jordan crossed her arms with a firmly present 'explain' expression upon her face.

"This is just another reason for Audrey to kill me," Haven said to herself then started explaining everything that had happened to Jordan.

When Haven had finished speaking, Jordan thought she was going to collapse. "Nathan's...oh my god. And you..."

Haven held up her hands when Jordan started to charge towards her. "That's why I called you, Jordan. Do you know anything about my Trouble?"

"Are you stupid?" Jordan shot back and when Haven didn't seem to grasp it, she scoffed. "Do you not remember what happened on Halloween when you killed Werner? You were at full power thanks to his Trouble and you used a different Trouble that you absorbed. So why the hell didn't you do that with Nathan?!"

Haven felt like the stupidest person in the world for not putting that together before. "I – I killed Noelle. I was in shock...we all were."

"Screw your shock," Jordan said as she grabbed Haven's arm and pulled her towards the car. "I'm tracking Nathan's phone and you're going to bring him back to life. Now."

Audrey was trying to get Moira's Trouble to activate when she heard a call pull up in the driveway. She went outside to see who it was because it couldn't be Duke. Moira told Audrey that she had witnessed Tommy kill Nathan and Nathan say that Tommy was the Bolt Gun Killer, so Audrey called Duke to warn him and tell him to keep him away.

When Audrey saw not only Jordan but Haven get out of the car, she didn't know what to expect. "You were supposed to stay at the house," she said to her sister firmly. "What are you doing with her?"

Jordan answered for Haven. "Maybe if you stopped being pissed at her for two seconds you'd realize that she's the one that can help you."

Audrey was very confused by that. "What are you talking about?"

"I can use Noelle's Trouble, Audrey," Haven explained. "I can't believe none of us thought of it before. I can tap into her Trouble and bring Nathan back."

Honestly, Audrey couldn't believe that they didn't think of it before but she could understand why they didn't. They were all in shock – to say the least. When the realization kicked in, Audrey gasped, "Oh my god." She quickly waved Haven over to her, "He's inside, come on."

Jordan was about to follow but Audrey stopped her. Audrey turned to face her and said, "Jordan, go find Duke and bring him back here."

Jordan didn't understand the request. "Why?"

"Because," she replied, "he's with Tommy and Tommy is the one that shot Nathan. And more importantly, Tommy's the Bolt Gun Killer."

That was all Jordan needed to hear so she got the address from Audrey and quickly went on her way.

"We so have to talk when this is all over," Audrey said to her sister as they went inside.

Haven scoffed, "No duh," and stopped in the foyer when Audrey did.

Audrey had to know something for sure before they went into the other room. "I've been trying to activate Moira's Trouble but haven't gotten anywhere. Are you sure you can do this?"

Haven pulled off her gloves with deep exhale. "Keep trying with her in case I can't."

Audrey accepted this answer then they walked into the living room together.

Haven tried to get the Trouble to work but she just wasn't connecting and Audrey wasn't getting anywhere with Moira. Audrey was beyond emotional and took it out on Haven, "Why can't you just do this! Why can't you just bring him back!"

Haven got to her feet and defended herself. "It's not an exact science, Audrey! I don't have a Trouble manual in my other pants that tells me what to do! You didn't even think of this before, none of us did. I know you love him Audrey but please shut up and let me try to bring him back!"

After Haven's outburst, a red aura glowed around her hands and she instinctively went over to Nathan. Haven placed her glowing hands on Nathan's face and the red aura moved over his entire body before it absorbed into him. Haven gasped when she took on Nathan's wounds and collapsed on the floor next to him. The difference between Noelle's Trouble and Haven replicating it...Haven didn't heal.

Audrey felt so relieved that the Trouble worked on Nathan but found Haven wasn't waking up. "Haven?" she asked concerned then rushed over to her sister. "Haven! Oh my god, Haven!" Audrey saw two bullet wounds in Haven in the same place Nathan had his and she couldn't find a pulse. "No!" She didn't mean for this to happen, not at all.

Audrey cupped her sister's lifeless face and whispered, "I'm going to fix this." She got to her feet and went over to Moira. The sun was getting close to setting and she needed Moira's Trouble to kick in before that happened. Audrey couldn't lose her sister. "Noelle's Trouble kicked in when she saw someone she loved die, right? Well that's going to be the same for you."

"You're going to kill someone I love?" Moira scoffed. "Who?"

"The only person you care about now," Audrey answered and pulled out her gun. "You."

Moira didn't but it. "You're bluffing."

"My sister is dead, Moira. I will do anything it takes to get her back." Audrey made that pretty damn clear. "If I shoot you in the right place you won't die right away. I just need you alive long enough to bring her back – until sundown."

Moira looked at her eyes and shook her head. "No, you're not a killer."

Audrey's face hardened when she answered with, "You have no idea what I am...and I want my sister back." In case Moira thought she was still bluffing, she fired a shot right into the floor next to her chair.

Despite this turn of events, she still thought Audrey was bluffing.

Duke and Jordan ran into the room at that moment and saw Haven, lifeless on the floor. "Haven!" Duke exclaimed and rushed right to her side. He tried to get her to wake up but it wasn't working.

"Where's Tommy?" Audrey asked to which Jordan answered with, "He got away, for now."

Duke held Haven in his arms as tears welled in his eyes. "What happened!" he demanded to know.

"Haven managed to tap into Noelle's Trouble to bring Nathan back. Problem was...she didn't heal," Audrey replied then turned back to Moira, "So now I'm trying to activate hers." She looked at Duke saying, "We're going to get her back, Duke. We're not going to lose her. Now please check Moira's blood and see if she's Troubled now."

Duke would do anything to get Haven back so he gently laid her back down before going to her boot to pull out the knife he knew she always kept hidden there. With the blade in hand he went over to Moira and despite her shouting for him to get away from her, he sliced her hand and touched the blood with his. Duke waited for his own Trouble to kick in but it didn't. He tightly clenched his fist and said, "She's not Troubled."

He was so upset by that fact that when he got to his feet, he smashed a nearby lamp. Duke's emotions were running high and his words were heated when he pointed towards Audrey. "If she doesn't come back, that's on you. And you'll pay for it."

Audrey wasn't playing around now. She went over to Moira and pressed the gun into her. "You thought I was bluffing?"

"Yeah," Moira answered nervously.

"Then maybe that's why it didn't work. Because you didn't believe me." Audrey words were getting more heated by each passing moment. "So this time, I am going to shoot you."

"Audrey," Jordan said cautiously, "what are you doing?"

"We are running out of time," Audrey emotionally answered. "I need to do something!"

"Does it make you feel crazy?" Moira asked as she looked at her. "Because that's how I felt that night, waking up in my dad's truck with my sister crying next to me and my dad gone forever."

Audrey was processing her words but something didn't add up. "You woke up in a truck?"

Moira nodded, "Yeah."

"But the police report said it looked like you were ejected from the vehicle," Audrey replied.

"I was knocked unconscious in the truck," Moira corrected. "One of my dad's toolboxes hit me on the back of the head."

Audrey gasped in realization and holstered her weapon, then went to unlock Moira's cuffs.

Duke didn't understand why she was doing that. "Audrey, what are you doing?"

"Show me where," she said to Moira, and Moira did show her the scar on the back of the head. Going off her gut feeling, she went over to Noelle's body and found the exact same scar on her body. Knowing this, she looked up to Moira and said, "You weren't unconscious. You were dead."

"What?" Moira asked incredulously.

Audrey proceeded to explain. "Your sister, she has the same scar. She brought you back."

Moira shook her head because she couldn't believe it. "No. Because that would mean..." she swallowed a lump in her throat as it started to set in, "That would mean she saved me and not our dad."

Audrey didn't understand something. "Why didn't she bring your dad back too?"

Moira took a breath. "Because she couldn't. Dad always told her that if she saved two lives in one day that it might not work, could be fatal, so she could only save one of us."

Audrey started to get teary eyed. "But she chose you, her sister."

Moira's breaths were sharp as she sobbed because everything was hitting her now. "Oh my god. All these years, I've made her life hell." She started hyperventilating a bit, "All – All because she saved my life."

Audrey hoped this would do the trick to get Moria's Trouble activated. "Do you love your sister now, Moira?"

"Yes," she sobbed, "The wrong one of us is dead." She looked outside and saw the sun was setting. "Oh my god, I hope I'm not too late." Moira quickly went over to Noelle and Haven and placed one hand on each of them but it didn't work. They didn't wake up – Nathan included. "I'm so sorry," Moira cried and moved away from them to grieve.

Audrey felt like her entire world was falling apart and Duke was losing it. He couldn't accept this. "No, no." Duke went to Haven and cupped her face. "Don't leave me, Flipside, please." He tried to get her to take his Trouble and heal but nothing was happening. "Haven, please...I love you."

While Duke was professing his love to Haven, Audrey was doing the same to Nathan. She was just about to leave his side and go to Haven when suddenly Moira started groaning as their wounds were transferred to her.

Nathan woke up and smiled when he saw Audrey there. "Hey Parker, where's the funeral?"

Haven was the next to wake up with a strong gasp as she instantly reached out and held onto Duke. "Am I alive?"

"Yeah," Duke said with relieved laughter as he looked at her. "You're alive."

Audrey left Nathan's side so Jordan could be with him and went over to her sister. "Haven I...I'm so sorry. I never should've..."

Haven cut her off by taking her hand and saying, "Could've, should've, would've. Everything's easier in the past tense. We don't have time to dwell on it."

Audrey practically broke down as she pulled her sister in for a hug. "I love you, Haven."

Haven hugged her sister back, "Love you, too."

Noelle woke up with a groan and saw her sister's wounds. "Oh my god, Moira."

"She saved you," Duke said to her, "Haven too."

"She brought two people back at once!" Noelle exclaimed, "It'll kill her!" She rushed over to her sister and took her hand.

Moira looked at her sister and weakly spoke, "You saved my life and not Dad's."

Noelle cried as she nodded.

"Why didn't you tell me?" Moira's words were getting harder to get out.

Noelle sniffled. "I didn't want you to feel guilty."

Moira sighed, "Oh, Noelle, you should have told me. Things would have been so much better with my sister."

The next day, Nathan and Audrey tracked Tommy down but in the pursuit to get him the boat he was escaping in exploded. Tommy had beaten Vince and Dave in the night for information but none was received. On a happier note, Noelle, her boyfriend, and her sister were being relocated somewhere new to start a whole new chapter of their lives.

Haven wasn't a part of any of this and heard about it second hand. After coming back to life she kinda hid out in their loft above the Gull and that's where she stayed even when she heard the music from the party downstairs. The real reason for the party was because she and Nathan came back to life, but the public reason was Taco Tuesday.

Haven was curled up on the couch sketching when Duke came in with his ukulele, "How you doing, Flipside?"

"I'm alive, which is a relief," she answered as she kept sketching. "I can't stop thinking about yesterday, though."

"Weren't you the one that told Audrey not to dwell on the past?" he asked as he sat next to her on the couch.

Haven sighed heavily because she knew he was right. Alas, it didn't stop her from thinking about it. "I killed Noelle, Duke."

"True," he replied, "but she was brought back, so no charges." He grinned, hoping to make her smile.

"It's not funny," she said firmly and set her sketchpad aside. "When I honed in on her Trouble it was all I wanted. I don't remember anything except that feeling. What's happening to me, Duke? It's like after what happened with Matthew I'm more in control but I'm also more capable of losing it."

Duke took her hands in his and spoke softly, "Hey, you're going to get through this, okay?"

"Maybe," Haven replied with a sniffle. "Until I vanish in a few weeks. What's going to happen when I come back again, huh? What's going to happen to that Haven?"

Duke looked at her with pure love as he said, "I'll make sure she's okay, too."

Haven didn't think it was possible for her to love this man any more than she already did, but in that moment she discovered that she could. She was about to say it when Duke asked, "What were you drawing?"

Haven cleared her throat and showed him the sketch pad. "Felt like sketching the McCall pack."

"This from that TV show you love watching?" he asked as he looked at the sketches of werewolves, a Jeep, a girl with a bow, and a different screaming girl.

"That'd be it." Haven laughed as she pointed to the book. "If there's ever an invention where I can get sucked into the TV and go to their world, Teen Wolf will definitely be the first."

"Who knows," Duke said with a grin as he set the book back down, "there might be a Trouble for that."

Haven playfully swatted him, "Don't tease."

Duke laughed and stood, holding his hand out to Haven. "Want to come down to the party? Tacos are being made in your honor after all."

Haven sighed with a smile. "Well, how could I girl say no to that?" She accepted his offered hand and stood. When she did, she could have sworn she saw a building in the loft's view line that she hadn't seen before.

Duke caught her 'wtf' expression and asked, "Everything alright?"

Haven looked to him then back to the window and found that what she thought she had seen wasn't there anymore. Haven wasn't going to dwell on it so she looked at Duke with a smile. "I'm alive."

"Thank god for that." Duke kissed Haven lovingly before they headed down to the party.

Haven placed her other hand over his as they walked and repeated his words, "Thank god for that."

End Season 3 Episode 8