You'll Never Know Until You Try It
Chapter 49. Sex, Lies, And A DVD Part 2
Author: twin who likes to travel
Rating: R/NC-17
Summary: This is the second part of Kerry cheating on Nikki and the inevitable outcome.
Disclaimer: I own nothing.
Reviews: I would like them. Constructive criticism is ok.
Kerry gasped as her hands were then placed on the other girl's chest and was instructed to grope it. For the third time, she did as the other girl wanted her to do and began moaning as Alison did the same to her. After a minute, Alison slid slowly off of Kerry and ended up snuggled up against Kerry's left side. She leaned in to kiss Kerry's lips again while she used her left leg to spread Kerry's legs farther apart. The redhead began to moan as the other girl's upper thigh pressed up against her groin while her own left thigh was doing the exact thing to Alison. The moans got louder when a hand caressed her chest again. She knew this was very wrong and that she should stop, but the beautiful girl was stirring up emotions that only Nikki had ever been able to do.
She became worried when Alison pulled away from her. But that disappeared when her legs were spread even farther apart and the girl above her got between them. Kerry got worked up again as lips began kissing her neck before moving to her chest. Kerry ran her fingers through the black hair while lips and a tongue kissed and caressed her chest. After a few minutes, Alison began kissing her way down Kerry's body. The redhead below her felt a shudder as lips landed on the remaining piece of underwear. She felt her temperature rise as Alison left a trail of kisses down and back up her legs. When she was making her way back up Kerry's legs, she kissed her inner thighs.
Kerry became confused as Alison pulled away a second time. She gulped as fingers suddenly grabbed the sides of her underwear and began to pull it off. Half of her mind was screaming at her to stop before going past the point of no return while the other half was screaming for the other side to shut up and that they were already there. That side won as Kerry lifted her butt off the bed just long enough for them to be pulled past her butt. Alison then backed up slowly and removed the underwear as she did. After it was off, she tossed them onto the pile of Kerry's other clothes. Then she instantly lay down long enough to pull her own off. As the brunette started to climb back on top of her, the redhead pulled the covers up to her chest. She was too caught up in pulling them up to even notice the red light of the video camera that was still running.
The girls were face to face again as a few fingers slid down Kerry's stomach and into her body. Kerry heard Alison remind her that it was her time to join in. Kerry slowly put a few of her fingers inside of the girl above her. Both girls heard and felt each other reaching their peak at the same time. This happened a few times as the fingers explored as much as they could. Fear and disappointment sunk in to Kerry's mind when Alison pulled her fingers out of her and pulled out Kerry's fingers as well. The redhead let out gasps as the older girl moved down her body until she was totally hidden by the covers. Kerry gulped as Alison placed Kerry's legs over her shoulders under the covers They turned into moans and shouts as she felt hands on her butt and a tongue enter her body. They got even louder and Kerry actually felt herself kick the other girl's back as it continued.
Around ten minutes later
"How was that, Cutie?" Alison asked before smiling at Kerry.
"It was great, b-but th-this c-can't ev-ever h-happen a-again."
"Because of what's her name?" Alison claimed as she leaned in.
"Her name's Nikki," Kerry revealed as she put a few fingers on the soft lips in front of her, "If you plan on kissing me again, you better brush and gargle first."
"Why?"
"Because…"
"Because you don't want to know what you taste like or that you already know?"
Kerry turned red before answering, "Because I don't want to kiss you immediately after something like that, ok? It would be just too weird."
"Ok, but before I do, I want you to go down on me."
"I…can't." Kerry muttered before frowning briefly.
"Why not?" Alison questioned after giving her an equally long frown.
"I just can't, ok? I wouldn't feel comfortable doing that."
"Because?"
"Because it feels too weird."
"Did you ever go down on Nikki?"
"That's none of your concern," Kerry informed but continued when the other girl gave her an intense stare, "Ok, fine. I did, but it was only because I was curious. When I told her I wouldn't do it ever again, she understood and hasn't asked me to do that since then."
"Alright, I'll be right back. Don't go anywhere, ok? I would hate to have to hide your clothes while I'm in the bathroom."
"I promise."
The two had a short staredown before Alison climbed out of the bed and strolled to the bathroom without stopping to put on anything. While she left the room, she peeked over her shoulder to see Kerry smiling at her. Then the redhead let out a sigh and lay back down on the bed, giving the camera a clear view of Kerry's naked upper body and her watching Alison walking away. When Alison returned a few minutes later, she approached at the same pace and crawled back into bed beside Kerry.
"Cutie, have you and your girlfriend ever talked about having a threesome before?"
"Yeah."
"And?"
"She said she's not into that because she doesn't want to share our intimate moments like that with anyone else, but…"
"But you'd be up for it?" the beautiful girl interrupted.
"M-Maybe."
"Great, I know just the person."
"Who?"
Before another word could be spoken, the girls heard the sounds of a door opening and closing and a girl calling out, "Hey, Ali, are you home?"
"In my bedroom, Hailey," Alison shouted as Kerry gulped and covered up her chest with the covers. She added when they heard a soft knock, "Just come in."
"Ok," a voice agreed before a hot, young blonde walked in, closed the door, and spotted the girls in bed and two piles of clothes, "Oops, s-sorry. I can come back after you've gotten dressed."
"Don't go, Hailey. I want to introduce you to one of Ms. Beaumont's star art pupils, Kerry Hennessy. Kerry, this is my best friend since high school, Hailey Adams."
"You mean Ms. Beaumont, the cougar?"
"Yeah," Alison admitted before sharing a laugh with the blonde.
'That means she's…"
"Yeah, she's the one."
"The one what?"
"The one she told me about after she got home yesterday."
"You're her roommate?"
"Not a roommate, just her best friend from high school, like she said. I'm staying here a few days while her sister is out of town and my apartment's being repainted and fumigated."
"SO, if you're not busy and interested, would you like to join me and Cutie here?"
"I thought her name is Kerry."
"It is. I just like calling her what she is. She's just as cute without the covers. We're both up for a threesome. You told me before that you would like to try it doing it with a girl at least once and maybe a threesome. So why not kill two birds with one stone."
"I guess, if she's really up for it," the blonde replied as she watched the redhead, who seemed to be shaking a little.
"She is. She's just nervous because it's her first threesome and she just met you."
"Ok," Hailey stated and smiled when she got a nod from the almost stranger.
Kerry could feel the anticipation and fear as the blonde took off everything. She had to admit to herself that the blonde was just as hot or beautiful as Alison. As the blonde began to make her way to the bed, she saw the red light that Kerry had missed. She was about to say something, but a pleading look from her friend shut her up. She then climbed into the bed with the other two. Kerry was now in the middle of the bed with Alison to her left and Hailey to her right.
"So, uh, how are we going to do this?" Kerry inquired.
"Isn't she just the cutest thing you've ever seen?" Alison said to the blonde across from her after seeing the redhead blush.
"She isn't a thing, but yeah, she is cute. No offense, Red, but the two of us are just a little bit cuter than you."
"I know," Kerry told her before frowning.
"Hailey, that was rude. You don't say something like that to girl you're about to have sex with. Apologize."
"I'm sorry, Red. Do you forgive me?"
"Yeah, but why are you calling me Red?"
"Because of your red hair, and I thought that nickname sounded just as good as being called 'Cutie'."
"Well?" Kerry mumbled.
"Oh, right. Well, first, we'll do to her what we have done to each other. Then she'll do the same to us. Sound good?" Alison suggested.
After the other two girls agreed, Alison had Hailey and Kerry switch places so that the blonde was now in the middle. Kerry gulped when the brunette gently grabbed Kerry's right hand with her left, interlocked their fingers, and pulled them over Hailey's body. The redhead gasped as Alison put the interlocked fingers inside of the blonde and moved them all around, getting them into a very enjoyable pattern by the way Hailey moaned. The moans turned into light shrieks as their other hands caressed and squeezed her butt. She groaned in disappointment when the hands were no longer on her butt.
She was pleasantly surprised when they began kissing her on the mouth and chest and caressed it as well. Kerry and Alison alternated every so often. While one was kissing her on the mouth while caressing her body, the other was kissing and caressing her chest and stomach. When a few minutes had gone by, Alison pulled their fingers out of the blonde, clearly aggravating her. The next thing Hailey knew, Kerry was kissing her on the mouth as a hand caressed her chest. While Kerry was dong that, Alison started going down on Hailey. She gently grabbed Kerry's butt with her left hand and Hailey's with her right at the same time, causing the other two to moan and shriek a little louder than before.
About five minutes later, Alison and Kerry pulled away from Hailey. Hailey sighed before being told, "It's your turn now." Hailey appeared confused as Alison ordered the other girls to change places again. She understood when her best friend pushed Kerry onto her back and grabbed one of the blonde's hands just like she had done with Kerry's earlier.
This time it was the redhead's turn to be the one to experience what had happened to Hailey. The only difference was that before they finished, both had gone down on her. As Hailey leaned in to kiss Kerry on her lips, Alison advised her to stop and make a trip to bathroom. When the blonde asked why, she explained Kerry's aversion to something like that. Hailey simply smiled as she slid out of bed and made the trip to the bathroom without putting anything on.
When the blonde came back, the brunette reminded them it was her turn now. This continued until Alison confirmed she was totally satisfied. Hailey leaned in and kissed Alison on the lips and even gave her a little bit of tongue. Kerry couldn't hide the disgusted expression from the other two, who just shrugged it off.
"So, how much time do you have before you have to leave?" Alison asked the redhead as she brushed some hair out of Kerry's face.
Kerry glanced at her watch and confirmed, "I have an hour before I need to leave."
"Then stay here a little longer. You seem to be a little bit tired. I'll set the alarm in case you fall asleep," Alison offered with a small smile.
"O-Ok," Kerry murmured and fell asleep within a few minutes.
When she saw that the girl was asleep, Alison got up and shut off and hid the camera. Then she set the alarm clock and climbed back into bed for the third time. She cuddled with Kerry from behind. Hailey followed Alison's lead and snuggled up against the redhead behind her while wrapping one of Kerry's arms around her stomach. The warm feeling sent the last two into a peaceful sleep.
An hour later, Alison's bedroom
All three heard the alarm, but Kerry was the first one to do something.
"Oh, no!" Kerry yelped and sat up immediately after realizing that she was naked and in the middle of a spooning, involving Alison and some girl she barely even knew, "Please tell that what happened earlier didn't happen and this is the beginning of a nightmare."
"No, everything that happened since you got here is real."
"Oh, no," Kerry repeated before jumping out of bed and crying as she quickly started getting dressed.
"Why the tears, Red? It was abundantly obvious that you enjoyed everything except the kiss Alison and I shared at the end."
"Because…Because I h-have a g-girlfriend, and I cheated on her with two girls. One I had just met and the other I had only known for about twenty four hours. How could I do something like that?"
"YOU HAVE A GIRLFRIEND!" Hailey yelled and received a nod from Kerry, who was still crying, before she turned to her best friend, "WHY DIDN'T YOU TELL ME SHE HAD A GIRLFRIEND?"
"No need to shout, I'm right here, and you never asked."
"I didn't think I had to ask. I never thought you'd do something like this," Hailey argued as she got out of the bed and got dressed just as quickly as Kerry had and turned to the redhead, "Red, I mean, Kerry, I would have never done that with the both of you if I knew you were dating someone. I was cheated on by my boyfriend less than a week after I slept with him for the first time. So I know the pain that comes with it. Please forgive me."
"I'll f-forgive y-you if you can f-forgive m-me for bringing you into the whole mess."
"Good," Hailey sighed while getting out of bed and turning back to her now former best friend, "As for you, what the hell is wrong with you? I know it's been a few years, but the Alison I once knew wouldn't have done this and wouldn't have dragged her best friend into it. Does she even know you recorded the whole thing?"
"SHE RECORDED IT!" Kerry hollered as she searched for the video camera.
"Well, she does now."
"Give it to me," the redhead demanded, "You had no right recording me without my permission."
"If you let me keep it, I won't tell your girlfriend you cheated on her and how easy it was. Take it or leave it."
"If I let you keep it? That sounds like blackmail."
"Call it what you want. Your relationship will be over, regardless of who tells her. So I'm not really worried about it."
Kerry saw the brunette's phone on the desk beside her. She grabbed it, erased her number, and threw it at Alison. She then left the bedroom in tears as she headed for the front door.
"I'm out of here. Don't call me again until you've gotten over whatever emotional trauma fucked you up in the head," Hailey ordered.
Alison sighed as she got up. Before she even left the room, she heard her former best friend stop Kerry and offer her a ride back to Columbia University. Kerry waited patiently as Hailey rushed through the last steps of packing up the rest of her things. They both glared at Alison, who was standing in the open bedroom doorway in just underwear, before slamming the door behind them. As the blonde drove, she promised the redhead that Nikki wouldn't find out from her what had happened. Kerry softly thanked her, got out of the car, and closed the door. Then she made her way to her dorm as she let the rest of her tears flow down her cheeks. She stopped at the bathroom on their floor to make sure she looked ok before going back into her dorm room, where Nikki was going to be waiting for her.
Around 1:00 PM, Kerry and Nikki's dorm room,
"Hey, Beautiful, you're a little late, aren't you?"
"Yeah, sorry lost track of time."
"Well, we haven't got much time before our next classes so grab what you need and we can head to the cafeteria for a quick, late lunch. You know, nothing major. Then tonight we can have dinner together."
"Actually, can we skip lunch? I'm not that hungry, and I just want spend the time we have right now with you?"
"Something wrong? You're usually in a better mood than this."
"No, I just missed you, and it's been a long morning."
"Aw, does my girl need some love from her princess?"
"It could help."
"How much are we talking about: topless, half dressed, or totally naked?"
"How about a combination of the first two?"
"I think I can manage that," Nikki assured her and didn't waste any time getting herself out of her shirt, pants, and bra.
Then she lay down on the bed that hadn't been made that morning. Kerry joined her on the bed less than a minute later. They used as much time as they could spare before getting dressed and heading to class. After departing in separate directions, Kerry felt the guilt of what had happened at Alison's apartment almost drowning her, figuratively speaking of course.
Friday, February 2nd; late morning, a café on the campus of Columbia University
Nikki was taking time during her short break between classes to book the surprise flights to Florida for their first college Spring Break together. She was unaware that a short girl with short, black hair was strutting up to her. She had just confirmed the purchase of the tickets and drank some of her cappuccino when she heard someone trying to talk to her.
"Excuse me, are you Nikki Alcott?"
Nikki turned halfway around in her chair, "Yes, I am. Who are…"
"The same Nikki that's the girlfriend of the cute redhead that goes by the name of Kerry Hennessy?" the same girl guessed as she interrupted Nikki again.
"That's right. Who are you?"
"Alison Brown."
"Sorry, I don't remember you. How does Kerry know you?"
"From her art class. Can I talk to you for a few minutes?"
"Sure, I've got some time before my last class of the day," Nikki declared as she smiled at the very attractive girl sitting in front of her.
"Thanks, you're just as cute as Kerry said you were."
"Thanks, so are you a classmate?"
"Not exactly."
"What do you mean?"
"I'm not a classmate of hers. I'm the girl who posed nude for her art class."
"Oh, she mentioned you. She's right about what she said about you."
"And what did she say?"
"She said the model she sketched was very beautiful. When I asked her a few questions about it, she described you perfectly."
Both girls shared a smile after Alison stopped blushing at the compliment from the girl whose life she was about to ruin, socially anyway.
"Yeah, she's pretty talented, smart, cute, and…sweet."
The change in the tone instantly got Nikki's attention.
"Yes, she is. Is this your way of telling me you're in love with her? Not to be rude, but she's in love with me. And I'm in love with her too. I may even ask her to marry me some day, so you're wasting your time."
"Well, not to be rude either, but you might want to hold off on thinking about ring shopping any time soon," Alison implied as she watched Nikki finish her drink.
"And why is that?"
"Because she cheated on you twice. The first time was with me. The second time was with me and my former best friend from high school," Alison whispered after leaning in closer.
"You're lying," Nikki growled softly, "You think just because you're more attractive than me that you can get me to believe that my girl cheated on me. I don't know what kind of game you're trying to play here, but Kerry would never do that to me. She said I had nothing to worry about. She even promised that if you wanted to have sex with her, whether it was just the two of you or a threesome, she wouldn't think twice about saying no to you."
"Well, then either she lied to you or has the worst memory ever. I didn't even need to get her drunk either. All it took for me to get her naked was some small talk, showing me the rest of her artwork and things she had written in the past, and a very thorough massage. And she liked the threesome. My former friend, Hailey and I wore her out enough that she crashed my bed for about an hour. She didn't even bother getting dressed until she woke later."
"Quit lying," Nikki insisted in a louder growl while trying to control her anger at hearing what had to be nothing but lies.
"I'm not lying. I have substantial proof."
"What kind of proof?"
"This kind," Alison confessed as she took the DVD out of her inside coat pocket.
"You made a sex video?"
"Yeah, starring me, your girlfriend, and my best friend. Well, former best friend. I just have to say she was more flexible than I thought she would be."
"Give me that," Nikki snarled loud enough to get some people to start staring at them.
"Ah, ah. If you want to see it, I get to come with you."
"Why?"
"Because I want to see your face when you see how easily the last piece of underwear came off of her. So your place or mine?"
"Mine, Kerry is in class right now. When that's over she has about half an hour before another starts and that one will last for an hour. So we have more than enough time to prove that you're lying."
"Aren't you worried about her stopping back at the dorm before she goes to the other class?"
"No, she uses that brief time to grab something to eat and head to her next class. We like to give each other some time to be alone. That way we don't get sick of each other."
Ten minutes later, Kerry and Nikki's dorm room
Both girls got comfortable before Nikki started up the DVD. It hadn't even been a minute before Kerry was stripping down for the massage. Nikki almost instantly got uncomfortable at observing the somewhat of a stranger massage her half dressed girlfriend without any signs of resistance and even heard happy sighs. It got worse when she saw the redhead take off her bra and lay on it while the other girl took off her shorts and socks. After viewing that, she turned to the left and caught a glimpse of Alison smirking.
She wanted to smack that right off her face but went back to watching the screen. She turned up the volume slightly as Kerry was attempting to get up and put her bra on. She gaped at the fear on Kerry's face as the girl beside her straddled her and held the redhead down by the wrists. She felt herself getting sick at seeing Alison not being stopped. Tears began to fall down her cheeks as she saw how easily the rest of Kerry's underwear came off, just like Alison had said.
"GET OUT NOW!" Nikki demanded as she didn't stop the tears from falling.
"Not yet. A few of the best parts haven't happened yet."
"And what would that be?"
"Just watch."
Nikki continued to keep her focus on the screen and cried more when she noticed where the girls' hands disappeared to by the loud moans. Almost every part was telling Nikki to get up and throw out the girl that helped in breaking her heart. But she was still in too much shock to move or even speak another word. It reached the breaking point the moment Alison had moved totally under the covers. She stood up instantly after hearing the first shriek from her now ex-girlfriend.
"Well, that's enough for me," the brunette announced before laughing.
"Then I'm throwing you out," Nikki commanded and grabbed the other girl with a good amount of force.
"You can keep the DVD by the way," Alison taunted, "You still have the threesome to watch."
"Don't ever come back, BITCH!" Nikki warned as she pushed the other girl hard enough away from her dorm room that Alison's back hit the opposite wall and she landed on her butt.
"I will if Kerry wants me to,"
"She won't be here. I'm kicking her out. I'm the one that got us this room, so I'm staying."
The girls then realized that they had an audience. It seemed that everyone in their hallway had seen them by the looks of complete shock and some fear. She slammed the door shut and actually checked out the rest of the DVD. When she was finished, she began packing enough clothes for the entire weekend and planned on blowing off the class coming up very soon.
