I'm sorry but the tartie getting together seemed like a last minute thing so here's how I would have ended Tike
The 5 year time jump
Mike was a successful choreographer and had just did a few shows on Carnegie Hall and even danced backup for Michelle Williams, Keyshia Cole, and Nicki Minaj. He was about to open up his own dance studio in New Orleans but before he could do that he had to get Tina back first. When she approached him at the wedding about them getting married he was shocked because he always wanted to propose to her and plus it wasn't the right time for them to get married. He wanted to have a career before he settled down and had a wife and kids. That's why when he found out she was dating Artie he was shocked but happy that way it gave him time to get everything for her.
That's why when he walked into McKinley he was prepared to get Tina back by any means necessary even if that meant losing a friend in Artie. He had her engagement ring in one of his pockets and a single red rose in his hand. He looked around seeing all his old friends and their significant others. He was shocked to see Mercedes and Sam showing PDA since Mercedes wasn't that kind of girl. He still remembers when they him and Tina went on a double date with them and every-time Sam went for a kiss Mercedes would block him. He seen Puck and Quinn talking on the phone he figured they was talking to Beth.
He seen Blaine and Sebastian talking and making heart eyes at each other. He seen Kurt and Adam talking and Kurt genuinely looking happy. He was looking for one person and one person only and that was Tina.
Artie was a successful film director and had won a lot of many independent film awards. Most of his films was about what he went through when he was at McKinley. For the first part of him and Tina's relationship it was good but later on it became bad because both of their hearts was with other people. Even though Artie did her wrong when he went to New York his heart was with Kitty and Tina's heart was with Mike. So after 3 months of dating they decided to break up but remain the best of friends. Artie rolled into McKinley with one goal in mind and that was to get Kitty back.
Kitty and Tina walked into McKinley each of them happy in their careers. Kitty was a counselor for teenagers who have been sexually molested. Tina became a model for Kurt's clothing line and a best-selling author. Even though they was happy in their careers they still wanted somebody to share their happiness and success with. Kitty still loved Artie as much as he pissed her off and hurt her even when she found out he got back with Tina she still loved him. Tina was still in love with Mike even when she was with Artie she still wanted to be with Mike.
Mike was talking to Sam and Puck about his dance studio and how he can't wait to invite them down and teach them some dance moves. He was brought out of his conversation when Artie asked to speak to him privately. He excused himself and followed Artie to a empty classroom and sat down in one of the chairs.
"What's up Artie?"
"I don't know if your upset about Tina and I dating and if you are I'm sorry. I shouldn't have did what I did knowing you guys wasn't done with each other. I need your help man I'm trying get Kitty back and she won't even give me the time of day. I didn't mean to hurt her when I went to New York and I didn't mean to lead her on and then go and date Tina again. Out of all the girls I dated I treated her so badly when we broke up and I feel bad."
"I'm not mad with you Artie for dating Tina. You was her boyfriend first and I can't get mad. I'm in for helping you get Kitty back but I'm trying get Tina back so maybe we should help each other maybe we should perform a song for them like pyt. Artie smiles and they talk for another hour coming up with a gameplan. After their talk they each texted the girls telling them to meet them in the auditorium they had a surprise for them.
When Kitty and Tina entered the auditorium they was met with a screen showing pictures of Tina and Mike and of Kitty and Artie. They then seen two single roses left on the stage and picked them up and looked at each other strangled then they heard Artie's voice.
Artie
You know you, you make me feel so good inside
I always wanted a girl just like you
Such a P.Y.T., pretty young thing, ooh!
Where did you come from lady?
And ooh won't you take me there?
Right away, won't you baby?
Tendoroni you've got to be
Spark my nature, sugar fly with me
Don't you know now is the perfect time
We can make it right, hit the city lights
Then tonight ease the lovin' pain
Let me take you to the max!
Artie and Mike came down the ramp singing and dancing with two other red roses. They rolled down the ramp and did the same moves they did when they performed it in the choir room.
I want to love you
(P.Y.T.)
Pretty young thing
You need some lovin'
(T.L.C.)
Tender lovin' care
And I'll take you there, girl, hoo!
I want to love you
(P.Y.T.)
Pretty young thing
You need some lovin'
(T.L.C.)
Tender lovin' care
I'll take you there
(Anywhere you wanna go)
Yes, I will, ooh!
Tina and Kitty blush and giggle as they watch them perform. Tina remembered when Artie and Mike did that song for her and Brittany and she just smile.
Nothin' can stop this burnin' desire to be with you
Gotta get to you baby
Won't you come? It's emergency
Cool my fire yearnin', honey, come set me free
But don't you know now is the perfect time
We can dim the lights, just to make it right
In the night, hit the lovin' spot
I'll give you all that I've got
Mike helps Tina and Kitty on the stage and Artie surprised all by getting out the wheelchair and dancing. He was a little wobbly but he was happy to be out the chair. He walks over to Kitty and starts dancing with her and wraps her up in his arms as she cries. Tina and Mike dance as Tina cries for her long time best friend finally getting his wish and walking.
I want to love you
(P.Y.T.)
Pretty young thing
You need some lovin'
(T.L.C.)
Tender lovin' care
And I'll take you there
Yes, I will, yes I
I want to love you
(P.Y.T.)
Pretty young thing
You need some lovin'
(T.L.C.)
Tender lovin' care
I'll take you there
Yes, I will, hee!
The two couples continued to dance while Artie continued to sing. After he sung the last note with the other three help they all smiled and had a small group hug. Tina went over and gave him a tight hug crying into his shoulder. She pulls back long enough to smack him on the back of his head.
"Why you didn't tell me you got the surgery?"
"I wanted to surprise you guys and get it on my own I knew you guys talk me out of it and I didn't want that." Kitty furrows her brows in confusion and steps up to him and caresses his cheek. Tina steps away and goes in Mike's arms and hugs him tightly while watching her two friends.
"I wouldn't talk you out of it when I know how important it is to you. I'm happy that your walking and that your famous." Artie says nothing but gets on one knee and takes out a engagement ring.
"I'm happy about all that too but I'm not happy about not sharing it with somebody. I did share it with Tins but our hearts wasn't waits each other. My heart was with a bitchy cheerleader who went to a carnival with me and sung the Beatles with me. So Kitty Wilde please do me the honor of being my wife I promise to make you happy and never do anything to make you want to divorce me." Kitty wipes her tears and helps Artie up and kisses him lightly on the lips.
"Artie if you hurt me like the way you did in New York and when you went back out with Tina I make your life a living hell. Due to the fact that you made me happy when we dated I would love to be your wife." Artie picks Kitty up and twirls her around and places the ring on her finger. Artie turns around and smiles at Tina and Mike and motions for Mike to make his move. Mike unwraps Tina from his body and gets down on one knee shocking Tina at the same time.
"So Tina we met at an Asian camp and from there on you have been my muse. I did everything just to make you happy and you have been there for me. Even when I was being stubborn and didn't want to confront my dad about me going to dance school you was there. When we got back together during grease and then the whole wedding thing." Tina, Artie, and Kitty chuckle at the craziness that was Tina. So Tina please marry me and make me the happiest man in the world?"
"Of course I'll marry you Mike who else is gonna deal with my craziness." Mike jumps up and places the ring on Tina's finger and kisses her passionately. Tina and Kitty look at each other engagement rings and squeal loudly and go to the reunion to brag and show off their engagement rings. Artie and Mike look at each other and smile and go to join their fiancé's at the reunion.
So in my whacky head canon Artie got the surgery and all of this happened. Uhm yea excuse all the grammar and stuff and I own nothing but my imagination. Song used pyt by Michael Jackson
