Dee Hensley: haha I'm so sorry for making you think of the song again! If it's any consolation, it's in my head too. juicetroop82: Hmm, I think there needs to be an epic face-off with Becky. Not sure how that should happen though. DarkWriterXX94: Sorry that the sex scene was so short. I totally suck at smut. :( peterpeter: Thanks! It makes me happy that you like the way Scotty talks. I love '90s slang. haha. Megan: Hi, there! I'm glad you like the story. We're definitely nowhere near the last chapter. :D
Alex strutted down the hallways of her high school that Monday morning with her head held high. She usually stopped to talk to Abbie and Olivia, but instead she handed a scented letter to Olivia and blew her a kiss as she continued to strut by.
"Got any fries to go with that shake?" Abbie teased as she checked out Alex strutting by her in boots and tight jeans.
"Abbie!" Olivia said in disbelief.
"What?" Abbie asked innocently. "Alex has a cute butt. Are those new jeans she's wearing?"
"I don't know," Olivia shrugged. "I miss her old jeans and sneakers and her glasses."
"What's the note say?" Abbie asked.
"Meet me under the bleachers at midnight," Olivia read aloud to Abbie. She quickly folded the note and stuck it in her binder, not even giving it a second thought.
"That's so hot," Abbie said. "Are you going to?"
"No!" Olivia told her. "I'm grounded."
"Liv," Abbie said and started shaking her head. "Think of how tight those jeans are. You know damn well she's not wearing any underwear. And she wants to meet you at midnight! Meeting at midnight is not for talking. She wants to fuck you."
"What if I don't want to be…fucked?" Olivia said softly. "I want this relationship to be about more than sex."
"You're so weird," Abbie told her and then headed off to her first period class.
Olivia re-read the letter and then shoved it back in her binder. She thought about what Alex was wearing at that moment in comparison to what she used to wear. She missed the way her girlfriend used to dress and the way her girlfriend used to act. The Alex Cabot she fell in love with didn't strut and she didn't wear skin-tight jeans. Olivia noticed guys checking Alex out as she was walking by, but instead of feeling jealous, Olivia was indifferent. Alex was turning every head but Olivia's. Maybe Abbie was right; maybe she really was weird.
When Alex arrived at Serena's locker, she found Serena, Connie, and Casey waiting for her.
"You look great," Casey said and Alex gave her a quick hug.
"Thanks," Alex told her. "I miss you."
"I miss you, too," Casey said. "I bet Liv is going to be feeling the same way about you soon."
"What's going on?" Connie asked.
"Softball season is starting up," Alex informed Connie. "You and I are going to be softball widows. That sport is going to be their life until May. It has its perks, though."
"Like seeing Casey in her uniform?" Connie asked and winked at her girlfriend.
"It's not as hot as seeing you in your cheerleading uniform," Casey responded. "Or seeing you out of your cheerleading uniform."
"I'm sorry but softball uniforms and cheerleading uniforms are nowhere near as hot as Abbie's track uniform," Serena pointed out. "That uniform hugs every curve of her body."
"Abbie has no curves," Casey reminded her. "She weighs two pounds."
"I think she's up to three pounds now, Case," Alex teased.
"I hate you all," Serena said. "My girlfriend is perfect in every way. Have you seen how firm and tight her body is? I love the muscles in her forearms."
"I think Serena needs a cold shower," Connie said jokingly and Alex and Casey started laughing.
"I need to meet some of my teammates before class. I'll see you all later," Casey said and turned to leave.
"And your widowhood begins, Connie," Alex teased.
"So how was it with Liv?" Serena asked once Casey was out of sight.
"Mind-blowing! Earth-shattering! I could go on and on," Alex said. "I feel like Olivia made me into a woman that night."
Connie and Serena exchanged glances before Connie pulled a pink notebook out of her locker and handed it to Alex. "You need to write about it for us," Connie urged her.
"What's this?" Alex asked as she started flipping the pages.
"It's 'the book'," Serena informed her. "Connie and I use it to rate and describe in full detail all of our sexual encounters."
"So you're rating your girlfriends' performance?" Alex asked.
"Exactly," Connie told her. "We use a 5-star rating system. One star means it was either boring or your girl didn't know what she was doing. Two stars means it was heated but you didn't come. Three stars means the sex was good, but not great. Four stars means the sex was euphoric. And five stars—"
"Five stars means you can still feel her inside of you and you have no idea how you're going to walk tomorrow," Serena interrupted. "Or she took you to church."
"Took you to church?" Alex asked and Connie started laughing.
"That's when she makes you call out to your deity of choice," Serena said and had a hard time keeping a straight face. "For example, 'Oh, god! Oh, god, Abbie! Yes! Yes!'"
Serena received a few stares from people walking by, but she didn't care. She just started laughing again.
"Don't you feel as if this book is exploiting your girlfriends?" Alex asked and Connie and Serena gave her a confused look.
"Not at all," Connie told her. "How is it any different from locker room stories?"
"Locker room stories?" Alex asked.
"Casey and Olivia are on the same team," Connie reminded her. "You don't think they're going to be bragging to each other in the locker room about whose girlfriend puts out the most or gives the best head? This is just our own version of doing that."
"I guess you're right," Alex said hesitantly.
"It's just a little friendly competition," Connie pointed out. "We get to brag and learn new techniques and positions from each other."
"We barely started this and I already have seven entries in there," Serena bragged. "Connie has four of them and some of them are really good. You better get on it, Alex."
"Or get on Olivia," Connie teased.
Alex started to feel nervous again. "No problem," she said, trying to sound confident. She knew Olivia would be devastated if she found out about the book, but she tried to block that from her mind as she mentally outlined what her first entry would say. Sex with Olivia was supposed to be about love, not bragging rights, but as she glanced at Connie and Serena's entries, she vowed she'd do whatever it took to make her entries the most exciting and the most explicit.
Alex ran up to her bedroom and locked the door the moment she got home. She knew she should be doing her homework, but she pulled out the book instead and started to read some of the entries. The first one was Serena's, of course.
Date of conquest: December 31, 1991
Location: my bed
Rating: 5 stars
Abbie had me handcuffed to the metal headboard of my bed. The handcuffs were digging into my skin, but I didn't care. I placed a full-length mirror next to the bed, so Abbie could watch herself fuck me with a strap-on. She loves watching herself have sex and I don't blame her. She looks so hot when she's fucking and when she watches herself in the mirror her thrusts become more rhythmic.
The strap-on was fun, but it still doesn't compare to what Abbie can do with her tongue. I know I said she wasn't that great at first, but she gets better each time. I can just imagine what she's going to be like a few years from now. I felt like my body was going to convulse when I had an orgasm and the clanking of the handcuffs against the metal headboard just intensified that feeling. She gets bonus points for being a sweetheart afterward. She held me close and told me I was the only girl for her.
I know that hardly sounds like something that would earn five stars, but what made everything better was that we have it recorded! Yes, Abbie and I have our own X-rated video. It's the first of many to come. And I mean come in every sense of the word. We're going to try our hand at lesbian 'squirt' porn. I've seen some videos and Abbie is so much better than all of those girls. I can't wait! It's going to be my Valentine's Day gift to my girlfriend. I promise to write all of the details.
-Serena
Alex had only read one entry and she already felt intimidated. She knew Olivia would never do anything like that with her. She decided to read Connie's in hopes that it would make her feel better. Connie was with Casey and Alex knew Casey was as vanilla as a girl could get.
Date of conquest: January 1, 1992
Location: the Disneyland Hotel
Rating: 5 stars
I can't believe my first time with Casey was at Disneyland! Not at the park itself because we could get arrested for indecent exposure, but the hotel still counts, right? Our whole day was perfect. We had so much fun on all the rides, especially Space Mountain and Star Tours. Casey is such a nerd sometimes, but it's cute. Her hand brushed against mine while we were on the Haunted Mansion and that's the moment I knew I wanted to kiss her. She has the softest lips! Our first kiss was awkward, but sweet and what made it even more memorable was that it was during the part of the ride that looks like a cemetery. It doesn't seem romantic but it was. We counted down to the New Year together and watched the fireworks over the Matterhorn. Casey kissed me again when the year '1992' lit up and we didn't care if anybody gave us any weird looks.
She says she didn't expect us to have sex that night, but I ended up seducing her. She was in the bathroom, taking off her make-up and putting her pajamas on and I took it upon myself to go through her suitcase and look for her Nirvana shirt. I took all my clothes and underwear off and slipped the shirt over my naked body. Casey nearly started drooling when she saw me. She pulled me close to her and felt how wet I was. We made out for a few minutes until I couldn't take it anymore. I stripped her from the waist down and got on my knees for her. She should get extra points for the way she tastes. You were right, Serena, it's definitely possible to start having cravings for a certain girl's flavor. I definitely crave Casey all the time now. And the noises she makes when she comes are some of the most beautiful I've ever heard.
When we finally made it to the bed, she wanted me to show her how flexible I am so I decided to do the splits while I was lying down, leaving myself fully exposed and fully open to Casey. She started teasing me before she gently stuck three fingers inside me. She said she nearly came again when my walls started tightening around her fingers. She removed her fingers and started to taste me. That's when I couldn't hold back anymore. I started screaming her name and some obscenities that I can't even remember. Vacation sex, Serena! Try it!
-Connie
Alex felt her confidence drop when she read that her awkward and shy ex-girlfriend had become some kind of sexpert. Then she thought about who Casey's new girl was. She knew it wasn't hard to have great sex with Connie. Connie was a cheerleader and a gorgeous cheerleader at that. There were things Casey did with Connie that she'd never do with her and she was going to have to accept that. Besides, she had Olivia and Olivia definitely gave her a moment worth writing about.
Alex decided to read through all of the entries before she wrote her own. She had expected them all to have 5 star ratings but she was surprised at how brutally honest Connie and Serena were when it came to sex with their girlfriends. Connie had given Casey one star for being sloppy with a strap-on (they vowed never to use it again), but Alex thought Serena's one star rating for Abbie was hilarious.
Date of conquest: January 7, 1992
Location: my bed
Rating: 1 star
Whatever you do, do not use honey while you're having sex. Abbie loves the taste of it, so she squeezed some on to my clit and some other areas of my body. It was sexy at first, but it ended up becoming a sticky mess. Plus, I didn't know that honey crystallizes and practically sticks to your body. I had a hard time washing it off down there and I'm still sore from practically scrubbing it off. That's the last time I let her suggest something to lick off of me.
-Serena
Rena, how did you NOT know that honey would be a bad idea?
-Connie
You're such a skankoid and at least my girlfriend knows how to use a strap-on.
-Serena
After Alex finished her mental outline, she started writing her entry.
Date of conquest: January 12, 1992
Location: some hotel near Heat
Rating: 5 stars
Olivia is everything I have ever wanted and more. She's so sexy! After the club, we went to a hotel and she stripped in front of me. I nearly creamed when I saw her naked. Her body is so sexy. She has the most perfect breasts. I wanted to kiss every inch of her body. When we were under the covers, I spread my legs underneath her and she started grinding herself into me. I could feel my wetness mixing with hers and when I was about to come Olivia pulled away and started to go down on me. She licked me so hard and so thoroughly. I felt like she left nothing untouched. When she inserted her fingers in me at the same time she was sucking on my clit, I came all over her. She was literally dripping with my wetness. That's the first time that ever happened to me.
After that, we got in the shower and I couldn't take my eyes off of Olivia. I was turned on again when I saw the water trickle down her body. I wrapped my arms around her waist from behind and she slightly turned her head so she could kiss me. As we were kissing, I lowered my hand and started rubbing her clit. After a few minutes of playing with her clit, Olivia came so hard. I know you girls think she's a total top, but I learned that she loves being dominated sometimes. Just don't tell her I told you that. It's our little secret.
-Alex
Alex knew Olivia told her she couldn't meet her under the bleachers, but she was just itching to have one more entry in the book. She decided to go over to Olivia's house at midnight regardless of Olivia being grounded. She knew she couldn't knock on the door so she decided to knock on Olivia's window.
"What are you doing here?" Olivia asked after she had let Alex in through the window. She knew it was a dumb question. She saw that her girlfriend was dressed in tight jeans and a crop top and, much to Olivia's disappointment, she was wearing contacts instead of her glasses. There was no doubt about what Alex had on her mind.
"I risk being grounded and that's the kind of greeting I get?" Alex asked as she pushed Olivia down on her bed and got on top of her.
Alex started to kiss her and Olivia went along with it for awhile. She loved Alex and she loved kissing Alex, but she didn't like who she was becoming. When Alex removed her shirt and bra and tossed them aside, Olivia forgot all about holding back. She undid the buttons on Alex's jeans and she learned that Abbie was right; Alex wasn't wearing any underwear.
"Touch me," Alex said once her jeans were off. She guided Olivia's hand right where she wanted it and Olivia felt herself become aroused when she felt how wet Alex already was.
Alex knew Olivia wouldn't be able to resist once she felt how wet she was. "My parents have a camcorder," Alex told her girlfriend. "What about if I take it one night and we make a video of the two of us?"
"No," Olivia said. "I'm not really into that. What if someone found it?"
"So what?" Alex said and started nibbling on Olivia's neck hard enough to leave a mark. "That'd make it more exciting."
"What's come over you?" Olivia asked angrily. "I miss who you were. You were my girlfriend and my best friend in one and now you're not acting like you're either of them. I wish we never would have had sex. Instead of it bringing us closer together, it changed you and now you're this completely different person and I don't like it. I don't want to make a video and I don't want anyone else to know about our sex life. It's something that's supposed to be beautiful and just between us, but I don't even know if I want to have sex with you anymore. You're acting like a tramp right now."
Alex tried to hide how hurt she was. "I may be acting like a tramp, but I'm acting that way for you," she pointed out. "All you're doing for me is being a prude. Connie and Serena are so lucky."
Alex left without even giving Olivia time to respond. She knew she had to go to school in a few hours, but there was something she had to get off of her chest. The moment she got home, she opened the book and gave Olivia her first one star rating.