I Want Her To Be Mine

By WorkingGirl22

I just wanted to say that Puckleberry are just really close friends who hold hands and call each other pet names and kiss each other on the cheek, Rachel is bisexual in this story and does have boyfriend right which is Hakeem but they have only been together for two months and not so serious, Hakeem knows his girlfriend likes girls and it's fine with him. It will end as Pezberry.

Oh Santana calls her daughter Manni,Mara and Amar for Amaira as nicknames just so you don't get confused. It will also be told in Santana's and Rachel's POV at times, I hope you are enjoying it so far.

I'm adding Rachel an older sibling. Gianna Berry, She will be her older sister who lives in New York with her daughter Aubree.


At The Lopez House.

Santana just changed Amaira and was now sitting on the couch playing with her little girl. She finished her homework before she came home. She wanted to spend as much time with her little girl before putting her to bed. Everybody in GoldStars weren't too happy with Roberto. Finn broke up with Quinn after Faria blurted out the truth about the cheating. McKinley's Golden Couple were offically broken up. Quinn was staying by Roberto's side these days. It seems like they were offically together now.

It's Friday and Rachel wasn't coming back to school until Tuesday. It's been hell for her. She just wanted her girlfriend speaking to her again.

Marisol walked into the house and put her bag on the dinning room table.

"You still pissed off at me Marisol? I thought I was doing what I thought was best for Faria by not having Rachel tell her." Santana tells her.

"What good would that do? if Faria asked Rachel if she knew about it then who's fault would have been? yours because you told Faria's best friend not tell her. She wasn't going to listen to you anyways when it comes to her friendship with any of the GoldStars members." Santana listened looking away from her.

"Look I don't understand why you thought this was right? don't act like an idiot, it doesn't look cute on you. I saw the look you gave Rachel before you went to check on Quinn at the nurses office." Santana was about to speak but Marisol cut her off.

"You scolded your girlfriend for telling her best friend the truth? Santi you should have known that Rachel was going to tell her best friend about Roberto's cheating. They have been best friends way before you were part of Rachel's world." Santana looked at her.

"You don't think I know that Mari? trust me I know for a fact that I screwed up by going to check on Quinn that day. I should have just stayed with my girlfriend. I know I shouldn't have told Rachel to keep quiet. Faria had every right to know the truth." Marisol walked over to her giving her a stern Lopez look.

"Let me ask you a question. Why did you go check on Quinn when Rachel Berry's your girlfriend? shouldn't she matter more to you?" Santana nods.

"Yes she should have but I felt like Quinn's been my best friend for so long that I had to see her. Your right I should have just stayed with Rachel."

"Fix your relationship with her because I actually think she keeps you grounded and good. You two are made for each other so woman up and call her." Santana frowns.

"What if she doesn't want to talk to me?" Marisol raised an eyebrow at her.

"Since when are you the one to give up on what you want? is Rachel what you want?" She nodded.

"Then like I said woman up and call your girlfriend. I'm going upstairs to start on my homework so I don't have to do it on Sunday." She watched her sister go upstairs.

Santana sighs putting her sleepy daughter next to her up against the pillows and put on the little Mermaid for her. She looked at more pictures of her and Rachel together. She needed to make it up to her baby but how was she going to do that? first a good start would to call her.

Her phone starts ringing and she sees that Quinn calling her.

"What do you want Q?" She asked annoyed.

"I'm on my way over, we need to hang out since you stood up for me against Roberto's ex on Monday. I never got to thank you."

"I really don't want you over here Quinn." She heard nothing then a sigh.

"Why not we've been best friends since we were in 3rd grade. Why are you giving that up?"

"Listen to me Q. You think your better then everybody and as the year as gone by I've been putting up with it but not anymore. You'll always be my best friend but right now you come third when it comes to my daughter and Rachel." She hung up after that and called Rachel hoping she would answer.

Amaira makes a noise. Santana smiles at her girlfriend as she looks at the Tv. Amaira was so cute.

"What are you doing silly girl?" She tickled her little fit. Amaira giggled cooing.

"Do you think mami should woman up and call Rachel?" Her daughter just makes another noise. She takes that as a yes and calls Rachel.

"Hi Santana how are you?" Santana smiles hearing her girl's voice.

"Hi baby I'm good. I miss you." She doesn't hear anything after that.

"Rachel I'm going to make it up to you. It's no fun without you here. We're still good right?" She looked at her phone and saw that Rachel was still on the line.

"Baby did you hear me?"

"Yeah I heard you. Honestly I really hope we are." She heard Rachel say softly.

"I hate fighting with you. I'm sorry for siding with Quinn that day. I should have just left her to be taken care off by Tina and Bailey."

"Santana she's your best friend. I'm not going to stop you from making sure your friends are okay."

"No she's not my friend right now. She's a bitch and I shouldn't have glared at you for telling your best friend the truth. What can I do to make it up to you?"

"Figure it out yourself." Rachel tells.

"Alright I'll do whatever I can to make it up to my beautiful and hopefully forgiven girlfriend." Santana tells her.

"Oh Santana?"

"Yeah baby?"

"I miss you too." She said before hanging up. Santana couldn't help but grin to herself before placing her daughter on her lap as they watched the movie together.

In Australia.

Rachel stared at her phone after she hung up on Santana. Hearing her call her baby really hurt and she couldn't stay on the phone after that. She's still hurt that Santana gave her a disappointed look for telling Faria the truth. She had a right to know the truth and what does Santana do? she goes to comfort Quinn Fabray. She wasn't even speaking to the girl since they got out of the hospital and now they were suddently best friends again? that doesn't even seem right.

She really doesn't get Santana sometimes. It's hard to figure out what goes on in her girlfriend's head but she was still going to be in a relationship with her. She really has strong feeling for the latina but it's not easy being her girlfriend.

"Call her back Rae." Rachel looked up at her bestie.

"Why should I Faria? It felt like she was scolding me for even telling you about Roberto's cheating ass. It didn't feel right when she just shook her head and walked out the room to be with Quinn. I felt like crying that day." Rachel tells her sadly.

"Because she's your girlfriend, you two love each other and you two just got back together not too long ago. Don't throw everything away just because my relationship is over. She loves you just as much as you love her." Rachel still wasn't sure.

"Maybe we rushed just getting back together. Maybe we should have just focused on being friends before jumping a few steps." Faria shrugged.

"Do what you feel is right chica. If you don't call her today, atleast then call her tomorrow." Faria leaves the room while Rachel sighs tiredly.

The next day Rachel woke up feeling well rested. Being out of town always made her sleep peacefully and made her relax more.

She turned her head to see Faria sleeping next to her with a tear stained face. She must have cried herself to sleep in the middle of the night.

"Faria wake up." She stirs in her sleep. She didn't get much sleep after crying over Roberto even though she shouldn't be.

"Did you climb in my bed and cry yourself to sleep again? sweetie that's not healthy. You shouldn't be crying over him." Rachel whispered.

She opened her eyes sadly. Roberto was her everything. They were each others first and there families got along great. Now he was trying to fit into a new girl's family?

It just wasn't right. Roberto was supposed to her hers. Now all she had was a bandage hand from fucking Quinn's face up.

"I can't help it Rae. I thought we were happy together. Now he's with that blonde slut. I don't care if she's Santana's friend. She stole my man and she deserved to get her ass beat." Rachel just held her close as they just cuddled up to each other.


It was now Tuesday and Santana stood at her's and Rachel's locker waiting for her to show up wearing her cheerios uniform. She saw Rachel's friend Allia on Artie's lap. She was confused. She thought Brittany was dating Artie?

"Santana?" She turned her head to see Rachel wheeling up to her looking refreshed from her trip. She stops in front of her with a soft smile on her face.

"Rach." She whispered. She smiles so happy to see her.

"How was your trip?" She asked bending down hoping to get a kiss. Rachel just turned her head so Santana kissed her cheek.

"Amazing. I took great pictures and I had some funny moments with Faria. My bestie needed to get away after her breakup with Roberto." Speaking up him. Roberto walked up to them.

"Rachel can I talk to you?"

"Can pigs fly?" Rachel asked.

"No but-"

"Bye Roberto." She waved him off. He sighs yelling damn it then walks off.

"So I was wondering if you wanted to go on a make up date with me on friday?" Rachel looked at her for a second before responding.

"That would be nice but I don't how good it's going to be when I'm in this chair." Santana stared at her.

"Just because your in a wheelchair, doesn't mean you can't go out." She knew that but it's not the same as actually getting out of the car without having to get in and out of a wheelchair.

"So are you up for that date?" She shook her head.

"No I can't sorry. I just don't feel comfortable being in a wheelchair on a date." Santana leans down staring into her eyes.

"Rach if you want our make up date to be at your house then we can have a sleepover and Amaira can join us then it's fine with me. I'll even cook us dinner. I just want my girlfriend to be happy with me again. Don't you want that?" Rachel nods.

"Yeah I do. Okay a date/sleepover at my house sounds great." Santana grins.

"Can I get a kiss on the lips before our make up date?" Rachel thinks about it then leans in kissing her girlfriend's lips. Santana smiles pecking her lips a few times.

Somebody clears their throat. They pull back to see Coach Sue standing there with a scolded look on her face.

"I thought you two were broken up?" They stared at her confused.

"No we're not broken up. Do you need something Coach?" Sue just mutters annoying glee club members and their romance before walking off.

"Does she not like the Glee club or something?" Santana nods.

"She's always hated New Directions. She wants us to lose so she can get her cheerios budget back." Rachel just nods.

"So are you free to hang out this afternoon?" Rachel shook her head.

"I have a doctors apointment. I've been doing really good with my legs and my back. Hopefully the doctor will tell me that I'll just need be in crutches."

Santana smiles at her girlfriend then pecks her lips again. Rachel smiles at her then pulls back.

"I'll see you later okay?" Santana nods watching Rachel wheel off to class.

"Rachel do you forgive me?" Rachel turn around.

"Not quite yet." She called out to her then turns around and kept on wheeling to class.

Find Out what happens next.