Italics are Thoughts

I do not own any of the characters, only the situation.

FORWARD: I'm really starting to enjoy this. I'm loving the characters and I'm trying to make it as real as possible. If you have any ideas or reviews, let me hear them.

Night #18: Part 2

KURT

Kurt quickly, yet gracefully and perfectly, finishes painting Tina's toenails before refocusing all of his energy to glare daggers at Quinn.

Oh Quinn. Perfect Quinn.

Over the past few hours, Quinn had continuously sat by, and flirted, with Puck at every chance she got. He kept moving away, but she followed. He ignores her by focusing on the video games.

"Are you sure you don't want me to give her a beat down?" Santana asks as she moves to sit on his lap.

Kurt instinctively wraps his arms around the girls waist.

"No. I don't want any trouble." Kurt says quietly.

Santana snorts. "Sure you don't. Like you're not thinking about the many ways to ends her. Nope. Definitely not."

Kurt shares a knowing smirk with Santana before continuing his glaring at Quinn. "I just want her to get over her stupid infatuation with my boyfriend."

Santana smirks. "I'll take care of it."

"Santana?" Kurt hisses as Santana gets out of his lap and saunters over to Quinn and Puck.

Santana glares briefly at Quinn before sliding into a relieved Puck's lap. Quinn tensed up as Santana leaned in to whisper into Puck's ear.

Kurt glances to Sam, catching his eye. Sam smiles at him, so Kurt forces one. Sam notices. He quickly excuses himself from the games before walking over to Kurt.

"What's wrong Kurt?" Sam asks as he sits down and wraps hi arms around the pale boy.

Kurt sighs and leans back into Sam's chest. "It's Quinn. She won't stop flirting with Puck."

"Has he given into it yet?" Sam asks.

Kurt shakes his head.

"Then what do we have to worry about?" Sam asks as he kisses the top of Kurt's head. "He's strong."

"I know. I just think that he might want to go back to woman." Kurt admits quietly.

Sam turns Kurt around in his arms so they're now facing each other. "Kurt, in all honesty, he might." Kurt's face drops. "I don't want him to. And right now, he might love being with us, but not all relationships last. I mean ours has lasted for awhile. Even with all the crap."

"You mean how I wanted to make it a contest? Or pretending to date Santana?" Kurt's disgusted with himself.

Sam chuckles. "Yeah. Those were stupid ideas. But we all have each other now. Just focus on that. He wants you now. And he won't cheat."
Kurt smiles in relief. "I know. I'm just a bit paranoid."

Sam chuckles as he kisses Sam on the forehead. "You're caring. Plus. You have Santana to look out for us."

Kurt cranes his neck around as Santana is walking back towards him. She smirks as she sits down between the two. She wraps her arms around their waists and they wrap an arm around hers.

"What did you do?" Kurt asks with narrow eyes.

"I was just getting Puck in on the plan." She says as she kisses his forehead.

Kurt pulls back from her lips. "And what exactly is the plan?"

Santana smirks and leans toward Sam. She whispers in his ear. Kurt's eyes grow narrow as Sam's grin grows wider. Santana sits back with a smirk.

"What?" Kurt asks slowly.

They both look at him with smiles.

"Just watch, and pay attention young one." Santana says as she slides off of their laps.

Kurt glares at her before turning to Sam. "What's going on?"

Sam gives him a light kiss. "Just play along."

"What?"

"For us."

"What are you-"

"Never Have I Ever!" Finn shouts.

Kurt glares at Sam.

Sam shrugs. "Puck gave him the idea."

"You mean Santana." Kurt points out.

Sam smirks as he stands up. He leans down and puts his hands on Kurt's waist to lift the small boy up. Kurt yelped in surprise and glared at Sam once he was on his own feet.

Sam grabbed his hand and drug him to the circle. Puck immediately sat down on Kurt's left. He leaned down to give Kurt a quick kiss before doing the same to Sam.

Kurt's smile falls when he glances across the circle. Quinn is glaring daggers at the trio. Kurt only smirks as Finn passes out the shot glasses.

"Alright guys," Finn says as Mike fills up the glasses with small amounts of beer. "We don't have that much beer to begin with, so hopefully everyone can come up with some good ones so we don't finish to early."

"We wouldn't want that again." Santana whispers to everyone.

Finn blushes at the laughter.

"I'll start everyone." Rachel says with a smile. "Never have I ever stolen something."

Puck and Santana snort as they take a shot along with everyone else.

"Not good enough Berry." Santana snaps as everyone refills their shot glasses. "Never have I ever had a threesome."

Puck bites his lip and glances at Sam and Kurt before taking a shot along with Santana and Brittany.

Puck smirks. "Never have I ever been caught doing anything sexual."

"Is masturbating sexual?" Brittany asks.

Puck nods. Brittany happily takes a drink, as does Puck, Santana, Sam, and Tina.

Everyone watches Tina with shock on their faces.

Kurt clears his throat. Tina sends him a grateful glance. "Never have I ever been in love."

Quinn stares at Puck while she takes her shot. Kurt takes his shot before kissing Puck and Sam on the cheeks. Sam and Puck take their shots and give Kurt and the other a quick kiss. Kurt blushes as Quinn gets angrier. Everyone else quickly takes a shot.

Sam bites his lip. "Never have I ever been jealous of someone."

Quinn immediately takes her shot. Sam eyes Kurt and Puck before all three take their shots. Everyone else does too.

"Alright guys." Finn's voice is already slurring.

Lightweight.

"Come up with some good ones. We're running low." Finn continues.

Quinn scoffs. "I got one. Never have I ever been in a secret relationship with the person I love while the other person is still in a relationship." She doesn't even take her own drink as she glares Puck down.

Everyone shifts uncomfortably at the tension. Kurt takes Puck's hand. Puck squeezes his hand.

"Seriously?" Quinn yells. "Never have I ever lied about my previous never have I never."

No one takes a drink.

"Liar!" Quinn yells, her words finally slurring. "You're a liar Puck. Why don't you tell your boyfriends about me and you."

"There is no us." Puck growls. "You just keep throwing yourself at me."

"Because there's no reason for you to be with that fairy." She spits out.

Kurt cringes.

"Hell to the naw!" Mercedes yells.

Santana stands up and crosses over to Quinn and slaps her.

"You bit-"

Santana slaps her again before grabbing the front of her shirt. She pulls Quinn up and pushes her up the stairs.

"I'll be back after I take out the trash." Santana says to the group before pushing Quinn out of the room.

Rachel starts giggling. "Movie time."

The trio of boys stays sitting as everyone slowly moves to the couch. A few of their teammates offer them supporting smiles.

Kurt sighs as Puck and Sam stand up.

"You okay?" Kurt asks Puck.

"I'm fine." He grabs Kurt and Sam's hands. "I just want you to know that nothing is going on. I would never do that to you."

Sam gives him a gentle kiss. "We know."

Kurt's smile turns into a frown. "So was that the plan?"

"Yep." Santana answers for him as she marches down the stairs. "Get Quinny to throw a tantrum so I can throw her out. Now everyone hates her. More support for you guys."

Kurt smiles. "You really are a great friend."

"I know." She says proudly. "So come on. We have a movie to watch."

"Wait a second. How is Quinn getting home?" Kurt asks, only slightly concerned.

"She's not that drunk. And she only lives a bit away. She needs to walk off that baby fat." Santana smirks as she goes to the couch and flops down by Brittany.

The blonde girl immediately lies her head on Santana's shoulder. Kurt chuckles as he drags his boyfriends to watch the movie.


Ta da. So, I have the rest of this story planned out. So up to ten chapters left, depending. So let me know what you think. I love reading reviews, so please critique everything that I write.