A/N: Thank you so much for all the awesome reviews! :)

Disclaimer: I don't own Jack, Elizabeth, etc.

Tooth Captain

"This is ridiculous," Elizabeth whispered, receiving a warning look from Jack who glanced at her over his shoulder.

She rolled her eyes and they continued crawling across the moonlit cabin.

When they were next to Blaxton's bed they stopped and holding their breath slowly raised their heads to the level of the bed.

Blaxton was fast asleep, his cheek pressed against the pillow, his hat placed on another pillow next to him.

Jack and Elizabeth exchanged a smile but when Blaxton shifted in his sleep they fell to the floor as fast as possible, their heads colliding.

Stifling hisses of pain, they waited a few moments before risking to check on Blaxton once again. Luckily, he was still asleep.

Jack motioned for Elizabeth to lift the pillow, and she did so very gently, biting back a chuckle at the sight of a tooth.

Slowly, Jack began sliding a spyglass under the pillow, his and Elizabeth's eyes fixed on Blaxton's face.

As soon as the spyglass was properly placed, Elizabeth dropped the corner of the pillow and soundlessly smoothed it with the palm of her hand.

Jack nodded, and they began creeping out of Blaxton's cabin, sighing with relief and laughing only when they were safely back in their own cabin.


On the next morning Blaxton ran into the galley, his face beaming with joy. "Mum! Dad! Look what I've got! It's a spyglass from Captain Tooth! He really did come!"

"Of course he did," Jack said with a smile. "He always does."

"And he brought you exactly what you wanted!" Elizabeth noted enthusiastically.

Blaxton nodded, showing off the spyglass to his parents. "But guess what, Mum."

"What is it, sweetheart?" Elizabeth asked while Jack examined the spyglass with narrowed eyes.

"Captain Tooth forgot to take my tooth!" Blaxton exclaimed joyously, showing Elizabeth the tooth.

Jack blinked. Elizabeth bit her lip.

"So I can leave it under my pillow today again!" Blaxton continued, clearly delighted by the prospect. "Captain Tooth will think it's a new one, right, Mum?"

"Well-" Jack started but Blaxton cut him off, too engrossed in inwardly rummaging through his wishes.

"I'll ask Captain Tooth for a sea turtle!" Blaxton announced happily, and then ran out of the galley to inform the crew about what had happened.

When the door closed behind him, Jack and Elizabeth looked at each other in silence.

"How are we going to sneak a sea turtle under the pillow?" Jack asked after a pause, sincerely worried.

Elizabeth laughed.